Bio
I love to write and have been blogging at Four of a Kind (formerly Three of a kind working on a full house...) since April 2007. I tweet @F...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Tweeting a Funeral: A Step Too Far or a Space for Comfort?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 66
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When I first heard that my friend Lori, from Write Mind Open Heart, was going to be "live tweeting" the funeral of the husband of fellow blogger Melissa, from Full Circle, I had mixed feelings. Though I knew that Lori had gotten Melissa's permission and blessing to do so, my initial reaction was cynical and I questioned if tweeting during, and specifically about, a person's funeral was taking the role of social media in bereavement too far. However, I tried to reserve further judgement until after I had a chance to read Lori's tweets and see how the whole thing played out.

I was able to read a few of Lori's tweets (which used the hashtag #luvmel) on my phone that afternoon. But I didn't have time to sit down and scroll through all of them (in reverse order as it turned out, because I started with the most recent tweets and went back from there) until late that evening when I got home from a meeting. As I started reading each thoughtful tweet that Lori had typed and viewed many of the touching pictures she shared, I was very moved. I was struck by how much a part of things I felt, not having been there.

I don't really know Melissa, though I have visited and commented on her blog a handful of times over the past year via Perfect Moment Mondays. So though I can appreciate what a tragic loss this is for her and her family, I am experiencing all of this as more of a caring and concerned bystander, than someone who really knows and loves them. That said, I can only imagine how much Lori's #luvmel tweets meant to those who do know and love Melissa and her family that weren't able to be with them in person for her husband's funeral that day.

I may have been skeptical in the beginning as to whether or not "live tweeting" a funeral was appropriate, but in the end I think it was a beautiful and inclusive way for those who love and care about Melissa, her late husband and their family (including all those who knew them through the "blogosphere" and "twittersphere") to feel a part of (and even participate in) the memorial service and celebration of life. Though it would have never occurred to me, prior to that day, to tweet about something like the funeral of a loved one while I was experiencing it, I do understand why it was a worthwhile endeavor for Lori to take on. I also believe now that it was a very kind gesture for Lori to offer to do on behalf of her friend Melissa who is grieving the tragic and unexpected death of her husband and the father of their soon to be adopted foster children.

At one point in the midst of her "live tweeting," Lori invited all those who had "tuned in to the funeral, (to) please tweet something with (the) #luvmel hashtag so Mel knows who was here." I thought that was a wonderful idea, as now long after these end of life festivities are over, Melissa will have another "virtual guestbook" to read through. Hopefully feeling the love and support that was surrounding her from all over the country (and in some cases even the world) that day will bring Melissa some comfort in the days to follow as she begins to work through her grief and learns to adjust to this "new normal" in her life without her dear husband by her side.

I know that losing one's husband is not the same thing as losing a child, however as a bereaved mother and "wounded healer" I often feel drawn to those who are suffering after the loss of a loved one. Though every loss is different, I have found that anyone who has had to bury a family member (of any age) that left this world too soon has a lot in common. I had not yet joined Facebook or Twitter during my pregnancy or at the time our daughter Molly was born and died (from a rare and severe combination of Congenital Heart Defects) in April 2008. Beyond sending email updates to family and friends and blogging about our experience, we did set up a CarePage to keep loved ones and other "Heart Families" who reached out to

  • 66
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
JuneGardens 5 pts

I honestly don't know this--because I'm old: What's the difference between live tweeting and regular tweeting?

Kathy Benson 6 pts

JuneGardens Great question! Live tweeting just means that she was doing it while she was at the funeral, as opposed to tweeting about it after the fact. If you "live tweet" something you are doing it while you are experiencing an event in your life vs. reflecting on it later. Thank you for reading!

TheKirCorner 7 pts

What a beautiful post Kathy, so proud and happy to see it here!

as someone who followed this tweeting the day of the funeral, I felt that Lori's words to us were respectful, dignified and full of love. It allowed us all a chance to hold the grief for Melissa for a little while, to be present with her. In this world of constant media presence I think that sometimes words can help the healing. I believe this was one such case.

