Bio
I'm the BlogHer Contributing Editor on parenting children with special needs, and I'm at your service.  I am more than a parent, but with three...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Alleged Special Ed Abuse and the Court of Public Opinion

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 17
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I already had a spitfire six-year-old daughter and a boisterous four-year-old autistic son when my youngest, Mali, was born. Though I had scoffed at family and friends who suggested enlisting extra hands when our herd expanded, it was soon clear that I could really use some backup. That was when Alexia Bogdis entered our lives. She became one of Leo's best friends. She worked with him for almost three years -- his most difficult years. She brought our home life out of crisis -- like a Mary Poppins, but for an autism family.

New Preschool ClassYou may wonder why I'm using Alexia's real name, instead of protecting her privacy with "Therapist X" or "Babysitter X" as is my usual blogging practice for the many people who have worked with Leo. But Alexia no longer has the privilege of privacy -- last week, she was charged with mistreating children in our school district's early intervention preschool.

While it was shocking to hear about the charges, I understand completely why the matter proceeded as it has. Our children's safety should always be our top priority, and if classroom abuse is reported, what happened to Alexia is the procedure that must and should be followed. We cannot knowingly expose our children to risk.

We can, however, remain aware that allegations are not verdicts -- as difficult as maintaining that awareness is, especially when headline writers are forced to prioritize sensationalism over fairness, and when mugshots of people who have yet to see their day in court are nevertheless made available to news services. Alexia's story spread at near-viral speed from Internet news services to the special needs email lists and blogs in my communities.

I spoke up about the difference between allegations and verdicts whenever the story hit my inbox or my screen, and some folks appreciated the reminder. I did not speculate about the charges -- nor will I here -- because I did not visit the class during the time frame in question, and I have not spoken with Alexia about the allegations. This is a legal matter now, so I can only comment on that which I have personally observed.

But I can vouch for her character. And here's what I've personally witnessed, and documented: Every one of my friends and family members is as shocked by the allegations as I am. We have known Alexia for seven years; we know she is the sort of person who literally gives others the shirt off her back. We've seen her set aside her own vacations and weekends to accompany Leo to events and on family trips that would otherwise be un-doable. We know she was there for him when he struggled with self-care hiccups. When he was trying so hard to make sense of the world and sometimes just couldn't, despite his and all our best efforts -- and kept lashing out at it, and us, instead.

I can also tell you that the allegations are now affecting more than just Alexia and her class. Due to national and state child welfare regulations regarding Mandated Reporters -- people within the district who are legally obligated to report child abuse -- several other special ed department folks have been placed on administrative leave. They will stay there until it is determined what exactly happened and whether or not said people had any awareness of Alexia's alleged incidences. These are good people who serve critical roles, and we have to remember that their being placed on leave is a matter of procedure -- again, to do everything possible to protect students -- rather than evidence of wrongdoing. Those administrative leave changes have the potential to disrupt learning, IEP, placements, and classroom for every child who receives special education services from our districts, which leaves me even more upset: those changes could possibly circle around and affect Leo.

  • 17
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Mrs.Wiljc3 6 pts

I agree with the general idea of your post, but just because you know this woman personally doesn't mean she is isn't capable of committing a crime. I worked with a woman once in a group home for adults with developmental disabilities. She was an amazing individual who the residents adored. A few years later she left our organization and went to work for a different one. She was caught on camera beating a non-verbal resident senseless. I was so shocked that I cried for days. It just didn't seem possible, but there was no denying what happened. She was tried and convicted. Working with people who have special needs is very difficult and highly stressful. It can get to the kindest and most gentle of people, trust me. Good people get burned out or lose their cool and make awful decisions that hurt the people they are supposed to serve. I can understand your desire to not to jump to conclusions, but it could still be that she is truly guilty.

SunbonnetSmart.com 2511 pts

Writing this post and offering character analysis on any of the parties involved negates your assertion that the case should be tried by the legal system, not by public opinion.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 10 pts

You misunderstand. I think it's wrong that cases like this get tried in the court of public opinion -- but they do anyhow. So I wrote this essay to provide the balance that the media has not.

SunbonnetSmart.com 2511 pts

 Shannon Des Roches Rosa Oh...OK

The facts are simple to understand. You are passing judgment in the court of public opinion rather than letting the judicial system handle it.

AutismAdvocate 5 pts

There were 6 teachers aides that got fired for not reporting this, and a few others that provided evidence. There is a child in the hospital for a health problem related to the accusation. In my book, that is really really convincing. What do you think folks? 

