Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Balance Is a Big, Fat, Lying Liar Lie for (Especially) Working Parents

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

As we grow closer to the end of 2008 and the all important Season of Resolutions, let's talk about balance, baby. Or perhaps what a big, fat lie it is for the ambitious working parent.

I'm not saying that's entirely a bad thing. Let's just not delude ourselves. You can bring home the bacon and fry it up in a pan and never, never, never let him forget he's a man, but your kids will go to school in their underwear, your relatives will get their Christmas gifts in June and your best friend will replace you with a cat. Yeah, you, who hasn't called her in six months. You know I'm talking to you.

Why is this balance bag so hard? When we think balance, we tend to think of an equally weighted scale, and that, my friends, is not how life works. Take for instance, the executive moms. We're still questioning if they can even have families.

Journalist and blogger Eve Tahmincioglu writes:

When I did a profile of a major health insurance company in Philadelphia a while back I was given access to all the top woman at the firm. The reason I decided to write about this particular company for a magazine was because so many women were in the corner offices. One question I asked, and I ask this of men and women in top positions all the time, was if they had children. To my chagrin, the majority of the top level females told me they did not. Some said they had cats but no kids. That experience left me with this gnawing feeling inside. Was this how it really was. Family and high-level success just don’t mix?

Maybe it can. But not the way you think. Executive blogger Penny Herscher writes:

Women often have an over developed sense of responsibility -- the belief that they have to care for it all: work, children, husband, aging parents -- caring for everyone else. Recognize that's what's going on in your head, give it up and prioritize what you have to get done.

Kids and high-level success? Maybe, for the right personality (ahem, Lisa Stone). Kids, big jobs and "balance"? Um, no. Not for a minute. But balance can mean more than one thing, right?

Risa Green of Mommy Track'd writes about getting lectured on balance by her Wii Fit personal trainer:

I don’t spend all day sitting around inside of a virtual gym, working on my virtual six-pack and flirting with virtual hotties. I spend all day running around like a freaking maniac. I schlep kids to dentist appointments and to after school activities, and I help them with homework and I make dinner every night, and I fill out camp forms and in case you haven’t noticed, I just spent three days cooking for twenty-seven people, and all of last weekend hand-sewing a Native American baby carrier for my first grader’s Thanksgiving costume at school. And oh, yeah, I also, allegedly, work. So of course I’m a freaking novice at balance, Gengis! I’M A GOD DAMN WORKING MOTHER.

I understand her pain. My biggest motherhood challenge is attempting to appear normal and professional in the office at the same time. Trying to meet deadlines when I've had no sleep. Trying to sell ideas when I'm worried about my daughter's dentist appointment. Trying to hold up my end of a conference call from the road because I'm late for daycare pick-up. I've often envied stay-at-home moms because at least they could focus on parenting.

However, it's lately occurred to me they might wish they had the balance of a job to offset so much energy in one area of their lives. Eh?

To me, balance means not falling off the bar. As long as I'm not falling off, I'm okay, even if I'm waving my hands frantically and screaming at the same time. (And those who know me know that waving my hands and screaming is my normal state of affairs, although I won't show you mine unless you show me yours.)

Balance also means realizing that if one part of my life temporarily takes on greater importance (a work trip, a book tour, a sick child), then I have to throw everything I have in its direction before I take a tumble. That means the other areas suffer.

By definition.

If you are balancing

  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Kerry Anne Ducey 5 pts

Kerry Anne Ducey

 I just wrote a post on the subject of balance "The Many Hats We Wear", I've been thinking a lot about this subject because I just never feel "in balance".  After some thought and prayer, I think it is a state of mind and not a state of circumstance in life.  Peace, that's balance.

Lisa Stone 6 pts

Rita, I saved this piece in my bookmarks one month ago and have just gotten around to reading it. Now I'm laughing out loud that you linked me as someone who can have a career and children. This is why I got up at 5:30 a.m. on a Saturday to write a memo. Because I'm stretched to the max! I laughed until I almost cried when I read your line about best friends getting cats to replace off-balance girlfriends who disappear into their to-do lists.

