Bio
Hi, I'm Karen Ballum. but I'm better know around the web as Sassymonkey. I live in Ottawa, Ontario -- Canada's national capital. (No, I do not wo...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Banned Books Week: Harper Lee's Classic "To Kill a Mockingbird"

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 89
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In celebration and acknowledgement of Banned Books Week we'll be featuring some of the books that have been banned or challenged across America this week. We'll look at why they were banned and why readers have found them important. Some of the titles might surprise you.

Harper Lee's To Kill A Mockingbird might be my favorite book that I was never forced to read in high school. My best friend had a different English teacher in high school than I did and her class read it. I remember many people in her class complaining about it. I didn't read it until I was in my 20s and it was instant love. I fell for To Kill a Mockingbird. Hard.

to kill a mockingbird harper leeIf you were to ask me what it was about To Kill a Mockingbird that I loved so much I'm not sure I could tell you. There's an innocence there, yes. I rather like Scout's stubbornness and loyalty. There was just something about it that spoke to me. I think that like That Clever Chick, Too Kill a Mockingbird redeemed the term "classic" for me.

Some books are classics seemingly only because people are continuously forced to read them. It’s like group bonding through shared suffering, and has little to do with the actual merits of the book (I’m looking at you Great Gatsby, and Madame Bovary). This is not one of those books.

I think also, as Stef, who also didn't read it in high school, states, it's Scout's voice that really does it.

This book is considered by pretty much everyone to be Required Reading for Americans, and rightfully so. It captures the innocence of childhood from the perspective of a somewhat jaded, ridiculously intelligent adult, looking back on her life and wondering how she coped with trauma so matter-of-factly. The narrative perspective of Scout Finch, feisty tomboy, is one that I wish I could hear in other books.

While I shake my head anytime I hear that books are being challenged, hearing that this book is being challenged makes me a bit sad. Yet, To Kill a Mockingbird is one of the most challenged books.That's not to say that I don't understand some of the problems that people have it with the book. Yes, it can be hard to discuss racial epithets and rape in the classroom. Yes, you can argue that the black characters in the book are marginalized. I guess maybe I just take a different stance on that -- I think that the difficult discussions are the ones most worth having.

Classics aren't classics because they are perfect -- they are classics because they shine a light on something and give us something to discuss. Lizzy attended a group reading of To Kill a Mockingbird and took not of the questions that the moderator, Richard Holloway, asked. They are great questions. I think this is my favorite.

"Can you think of a contemporary novel that takes on society’s big issues as successfully as To Kill A Mockingbird?"

Like most people, I went from the book to the movie (in my mind, the one and only proper order of operations). I cannot picture anyone but Gregory Peck as Atticus. I just can't.

Did you read in To Kill a Mockingbird in school?

BlogHer Book Club Host Karen Ballum also blogs at Sassymonkey and Sassymonkey Reads.

  • 89
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
fringster 5 pts

My teacher asked us to read this book when I was in high school. She was right - the book is awesome. I made a book review about it and got excellent remarks from my teacher! I really like the moral lesson of the story. Thumbs up for Harper Lee!!!

trigirl13 6 pts

I absolutely love that book. It was not required reading for me. While parts of it were difficult to read, I think the overall themes of the book are wonderful, particularly the strength of the human spirit. I would imagine that most teachers would really highlight that.

SherryMc 6 pts

I'm listening to the audio book now in my car each morning on my way to work. It had been many years since I had read the book or seen the movie, so thought I would review it. I have enjoyed listening to Sissy Spacek's voice depicting each character. One of the best books ever!

CMcGowan 5 pts

I teach this book every year. It is always a huge success and I've never had a student not enjoy it. Yes, it is required reading per say - but there are other books I could choose. I've deviated once or twice from Lee's masterpiece, but when I do I regret it. I always come back to Mockingbird.

The UDG 14 pts

My mother had me read To Kill a Mockingbird, as it was required reading to be apart of our family and to this day, it's one of my favorites. Not only does it lend itself for discussions on social issues, but the writing itself is crisp and clear and should be studied by students of form.