I can only hope that I if I lose someone or it's my time to leave this world, that my "tribe" is there to bring the words of love to me or my family in their time of sorrow.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

TheKirCorner Thank you Kir! Your kind words mean a lot to me and I agree with your thoughts on this. I am sure that if in the future you lose a loved one and/or leave this world too soon that your tribe would rally around you and your family, as they already do during wonderful and challenging times in your life, to share words of strength, love, healing and comfort. xoxo

Emsxiety 8 pts

I hope someone does Twitter or Facebook my funeral. I think for those that can't be there, it allows them the ability to participate. My brother and niece live in other states, when I visit my Mother's and Sister's graves, I send them picture messages. They all appreciate it because they can't be there themselves.

I agree, there is NO wrong way to grieve.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

Emsxiety Thank you for weighing in. After this experience I wouldn't mind if someone tweeted or Facebooked my funeral too. I think it is really nice that you send pictures to your brother and niece after you visit your mother and sister's graves. Over the years I have taken pictures of my daughter's grave when I go to the cemetery, as I like to be able to look at them in between visits. Thank you also for reitteating that "there is no wrong way to grieve." We all need to do what works for us as we grieve and heal.

Sofia Michaels 8 pts

This one is out of my comfort zone. It seems disrespectful to me. Maybe in our social evolution is will be similar to the old saying "If the music is too loud, you're too old." (moderization of funeral traditions)

Really the question is about how do you pay your respects to the dead and their family and how do you grieve.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

@Sofia Michaels Thank you for sharing your perspective on this. I appreciate where you are coming from. It's interesting to think about the "modernization of funeral traditions." as you said. I imagine there are more common things that we do as part of our memorial services today, that seemed unusual and maybe even disrespectful years ago, before they became more socially acceptable. I agree that the most important thing is "how (we) pay our respects to the dead and their family and how (we) grieve."

Kissing Up 6 pts

It seems to have been live-tweeted with love. And I think anything that helps enhance the memory of a dear loved one is positive.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

@Kissing Up I think so too. Thank you for reading and sharing your thoughts.

Lavender Luz 7 pts

I've been thinking a lot lately about intentions, and how much they matter when prompting a certain action. I'm concluding that they do matter.

I do see the viewpoints of some of the commenters -- that I wasn't fully present, that my tweeting (silent and unobtrusive as it was) may have disturbed other mourners, that social media breaks old school rules -- all true.

But backed by the intentions to support a good friend in a way that worked for her, and to help bring in OTHER support for her from friends who care but weren't able to be there, well let's just say I have a clear conscience about live-tweeting this particular funeral.

mmdenton 10 pts

Lavender Luz Love you, sister.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

mmdenton Lavender Luz Thank you so much for weighing in Lori. I couldn't agree more about intentions. I believe that they do matter, a lot. I am glad that you have a clear conscience about all of this. Your good intentions have brought peace and comfort to Mel and so many others through this experience. Many thanks to you and Mel for supporting and encouraging me in sharing this story.

sassymonkey 119 pts moderator

Y'all are invited to tweet my funeral. You are also invited to blog it, Facebook it, Google + it or whatever it is that you. A large part of my life is online. It would be only fitting that part of my memorial happen there as well.

Just not from my personal accounts. That would be creepy.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

sassymonkey Good to know Karen! Yeah, that would be kinda creepy if someone was blogging or tweeting as you after your death. I can appreciate where you are coming from and would imagine that a lot of bloggers, tweeters and Facebookers (to name a few) feel the same way (in regards to some or all of their memorials being shared online). I think about from time to time about what happens when a person who is beloved in social media circles dies. How do we grieve and mourn and process their death, especially if we don't live anywhere near them and in many case never met them in person? A friend of a friend who was an interior design blogger died unexpectedly in a car accident awhile back. She was actually with another blogger that she had met online when the accident took place. Her husband took on the task of sharing about her death and his pain in a blog post on her blog not long after she passed away. The woman who was with her in the car also blogged about the experience and how much she cared about and missed her friend. The whole thing was so sad, moving and yet also beautiful to witness at the time. Of course we all wish she was still here with us, but I was fascinated by how her online friends rallied around her husband and her family and friends from offline. I know there are so many examples of this happening with bloggers and/or their loved ones deaths. Anyway, your comment called that experience to my mind. Thank you for joining the discussion here.