It ain't easy, is it? I love what you, jenlouden and braingear have to say above. It's a constant act, doing what I need to do for work and not getting stretched to the breaking point (every time at least) by outside demands. I found it so cathartic to read all these comments. I think we have to just say it out loud...and then give ourselves permission to take one step at a time, just like Lovebabz says. WE have to decide what is valuable, what is the ultimate balancing act. It's different for everyone. And yet hard everywhere...

I will say this: Because I'm a parent, if I didn't have fantastic parents who live nearby who allowed me to travel for work, I absolutely could NOT do what I do. Indeed, I would choose not to. And I reexamine my choices weekly if not daily. Thank YOU for all the food for thought...

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )
Surfette ( http://surfette.typepad.com )

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/politics-news ).

bRaingear 5 pts

Balance means what?  It means that you have both sides in check.  But what's balanced?  What unit of measurement are we talking?   Balanced hours (NEVER!)?  Happiness (How do you measure THAT)?  hmmm...

No matter what it is, it's fragile and it breaks easily... so it's momentary balance at best...

 BEWAAARREE the GROOOOOVE!    

God help us all! 

Tre - 5 pts

 Rita, you've hit a goldmine in this topic...i'm not married and not a mommy...and i'll throw out 'yet' to both b/c i think i want both...sorta...but i will say i battle with balance and guilt about it muchly.

hugs to all of you for your honest window into your thoughts/comments...alyssa, love what you said about valuing...and sifting thru what that is....lovebabz...you crack me up with your sheer honest tellin it like it is...from your comment i feel a real pull to have compassion but not pity and to set our own standards..amanda,and delaine, your admittance to choices you made to support and own the life you wanted for yourselves humbles me....I could say that to all of ya'll who wrote and commented.

Truth? for me, i align the word balance to poise, grace, inner peace...and i think it's right to yearn for it...for the sense of calm and productivity, joy and the craziness of allnighters and / or no sleep to get it all done. But how all of us define what gives us peace, productivity, joy, etc differs as much as the music we like, decor we feel embraced by and types of work we seek. key to me, actually essential to me is to keep myself very aware of bigger goals and objectives and continually backwards plan to frame the day to day with smaller needs. but even that stuff is just the hope. the day to day tends to be all about getting done what matters most...what i value most...and carving moments hither and yon to fit it all in as i can...a recent visit from my sis (who's a bigwig exec) and my mother (whose a bigwig philanthropist) for about 48 hours made me feel really small....but in relationship to what i found myself asking? What matters most is to do whatever will ensure you don't allow your peace to ever be robbed...and this really boils down to self care b/c it will never matter how much you get done in a day if you did it all feeling angry or were condemning yourself along the way. There's really no better job any of us can give ourselves than to be our own mommies and wives and husbands and mentors and take care of our hearts as only we know how to....no matter if that finds you getting up at 4am for a few moments of quiet time or not going to bed til then to fit it in....I sometimes wanna hug the world of women and say 'remember to love yourselves'...refuel and keep refueling so you can continue to outpour. But for me it's a moment to moment endeavor and a constant having to be utterly honest with myself about how i'm doin. ....And not to give into all the stuff that would say 'ah, you can tend to your self care later'...balance for me is synonymous with self knowledge and honesty...being gentle to my child within and teling her when to put the big girl pants on and comforting her and holding her and reminding her how precious she really is. hugs to ya'll for a happy holiday season and nurturing your inner peace :)

Tre ~ http://thoughtbythought.net

MrsWsKitchen 5 pts

When I worked, I worked hard.  I was on the fast track to success--and on the way, I discovered that my marriage was lacking, I had no time to work on having that family I so desperately wanted, and found that our health was beginning to suffer because most of our meals came from convenience foods or take-out/restaurant meals.

My male coworkers were able to have all those things--because they had a wife at home who didn't work and took care of everything.  But my female coworkers were (a) unmarried or (b) married & childless.  The few ladies at the office who did have families got themselves into a comfortable desk job and didn't worry about promotions, because they didn't have time to become the shiznit.  They had doctors appointments and PTA meetings.