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 10 pts

 AutismAdvocate "What do you think folks" is exactly the problem I described, as is bringing in unsubstantiated accusations of child hospitalizations (if anyone is hospitalized, my heart goes out to them -- but it's up for the investigators and court to decide about causation, not us). Everyone who could possibly have contributed to the alleged harm has been put on leave until the investigation is over, with the goal of protecting the kids first and foremost. That is not evidence of guilt, that is procedure. Unless you were personally involved (in which case you would be under orders not to discuss the case), you, like the rest of us, will have to await the formal verdict. Again, our legal system's foundation is "innocent until proven guilty," difficult as that is to remember in extremely emotional cases like this.

Here is the just-released school district statement regarding the affair: http://www.rcsdk8.net/site/default.aspx?PageType=3&ModuleInstanceID=1524&ViewID=047E6BE3-6D87-4130-8424-D8E4E9ED6C2A&RenderLoc=0&FlexDataID=4140&PageID=1

AutismAdvocate 5 pts

 Shannon Des Roches Rosa

 I dont know Shannon. Children that cannot defend themselves, and at least 6 people that provided enough information to be given "disciplinary action" speaks volumes to me. This teacher, guilty or not, is not the issue here. The issue here is WHY this has to even be a concern. Put yourself in one of those parent's shoes Shannon. Would you be advocating so favorably if your child was in this classroom during that timeframe? I think we ALL need to keep our mouths shut nd wait for the verdict.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 10 pts

 AutismAdvocate "I don't know." That is the point. None of us know. We weren't there. We can only comment on what we *do* know. So asking me to put myself in the parents' shoes is not only irrelevant, but offensive as it implies a lack of compassion on my part.I know Alexia's character, which is what I have commented on here. With my full name, I might add.

 

I am also not commenting on anyone's guilt or innocence. However Alexia pleaded "Not Guilty" today, btw, saying "I have never abused a child, and I can't believe this is happening. I have nothing else to say."  Full article at:http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2012/03/01/BATH1NER4Q.DTL

Cooking Contest Reject 23 pts

I don't know if you know who Alexia's accusers are, but perhaps it would be worth it to find out so you could take their character into account and, you know, "consider the source." Sometimes that speaks volumes.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 10 pts

 Cooking Contest Reject "Considering the source" is another version of the court of public opinion, much as I get what you're saying and why you're saying it.

Valerie Strohl 6 pts

I hate to see this. Especially, when sometimes special education teachers need to use different behaviors which may look very bad from the outside. I hope this turns out well for all.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 10 pts

 Valerie Strohl That is true. The district behaviorist, who helped train Alexia, uses ABA approaches and techniques -- not the horrible, aversives-using Lovaas style, but the gently-motivating contemporary style. I could see how they could be misinterpreted, as in "first X, then X" setting off a child's meltdown. And as we are talking about a preschool class, it may be the very first therapeutic setting many of the children experienced, the first time they have had structured demands placed upon them.

simplyjune 34 pts

Thank you for posting this story. The problem with being charged with abuse of a child, is that as a society we cant risk the safety of our children so until it is proven otherwise we would rather be safe than sorry. What really makes me mad is the people out there who falsely claim and point the finger at another person, knowing full well it is a lie. They give legitimate victims everywhere a bigger load to carry.
I have two family members who, in the midst of a divorce, decided to falsely accuse the father of sexual abuse just to be mean, spiteful and to get full custody of the children. It was a horrific thing to do. Most of the family didn’t believe the allegations. Five years later we all heard the truth straight from the horse’s mouth. She said she felt remorse. She said she was pressured into lying. She showed her true character years later when she was in trouble with the law, claiming she wasn't in her right mind because she had been abused by her father. It was unbelievable. I'm so glad we all supported her father then, and years later. Bravo for doing the same.

Cheney 14 pts

It's a shame that even though "innocent until proven guilty" is supposed to be the way of things, they often aren't when the media gets their hands on them.

Good for you - be proud.

jennyalice 8 pts

Thanks for publicly backing up Alexia. I have always been against mugshots in breaking news stories, and it hits home this time.

wordsandmusic365 19 pts

I too am the mother of a son with autism and I applaud you for having to courage to vouch for Alexia. When my son was younger, I had the experience of complete strangers bolting up to me while I was trying to buckle my son into a car seat during a total behavioral meltdown and asking "JUST WHAT'S GOING ON HERE?" And many times, what's going on is that you are trying to keep yourself and your child safe using whatever dumb idea you can think of to get through the day with some grace (and a ton of love, because that's what it takes). Love your story!

mamabegood 6 pts

I love that you are courageous enough to speak up for the person you know instead of wallowing in the gossip that usually goes along with these kinds of things. Brava, woman.