Denise 125 pts moderator

sassymonkey Good because I would have anyway. Hah.

For the record, yes please tweet mine or Facebook mine. I prefer you avoid G+ though but if that's all you've got, then do that. (I'm anti Google, lol.)

Denise

BlogHer Community Manager

Kathy Benson 6 pts

Denisesassymonkey Ha, ha! Thanks for chiming in Denise. It's nice to have some comic relief in the midst of this discussion on a such heavy and somewhat divisive topic. It will be interesting to see in the future if tweeting and Facebooking funerals and memorial services becomes more socially acceptable and less strange to those who might hear about and/or witness it happening.

sassymonkey 119 pts moderator

Denise As long as you also remember you are to shut down my online accounts. I don't need my Facebook page to live longer than I do.

mmdenton 10 pts

My husband passed unexpectedly and many family and friends couldn't come. It was a way of being connected and wasn't some massive Twitter Party where Smartphones were clicking away. Not by a long shot. Lori is a beautiful, dear friend and it was done discretely with the utmost taste and thoughtfulness. My family appreciated the love and support as did I.

There is no right or wrong way to grieve. Trust me on that one.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

mmdenton Thank you so much for commenting here Melissa. I really appreciate you sharing your first hand perspective about this experience in your life. I hope that this discussion is not upsetting to you as your grieve the death of your dear husband. I am so glad that you and your family appreciate the love and the support that Lori's incredible act of kindness brought to you on a very painful and bittersweet day in your life. I can only imagine what this experience has been like for you and I do hope that the #luvmel tweets from Lori and everyone carried some peace and comfort with them. I couldn't agree with you more that "there is no right or wrong way to grieve." I know that myself from having lost a child. It has been hard for me over the years, since my daughter's death, to understand how and why loved ones think it is okay to say or to insinuate that some of the ways that I choose to grieve and/or honor our baby girl's life and memory is anything but appropriate. But I know that until you have "been there," some people just don't "get it" and never will. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts and feelings so openly with all of us as you mourn the death of your husband. I continue to wish you peace and comfort as you honor his memory and learn to live without him here on Earth.

mmdenton 10 pts

Well thank you for the beautiful post, my friend!

Everyone has a right to their own opinion.. and it's interesting to see all of them here. No harm, no foul. The friends that know Lavender Luz know how truly kind and special she is. Her friendship is one of the many blessings I have counted since that horrible day. To me, it was Social Media at it's finest and it brought peace and strength. :)

Lavender Luz 7 pts

mmdenton You and Kathy Benson are making me cry. XOXO

Kathy Benson 6 pts

mmdenton Lavender Luz "To me it was Social Media at it's finest and it brought peace and strength." This really says it all... Thank you Mel and you are so very welcome. xoxo

monkeysoup1 6 pts

I think that this was done in taste, and thoughtfulness. She had permission from the family, and I think that as connected as they were via Social Media, it was appropriate. I am sure that many people, friends and family who couldn't attend, probably felt connected.

I do think that it depends on the family and the situation. Last week, my husband's Great Aunt D passed away. Within minutes of her death, my husband's niece posted a Facebook status sharing her death. The problem is that not everyone had been called. There were many family members who had not been notified who found out about Aunt D's death via Facebook. That was not kind, it was not fair, and it has caused much hurt and anger, when the family should be coming together to help one another, reflect on the life of this last member of "Greats" that we have lost.