I chose to quit.  It wasn't worth sacrificing everything I truly wanted in life to live far away from my family, occasionally see my husband, and live in Atlanta-area daily commutes.

Frankly, I don't personally know any women who have been able to do the whole thing--unless they have unemployed/worker-bee husbands who can be the spouse who handles it all.

That's a lie.  I do know one woman--she took a job overseas and moved her husband & 3 boys to South Africa, where the job will pay her enough to hire a maid/cook/housekeeper/babysitter on the local economy and still live like royalty.

Amanda
Mrs.W's Kitchen ( http://mrswskitchen.blogspot.com )

jenlouden 5 pts

I've been saying it for years, shouting it sometimes when giving talks on "balance" and being interivewed for "ten tips for balance." I've actually wished I could take balance out of the subtitle of my first book - The Woma's Comfort Book -  but hey, it was 1992, I was 28, what did I know about balance? 

Balance can, so easily become just another way for women to feel inadequate, to put the focus on what we don't have and aren't doing, instead of what would work for us, day by day. "I'm not balanced, something must the matter with me!" It's like the girdle my mom would squeeze herself into on a Saturday night-- the popular idea of balance tries to squeeze us into something that we can't attain because it does not exist - although you would not know that from the women's magazines. Balance is NOT a one size fits all acheive it and you are done thing. It's improv, it's creation, it's what you decide to shape. It's changes moment by moment!

Nor is balance an invitation to kill yourself in some mythic pursuit of  perfection, some toothpaste commercial idea of life. Balance is a soul call, at it's heart. What do i want my life to be? It's about making it up as you go along, and surrounding yourself with other women who get that.

Okay, had to rant, whew! Thanks for listening.

Delaine Moore 5 pts

I'm a stay-at-home mom with a full-time nanny - that statement alone should raise some eyebrows and form some scowls.  I KNOW this because I've seen it on people's faces right in front of me.

After the birth of my third child, I told my ex husband, who worked out of town, I couldn't be a full-time mom alone anymore - I was drowning.  Even HE looked at me like I was wimp - he said: "My grandmother had eight kids, no appliances, and had to grow her own food.  What the hell are your griping about?"

But I held tight - I knew the 24-hour job of parenting of three kids in diapers was killing me.  I had no social life, was stressed, exhausted, and emotionally, I felt at my rope's end.  Maybe other women can/could handle my role and have cherry pie on the table every other night - but not ME.  I wasn't happy - and I wanted HAPPINESS, not just balance.

My point is you have stand strong in whatever choices you make even if it doesn't resonate with others.  Like choosing to be a stay-at-home mom.  Like having a full-time nanny to help me out.  For at the end of the day, a sense of balance comes from within - on YOUR terms.   

Delaine * www.iamdivorcednotdead.com ( http://www.iamdivorcednotdead.com/ )

megansul 5 pts

I love reading these posts and comments if for nothing but to know I'm not alone. I've actually made a decision recently as a result of feeling overwhelmed with this concept of balance. We've decided to hire an Au Pair. My husband was resistant to this concept since we will have to give up some of our privacy and have someone live with us. But truth be told, and I adore my husband, he's not the one trying to make it all work. If he misses a train and gets home late, he has no guilt that the kids book reports will be finished on time or the patches for our daughter's daisy vest will be sew on in time for her next meeting. He would just let it all go - I can't. So rather than build a huge resentment since I feel like I carry the burden of keeping the household going, I'm going to get myself more help. She'll work more hours than my current babysitter and will be less expensive. And, she'll be available for when my husband and I want to go out on Sat night (which we haven't done in a while and need to). She'll also be on duty in the mornings so I can actually think about working out - didn't say I would work out but nice to have the option.  Am I nervous about having someone live with us - yes. But am I willing to try it in an effort to alleviate some of the stress in the household. Wish me luck.

