Bio
Kalyn Denny is a former third grade teacher from Salt Lake City, Utah, who discovered blogging when she wanted a place to share her recipes online....
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Are Fresh Fava Beans Worth the Effort?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Every spring fresh fava beans burst on to the culinary scene. They appear in markets and gardens, and of course food bloggers start writing about what they're making with favas. Interesting that favas would get so much attention, when by all accounts, they're fairly labor intensive to remove from the pods. Are they worth the trouble?

Unfortunately, I can't say from personal experience. The one time I scored some fresh fava beans while on vacation and was planning to try my luck at shucking them, I ended up leaving them in a hotel refrigerator. I'm not sure if they don't grow well in Utah or I just miss them, but I've never seen any for sale here. I don't know if I would have decided favas were worth the trouble, but every spring I start wondering about them again.

Some People Are Definitely Fava Fans:

Photobucket
Photo of Fresh Fava Beans from Hunter Gardener Angler Cook,

One blogger who definitely thinks favas are worth the trouble is Hank from Hunger Gardener Angler Cook, who says "Favas are my labor's love." His post on Fresh Fava Beans has good information on growing and shucking them, and his Fresh Fava Bean Spread sounds like a great way to use them.

Michelle from Bleeding Espresso makes Calabrian Sausage and Fava Beans and although she says "you have to *really* want to eat favas to go through the work involved" she ends up concluding "They are worth it, I promise."

Photobucket
Photo of Fresh Fava Bean Salad from Cookbook Catchall.

Sabra from Cookbook Catchall is also a fan and turns her fresh favas into the delicious-looking Fresh Fava Bean Salad you see above. She says "They are a bit of a pain to shell, but it’s a mindless task and well worth the effort to uncover the glossy green gems."

Stephanie from Scrumptious Street raves about how much she likes the Fava Bean and Tomato Salad she makes and says " . . it's worth the work with the beans."

Photobucket
Photo of Fava Beans, Watermelon Radish, and Halibut from Ms. Glaze's Pommes d' Amour.

When she makes Fava Beans, Watermelon Radish, and Halibut with Buerre Blanc Sauce, Ms. Glaze says "Fava beans are worth it. And I look forward to them every summer."

At Food Blogga, Susan has nice photos to show the process of shucking the favas and says ". . . trust me, they're worth it." I think you'll believe her when you see the Fava Bean and Dill Crostini she made with her beans.

Umami Girl calls it The Year of Magical Beans and enrolls the whole family to shuck when she gets a lot of fava beans in her CSA box, and says ". . . favas continue to seduce me with their simple, earthy charms." This post has a recipe for Alice Waters Fava Bean Puree that looks just delicious.

However, Not everyone is convinced:

When Marisa tries out fresh favas and writes An Introduction to the world of Fava Beans at Slashfood, she says, "I enjoyed them, but I'm not sure they were worth the work it required to get down to the edible part of the vegetable."

At Exploring the Silver Spoon, Sara makes Fresh Fava Bean Puree and finds the process of peeling them is so labor intensive that she decides "I think it'd be difficult for a fava bean recipe to ever get a really high grade here due to all the shelling and peeling."

More About Fava Beans:
How to Shell Fava Beans by Molly Watson at About.com
Fresh Fava Beans are a Delicious Sign of Spring at BlogHer

Have you tried fresh fava beans, and if so, did you think they were worth the effort? Please let us know your fava bean experiences in the comments, and if you have a good recipe for fresh fava beans, do share!

Kalyn Denny shares her passion for low-glycemic cooking at Kalyn's Kitchen where she's still hoping to try fresh fava beans, but is making salads with edamame in the meantime.

  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
HomeRearedChef 3397 pts

OH, but if I may, please, fava beans are most certainly worth my trouble of shucking them.  :)    You've just reminded me that I need to head out to the store and get me a box full (which I have been known to do). My husband and I LOVE fava beans, and don't mind shelling them.

 

We learned to eat them from an old Sicilian couple, way back when. They served them simply with good fresh pasta tossed with a little garlic and extra-virgin olive oil. I am drooling just thinking about it. I will make them soon, take pictures, and post my semi-altered recipe here on BlogHer.

 

Thank you for the inspiration, Kalyn, I am so very glad I found your post here today!

~Virginia

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

I still have not tried them myself, and would like to try it once.  (But I'm guessing I might agree that they are not worth the trouble.)

jencote316 5 pts

OK, after another newspaper article waxed poetic, I thought: "Fine! I'll go for it!" Spent the morning shelling and husking, first the outer layer, then the inner... Yes, the yield was paltry returns for my labor. AND, no, I didn't think they were worth it! My mom has always raved about them... I suppose that, as in any labor of love, if you know how much work someone went to, you might slow down and pay attention to what you're eating, and perhaps especially appreciate the efforts gone to.

But I didn't! (I just thought, "Well, there's an hour of my life I'll never get back". Ha.)

However, if you serve them to me, I WILL appreciate that you took the time. Because I'm not going to!

