2009 BET Awards: Michael Jackson Tribute or Travesty?
by Megan Smith

BET gave out their annual music awards last night.  I'm going to be straight up right now and say I didn't watch it.  That's right, I'm the BlogHer TV Contributing Editor and I didn't watch that TV show. In fact the only way my cable box ever lands on the dreaded BET channel is if my finger slips on the remote.  Then I make sure to get the heck out of there before my eyeballs fry and my blood boils.

If you're not sure why, read up on why "BET Dishonors This Black Woman" and just insert my name.  Or read my open letter to Al Sharpton awhile back about the image of black women and the music industry.

So this morning when I started hearing all the rumblings about last night's over three hour awards show and the Michael Jackson tribute, I began reading recaps, commentary and checking out videos on YouTube before they got pulled by Viacom (which owns BET).

The unanimous high point of the show was the appearance of Janet Jackson at the end of the show tearfully speaking about her brother. Other than that, the show sounds like it left a lot to be desired.  I'll let some bloggers who did see the show, tell you what they thought.

At Love Is Dope, even though LID liked some portions of the show, that didn't stop her from saying "I Am So Done With BET:"

Yes, they only had a few days to pull it off and yes award shows are very complicated to produce, but they had a chance to do it right.

BET failed miserably.

BET should have pulled together an exciting highlight reel of MJ's performances and topped it off with Ne-Yo doing his thing and maybe Usher doing a dance number and then just waited a week or two to put together a proper, star-studded tribute. 

Over at Hit Me Back, one blogger believed, "Michael Jackson Deserved Better:"

I was one of many who live-tweeted the show and started out praising New Edition opening of classic Jackson 5ive songs (swole up, whiskey-voiced Bobby Brown notwithstanding...) And when Jamie Foxx came out came out dressed like the Beat It video, I was stirring and tweeted that I thought his combination of talents made him the perfect host.

I genuinely expected a celebration. I wanted to sing, laugh, cry and be dancing around my living room talking about "Mama-se, mama-sah, mama coo sah!" -- Michael wouldn't have wanted anything less. Instead, we got a stiff, stilted evening that looked like it had been put together by amateurs.

The Lipstick Diaries, "BET Awards, Loved It or Hated It?" thought the show had some good points:

Throughout the entire show & it's high points...& some very low points (Lil Wayne & his Young Money crew, except for Drake) there was a moment that I truly cherished. That moment was Travis Barker's appearance AND great performance with Jamie Foxx's "Blame It."

Renee Ross of Cutie Booty Cakes who tweeted the show last night was kind of sorry she did:

I feel like I've been robbed. That is 3 hours of my life that I will never get back. Dang it for going against my better judgment and watching the awards show. 

Diary of An Anxious Black Woman:

It seems that the tears I shed for Michael Jackson should not just be for the end of his life, or the end of my childhood era, but also for the end of an era of black musical genius of the 20th century - which arguably began with Louis Armstrong, King of Jazz, and now closes with our very own King of Pop.

Verite Parlant of Whose Shoes Are These Anyway?

Many of the tweets I saw on Twitter did not give the show high marks. The highlight of the evening for me was the O'Jays performing their hits. The show, otherwise, was let down. I even wish Maxwell had sung something else, but I did enjoy him.

The performers continued patting themselves on the back during the after show because they put the tribute together in so short a time. I guess I'll cut some slack given the time factor, but really I think some of them need the Auto-Tune, the machine about which Jay-Z speaks in his song "Death to the Autotune." He performed it tonight, which in some ways is glorifying the inability to sing well.

Jamal at Jamal Street Journal:

Why the hell was Lil' Wayne up there performing that offensive song about women, that needed to be censored every 10 seconds, with a group of prepubescent girls dancing prancing on stage? Both Weezy and BET are confused as hell if they can't tell the difference between who belongs in the background and who belongs on the playground - one is for adults, one isn't.  

A post from Pitts Indeed (via Jack and Jill Politics), "Dear BET, What The F*ck Was That?"

I understand Michael Jackson's death threw a monkey wrench into their show's plans. But you know what? Don't one monkey wrench stop no show. They didn't have to make some historic adjustment to acknowledge Michael's passing; they merely needed to honor him; to gracefully acknowledge that his musical contributions were such that marking his passing was far bigger than anything that was scheduled to take place that night.

But they didn't.

A pop icon who was, at times, the best of us, was dishonored by a network that is, more often than not, our worst.

Finally, the most scathing comments about the show came from Tazz of Tazz Daddy, via SoulBounce.  He gave the "Top 10 Reasons Why The BET Awards Made Me Want To Vomit."  

I said they were scathing, didn't I?

Here's his number 3 out of the 10:

3. Debra Lee: The New head of BET is such a pioneer! No one thought that BET could sink any lower than Bob Johnson's level of coonery and you proved us all wrong! Moron! I bet you think you've done something substantial, but you have only managed to embarrass us on an international stage due to the fact that CNN has been covering this abomination! 

