Bio
My name is Amy Gates (also known on the ‘net as amygeekgrl or the Crunchy Domestic Goddess). I live in Colorado with my husband Jody (yes, he’s a guy...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

"The 10 Biggest Mistakes Parents Make" - Seriously? Seriously??!

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 27
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

If I had to make a list of the things that I'm most intolerant of, I'd put fear mongering up there near the top. I'm not a fan of advertisements, public service announcements, campaigns, TV shows, articles or blog posts that use fear to push their agenda. Which is why when I read the Lifescript post Top 10 Mistakes Even Smart Moms Make, I was more than a little upset. Don't get me wrong, there are some things on this list I definitely agree with, but when it starts out with number one saying it's a mistake to share a bed with your baby, you can bet that I'm going to take the whole list with a grain of salt.

Here are what Lifescript calls the "10 Biggest Mistakes Parents Make:"

1. Sharing a bed with baby.
2. Putting your child to bed with milk or juice.
3. Buying second-hand toys or baby furniture.
4. Showing your child "smart baby" DVDs.
5. Putting kids in the basket of a shopping cart.
6. Sharing utensils with your child.
7. Delaying or avoiding vaccines.
8. Leaving your child alone in the car "just for a minute."
9. Skipping helmets on tricycle rides.
10. Leaving your child alone in the bath or shower.

These are the "10 biggest mistakes parents make?" The biggest? Really?

If I had to grade myself as a parent based on this list I think I would get a big, fat "F" as I've done 9 out of 10 of these things at least once and about half of them on a regular basis. How about you? How would you rate?

It feels as though the author of this article assumes that none of us have any common sense whatsoever, yet it's directed at "smart" moms. It's also a slap in the face to any mother who's made educated and thoughtful decisions about things like co-sleeping and vaccinations.

I co-slept with both of my children as babies. It is a practice that is as old as time and can be beneficial to both mother and baby if it is done safely. Annie at PhDinParenting has put together a great list of the dos and don'ts of co-sleeping safety. I don't believe a blanket statement telling people not to co-sleep is the answer. I think giving them guidelines to follow to make it a safe environment is much more productive which I wrote about in this post about a surprising Fox News report regarding co-sleeping.

Julia wrote about why she co-slept with her children and Lactating Girl wrote her reasons for co-sleeping as well.

In the Lifescript article they say, "In 2008, when the U.S. experienced its largest measles outbreak in a decade, nearly half the 131 sickened kids were unvaccinated." Does that not translate into more than half of the sickened kids WERE vaccinated? That doesn't seem like the best argument in favor of vaccinations to me and I'm pretty sure that the "smart" moms will see through the data presented. I'm not saying vaccinations are good or bad, but I think parents should be allowed to make the choices that are best for their children.

After her oldest son began having terrible seizures, Steph of Adventures in Babywearing did a lot of research before she decided vaccinations were not right for her family. She feels, "This is an area that is not 'one size fits all.'"

On Raising My Boychick's Naked Pictures of Faceless People - a series of guest posts from diverse anonymous bloggers - one blogger shared about her decision not to vaccinate her children. She believes:

People need to step back, take a deep breath and do what is right for them without expecting everyone to come to the same conclusion. Alarmist propaganda is never ok and neither is demonizing an entire group of people for a personal decision. We trust parents to drive their children around in cars, to make other healthcare decisions, to guide their children’s dietary choices. This is no different.

Colleen wrote about why she chooses to delay vaccinations and said:

I know that doctors believe in supporting the AAP and the status quo. I know they believe that administering vaccines is in the best interest of our children and of all children. But I hope our doctor also understands that by educating myself about vaccines, by researching them and, yes, even by questioning the schedule and the ingredients in them that I am doing what is in the best interest of my child.

  • 27
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
kim arnold 5 pts

kim@www.margeryraveson.com

Revised List:

1. Frequently ignore child while talking on cell phone.
2. Insist on at least 3 extra-curricular activities per week.
3. Allow child to watch whatever she wants on TV.
4. Compare child to others in her grade.
5. Give child whatever she wants.
6. Live vicariously through your child.
7. Never schedule "family only" outings.
8. Never abandon your own schedule in order to play with child.
9. Don't read bedtime stories to your child.
10. Say "I love you" rarely, if ever.