Owlhaven 5 pts

Right now as I scurry to prepare to make Christmas memorable for 10 kids AND plow through a writing project (book deadline- Jan 30th) you can bet I am struggling with balance.  Am looking at this time of craziness as temporary.  Problem is, there'll be another thing after that keeping me racing...

Wish I could slow down.  But what would that mean I'd have to quit?

Thanks for this.

 Mary

Tracy Evans 5 pts

The Moxie Report. Giggles. Gaffes. Girl Talk. From television producer, writer and mom Tracy Evans. http://themoxiereport.blogspot.com ( http://themoxiereport.blogspot.com/ )

I always believed that you could have it all until...I had a kid. Now I see things clearly. None of us moms or dads really have it all. Something has to give from time to time. And that's okay. It really is. It doesn't mean you have to give up anything...except perfection. Because that's an illusion. There's no such thing as a Stepford Wife or Career Superwoman. There's just wonderfully imperfect you. So stay-at-home or go to work. Or figure out something in between. Just know whatever path you choose will have bumps and expected turns along the way. Enjoy the ride.

Mom101 5 pts

I needed you and you were here for me Rita! On the very day that I'm bemoaning my Type B mom status on my personal blog, and the UberMom in the class sends her kid to school with fancy cookies for every kid (um...huh?) here you are with a reminder that a sheet of snowman-shaped shortbread is not the end all be all. 

And thankfully, neither is that fancy, swept-up house.

(and wow, Lovebabz, I adore your enthusiasm.)

Mom-101 ( http://mom-101.blogspot.com )
( http://coolmompicks.com )

Cool Mom Picks.com ( http://coolmompicks.com )

CareerDiva 5 pts

People, let's not shoot ourselves in the foot here. We can live fulfilling lives without having so-called balance. What the hell is balance anyway? Who  the hell has balance in their lives? Nothing is perfect. But we can still be happy and have great careers and families.

Let's not allow the mommy-can't-have-it-all mantra that seeped into our culture to derail us from having a good life.

 It's tough for women, especially high-powered women, to balance it all but we are not damn gymnasts on some nasty balance beam. We are human beings living through our lives, sometimes tough lives, but we keep going because we're trying to pursue a higher good, a higher meaning, a better world, no?

This talk about how we're all so screwed is what Dr. Laura freaks want you to believe. The myth is you should give up all that has made you you, all that you are, for the sake of raising kids, and being there for your family.

That's bull. You can have a loving, great, funny, smart family. It won't be perfect. But it will be awesome. That's "all"  gals. It's just not going to be perfect. Just like it ain't perfect for women and men who stay home and have no careers, or identities. Nothing is perfect. That's life. Accept it.

And celebrate every day, even if you have a fight with your hubby, or can't believe your kid failed that test. Why do we have to define what the whole family package means? It means different things to different people. Isn't that what we fought for...equality to do what ever the "F" we wanted.

Live your life and live it to the max!! You're going to mess up. That's what makes the journey so freakin awesome!

alyssaroyse 5 pts

As I was getting ready to head out this morning, I was listening to the Today Show (which is to say running around too nutty to stop and actually watch it.....) and there was a woman being interviewed who had been a big time CEO and eventually left to be with her kids and now was back in the work force. (Had I stopped to look, I probably could have told you who it was, but, well, I'm a working mom, so not so much "stopping" in my morning.) 

In any event, she said something interesting, which I will clumsily paraphrase.  Her basic gist was that "having it all" is a myth.  But that you can have what you value the most. 

I liked that thought.  However, it means we have to figure out what it is that we actually value the most, and get honest about it.  Sometimes I think that actions truly do speak louder than words.....  If we always make time for work, but miss our kids, maybe we currently value work more.  If we always make time for our kids but drop the ball at work, maybe we value our kids more.  

There remains to right and wrong, but it made me think......  We can always have what we value the most, IF we can figure out what that is. Maybe, anyway.....