Still, after all that, I might grow some fava beans in the garden. They certainly add much fodder for composting, and... who knows, if I can't get to the grocery store... those beans just might seem more valuable!

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

Thanks for the feedback! I haven't had lupini beans either; not even sure I know what they are?

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

Ricki 5 pts

http://dietdessertdogs.com ( http://dietdessertdogs.wordpress.com/ )

We once received a bag of fresh favas in our organic box and while I do remember them tasting good, I'm not sure I thought they were worth all the work.  I'm in the process (and it's a two-week process!) of making lupini beans for the first time--we'll see if they live up to their reputation as well!

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

Although I'm in the middle of massive house renovations, so mail ordering favas might not be in the budget right now!

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

I tried the dried ones once, but they must not have been skinless, and I realized I didn't really know what to do with them. Will definitely keep looking.

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

Judith in Umbria 5 pts

Although it's true that I get them so fresh they don't need peeling, just shelling, the flavor when simmered a few minutes and then dressed with a bit of oil and salt... irreplaceable!  Frozen ones are OK in the way that frozen peas are OK, or better than what you can actually buy fresh at times.

Also astounding are skinless dried favas in winter.  Just chop onion, celery and carrot, salt it and add water to simmer a few minues, then cook the dried favas until soft.  Puree them, garnsigh with a thread of great oil and maybe some strips of fried red pepper.  This is a great Pugliese antipasto.

 http://www.judithgreenwood.com/thinkonit/

CherylDLee 5 pts

You may be able to order from Melissa's produce and have then delivered directly.

http://www.melissas.com/Products/Products/Fava-Beans.aspx

Good luck!

Cheryl D Lee

http://blackgirlchefswhites.wordpress.com

http://tinyurl.com/ LAcookingexaminer

http://www.culinoir.com

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

I'm not sure why I don't seem to find them, but I keep hoping to come across some.

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

CherylDLee 5 pts

Yes they are labor intensive, but they are so worth it.   Their flavor is like no other, and tossed with some butter, olive oil, pasta and shaved parmesan makes a lovely spring side dish. 

The key to shucking them is to sit in front of the TV, and shuck away while you watch some inane show.  Then blanch for a few minutes, and my trick is to make a small cut in the membrane and the beans slide right out.

If you can find them, please try them.   Try a local farmers market or Whole Foods.

It will be worth it, I promise.  (But don't get mad at me if you don't like them)  LOL

Cheryl D Lee

http://blackgirlchefswhites.wordpress.com

http://tinyurl.com/ LAcookingexaminer

http://www.culinoir.com

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

I admit, before I wrote about them a few times I always thought of that quote too. Now I'm just anxious to see what all the fuss is about.

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

Cookin Canuck 6 pts

I hate to admit it, but the first thing I think of when I hear "fava beans" is Hector "The cannibal" Lector waxing on about eating liver with fava beans and chianti.  Chills down the spine!

That being said, I have always heard that fava beans are a wonderful treat - and yet I have never tried them.  So Kalyn, maybe you have inspired me to do so. 

Cookin Canuck

http://cookincanuck.blogspot.com 

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

I'd love to come to your house and try shucking the favas, and eating them of course!

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

Christine Cooks 5 pts

Hi Kalyn,

I grow fava beans every year. Yes, they're labor intensive and, yes, the resulting end product is not near as huge as what you begin with, but fresh favas out of the garden and into a recipe of your own making cannot be beat, in my humble opinion.

It's not the shelling that's the intensive part.  After shelling you must blanch them then peel those bright green babies out of their protective membrane.  Five pounds of favas in the shell can yield as little as one pound of bright green beans.

 Still, if you have the time to spend, they're worth it.  They are easily grown, planted in the fall and allowed to winter over. We got heavy frost and snow this winter and still the favas made it through and are now blooming.

Come on out, I'll show you!  :)

Christine

FlourOnMyFace 5 pts

Arlene

I don't think I have ever eaten them. If the flavor was so exceptional then they might be worth all the trouble. And before long someone will come up with a gaget to make shelling them easier.

Kalyn Denny 14 pts

I guess I feel a bit less fava-deprived finding out there are so many others who haven't tried them, but I still really want to try them them myself!

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

mthomas2185 5 pts

I didn't realize they were so bright green! And I've never actually seen them listed in a recipe before. I'll be on the look out for them though, now that I've read this.

forkspoonnknife 5 pts

What gorgeous photos.. they almost convince you that all that peeling is worth it.. personally, I haven't tried it.. but I remeber my mum peeling fresh peas when they are in season and remember that they were way too much effort for the taste...frozen peas are just as good :) I guess this is the same..

FSK

Fork Spoon Knife - What's on the menu today?

http://forkspoonnknife.blogspot.com/

MrsWsKitchen 5 pts

This is not something that seems to be available in my area, either.  I'd be curious to try them, but they do seem so labor intensive.

Amanda
Mrs.W's Kitchen ( http://mrswskitchen.blogspot.com )