About
This BlogHer Spotlight was picked by the editor as a post you'd love to read. Learn more about the BlogHer Spotlight program.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Avoiding Default to Irate: How Do You Handle Nosy Questions About Your Family?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

How many of you have been asked an inappropriate question about your family? You know the kind; those questions that poke the soft spot in your psyche and make you see some shade of red. My most sensitive questions are about the open adoption we have with my daughter and her family. I try not to default to irate in my responses because I know people are genuinely interested, just uneducated. Harriett at See Theo Run recently wrote about the questions she gets regarding her son and his skin color.

It's easy to point out families that "don't match" or comment on a larger family's number of children. Each family, whether they match or not, has a question they've heard umpteen thousand times that works that very last nerve. What I love about Harriett's post is how she says she might not be able to control the questions, but she can control her answer. She's a smart one!

She starts out explaining why her family stands out in a crowd:

Mom and SonIt’s easy to get caught up in a “default to irate” mindset when you stand out as a transracial adoptive family: the looks, the comments, the fact that on a crowded playground no one can immediately identify me as my son’s mother, that people insist on asking where my son is really from when I say he was born here, that it’s fair game to run their hands through his hair.

We do stand out but we’re not the only people who face invasive questions. My friend is a tall, lean, angular woman with a long nose, almond eyes, and the olive skin of her Iraqi roots. Her husband, a tall, stockier WASP, managed to send all of his features along to his daughters. The result is a pair of identical twin girls with blond ringlets, large blue eyes and pale skin. Their mother says that people stop, look at her and speak very slowly so she can understand them as they assume she is the nanny. And then comes the “double trouble” comments (guilty as charged!), the “Who is older” remarks, and so it goes.

She asks how you handle invasive (and/or inappropriate) questions. How do you handle them?

Read more from Standing Out in a Crowd at See Theo Run

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Grace Hwang Lynch 21 pts

I think it depends on whether the person asking the question is genuinely curious or just being nosy/judgmental. It's soo common among mixed-race families to get these questions. Sometimes my family will be out somewhere with another Hapa family, sometimes it just the two moms, or some other combination, and I can just see the wheels turning inside people's heads because they're wondering who goes with who.

idyllicchick 5 pts

I recently added an adoption themed tattoo to my wrist in order to *encourage* questions! When I truly realized how many incorrect assumptions are made about adoption I decided that I could help dissuade some myths one person at a time by answering truthfully when someone asks about my tattoo. The more we talk about our non-traditional families, the less non-traditional they will become.

Denise 114 pts moderator

idyllicchick You are awesome.

radar5 5 pts

How do I handle it? I smile and nod.

As the mother of three interracial children I've experienced many assumptive and nosy strangers who have questions about my family. It's really better for my blood pressure if I don't engage.

Conversation from Facebook

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

Corey, I never thought to do that before (I'm not in the same exact situation but we all get a moment where someone gets nosey with their questions) and this is a great reply!

Leslie Whitney
Leslie Whitney

Rudeness is never good. But I think some people are too sensitive to other peoples questions. People are curious, why is that so bad? Yes it's "non of their business" , but if we went by that rule, we wouldn't have small talk or ice-breakers or getting to know someone. I think it shows some of your own insecurity if you are bothered by others questions. Be proud of your situation and answer with confidence. Chances are, you are educating the other person when it comes to adoption or inter-racial relationships or whatever the case may be.

Zulmara Maria Teixeira de Lima
Zulmara Maria Teixeira de Lima

Yeah...some people's ignorance just has no response that does it justice and walking away is the only option...

Anita Williams Weinberg
Anita Williams Weinberg

A woman came up to me in the grocery store and pointed at my daughter, who is Chinese, and demanded, "What's she mixed with?" I responded, "She's not a cocktail," and walked away. Another time an elderly woman shouted at me across a crowded grocery store, "Oh, your husband must be. . ."eastern." I replied just as loudly that I wasn't married, and didn't actually know much about her dad. She looked very uncomfortable and slunk away.

My other daughter is African-American, and another time when I had both of them with me, I was asked if I was the nanny.

Tiffiny Harmer Felix
Tiffiny Harmer Felix

I have a 15 year old daughter. And my husband and I just celebrated our 10th wedding anniversary. It doesn't happen as much anymore, but for several years after we married I would get "looks" or questions about the discrepancy. I would feel obligated to quickly explain that Don was my second husband...that my daughter's dad left us when she was 3 1/2...blah, blah, blah. Then one day I was telling a friend about the whole deal. Her husband, who was sitting nearby, looked up and said, "Why do you say anything? Why is it any of their business?" I remember feeling startled at first, and then I realized that he was right. It isn't any of their business, whether she was from a previous marriage or if she was born out of wedlock. So now I just ignore the looks, and redirect what few actual questions I get.

Corrie Beebe
Corrie Beebe

I think it was Dear Abby or Ann Landers or someone who had the suggestion of responding to any inappropriate question with a very simple "why do you ask?" or "why do you want to know?" Not asked snottily, but simply. That puts the ball in the other person's court and all but the most obtuse will understand they have breached etiquette and stop asking.