____________

Alyssa Royse

Just Cause It: ( http://www.justcauseit.com )A Web Site To Save The World

Start Her Up: ( http://www.startherup.com )A Blog for Women Entrepreneurs

AmberS 5 pts

... it took me 4 attempts to read this post, and another 2 to reply.  So, you know, I understand busy.  I may be on maternity leave right now, but I'm still pulled in 15 different directions.

I remember going back to work after my first child was born and being hit with the reality that I was always torn in two.  I couldn't do it all, or at least not all that well.  I have yet to find balance, to find that place where I feel that everything is getting sufficient attention, including me.  I think you're right - it just doesn't exist.

~ Amber

www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

JC 5 pts

I feel like I'm walking the tightrope almost every day (there are some days with relative calm).  So many obligations:  work, family, website, volunteering, trying to keep up with friends, family, neighbors, studies.  I gave up on striving for perfection long ago (as in having a perfect house, perfect hair, outfit).  Good enough has become my mantra.

http://www.storyrhyme.com/jcsblog

lisanoel03 5 pts

I write this while trying to complete 3 other work tasks, all while worrying about my mom who's health is not well, and how the kids are doign at home (with my husband, the stay at home dad) and school.

I had the chance to stay home for 6 months and I'd givemy left arm to be able to do it again. I may not be an "easy" job but at least it was my only job. These days I feel like I'm working 4 full time jobs: my "real" job, my mom job, my own business I'm trying to start and all my voluneer responsibilities.

http://www.lisanoel03.blogspot.com ( http://www.lisanoel03.blogspot.com/ )

Writer-Mommy 5 pts

What a good post and spot-on. 

The idea of balance is a total fallacy; try explaining it to a newborn that's howling with hunger {even though you just finished nursing that bottomless pit of cuteness an hour ago}.

I think it's far better for us as moms {and dads - I know my hubs is a juggler, too} to just let go of the idea that each category of our life is going to have a happy little check mark in it during these insane years of raising kids. 

One reason why I'm totally addicted devoted to blogging is the chance for us to have a real conversation about life as mom, how the shizzle really goes down each day, not how the ad agencies {who are just trying to sellsellsell!} portray our lives as parents in thirty seconds or less.

I'd chat more, but my over-volunteering self is running late for library duty and my toddler has destroyed the Advent wreath and the dogs need to go out and...well, you know.  Life demands me as it demands us all.

;)

Lovebabz 5 pts

Balance is the shit other women tell other women to keep this lie going. We can't have it all at once. Something is going to slip.  Men never trouble themselves with this. I they fuck up or do nothing or sit on the couch or whine about how hard they work...we all nod and say yes yes yes...

But when women knock themselves out in the home and on the JOB we say to each other ...GIRL DO MORE! We are insulted when someone suggests Merry Maids.  We want to make bread form scratch because we think our worth is tied to that shit.  That someohow hoemade bread say LOVE. Fuck that.

Women have have to learn to chart their own course and not listen to folks giving them models of success. We have to be our models of success. and leave the guilt at the door. AND not chastise or sit in judgement of women who make different choices. 

When you work there is a price to pay...It is not where you work..in the home or outside the home. Women are capable of doing and being a lot more than we give credit. We fuck it up when we want to follow some script that wasn't written for us....that is imposible to follow or adhere to.

We need to make peace with our desires and ambitions.

Be loving & Be in LOVE

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

I'll get that right one of these days.

I think you say this too - that the balance myth has to do with how we define not only balance so much, but accomplishment - what are seeking to achieve in the first place? And can we delay gratification on some things, get others sooner etc.?  Is an A- or a B+ or even a C once in a while when it comes to how clean any one room is or how many courses any one meal has?

Expectations - I think they have a lot to do with that. That doesn't mean not expecting the best and even doing the best and getting the best.  But for every single chore and goal? In exchange for what?

Of course, if we had time to think about all these things - well - wouldn't that be nice!? :) 

Jill Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

Binkytown 5 pts

"As long as I'm not falling off, I'm okay, even if I'm waving my hands frantically and screaming at the same time."  I totally agree with this, I just think this is the challenge- to believe that you are still ok while you are screaming and waving your arms around. Good thing I get lots of practice.