Arnebya 5 pts

My daughter brought home a request from her English teacher to read the book. In sixth grade. I immediately recalled some of the scenes and language and...she's 10...I wasn't sure she was ready for the maturity of some portions. I don't think she'll get very far in it (I did agree to it, though). I kept coming back to your point: the difficult discussions are the ones most worth having. She is mature. She is reading on a 10th grade level (though I still haven't figured out how this is determined). At the same time, I question my subjecting her to the idea of rape so early. But then who am I to deny her knowledge of the world in which we live?

I'm reading it with her, after dinner each day. And we discuss it as we go, or after. I do think it's best for older teens or those in their early 20s. There are things she won't get no matter how well I explain them. The ultimate premise of the book, I think she will comprehend. I just couldn't say no, then have her Googling it at school or feeling the need to sneak and find out what I was keeping from her.

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

Arnebya Ok, yeah, 10 does seem a bit young. I'm glad you are reading it with her though, because as you rightly pointed out it's possible she would have sought it out on her own. That's the thing about withholding, challenging and banning books - it just makes kids want to read them more.

I think To Kill a Mockingbird is one of those books, and I think this is one of the hallmarks of a classic, that you can read at different stages in your life and take different things from it.

CMcGowan 5 pts

I agree that 6th grade is way too young for this novel. I think it is being pushed at younger grade levels because the Lexile reading level is not that high, but the content is. You were right to be concerned. Arnebya

RaeAnn 5 pts

My first 'meeting' with the book was actually a reading of a part of the trial...and I was instantly drawn. Atticus, Dill, and the convicted( sorry, I couldn't recall the name; I'm furious of myself about it, believe me), even the supposed victim (I think her name starts with 'm', rite?), were all simply compelling. Its a classic, which means I kinda had a hard time following the story, but, it speaks to me.

Love it.

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

RaeAnn The trial scenes are really quite good. :)

beyondelsewhere 5 pts

I made a video response to you! (well, sort of a response, this question inspired it!)

The blog post is <a href="http://beyondbooks.ca/?p=4465">here</a>!

beyondelsewhere 5 pts

Well, that link didn't work well. :( Sorry.

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

beyondelsewhere Livefyre does not like hmtl. Just paste in the link. it's a long one shorteners are good.

Here's Cat's link! http://beyondbooks.ca/?p=4465

Summerstead 5 pts

I didn't read it until just a year or two ago. I am so glad I wasn't forced to read, since I probably would have hated it. As I read it as a 31/32-year-old, I fell in love. It's one of those books that I will be reading over and over again.

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

Summerstead I don't know if I would have liked it as much if I read it in high school. It would have depended on the teacher and the discussions. Certain discussion questions and assignments can kill a perfectly good book.

Polish Mama on the Prairie 15 pts

I read it in high school. Twice because I just didn't see what was so great about it the first time so I decided to read it again on my own time to try to give it another try. I just didn't enjoy it. It did not speak to me at all. However, it is an American classic and there are some merits to the book. It just wasn't for me. It wasn't written in the style I enjoy, it wasn't about a topic I find interesting at all, it wasn't about something I could even relate to.

But, to think of it being banned confuses me because I don't understand why it would be. What about that book makes it so infuriating to someone that they would ban it? Because it was too hard a read for them? Was it the topic? How sad that in the country with freedom of speech we can be so censored and yet books about how to "properly" molest a child have been sold on Amazon and the Pearls are doing a killing talking about how to properly beat a child in the name of the Bible and the Lord. The wrong books are being censored and the the ones deserving censorship are everywhere. Even my local library.

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

Polish Mama on the Prairie Most of the challenges I've seen revolve around the language, particularly a specific racial epithet, in the book.

Michelle Santagate 5 pts

First off, I can't wait until I'm someone's favorite English teacher; I know I will be. Secondly I feel gutted whenever I read that books are being banned or challenged. I believe it was my sister-in-law that told me Huckleberry Fin was being censored (re-written in a PC way) in Texas schools (she and my brother and their family live in Texas). I wanted to vomit. And protest. And rip my hair out with frustration. WHAT??? How could this be? How could this happen in AMERICA? In a society that justifies EVERYTHING with how much money it makes, the smut on reality TV, the trash tabloids on view at every supermarket, WHY are we looking to ban well written, thought provoking and timeless stories that have pushed our society forward and awakened our sensibilities to topics that others didn't dare touch? Mean while we lap up every sexcapade that Snookie ventures on. WHY? (No offense Snookie). Maybe because the classics aren't copy writed? If they were I'm sure everyone would leave them alone. But they are vulnerable, as all great art is, and depend on our courage and conviction to protect them. There is no way To Kill a Mockingbird should be banned anywhere. I experienced two life changing quotes before I reached the fifth chapter. Such simple and timeless wisdom. And we're tearing it apart because of the way we interpret it from our 21st century bias? No. We have to let these pieces of art be. Would anybody demand the Sistine Chapel be repainted to cover up the exposed genitals of saints and men and angels? I really don't think so. We must preserve books in the same way. Even the parts that make us uncomfortable. Because discomfort is what makes them so effective. No pulled punches. Honest and raw and filled with truth. You have to be brave to write a book like that. And you have to be brave to be receptive to it.