And in case you think Tazz may be alone in his opinions, he cross posted the post on Facebook and at last count there were over 700 comments.   God knows I didn't read them all, but I read a bunch and the majority were cheering good old Tazz on.

On a related note, I was originally going to write about the reaction on Twitter by some people that the trending topic last night was the BET awards. 
Womanist Musings made the sarcastic point:

There are those that found the trending topics disturbing. How
dare black people have the nerve to communicate with each other in such large numbers. Did we actually forget that the internet was created for whiteness? 

One tweet by BrightEyesJulie said:

Did anyone see the new trending topics?  I don't think this is a very good neighborhood.  Lock the car doors kids.

Then there was KashaSeptember:

Why are all these black people on trending topics?  Neyo, Beyonce, Tyra, Jamie Foxx.  Is it Black History Month again?  LOL.

I mean really, what is there to say to that?  How about, black people are on the internet...deal with it! 

 

Megan Smith is the BlogHer Contributing Editor covering Television and Online Video.  Her personal entertainment blog is Megan's Minute, Quirky Commentary Around The Clock.

 

Comments

 

Guuurrrrrl!

I've come across lots of blogs since this topic came up with people saying they hated the show.  Hmm. And I thought I was being hard. :-)  Just saw tweets from one person, who also blogged her distaste. To non-tweeple reading this, start at the end of the time-stamped tweets of her relaying a tiff with a relative over the BET Awards and read up:

leave me the hell out of it. She said she didn't see what I meant and I said make a paradigm shift and move up a class tier. was i wrong?
32 minutes ago from web

then she said I was judgmental and she wanted to support our people. I said if want to identify with lower class dysfunction be my guess but
33 minutes ago from web

I said it was a display of dysfunction & coonery for the world to see.  
34 minutes ago from web

my relative told me not to speak to her b/c i gave my opinion about BET Awards. I didn't make this up.
about 1 hour ago from web

Had a nightmare that BET Awards was on tv last nite
about 18 hours ago from mobile web

(HG)

And she's generally pretty low-key.

Lots of people are not happy with what they saw last night, and I think part of it was BET's build-up that it would be a tribute to MJ. People expected more for Michael Jackson, I guess, even from BET, which they otherwise don't seem to expect much from.

I didn't mention it in my post, but Lil Wayne with the girls who looked like tweens bothered me. I tweeted that much last night. 

Nice round-up, Megan.  No comment on white people who think only white people are online. :-/

Nordette Adams is a BlogHer CE & you can find her other stuff through Her 411.

 

Yeah, That Whole Supporting "Our People"
Thing

I've got nothing against "supporting our people," but I'll be damned if I sit silently by while some of the clowns of the music industry pretend to represent me.  They don't.

If they just went about their business making bad, non-mysogynistic music, I'd say go right ahead.  But when they start talking about how they're "the real black people" I've got a problem.

Dude, I'm almost ready to bring back the days when Jesse Jackson "spoke for all black people."  Or even better, when Spike Lee was the media-anointed king of "what black people are thinking."

Almost.

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video

Megan's Minute 

 

Letters to BET

I think that you hit the nail on the head when you said that BET really hyped the show as an MJ tribute but it never manifested. Although I was live tweeting and was subsequently booted from twitter, I did not see Lil' Wayne perform. Let me clarify that - I did see him on the screen but my eyes glazed over and I continued to focus on talking with friends on facebook about this travesty of a show.

I had NO idea that he had children on the stage because I did not look up after his appearance on screen and the numerous bleeping made it impossible to know what he was rapping about - the profanity made the performance a fail for me.

However, this morning it has come to my attention that the lyrics were not only filled with explicatives but were of a sexual nature - he had his child and other children on the stage during this performance!

I AM SHOCKED! Here is a link to the lyrics - http://jezebel.com/5303695/bet-awards-recap-lil-wayne-performs-inappropr...

All I can say is I was embarrassed that I watched the show and now I am horrified. I will be writing a letter to express my disgust and hope that more people do too.

Cutie Booty Cakes

 

Booted From Twitter? I Thought You Were
Joking

I thought you were joking when you said in your email that you were booted from Twitter.  Please, tell us what happened in more detail.

As far as Lil' Wayne, I was appalled when I read the description of his performance, but unfortunately, I wasn't surprised.

You can send an email to BET here: contactus@bet.com

Or here are BET's addresses and phone numbers:

BET Networks
1235 W Street, NE
Washington, D.C. 20018-1211
202-608-2000

BET Interactive
General Inquiries
1235 W Street, NE
Washington, D.C. 20018-1211
202-608-2000 or 212-258-1000

BTW thanks for the links to Tazz on Facebook and to Womanist Musings.  ;-)

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video

Megan's Minute 

 

Megan Smith, take a bow

This is one fantastic piece of journalism-meets-commentary. Thanks for your wrap-up.

Renee, I hear you re: letters to BET. Is there a petition site out there that you're using to get the word out? Or do you recommend snail mail?

Best,
Lisa

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.