Obviously, the original list was safety-oriented. But the safety of the psyche is equally as important as physical safety in raising a healthy child.

lauracarroll 5 pts

Are the ones who impart and set examples on the big stuff...They don't raise kids to grow up with a sense of entitlement. They send the message to their kids early that they are not the center of the universe. They teach them humility and generosity. They cultivate their child's interests and don't force him/her to become what they want them to be, but help them discover all of who they are.

Laura
Families of Two
http://lauracarroll.com

TammyJones 5 pts

I agree that there is way too much fear-mongering going on in the media and in our society. "Helicopter parenting" is a huge concern/peeve of mine. However, there is a lot of evidence that bedsharing, particularly with young infants, is of grave concern and can considerably heighten the risk of death. It doesn't sit well with a lot of folks, but it's factual, nonetheless.
The article linked above on co-sleeping safely contains some errors. Dr. McKenna never found any protective benefit. He found physiological change, even an increase in apnea - but he never found anything that could be called protective. That's a myth commonly perpetuated in AP circles but if you read the actual research (or ask Dr. McKenna outright) he'll tell you he was not able to demonstrate bedsharing to be protective. In addition, the article linked also fear-mongers that deep, hidden conspiracy of the evil crib manufacturers ;) and encourages the use of soft bedding - a known danger no matter where an infant sleeps.
My point is, yes there is a lot of BS out there but part of being a good parent and a critical thinker means that we may have to question our own practices. We may *want* them to be safe and ok, but sometimes they're just not.

Metropolitan Mama 5 pts

If these are the 10 biggest mistakes a parent can make, then I'm in serious trouble! ;)

I agree with Steph of Adventures in Babywearing. Our culture would be much better off if parents spent more time trusting their hearts, holding their babies, talking with their kids, and investing time into their families.

Thanks for posting this!

victorias_view 21 pts moderator

Does the person who wrote this Lifescript article even have children? Needless to say I think I'll join in with WritRams and sing a little kumbaya.

Joanna Cake 5 pts

If you read some so-called experts, it's amazing that some of our kids ever get to be teenagers!

I think we all beat ourselves up far too much. We should perhaps compare ourselves to mothers in days gone by who didnt have the luxuries that we do and had to send their little ones up chimneys into factories. A bit like some of the mothers in the third world today.

Why does motherhood turn into one long mea culpa? Why can't we just celebrate our diversity and rely on our own instinct to produce healthy, happy, socially educated offspring who can survive in today's cut-throat world?

Because once they become teenagers, there is so much more serious stuff to fret about than the little mistakes we might have made when they were younger.

Joanna Cake is a writer and blogger who discusses relationships, sex, intimacy, parenting, health and anything else that life would care to throw at her on her blog at Having My Cake and Eating It Too ( http://andeatingit2.com )

thewritingmother 5 pts

That is the silliest "biggest" list ever.

Heather

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
www.heather-cook.com
www.thewritingmother.blogspot.com
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*

myfunnyfunnyfamily 5 pts

Guess my kids must be the most botched monstrosities ever because i have done nearly all of those things at one time or another. Funny that they are healthy, emotionally well-adjusted, happy and smart.

What a narrow-minded, stupid and unimaginative list. I can think of WAY bigger mistakes to make with a kid. Like, um, abuse drugs and alcohol? Beat them? Drive without car seats? Blame them for your shortcomings? Use them as a pawn in emotional wars with your spouse?

Adventures In Babywearing 5 pts

I think that one of the biggest mistakes of all in parenting is not following your instincts and instead following the "rules" made up by society. Books are great, websites are helpful, friends are well-meaning, but you have to take in all that advice and apply what is best for you, spit out the sticks, and parent in the way that is best for YOU.