Peace and Love all-

nokomismichelle

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

Michelle Santagate Yep, we wrote about the Huck Finn thing back in January. http://bit.ly/n5bPMj It's not a global re-write -- one small publisher is doing it.

victorias_view 418 pts

My favorite grade 9 teacher taught this in English and I loved it.

sassymonkey 140 pts moderator

victorias_view I think in my school they did it in tenth grade. It was the year that I had a teacher that didn't do any assigned reading. We had a reading period once a week and could read whatever we wanted.

Conversation from Twitter

papaT433
papaT433

mrsped The ALA has a great Banned Books Week program. I always read from their list of titles that have been banned.

mrsped
mrsped

papaT433 if mockingbird is on, we got problemo's señor. Or ANY book. If you don't like it, don't READ it. Good lord.

papaT433
papaT433

mrsped Their list includes books banned in school libraries by school districts. You would be amazed at the amount if censorship happening

papaT433
papaT433

mrsped I remember a few years back when Harry Potter books were being pulled frm school libraries. So much commotion over the dark arts : )

mrsped
mrsped

papaT433 Ridiculous. I'm vehemently opposed.

papaT433
papaT433

mrsped There is a great poster up in the CW library. I will take a pic tmw morning and post.

HarmsWayChad
HarmsWayChad

mrsped dollgina blogher i have been hearing about these....is this legit?

BusbyRescueFarm
BusbyRescueFarm

blogher podcastmama That is a CLASSIC, I can not understand why they would ban To Kill A Mockingbird

THATmag4Women
THATmag4Women

blogher You've got to be kidding me! WTF scuze my language...

Conversation from Facebook

Jaborandi Grove
Jaborandi Grove

How can you hate this classic? I LOVE it!

Dianna Whitehead
Dianna Whitehead

Yes, loved it. Read it again in college!

Karen Badon
Karen Badon

Love this book! It was one of the few books I actually read in school. I was a lazy student and usually just did the Cliff Notes!

Deanna Adams Hughes
Deanna Adams Hughes

Love, love, love!

Angel Gatson
Angel Gatson

Love it!

Dani Jane Phillips Stockham
Dani Jane Phillips Stockham

My husband has never read it and he just asked me tonight if I had ever heard of it. I am bringing it home tomorrow and we will read it together...for me, again! <3

Edith Carolina Rivera
Edith Carolina Rivera

To Kill a Mockingbird was my favorite book when I was in school. It taught me to fight the injustice and have the courage to do so .

C Kelley Black
C Kelley Black

Love it!

Jen Szabo Matuska
Jen Szabo Matuska

I can't describe in words how much I love this book! A true classic and my absolute favorite. I read it for the first time in fourth grade, loved it ever since!!

Jo Hilder
Jo Hilder

Love

Torrie LM
Torrie LM

I have a 5 week old son named Atticus. To Kill a Mockingbird is my favorite book.

Kristy Babcock
Kristy Babcock

I love this book. When we had to read it in school I skipped ahead and of my class and finished the book because I loved it so much.

Alysia Knop George
Alysia Knop George

one of my faves :-)

Renee Oliver
Renee Oliver

My favorite book ever! I cannot understand anyone not liking it. It's a well-crafted story with a wonderful underlying message about the injustices that are out there. I'm going to have to re-read it again now.

Patricia Honea
Patricia Honea

Named our son Atticus too.

Maureen Doyle
Maureen Doyle

Love it!

Leslie Logemann
Leslie Logemann

LOVE. On my very favorite list.

Belenda Kay Kemp
Belenda Kay Kemp

Maybe the best book ever written, so concise and not a word wasted, love Harper Lee.