Bio
I'll just be over here drooling on the new J. Crew catalog ...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Be my bridesmaid - but have some Botox first

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

My husband and I will celebrate our fourteenth wedding anniversary very soon. After all these years, people on both sides of our family still talk fondly about our wedding, about how simple and lovely it was, and about how much fun they had.

No one talks about what the bridesmaids wore, or about who had the best boobs or the fewest wrinkles. I promise. Apparently, though, that is no longer the case.

Today's New York Times has an article on a trend that has left me truly agog: brides who are asking their attendants to have Botox or other cosmetic proceedures as part of being in the wedding. In what I think has to be the most horrific moment in the article, one woman dishes about her engaged friend's request:

Becky Lee, 39, a Manhattan photographer, declined when a friend asked
her — and five other attendants — to have their breasts enhanced.
“We’re all Asian and didn’t have a whole lot of cleavage, and she found
a doctor in L.A. who was willing to do four for the price of two,” said
Ms. Lee, who wore a push-up bra instead.

Oh my. And I thought asking bridesmaids to attend multiple showers was a bit much.

I am not opposed to plastic surgery; I can't imagine having an invasive cosmetic procedure myself, but I know women who have had Botox and breast enhancement and other tweaks and have been very happy with the outcome. I am also not surprised to hear that brides -- especially older brides (and by "older" I am using the Times definition, which is women in their 30s which is not old AT ALL but let's just go with it shall we?) might want a little smoothing or tucking or peeling before their Big Day.

What makes me clutch my pearls and gasp is the idea that any bride would be comfortable asking her friends to have a boob job just so they will look better in the wedding pictures. Perhaps a bra fitting would be more apropos? Or -- dare I suggest it -- a different dress?

Let's not go crazy here, right? Right.

Michelle Preli, at Brides.com's Wedded Bits blog, sees this as an inevitable step in the evolution of wedding festivities: "But brushing aside the alliterative and attention-grabbing headline, what they're really magnifying is the trend of brides holding a skin care soiree as a modern twist on bridesmaids gifts. . . . Bonding over beautiful skin can take many forms and whether that's a massage, manicure, chemical peel, or Botox...well, that's up to your personal choice." Maybe, but it still seems like a lot to ask.

Marie, at Every Day is a Miracle, writes about her own simple, economical wedding and wonders about the larger value system at play here.

I have strong opinions about cosmetic surgery. Why take a risk by going
under the knife purely to look younger or more "beautiful"? I have
great respect for plastic surgeons, having been born with a cleft lip
and palate, and one of my favorite charities is The Smile Train, which
raises money to perform plastic surgery on children in developing
countries with cleft lips and palates.

But how can people spend gobs of money on temporarily looking younger...when so many are in need?

I confess I agree with Marie; I think there is a place in the world for cosmetic surgery, but perhaps a bridesmaid's luncheon isn't that place.

Marilyn Sewell has another take on this, from the vantage point not of the bride, but of a member of the wedding party. She tells the story of a mother whose daughter-in-law-to-be asks that she do something about the crow's feet before the wedding.

All I can is that if my son's beloved asked me to do that, I would take
my son aside and have a heart-to-heart talk with him. I would say,
"Son, I feel obliged as a mother to warn you. I will say this only
once. You're about to marry a woman who doesn't like herself the way
she is, and never will. She is a woman who will spend the household
money foolishly. She may never want to have children, because of
course the little tikes are demanding and do some damage to a woman's
girlish figure. She may spend more time staring in the mirror than
looking at you. I cannot tell you who to marry or not to marry, and I
will of

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
The Flirty Girl 5 pts

After working with brides in the Northern California Wedding industry for over a decade I can honestly say that I've never personally come across a single bride who has made such a request of her bridesmaids. In fact most of the brides I've had the pleasure of working with have been extremely empathetic when it comes to both the emotional and financial comfort levels of their attendants. For instance choosing a color but letting each bridesmaid choose the cut of her gown so that she will feel completely comfortable in a style that suits her taste and body type. Paying for part or all of their gowns and gifting them any jewelry they'd like them to wear on the wedding day. I've also increasingly seen brides go out of their way to personalize gifts to their attendants.

Being asked to be an attendant should be an honor, not an opportunity for a bride to point out the physical shortcomings of her friends and family.

Susan Wagner 5 pts

Especially that bit about finding better looking friends from the get-go.

You all know that I have a deep love for beauty products ( http://blogher.com/beautyhacks/ ) but I find it infuriating that these products are sold by playing so heavily on our fears, specifically the fear of becoming undesireable as we grow older. With the divorce rate as high as it is, it would be nice if the focus of a wedding was on the compatibility of the couple, and their commitment to each other, not on the size of the bridesmaids' boobs.

Fortunately, as with so many stories in the NYTimes style section, I think these women are a very tiny minority of brides. Or maybe I am just stupidly optimistic. Whatever.