Also, I think more parents should be given an emphasis on loving their kids, respecting them, and holding them more. :)

Stephanie

Adventures In Babywearing ( http://www.adventuresinbabywearing.com )

denverdoni 5 pts

a learning experience too. And sometimes we can even laugh about them later. One time I committed one of the most serious mistakes of leaving a child alone in the car only for a minute. My older daughter was swimming with friends and they called to say that she had sprained her ankle jumping into the pool. I pulled into the parking lot and parked the car and got out to go up to the pool entrance to help her out to the car. My 4 year old, the boy, unbuckled and jumped into the drivers seat and jerked the stick shift out of gear into neutral and the car was rolling across the parking lot! I left my injured daughter standing on one foot and ran over and grabbed the the car and stopped it with my bare hands. I'll never forget the look on my 5 year old's face in the back seat screaming "mommy!!! Matt is driving the car!!" Lesson learned: set the emergency brake. Oh, and never leave the boy in the car alone, he was positively gleeful about his little joyride.

I met a great granny at the hospital gift shop recently and she was telling me how she felt that her grandkids were just way too overprotective and the kids are not allowed to have fun anymore. I guess these fear mongering lists are part of the culture now and some people feel they have to be perfect at everything they do. But if you don't allow yourself and your kids to experience life and possibly make a mistake you also deprive yourself of learning opportunities.

superkeely 5 pts

9/10 here, and only because my kid isn't old enough to ride a trike.

That's possibly the most ridiculous list ever.

( http://un-mom.blogspot.com%3ethe%20un%20mom%3c/a%3... )

KarenVogel 5 pts

There's only one mistake to make, and that is following advice that does not fit your family or your child.

As for me, I've done 8 out of the 10 on the list. Too bad!

amygeekgrl 5 pts

I like how you said cosleeping and vaccinations are personal choices. That's an excellent way to phrase it. Those types of things do not belong on a list like this. Also you said, "And most parents don't take those kind of decisions lightly." Totally agree. The people I know who have decided either to co-sleep or delay or not vaccinate (especially) have done their research before making those decisions.

Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
BlogHers Act contributing editor ( http://www.blogher.com/special-events/bloghers-act )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

There are many other things we should be concerned with like:
are carseats properly installed?
could any of my furniture tip over on my child?
are our cleaning products and medicine stored out of reach of the children?
etc.
Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
BlogHers Act contributing editor ( http://www.blogher.com/special-events/bloghers-act )

AmberS 5 pts

I've done most everything on that list at one time or another. For example, I co-sleep. And I buy second-hand toys. Really? Allowing my daughter to pick up a second-hand doll using her allowance money is the biggest mistake I could make? I have a hard time believing that.

The truth is that, sometimes, bad things happen to kids. As parents, we can do our best to be vigilant and keep our children safe. But it's not always going to be possible. Living in fear won't save us, but it might lead to us sealing our children in a bubble and depriving them of freedom. That, in my book, would be a MUCH bigger mistake.

Keeping it real in the suburbs www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

muimi07 5 pts

I was just reading the list aloud to DH who agrees that whoever wrote that original list obviously did not have children. While there are a few I agree with, most specifically the not leaving a child alone in a car or bath, the rest are eye rollers at best, slap upside the head at worst.

I think we'd also fail this, having regularly done 6 of the 10 items. While cosleeping and vaccinations are pretty hot topics (personally I cosleep but don't delay vax), the no second hand toys or furniture just makes me think that whoever wrote this list must be independently wealthy or something. While there are some items that I wouldn't buy second hand (notably sleeping furniture and car seats), others like toys that are easily sanitized and generally not of interest to baby for more than a few months are so much better off purchased via consignment or even garage sales. Because, I dunno, some of us are on what one would call BUDGETS.

--

Michelle ~ http://www.mommymisadventures.com/

Clamo88 5 pts

The article mentions that manufacturers get very low response to recalls... so automatically it assumes these products are sold to unsuspecting bad mothers? And that everyone buying second hand items are too stupid to look up a recall list? I know lots of people who just throw a toy out if it is recalled just to save the hassle.

I have bought all my nursery furniture and toys second hand, after checking the current safety standards. A quick wipe over with some disinfectant and some time out in the sun, and voila! Ready for baby :)

You can find Glowless at Where's My Glow ( http://wheresmyglow.blogspot.com/ )?

selligwoman 5 pts

would be taking parenting advice from lists like that! holy cow! maybe we should start a "bad parenting isn't so bad" group!