 

Lisa, Thank You!

Lisa, thank you. You'll get an extra hug at BlogHer for that!

I don't know if Renee has a petition site, but I provided the BET addresses in my response to her comment.

Let's see if we can light a fire under 'em.

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video

Megan's Minute 

 

Petition site

Lisa, I am not aware of a petition site but if I come across one I will be sure to post it here.

Megan, twitter will kick you out if you send too many tweets in one hour. I had no idea that I was tweeting that much but I couldn't log on for received the too many tweets message. This has happened to me before but I was leading a twitter party and knew it was a possibility. I suppose it is a safeguard against spam. I turned to facebook to continue my commentary and interaction with my network.

I think everyone should send a letter to BET - the awards show received the highest rating of all awards shows on cable this year. More info on that can be found here:
http://www.blacktalentnews.com/artman/publish/article_2367.shtml

Cutie Booty Cakes

 

I'm Surprised I Haven't Been Kicked Off!

I have gotten notices on TweetDeck that I've reached my what-cha-ma-call-it limit, but then I just switch over to regular Twitter in my web browser.

Thanks for the info.

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video

Megan's Minute 

 

My thoughts exactly

Everything you guys said and esp this:

In fact the only way my cable box ever lands on the dreaded BET channel is if my finger slips on the remote.  Then I make sure to get the heck out of there before my eyeballs fry and my blood boils. 

I did try to watch a Boyz in the Hood one night and the commercials just got to me.  I could not even finish the movie.  I have blocked it on my kids' TV, I should just do the same on mine as well.

I hope no one was expecting anything less from Lil wayne.  I have seen enough of his interveiws and listened to his songs enough to know that he beleives his press clippings.

 

I have written enough complaints to BET to wallpaper a room.  I do not think they are listening.  Because after all they are catering to their market.  Whoever that is.

Michelle

I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/

 

Respect

I worked the show, I worked in the backstage (read parking lot area), where the seat fillers, mosh pit fillers and the 106 and Park pre party people were staged and shuttled over.

I was surprised to see how "undressed" most of them were.  If this is an awards show, shouldn't the attire reflect that?

Girls in shorts shorter than any Daisy Dukes I have ever seen.  Guys in jeans down around their knees (and these were the seat fillers!).

I understand that the "dress code" of some shows is not quite Oscar's, but it just shouted disrespectful to me.

As I was sitting backstage (I never actually saw the show), I was reading tweets on my phone from East Coast watchers and just sighed. 

I have never been a watcher of BET, don't even know if my cable carries it or not, but I guess I am just disappointed that a formerly respectable tv station and awards show has "jumped the shark".

 

A Network That Could Be A Source Of Pride

Hi Michelle,

BET is a network that could be a source of great pride instead of a source of embarrassment and anger.

And Adrienne, I find your experience interesting.  It's kind of like twenty-somethings wearing flip flops at Fortune 500 companies.    Like you said....sigh...

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video

Megan's Minute 

 

Shocking! BET Apologizes--And Who Cares?

This update from BET about the BET Music Awards last week via BlackTwitterati on Twitter:  today Drake and BET apologized for the number with Lil' Wayne that included young girls dancing onstage to explicit lyrics as a so-called tribute to Michael Jackson.

Here's part of the statemen from the BET website:

"BET Networks deeply regrets the performance by Young Money at the BET Awards '09 (featuring Lil Wayne, Drake, Gudda Gudda and Mack Maine). Elements of the performance were unplanned and should not have happened," the network said in a statement. "We value and appreciate the feedback from our viewers and have edited Young Money's performance for all BET Awards '09 encore presentations." 

My response:  Yeah, whatever.  Too little, too late.  Who let that crap get on stage in the first place? 

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video

Megan's Minute 

 

I updated too but can't blast a way like you
did here. LOL.

I updated at Examiner on that insulting performance which I saw the night of the show.

On my first column I linked back to you here.  Some of the comments on my column were disturbing, not just the defense of the performance by Lil Wayne fans who adopt the typical "If you don't like it don't listen" but that so many of the comments reveal how much our education system may be failing us and the breadth of the cultural chasm.

The Examiner is a broad, possibly more mainstream forum and I sent out an SOS for more people to comment so it didn't appear that people who objected to the "Every Girl" performance were invisible.  I'm grateful to those people who opposed the song and use of young girls for taking the time to comment over there.

It seems the people who found nothing wrong with the overtly sexual lyrics with young girls or who in knee-jerk response defend whatever rappers do are mostly young themselves and think this is just a case of stuffy old people bitching about nothing.  

As a parent, I can't imagine letting a 10-year-old listen to "Every Girl." What the hell is going on with people?

On BET's apology, I don't buy any line that "elements" were uplanned as though the network doesn't know what's going on. If you don't know what is about to be performed on a national awards show, then you need your FCC license yanked. Watching the show was culture shock for me because I don't watch BET regularly and neither one of my offspring are into rap.

Nordette Adams is a BlogHer CE & you can find her other stuff through Her 411.