Bio
Learn more about me or just visit my personal blog or come bargain hunt with me. Writing? Check. Parenting? Check. Shopping for shoes? Check. Yep,...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

No Man's Land: Too Old for a Sitter, Too Young to Be Left Alone

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Once upon a time I was one of the world's greatest babysitters. I don't brag often, but this is true: Kids and parents alike clamored for my services. I worked every weekend and even various weeknights, and when I bought my first car, I paid for it with babysitting money.

My best clients paid me $3/hour, which at the time seemed like a lot of money. (It's okay; go ahead and laugh. I do, now.)

Even funnier? I began my career at age 11, and was in regular demand by the time I was 12. My daughter is turning 12 in a couple of weeks, and as much as I love her, I'm not sure I'd entrust her with a house plant, much less a child or two.

As a single mother in New England, I knew that friends of mine were paying college students $8/hour and up to watch their kids. I smugly snared a neighbor when she was still in middle school; at $5/hour, I was paying her above what anyone else was offering, but still paying less than I'd have to pay someone older. And I always said I love to "raise my own" sitters -- she worked for us for years, her parents were right next door in case of any problems, and the kids loved her. As an added bonus, the fact that she could walk over meant I didn't have to figure out the logistics of taking her home when there wasn't a second parent to stay with the kids. I allowed myself one night out each week (for choir practice) and she served us well. Moving away from a longtime, reliable sitter was hard.

Once we came to Georgia, suddenly I had a second parent to help with the kids. That meant that if I had a meeting or something, most likely my husband could ride herd and we didn't even need a sitter. Imagine! Of course eventually we realized we might enjoy an evening out without the children, and then I tried my standard raise-my-own maneuver and found a reliable middle schooler to come sit for us. Well. That was pretty much a disaster.

See, I'd forgotten that the last time I'd hired a middle schooler, my older child was only five. This time, I hired a twelve-year-old when my oldest was nine. Let me rephrase: I hired a sitter only a few years older than my oldest child, who was still mourning the loss of her old babysitter (and friends and home). I feel like it was kind of an impossible situation I put our poor sitter in, and I'm sorry I wasn't a little smarter about that.

Since then, we've gone out very little. For a couple of events we've hired a college student at $10+/hour, but even though I can afford that, now, the cost makes me cringe. Particularly when we're talking about someone sitting on the couch watching television while the kids are sleeping. The bigger problem for me, now, is that my daughter is in that age range where she really, honestly, is too old for a sitter. Twelve-year-olds do not require a babysitter! But my son -- still a very young ten-year-old -- does. And while I trust my daughter alone, I do not trust her not to torment her brother. And quite frankly, I don't trust either of them not to stay up watching Teen Nick if we were to leave them alone at night.

So my dilemma is that I'm stuck in the no-man's-land of too-old-for-a-sitter, too-young-to-be-alone. And the end result is that we just don't go out except when the kids go visit their dad. (Which is rather pitiful.)

Others are perfectly okay with paying for a sitter, but are struggling with the cost. Lynn at TurtleHead has always assumed she was the greatest babysitting client around, but has recently discovered that the going rate is several dollars above what she's been paying. What to do?

Genevieve Theirs shares tips on what to pay your sitter over at Adventures in Babysitting and suggests that $10/hour may in fact be low in some areas (eek).

And as for where it's okay to leave kids alone when, check out the dozens of angry responses to Lenore Skenazy's article on ParentDish where she talks about a mother leaving her 5-year-old alone in the children's room at the library for just a few minutes. Wow.

I'm curious: What are you paying for babysitters? And how old was your child or were your children

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Tes Solomon Silverman 10 pts

When Shaina was 3 or 4, like you, I trained my sitter, who back then was a junior in high school and paying her whether we used her or not. That way, she couldn't sit for any one else. I paid her $6/hr and that was pretty good I thought. Flash forward to now than Shaina's twelve, I, too have the same dilemma since she thinks it's ok for us to leave her home, but I still feel that she should be with an adult for a few hours, especially at night. So I've resolved to paying my sitter $10/hr for 3 hrs max. That way, my husband and I can still go out and I feel comfortable leaving her with a twenty-three year old. We don;t go out that often, but we do try to have adult time once in a while. Hope this helps.

thebeanblog 5 pts

Wow! $10 an hour for babysitting? How many kids? I had no idea it's gotten so expensive. I can't really help you out on what a reasonable amount to pay a sitter is. I pay our teenager (he's 15, almost 16) to babysit his siblings when my husband and I go out for date nights. I pay him $5 an hour to watch his 3 siblings (ages 8, 10 1/2, 10 1/2). I think that's more than enough considering he barely ever steps away from his computer or comes out of his room while he's "babysitting," although he does make sure they eat and yells at them to go to bed before midnight. He's been babysitting for us for the last 2 to 3 years. In the last several months I've started to leave the other kids home alone in small doses. I started by leaving them alone while I took a quick trip to the store for milk (10 mins top) and now I've let them stay home for about an hour after school 2-3 days a week since my oldest now has soccer practice after school. What has really surprised me is they seem to act more mature when I leave them home alone. They take the responsibility very serious, like they need to prove to me that they are capable of doing this and I no longer need to treat them like a baby. It's been a good learning experience for all of us.

Christine
The Bean Blog ( http://www.thebeanblog.com )

tisfortiger 5 pts

I have an 18 year old (whom I do not let babysit her 12 year old sister due to the both of them fighting all the time) My 18 year old has two steady babysitting jobs. One is for a 6&8 year old. They pay $12 dollars an hour. The other is for a 1&2 year old, they only pay $9 an hour. If you ask me it should be the other way around. The younger the children (ones with diapers and short attention spans) should pay more.

As for when its okay to leave your kids alone. My neighbor leaves her 10 & 12 year olds home all the time. Date night with husband ect... I personally have never left my 12 year old home alone. When my oldest was younger, I left her alone for the first time at 13. But that was only for 45 minutes. It wasn't until she was 16 that I left her alone for more than a couple of hours. I know I'm a little overprotective, but in todays world, I trust no one !!!

JennaHatfield 249 pts

Our babysitter graduates high school this year. The only other teen who is of age to drive (necessary for where we live) doesn't have a driver's license and I don't want to inconvenience her parents. (We need a sitter every third week on my rehearsal night and occasionally for a conflict of newspaper/fire dept.) I have NO idea what we're going to do in the fall. :(

@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom ) from Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and
The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com )

mcwhclan 5 pts

As my kids got older I was more and more excited about them being able to stay home alone. But the reality is, my 15 year old daughter can't do it. I still can't leave her alone. Even with the locks on the pantry, and our bedroom door she gets into trouble. She takes our stuff, tortures her 12 year old brother, phones and harasses other kids, and that is the stuff we know about. My daughter has ODD and ADD. And we can't leave her alone in the house, in fact I have taken a leave of absence from work so that I can be around when she is.

There are families out there for whom a babysitter is just never an option, we are lucky because we have my parents who help out tremendously and watch our kids for us.

Sitters... ha, my daughter ate them alive...