Fashion Find ( http://wowwomensworldblog.com/fashionfind/ ) | Friday Playdate ( http://www.blogher.com/fridayplaydate.com )

magazinemilf 5 pts

If your friends look crap enough that you need to decree pre-bridesmaid Botox ( http://www.sugarshockbeauty.com/2008/05/botox-for-... ), why are you even friends with them? Clearly, the women profiled in the Thursday Styles story ( http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/24/fashion/24skin.h... )about bridal Botox parties are poor planners. Choose friends who have Pat Wexler ( http://15minbeauty.blogspot.com/2008/06/aging-tips... )
on speed dial, and rest assured everyone will be uniformly frozen-faced
for your big day. If you’re really on the ball, your fiance will be a Restylane ( http://jolienadine.com/blog/category/body-image/re... )regular too.

http://magazinemilf.com/2008/07/24/botox-brides-sh... ( http://magazinemilf.com/2008/07/24/botox-brides-sh... )

www.magazinemilf.com ( http://www.magazinemilf.com )

*always judge a book by its cover

Just_Margaret 5 pts

Silly me...I thought friendship was about the connections between humans, not the way a person looks.

I
was irked when a good friend directed me to purchase a specific brand
of pantyhose, to ensure that we had a uniform look. I smiled and
agreed and then bought my brand in the proper color. It was a
full length dress and no one ever saw our hose anyway. For
uniformity, she also insisted that I wear the same 3 1/2" heels as the
other attendants, when I already towered over all of them by 6-14
inches. (I did do that).

If any supposed friend of mine suggested that I surgically enhance myself so that I would look the way she wanted me to, could have the HONOUR of being a part of her wedding, I'd back out of being a member the bridal party.

And, I'd wonder how the hell I ever became friends with such a shallow b*tch.

~Margaret

www.maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com ( http://www.maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

mashadutoit 5 pts

As Laurie says:  Why not just hire some models?  And actually, why not go the whole hog and hire models to be stand in for the bride and groom as well?  That way you can be sure to have lovely photos memories of your special day.

Love_Is_Dope 5 pts

I think some women watch Bridezilla, Platinum Weddings and other shows like that as how-to guides. There's nothing cute about being abrasive, demanding and unreasonable. Asking your bridesmades to under-go surgerical procedures just to snap a few pictures with you for a couple hours? Ummmm, no. That's ridiculous. How sad.

Megan Smith 5 pts

How about I don't be your bridesmaid and tell you to have a nice life?

Megan Smith ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... )
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/YouTube ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/msmith )
Megan's Minute: Quirky Commentary Around The Clock ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Celeste Lindell 5 pts

I thought it was bad when my sister handed me a tanning salon membership about a month before I was going to be in her wedding (10 years ago). I'm a little mad at myself even now that I gave in and tanned a couple of times.

slynnro 5 pts

If someone asked that of me, not only would I no longer be in their wedding, I would no longer be their friend.  I get annoyed when people demand I get a pedicure for their wedding.

sassymonkey 6 pts

You know...if I ever decide to have plastic surgery that's my choice. If you decide to have plastic surgery it's your choice. It's one of many, many choices that we all get to make for ourselves.

I've stated that it would take a heck of a lot for me to be in a wedding again (6 times down the aisle - and no never as a bride). If a bride asked me, as one of her attendants, to have botox or plastic surgery for her wedding I'm pretty sure I'd come up with a few creative ways to tell her where she could shove my bridesmaid's dress.

And I'll leave it at that before I start ranting about the wedding industry and people spending more time planning a wedding than they do planning a life together.

Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca/ ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.wordpress.com/ ).

lauriewrites 5 pts

Michelle Preli, at Brides.com's Wedded Bits blog, sees this as an inevitable step in the evolution of wedding festivities: "But brushing aside the alliterative and attention-grabbing headline, what they're really magnifying is the trend of brides holding a skin care soiree as a modern twist on bridesmaids gifts. . . . Bonding over beautiful skin can take many forms and whether that's a massage, manicure, chemical peel, or Botox...well, that's up to your personal choice." Maybe, but it still seems like a lot to ask.

This part especially.  An inevitable step? Let's all bind our feet, too, shall we? Massages and manicures do not compare to the injection of foreign matter into one's face. Fail.

As a bridesmaid several times over, I could write a very long screed here that I'll spare you. I was honored to be asked, wanted to stand up in support of my friends and family, and for the most part was really lucky with how it turned out. But it is an expense and a time commitment, as well as occasionally an exercise in frustration when dealing with a group of (almost 100 %) women. The people chosen should be so valued that - beyond the traditional consistency in dresses and shoes - other adjustments to appearance should not even be a factor. And, like Marie, I have a cleft lip and palate and the usual accompanying strong feelings about elective plastic surgery (ie., you can do it, live and let live, but it really sucks so stay away from me with any further scalpels or needles, thanks.) Turns out, in no wedding I've been in has anyone run screaming from the room. ; ) 

Seriously, if women are more concerned with how their bridesmaids look than who they are, why do they not go out and hire models? Is someone really your friend if you want them to get a touch-up of any sort to hang with you? 

Oops, guess that did get long. Thanks for writing about this so well, Susan. 

Laurie

LaurieWrites ( http://lauriewrites.typepad.com )