As with everything, Social Media has a time, place and purpose. Using it in the way that Lori did, is more then fine. The family was supportive, and the deceased was connected to so many online.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

monkeysoup1 Thank you for your comment. I also agree that it depends on the family and the situation and that it was thoughtful and appropriate in this instance. Thank you for sharing your recent experience. I don't think that people can use social media as the only avenue to communicate with others, especially something as important as the news of a loved one's death. I am sorry to hear that this brought so much pain to your family during an already sad and difficult time in your life. May your Great Aunt D rest in peace. I am sorry for your loss.

justlinda 22 pts

I will only speak for what is right for myself. I don't know enough of others to judge their intent or motives or whatever, although I'll admit that seeing someone at a funeral standing in plain site texting would cause me to lift an eyebrow.

If I am at a wedding or a funeral (or other important events), I want and need to be present in the moment with the people who are there. I would feel very ... rude, I guess ... to be there and have my phone or whatever device out and sending notes to others or to the world at large. It just doesn't feel RIGHT to me.

But keep in mind, that's me. I turn my phone OFF when I go into any face to face meeting. I'm old school like that, I guess.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

justlinda I really appreciate you sharing your perspective here Linda. I agree that each of us can only speak for what works for and feels right to us. I also believe that we never know how we will feel or react in a specific situation until we are actually experiencing it. I think it is *easy* for us to imagine what we would do, but I know of many times in my life when I did things I would never have thought I would do or be comfortable with, but it made sense to me at the time. I also think if I had not known about Lori's "live tweeting" of Mel's husband's funeral, I too would be suspicious of seeing someone at a memorial service typing on their phone. However, from now on if I were to see that happening, I would certainly try to give them the benefit of the doubt, as you never know what their purpose or intentions (hopefully only good) might be. Thanks again for weighing in.

HereWeGoAJen 6 pts

I don't know Melissa, but I do know Lori, so I saw a little of the tweeting while it was going on. Like Kathy, I had mixed feelings at first, but once I heard that she had Melissa's blessing and saw what she wrote on Twitter, I was extremely touched. It ended up being a beautiful way to share with people who weren't able to be there in person.

I'd also like to add that I've experienced an outpouring of internet love during a very tough time in my life. I was on my blog and on Twitter while I was in labor with my son who had already died. And while I wasn't on social media the whole time by any means, the support and love that I received were absolutely invaluable. It made an awful situation just a little bit less awful.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

HereWeGoAJen Thank you for your feedback Jen. I was so very moved by the whole experience as well. Thank you also for sharing about how your friends were able to support you and surround you with their love via social media during one of the most painful and difficult times in your life. Again, I appreciate that communicating that way may not be helpful to everyone who loses a child, but what's important is that it brought you some care and comfort. I feel the same way. Receiving emails, messages on our CarePage and comments my blog during our pregnancy with our daughter Molly and after her birth and death meant so much to me. As you said, "it made an awful situation just a little bit less awful."

NotaMyrtle 6 pts

I was one of those who followed the twitter feed of #luvmel during the funeral.

When I heard Lori would be "live tweeting" I was unsure how that would work. But for those of us in the blogging world who interact with Mel on twitter and her blog, it was a way for us to "be there."

All of the tweets and photos were done with respect.  It was a way for us to share be there with Mel during this time.

It was also a wonderful way to be able to support Mel as she would read our responses and support at a later time.

And just remember, none of this happened without her approval. Mel completely approved of the idea. It is what was right for HER and for HER family.

It may not be for everyone, but it was a wonderful way to support her from afar.

Kathy Benson 6 pts

NotaMyrtle Thank you for sharing your thoughts here Suzy. It means a lot, especially since you know Mel and have a personal relationship with her. I really appreciate your perspective as one of her online friends who wanted to be there for her the day of her husband's funeral. I am glad to know that Lori's tweets helped you to feel more connected that day. Thank you also for reminding us that Mel wanted this to be done and was grateful that Lori was willing and able to do so. As Jenna said, we don't all grieve the same way and that is okay. Mel is blessed and lucky to have friends like you and Lori.

JennaHatfield 44 pts

I wouldn't be able to do it for anyone close to me, but I wouldn't mind if someone else did in such a respectful manner as is described in this post. I just don't know if *I* could do the tweeting at a funeral, not because of a belief that technology doesn't belong at funerals but because I'm usually not in a coherent state at funerals.

