Blog
Mom-101
Bio
Liz Gumbinner is a contributing editor to BlogHer Style but can also be found creeping around the political and parenting posts. She's the publisher...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Eco, natural and organic cosmetics - are they really eco, natural or organic?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

As the world goes greener (or at least talks a whole heck of a lot about going greener) I've started seeing a new infiltration of eco-cosmetic pitches in my overflowing inbox at Cool Mom Picks. There are organic moisturizers, all-natural eye shadows, cruelty-free cosmetics brushes. It almost seems that the only folks doing the same old skeery petrochemical formulations are the established mass drugstore brands. And even they're starting to get with the consumer demand. Why do you think Clorox bought Burt's Bees? Ahem.

I know it makes me feel better to know that no innocent rabbits or kitties or streams or scenic hillsides were hurt in an effort to give me vampy lashes or pouty lips but it's more than that. 

The skin easily absorbs the toxins of the world which can then build up in your organs. So when there are parabens in your bubble bath or petrochemicals in your
deodorant, they may not just stay on your skin.

I think what's difficult for consumers however is that there are all sorts of misleading "pure" and "natural" claims out there that aren't. Let's just say that that totally organic experience shampoo isn't actually totally organic (shocker!) and it probably passed legal because it was the "experience" they claimed was organic. Or something. Lots of so-called natural shampoos and soaps contain sodium lauryl sulfate which is the source of some controversy. In fact, evidently as much as 76% of eco-labeing is innacurate according to a TerraChoice survey, although that's better than the 86% it was two years ago.

Part of the problem is, there's no US standard for "natural" so you have to
do a
bit of work to figure out who's legit and who's not. One thing that helps, is looking for a respectable certification label, like:

-NaTrue

-Natural Products Association

-Germany's BDIH certification

-EU Eco regulations

-Europe's EcoCert

-Voluntary signatories to Campaign for Safe Cosmetics 

Each has its own logo, its own standards and its own governing board, so when you see it on a package you can feel pretty confident that you know what you're getting. You can also check the Environmental Working Group's cosmetic safety database which I previously covered here.

How about you? Do you buy the whole natural/organic is better line? Any products you thought were all natural and fabulous that turned out not to be?

[image: Cargo natural cosmetics]

 

Liz Gumbinner is the publisher and editor-in-chief of the shopping blog Cool Mom Picks, the author of Mom-101, and a contributing editor to BlogHer BeautyHacks

  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
HipMom 5 pts

I never heard of Eminence, I will definitely check it out! Korres is not completely natural, it's more botanic-based, but I've heard great things about them! I've only tried their soaps and realy liked them. Weleda is fantastic. It's a little too heavy for me normally, because I have oil-prone skin - but their products are really good. I use the Weleda diaper lotion exclusively, have been for years now, it's really good. And in a pinch, it'll work great to soften rough patches on elbows, too ;-)

Another really great European natural brand is Lavera, check it out, their makeup is pretty good too.

One that really kind of bothers me is Juice Beauty - they call themselves natural and even organic, but their products contain synthatic ingredients, some of them quite controversial. Unfortunately there are a few like that.

Mom101 5 pts

Recently, I've been into Eminence, Korres and Weleda. But thanks for all these suggestions -I'm excited to check them out now!

Personally I'm trying to figure out to what degree so-called natural cosmetics are better for us versus just better for the enironment. Either way, it's something I don't mind spending a little more money on provided they work well. 

Mom-101 ( http://mom-101.blogspot.com )
( http://coolmompicks.com )

Cool Mom Picks.com ( http://coolmompicks.com )

HipMom 5 pts

Excellent intro to natural cosmetics for newbies, Liz! Lots of great info.

I have hardly any "conventional" makeup/beauty items. I use Pangea Organics and John Masters Organics for face creams, cleansers and toners; Gabriel for foundation and concealer (free of synthetic ingredients); Alima Pure mineral makeup for blushes, eyeshadows and powder eyeliners and Jane Iredale for lipglosses. I have to admit I haven't found a natural macara I like yet, so I still use conventional ones, and I have a weakness for lipgloss so I do own a couple that aren't natural nor organic, namely Lancome Juicy Tubes and Bare Escentuals Buxom Lips.

I firmly believe thatthe amount of synthetic ingredients in the products we put on our skin influences us just as much as the ones we consume in food, drinks, etc - so I think healthy eating is not enough, "health" is a lifestyle thing, everything should fall in. Any effort in that direction is better than none at all, IMO.

Mom101 5 pts

Thanks so much for that fact Ron. I've done some consulting for an organic skin care company and discovered that indeed, there's a perception that something "natural" might not perform as well. It's funny that somehow chemical = effective, especially with so many amazing brands out there (some of which have been around for decades, as a testament to their efficacy) that do offer all-natural formulations. 

I look forward to spending some time on your site.

Mom-101 ( http://mom-101.blogspot.com )
( http://coolmompicks.com )

Cool Mom Picks.com ( http://coolmompicks.com )

Ron Robinson 5 pts

Hi Liz,

This subject has come up quite a bit on my website, BeautyStat.com.  We have surveyed hundreds of women and they have told us that although they like the fact that products are now offered in natural or organic varieties, first and foremost they want their beauty products to perform. 

However if their favorite product was offered in a natural, organic or eco-friendly formula, they would be willing to pay slightly more for it.

Thanks for posting this article.

Ron Robinson, Cosmetic Chemist, Founder http://www.beautystat.com