Bio
I'm crazy in love with the God that made me, and the hot, bald man He gave me. Our family was built through birth and transracial adoption. My kids ar...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Should We Adopt From Haiti? Should We Not? Yes.

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In the weeks since the January 12th earthquake that rocked the island of Haiti, there has been a tremendous increase in adoption inquiries.  As the rest of the world watches, we cannot help but hurt and hope and desperately seek ways to help.  Pictures of orphans and news stories of destruction cause us all to want to grab a passport and come home with as many children possible.

It is normal.

Yet, it is not practical.  At this point in time, it is also not best. 

Haiti's infrastructure is almost impossible for many Americans to comprehend.  There is no public postal system as we know it.  Chief Postal Inspector William R. Gilligan, Jr. of the USPS recently stated: "Members of the Universal Postal Union all are playing a role in rebuilding the Haitian Postal System."  Yet, those who are familiar with Haiti know that means starting with basically nothing.  If you pay for electricity, you are not guaranteed electricity in Haiti.  It comes and goes in no predictable pattern.  Infrastructure helps or hinders adoption.

The children of Haiti need every opportunity to be raised -- in Haiti -- in a safe and healthy home (even if, right now, it is a tent).  Due to the recent catastrophe, it will easily take weeks, possibly months, to locate family of displaced children.  Yet, for the sake of these kids, that must be the main focus at this time.

Just recently, Licia Betor of the Real Hope for Haiti Rescue Center (RHFH) talked about a young boy who had been treated at the US Comfort ship.  International rescue teams pulled him from rubble three days after the quake.  There were nine members of his family living in his home.  He was the only one to survive.  The people at RHFH worked diligently to find more extended family.  They discovered his father was living, but the two had no relationship.  Finally, an uncle was discovered.  "The family has no house to live in, so we will keep him here a while longer to recover. His uncle is working on finding a place for them to live," said Betor.

This boy will remain in his country, with family he knows and with whom he already has a bond.  That must remain the main goal for now as more people are located and more families are reunited.

On the flip side, UNICEF has certainly been at the forefront in the adoption discussion during the past weeks.  I do not agree with UNICEF's hardcore stance against international adoption.  While UNICEF does many things well, they have hurt and hindered children in this area.  In areas of poverty, political unrest and lack of infrastructure, I believe there has to be a balance.  UNICEF does not agree.

In 2008, after excessive pressure from UNICEF, Guatemala agreed to try a very radical approach to their orphan crisis.  Adoptions outside the country were closed and an aggressive campaign began to recruit foster and adoptive homes.  In October of that year, Oscar Avila of the Chicago Tribune wrote a piece on this program titled, "Guatemala Seeks Domestic Fix to Troubled Overseas Adoptions." He reported that the program was not only questionable but appeared to be falling on its face. "Only about 45 families in a nation of 13 million currently have taken in foster children since the program began this year," Avila wrote.

So, should we adopt from Haiti?  Should we not?

Yes. 

For now, we must wait.  For the children and all they deserve, we must wait.  It is okay to be fighting for those already in the process.  Those children have been matched.  Those regulations have already been met.  Yet, for those who just now appear orphaned, we must allow time for their story to be uncovered and their appropriate "forever" to be secured.

When the time does come, I encourage everyone who has an interest to begin to ask a lot of questions and truly learn what it is to raise a child from another race and/or culture.  If you don't love Haiti, you can't love these kids.  So, it's okay to find out and uncover whether or not this is more for you than just a tugging of the heartstrings.  I've had plenty of tugs in my life, but the actual parenting part requires some heavy-gauge wire!