I would feel very honored if my friends did something like that -- or, really, any way of reaching out, whether it was a tech-love-bomb or meals delivered to my door. Different people deal with grief in different ways.

*And that's okay.*

Kathy Benson 6 pts

JennaHatfield Thank you for your comment Jenna. I don't think I would be able to do it for anyone close to me either, but I also wouldn't mind if another person were to do so at a loved one's funeral. I am not sure how I would feel about doing something like this for someone I didn't know as well, but cared about. After this experience, I would certainly be open to it, especially if I was asked to do it and I knew it would mean a lot to the family members and friends of the deceased. I too would feel honored if one of my friends or family members were to do something like this for me or my family. I do think it can be done (and was in this instance) discretely and respectfully. I also echo your sentiments about how not everyone deals with grief in the same way and that is not only okay, but something we all need to try to respect and be supportive of, whether or not we believe that we would handle things differently if we were in their shoes.

Conversation from Twitter

shilohwalker
shilohwalker

blogher it's a step too far, IMO

Hokuboku
Hokuboku

geekbabe I think it is wrong to tell people how to deal with their grief. If that helps her then so be it.

geekbabe
geekbabe

Hokuboku I would never presume to tell anybody how to handle their grief, just sharing a post that might interest others

R3dawn25
R3dawn25

geekbabe Hokuboku You can tweet my funeral;)

Conversation from Facebook

Kathy Axe Benson
Kathy Axe Benson

Melissa (the blogger and widow) who helped to inspire this post by allowing Lori to live tweet her husband's funeral, commented on my post on BlogHer yesterday and I thought some of you might be interested to read what she had to say. Here is Mel's comment:

"My husband passed unexpectedly and many family and friends couldn't come. It was a way of being connected and wasn't some massive Twitter Party where Smartphones were clicking away. Not by a long shot. Lori is a beautiful, dear friend and it was done discretely with the utmost taste and thoughtfulness. My family appreciated the love and support as did I.

There is no right or wrong way to grieve. Trust me on that one."

Kathy Axe Benson
Kathy Axe Benson

Thank you all for sharing your thoughts, feelings and perspectives on this. I appreciate that not everyone believes it is appropriate to "live tweet" a funeral. However, my intention in writing this post was to show how sometimes things that sound inappropriate can turn out to be incredibly caring, thoughtful and moving expressions of love and support for those who are going through very difficult and painful times in their lives. Thank you to all of you who took the time to read my blog post and comment in light of what I shared. I do believe that those who have read the details about what actually took place the day of Melissa's husband's funeral tend to see Lori's tweeting in a different light then when those who have just heard about it happening. Thanks again for joining this discussion. It clearly struck a chord with many of you and I learned a lot from reading your comments.

Julie Dawn Sacharko
Julie Dawn Sacharko

If you are afraid something might be considered rude or insensitive then there is a chance someone WILL think that it is rude or insensitive. Technology is fine and dandy, but I think it is more important to be with the people in the room 100% whether it is a funeral, a wedding, a party, or the clerk at the grocery store. Technology does not exclude you from good manners.

Sandra L Mort
Sandra L Mort

I have a headache and don't feel like reading a long article, but wanted to comment. I live online. I have friends around the world who want to be up to date with what is going on. I updated fb when I was in the emergency room online and I had one of my births on webcam to share with them. I don't see a problem with it.

Karen Baglin
Karen Baglin

> BlogHer & Jessica: I didn't read the blog post before commenting above. Have since read it & can see both sides. Met a woman who tweeted right after her husband died suddenly of a heart attack & started following her because of it. I tend to be more private; need to process & then blog later. But since the wife was on board, I agree it probably was touching and another memorial for her. It's very personal. Even for the Royal Wedding, I watched it first & then tweeted about it later; wanted to just experience it.