Mamapoekie 5 pts

I think I score a whopping eight out of ten. Well seven for now and soon eight.
If I had to make this list, I think I would put Crying it out on number one! And spanking on two and tea cyp parenting on three... I think if I made thelist it would indeed be a lot different.
Glad to have found you, I will be visiting your blog. I hink we have a lot in common

denverdoni 5 pts

This is fear mongering for sure although in some small number of cases there can be tragic unforeseen accidents from these and any number of other "mistakes."

There is no failproof environment for children, and safety is a parent's number one responsibility, however some of these are just not on the scale. How does putting a child to bed with milk make it to the same level as leaving a child alone in a car or bathtub? Co-sleeping and vaccines are personal choices that parents have a right to make for their own reasons. And most parents don't take those kind of decisions lightly. I chose to co-sleep with my babies 30 years ago and I read numerous articles on child development that supported our decision. Vaccines were not really in question at that time, but today's parents have more information to base that decision on and I don't blame them for not blindly following the norm.

Yeah, and sharing utensils? Anybody who has ever had a baby knows that the baby is going to eat from your plate. They have no interest in food that is on their own plate, but if it is your food they want it.

Well, if this article is written for "smart moms" then my guess is most of them are smart enough to know these are not all equal on the mistake scale and probably don't need this list anyway.

jannajoy25@hotmail.com 5 pts

It sure seems to me that the person who has written this list has NOT been a mother. There are much bigger mistakes than these and in fact some of them are not mistakes.

I agree with you being upset, and yes vaccinations has been one of the things that tears me up as a parent. I just can't wrap my head around all the arguments of why and why not.

Janna -  The Adventure of Motherhood  ( http://tiny.cc/fzzq2 )& MommysPiggyTALES ( http://tiny.cc/25qae )

almostallthetruth 5 pts

If those are the worst 10 mistakes smart parents make then I am one big failure as a parent. There are definitely things we should not do on the list, but more than anything it is the tone and judging in the article that bothers me. And really, there is a lot more we could be worried about than what is on this list...

Brenna
Almost All The Truth ( http://www.almostallthetruth.com )
a little etsy love ( http://etsyfix.blogspot.com/ ).

WritRams 5 pts

Co-sleepers unite! :o)

Jacqueline Wilson (aka: WritRams) is a writer, blogger, educator, mother and wife. You can find her on her Writer Ramblings blog at www.WritRams.com ( http://www.writrams.com ) writing about a little of everything...maybe even you.

amygeekgrl 5 pts

I'll hold hands and sing with you. :)
Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
BlogHers Act contributing editor ( http://www.blogher.com/special-events/bloghers-act )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

In the article, they clarify that the issue with secondhand stuff is there could be safety recalls on the toys/furniture. So I'm guessing they don't really mean to avoid them because of the germs (though they do seem fearful of germs in general in the article). Of course if people are co-sleeping then they wouldn't have to worry about any recalls with the cribs at least. ;)

I happen to love secondhand stuff. Its cheaper and more environmentally-friendly than buying new. :)

Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
BlogHers Act contributing editor ( http://www.blogher.com/special-events/bloghers-act )

WritRams 5 pts

I've done 10 of those 10 things. :o|

My child is a co-sleeping-unvaccinated-hand-me-down-wearing-independent-DVD-watching toddler now and she seems "normal." (And just to prove she's acting as a "normal" two year old I wrote, "When Parenting Isn't Fun(ny)" http://bit.ly/cngvA6).

In all seriousness, I also hate all the fear mongering. Aside from basic needs and safety, I think everyone should decide what is right for them and their family (WITHOUT judgement from others).

Why can't we all just get along?!? (Kumbaya anyone? Come on...hold hands with me...)

Jacqueline Wilson (aka: WritRams) is a writer, blogger, educator, mother and wife. You can find her on her Writer Ramblings blog at www.WritRams.com ( http://www.writrams.com ) writing about a little of everything...maybe even you.

natalied6579 5 pts

I'm not a parent so maybe there is something to this that I am missing but what is wrong with secondhand furniture/toys? Furniture in particular. What are people supposed to do with old baby furniture and what are people who can't afford to buy the new stuff supposed to do? I'm guessing germs are the issue? so wouldn't people properly sanitize things? If that isn't the issue is it giving the kid a complex about the stigma of having second hand stuff? Cause...seriously?