In the meantime, there are some efforts beginning to surface in ways which we can all help children in Haiti by helping families.  Keep your eyes on Heartline Ministries, as they hope to soon be announcing the opportunity to sponsor an entire

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Rusty Hoe 5 pts

The situation in Haiti is not new.  Evrytime a disaster occurs we want to help, we need to help.  Seeing a child in need can make you feel helpless when you are sitting in your living room.  As a mum I know the overwhelming urge to reach through that TV screen to hold those kids and tell them it will be alright.  But if I am to be honest part of that desire is a selfish one.  Whilst I am not against inter-country adoption (and know many families who have done so successfully), I think in many respects the children would be best served in staying in their own country, with their own people and culture.  In the West we are often critical or fail to understand  other countries and their way of life, we tend to undervalue the importance of culture which we cannot despite our best efforts replicate.   Poverty in and of itself is not a reason to remove these kids.  All they have is currently turned upside down which is trauma enough for a life time.  To be removed from what little is left can be another trauma.  Supporting infrastructure, well run and loving orphanages, schooling etc is more beneficial for the child.  

A good example of this can be seen post the Boxing Day Tsunami.  Ache (Indonesia) was one of the worst hit areas.  Thousands of children orphaned.  Yet the call was to keep them within their culture and support them.  Children were reunited with family where possible or were allowed to stay in the orphange and provided with care, schooling etc.  These kids are now heading to highschool and University in some cases.  Displacing the displaced even further would be a shame.

We could adopt these children and 'save' one.  Or we can put our efforts into helping a generation of children find their paths and lives again.

Daniellaland 5 pts

It's sad and frustrating that so many want to jump in and snatch up children in Haiti when we have orphanages (complete with orphans!) right here in this country! 

Why have these people who are ready and able to make room for a child who needs a home not helping the children right here in their own backyard?

Perhaps what's tugging so hard at their hearts is a severe stabbing case of hero syndrome, not heartstrings.

Daniella - http://www.daniellaland.blogspot.com - Free corndog if you fall off of anything.

Houseonahill 5 pts

Christine,

These are such good points. The initial reaction id to scoop everyone up and "save" them.

As you related to us, it is a greater gift if we encourage one another to help make safer, more conducive evironments for the survivors. The children should see those they know and love before being uprooted.

And Shelly makes good points too! Giving donations to reliable sources is key.

We may also listen to our communities. Here in Chicago, some Haitians were airlifted to one of our local shelters before being reunited with their Chi-area  families. They needed all sorts of assistance and we answered.

There will be all types of opportunities to assist, but we must be mindful and make sure we are helping and not hurting.

Houseonahillorg

www.Houseonahillorg.blogspot.com ( http://www.houseonahillorg.blogspot.com/ )

www.HealthierHappierHouseonahill.org ( http://www.HealthierHappierHouseonahill.org )

Shelly Kneupper Tucker 5 pts

Waiting to adopt is good, to make sure it is not just a "tugging of the heartstrings."  And, I agree that the difficulties of raising a child from another culture or another race should be carefully considered.  I also concur that for most of these children it would be best to be raised within their own culture.

For those who want to help right now, we can send donations to the Red Cross or help give shelter so those families can re-claim their children.  You can donate to provide Shelter Boxes (which include a tent that will house 10 people and supplies to help get fresh water).  One place to do that is at Just Giving ( http://www.justgiving.com/Colorado-Bob ), where a blogger named Colorado Bob intended to raise the money for one shelter box and has instead raised the money for 95 (he's shooting for 100, so help if you can --- it's tax deductible, and the donation is a secure on-line payment).

If we can help those children in Haiti grow up in their own country with their own family, it would be a powerful thing.

Shelly Kneupper Tucker

writes at This Eclectic Life ( http://thiseclecticlife.com/ )

Twitter handle: @shellyktucker ( http://twitter.com/shellyktucker )

christinemoers 5 pts

There is one very interesting aspect of post-earthquake Haiti.  Some families may actually find themselves with an opportunity to rebuild in ways which far surpass their means before the quake.  Meaning - some families may be able to reclaim their children (or child relatives) and parent them!   

How amazing will it be if more families in Haiti DO become the best option for these kids?!? WOW!

Christine

www.welcometomybrain.net ( http://www.welcometomybrain.net )

Expat Mum 5 pts

Unfortunately there were already hundreds of children in orphanages who had been taken there by their parents or family members, who were unable to care for them. These children were not in the process of being adopted, mainly because they were no longer babies. It is unlikely they will ever be adopted in Haiti, so better they become part of a loving family elsewhere?