Amy Carlo
Amy Carlo

I read it and couldn't help but notice that it was devoid of any commentary or perpective from others at the funeral. It may have been helpful to the wife, but she was not the only one mourning that day. This man's parents, siblings, friends, etc were all mourning him as well. I'd like to see what their perception was of someone having a phone in their face, updating Twitter every few minutes with details of what should have been a very private day for them. Intimacy which should be present on a day like this was lost. I think many are forgetting that just because the wife encouraged it, does not mean others were not deeply offended by it. I would venture to say that unless she got the express blessing of everyone in attendance that day, allowing this to happen was disrespectful of other mourners. Also, how present and in the moment can someone be when they are on their phone all day? The Twitter "reporter" was really just that--she played the role not of a mourner, but of someone viewing the funeral as a spectator sport. Had I been in attendance I would have been horrified.

Tricia Smith Boutelle
Tricia Smith Boutelle

I did Jessica, and although my comment might feel a bit off-topic, it was my way of sharing an example in support of the topic. Everyone grieves in their own way. As long as it is done in a way that shows respect for the person who passed and their family, it is not anyone else's place to decide that it us "wrong". The tweeting in this case was meant to be a form of love, honor, and respect for a man who will be missed by his dear family. That is not, IMO wrong or offensive, but rather, kind, considerate, and a great show of love and respect for her friend.

Jessica Dally
Jessica Dally

Did anyone actually read the post?

Kathy Frederick
Kathy Frederick

I think I would have thrown a shoe at anyone who pulled out a smartphone at my father's funeral, which was just yesterday. There would be so many other ways to show support, like standing up right there and expressing thoughts about my father, so that the people who actually CAME TO IT could hear it.

BlogHer
BlogHer

For those who are against it, I want to ask if you read the post or are just responding to the idea? The author admits that she didn't know what to think of it when she first heard the idea, but then realized how helpful it was for the loved ones at the funeral. It allowed people who couldn't be at the funeral due to physical distance (or, in some cases, relationship-distance: they just didn't feel close enough to the family to be there, though they felt close to his wife due to interactions online) to send messages of love. I think the important point is that it was helpful to the person who people were attempting to help -- the wife. And therefore, it's a good thing, in my opinion. For me, it wouldn't help helpful to have people tweeting their support at me at a funeral where I am one of the... for lack of a better term... main mourners, but that's because I'm not a big fan of communicating through Twitter. I think the post points out that often what we think will be helpful for a mourner comes from our own point-of-view, and what she witnessed was someone supporting the mourner in a way that was helpful to the mourner. --Mel

Tricia Smith Boutelle
Tricia Smith Boutelle

Ya know, I see both sides. There are situations where loved ones simply can not be there. Time, distance, military service, etc can play a role. A dear friend of our family passed away recently and I was asked by the family to photograph the entire viewing/ceremony, etc. at Arlington Nat'l Cemetery (I am a photographer by trade). They wanted candids at the viewing, the pre, during, and post service, as well as graveside pics. I got A LOT of "looks" from people. A couple people had the guts to approach me and ask me why I was photographing everything. Once I explained that I was doing it for the family, at the family's request, it was accepted. What I did for them may be considered unconventional, and possibly offensive to some. It comes down to the fact that it doesn't matter one bit what everyone else thought. I did it for the family of this man that we all loved. Those pictures were what they needed from that time in their lives. Everyone grieves differently. As long as no one is being harmed, objectified or threatened, who are we to say if it's "right"?

Jacki Carugati McHale
Jacki Carugati McHale

Right so don't bust out the phone while standing at the grave but if you must do it in your car when you get there. I'm not one for Tweeting, FBing or anything my location. TMI for people.
I have to laugh at a friend of mine who was FBing the birth of her child and said "I have to put the phone down and push now" I laughed hard!! It is what it is. It's the future of everyone knowing your business if you want them too.

Karen Baglin
Karen Baglin

I've live tweeted conferences & TV shows; I get & love live tweeting. But when a woman I follow on Twitter was getting married this summer and said she was going to tweet it, that was taking it too far. Call me old school, but some things are just for experiencing first hand, in the moment. That includes weddings, funerals & birthin' of babies. Not saying I wouldn't tweet out a pic if I were to marry again; but to tweet the whole day? Um, no.