Bio
I am a journalist living in California, and this is my first foray into the virtual world. I worked as a reporter and copy editor for five years in v...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

After the Oscar dust settles...

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I thought I had written my last post on Slumdog Millionaire. Even then, I was apprehensive: some inevitable stories about the lives of the kids back in their slums had started emerging early. The latest to find a place among cable news headlines is about the Oscar-winning movie's youngest, wide-eyed star Rubina Ali's father trying to "sell" her off for $300,000 to undercover reporters posing as a rich middle-east couple eager to adopt the celebrity kid.

81st Academy Awards, 2009

The "news" was a sting operation by British tabloid News of The World. The story was on CNN and on Fox and everywhere else. The tabloid has fought off allegations that this was entrapment and said they had worked on a tip-off that the father was already looking to give up Rubina for a price. So, here's what we have now -- Rubina's father has denied wanting to sell his daughter (he did concede that he had met the fake couple), Rubina stands by her father, her biological mother is back to claim her and insists the girl's dad is evil and has successfully turned the child against her (video of the mother and stepmother slugging it out), the cops have dropped the case, and we have got a peek into an unsavory lifestyle that wouldn't move a fly in India, had it not been for the Oscars.

Father Of Slumdog Actress Rubina Ali Denies Adoption Speculation

A few months back, the other Slumdog star, the youngest Salim, who lives in one of Asia's largest slums, was reported to have been slapped and kicked by his father in front of cameras when he refused to talk to onlookers and passers-by mesmerized by the boy's worldwide fame.

For those familiar with poor education, poverty and life in the slums, this is business as usual. So what changed? Success. Fame. Oscar. Imagine what this can do to a child, to straddle two disparate worlds. To walk the ultimate red carpet one night and sleep on an excuse for a bed the next. With no help to cope emotionally, was this not bound to happen?

And this is not a first. Four years ago, Preeti (or Puja, as she is known in Asia's largest red light district in the eastern Indian city of Kolkata) was in the Kodak theater too, part of the team the picked up the Oscar for best documentary film, Born into Brothels by Zara Briski that documented the lives of children of prostitutes in the red light district of Kolkata.
That was then.
Unlike a couple of other children from the film who are studying in the United States, she has now joined her mother's trade. She says her trade has made her prosperous. But the memories of that night under the arc lights linger on. She says in this Times of India story

 

“It seems like a fairy tale now. I still see it in my dreams. I get goosebumps when I remember the heart-stopping moment when the award was announced. All of us kept screaming with joy. Zana aunty made sure we, too, went along to collect the statuette. My head was swimming, there were so many eyes on us, the deafening applause, so many cameras flashing...”
[...]
“Zana aunty and I are in touch by email. She was upset that I, too, had joined the trade like my mother, something she wanted to save me from. But this trade has really paid off for me.”

Twenty years ago, Mira Nair's path-breaking Oscar-nominated Salaam Bombay! also used kids off Mumbai's streets. One of them even won the President's award for best child artiste. Poverty, not success followed, and the kid had to pick up the pieces and move on. He is now an autorickshaw driver in Bangalore.

It's not that every such success entitles one to lifelong fame and fortune. But as I watched the two Slumdog kids from real slums soak in the L.A. sun and all the glamor that comes with it, I wondered how they planned to bridge this gap mentally and emotionally. It's great that the producers of the film have set aside a tidy sum for their future and have set up a trust to finance their education, but is it just about the money?

"These kids need a counselor, their families need a counselor," I

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
snigdhasen 5 pts

Thanks Lisa! Isn't Sabra's picture on her blog awesome? I wonder if that gets her into any trouble in the deserts.

Yes. I am not sure how much the producers, who live miles away, can do. 

snigdhasen 5 pts

Nordette, thank you for your perspective. This is a curious case
more so because it is international.

No, I don't think holding your dollars back will do anyone any
good because the makers of the film hadn't expected this film to go
anywhere in the first place, leave alone the Oscars. It wasn't
supposed to be a money-spinner. It happened.

In fact, perhaps the reason these children are even getting a shot
at a good education is because it is not a Bollywood
film but a British film with an international (read Western) audience
who have been moved by their poverty and are keeping them in the
limelight.

The Indian audience knows and lives with such poverty every day.
It doesn't move us the same way, unfortunately. There have been
attempts to
redevelop ( http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/dharavi-re... ) one such slum -- home mostly to Mumbai's migrant
laborers -- which are yet to see the light of day.
The general
idea is, I guess, that development will take its own time. So I am
not sure what such a film made for the Western audience is going to
achieve in India. Maybe such worldwide attention will shake people
out of their stupor, I don't know.

But if it pulls a few families out of it, that's great :)

Which is why, I think counseling is far more essential in their
case than promises of money. They need to be able to manage this
success and use it to gradually move out of their circumstances.

The government had promised to get the two kids houses, given the
"glory" they had brought their country. We'll have to wait
and watch if that will really happen.

Meanwhile, the tabloids will continue...

Lisa Stone 6 pts

Sabra from Stilettos in the Sand is a terrific discovery. I really appreciate this post and your expertise Snigdha. I'm still weighing what responsibilities I think the directors and producers may have, but I need to spend some time reading all these links down to the pixel first. Thank you!

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )
Surfette ( http://surfette.typepad.com )

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/politics-news ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Thank you for posting on this. I contemplated writing about this ghastly Dickensesque tale that's missing its happy ending, but decided it was too much to cover for someone who doesn't know enough about Indian culture. You've done a exceptional job with its many pieces. 

I love the movie, but the story of the children's return to conditions that I found horrific in the film has made me relucatant to buy Slumdog on DVD.  Then I wonder is withholding my money helping the children or hurting them if part of the money's going to them. But I get the feeling beyond an education fund, these children are not going to benefit from the striking success of this movie financially.  I wonder whether Bollywood is only making producers wealthy while others involved in the industry struggle due to inadequate legal representation.

The only silver lining I see is that the children's plight has directed more attention on the Mumbai slums and India's poor and perhaps that will encourage people around the world to work harder to crack poverty.  I just don't know. It's a disturbing string of events. 

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ): BlogHer CE and NOLA Lit Examiner ( http://nola101.com ). Blogs @ WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ) & UMBOP ( http://urbanpsalms.blogspot.com ).