The media news roundup for this Saturday includes important new rules from the FCC, ownership changes for two of the nation's largest news companies, an appeal from leading women's media advocacy group and a prominent White House correspondent busting a move.
This week, the US Federal Communications Commission narrowly agreed to new rules that allow media companies to own broadcast stations and newspapers in the same top 20 markets .pdf document. Free press and diversity advocates worry that the new rules, combined with ongoing media consolidation, will bring to life the old adage: "Freedom of the press belongs to those who own one."
The National Organization for Women sided with the two FCC commissioners who opposed the rule change:
"For decades, NOW and the NOW Foundation have petitioned the FCC, advocating for greater opportunities for women and people of color in the media industry. Two months ago NOW Foundation President Kim Gandy testified at an FCC hearing in Washington, D.C., on media ownership and the responsibility of TV and radio broadcasters to serve their local communities.
When Congress returns for session in the New Year, NOW will be issuing an action alert calling on all women's rights supporters to write to their members of Congress, urging them to repeal these new rules that favor big business over a vibrant media marketplace."
Columnist Richard Prince also cited concerns about the impact of the decision on women and minority ownership, but noted that the FCC also won praise from diversity advocates for a ruling banning racial discrimination in advertising. Under this rule, advertisers will no longer be able to exclude media outlets from advertising buys because the the racial composition of their audiences.
Presidential candidate Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) denounced the change in the ownership rules, and urged congressional action. He is one of 25 senators who sent a protest letter to FCC Chairman Kevin Martin the day before the vote.
BuzzFlash named Martin Media Putz of the Week for the decision.
The FCC announcement comes in the same week as the announcement that billionaire Sam Zell concluded negotiations to buy the struggling Tribute Company, which owns the Chicago Tribune. Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, Newsday, and the Chicago Cubs among other important properties. Gawker chided Zell on his grammar and grandiosity in an email to investors:
"Zell anounces an era in which the Tribune saves not just your soul but our nation's as well. 'We will take intelligent risks and reward innovation," he says. 'We will tear down bureaucracy and reward entrepreneurial spirit. We will compete fiercely but with integrity.' We will use anaphora! We will! We will!"
Muckety.com has a handy interactive chart with details on the new Tribune Company's board of directors. In Laurie Bennett's accompanying report Zell expressed impatience with the naysayers in the news industry:
“I’m sick and tired of listening to everybody talk about and commiserate over the end of newspapers,” he told the Los Angeles Times. “They ain’t ended and they’re not going to end. I think they have a great future.”
The Tribune sale comes on the heels of last week's conclusion of the sale of the Dow Jones Corporation to Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation. Industry watchers are still trying to glean what the News Corp takeover will mean for respected publications such as the Wall Street Journal.
Meanwhile, Women in Media and News, a prominent critic of sexism and racism in media, is appealing for help. Friend of BlogHer Jen Pozner says WIMN needs your tax-deductible donations build on 2007's accomplishments, which include:
"# Placed women as featured experts in major news outlets such as Fox, ABC News, MSNBC, PBS, NPR, and Pacifica Radio and in the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, Bitch, Ms., In These Times, the American Prospect, and many others.
"# Conducted media trainings for more than 20 women’s groups such as the NYC Alliance Against Sexual Assault, the New Orleans Women’s Health and Justice Initiative, and Vibe Theater Experience, and led media literacy programs for more than 1,000 young people at colleges across the country.
"# Advocated for media justice in powerful arenas: Following conversations with WIMN, Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards’ campaign began speaking publicly against media consolidation."
Finally, on a lighter note, did you catch NBC White House correspondent David Gregory getting his swerve on with Mary J. Blige on Friday's Today Show? Krista says, "[I]t's just too fly to ignore."
You can watch the video for the entire song here.
Comments
No on can resist the power of MJ!
Thanks for that last clip, Kim. It seriously put a smile on my face.
On a more serious note, it's hard to imagine how our media could become more consolidatyed and dominated by a few non-diverse and non-representative voices than it already is...but I guess we'll find out what that looks like!
Elisa Camahort
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.org
Unless Congress acts, that is
Hey Elisa,
There are two things Congress might do that will reverse the FCC's decision. One is to pass the Media Ownership Act of 2007 which would force the FCC to be more "transparent" about their process for adopting new rules. It would also authorize the creation of an independent commission to look at ways of boosting media ownership by women and people of color. A .pdf of the bill is here. Sponsored by Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-ND), the bill's two dozen co-sponsors include all of the Democratic Senate presidential candidates, Trent Lott (R-MS) ,Larry Craig (R-ID), and three other Republicans.
The other action that is being contemplated is a special kind of resolution that would effectively nullify the FCC decision. More details about that are available in the Dec. 21st podcast of Media Minutes. It will be interesting to see what happens after the current recess.
I think David Gregory is getting a bum rap. Huffington Post said he set white people back 60 years. And then his NBC co-workers compared his moves to that famous scene in "Seinfeld" in which Julia Louis-Dreyfuss does this dance that makes her look like a possessed zombie with an itch she can't reach. That's cold. Besides, he's become a hero to people like celebrity legs, "as a dorky white journalist who will totally dance to some Mary J (or Chris Brown) given the opportunity."
I say, work it DG!
Kim
BlogHer Contributing Editor|Professor Kim|
Media Consolidation
It's hard to believe that Kevin Martin almost single-handedly overruled the wishes of the American public and ignored Congress speaking on our behalf (for a change). I was stunned when I saw this report on Bill Moyers Journal and how inevitable the vote was despite the protests shown.
Though my outrage is tempered a bit by the other vote to limit cable franchises to serving only 30% of a market which I think, while being given by the FCC as a gift to telecoms, will actually lead to at least price and service competition and allow some leverage of municipalities over cable companies since they will need access to install fiber optic lines and equipment. The progress though that the telecoms have made in convincing states to limit municipal regulation over their (not cable's) service and to centralize it at the state level limits my optimism.
And may I just add, I heart David Gregory in all his funky glory. There truly is no shame in his game.
Kleenex® Let It Out™ Blog
Beyond Help
Yes, and add in the loopholes and the
upcoming spectrum auction
Hi Maria,
One of the disturbing things about the way this vote was pushed through is that, according to one of the dissenting commissioners, the final version of the rule didn't even get to them until 2 am on the day of the vote. He said he wasn't even sure what the full implications of the rule were. The only thing he could say was that there were so many loopholes that he thought it wouldn't be difficult for companies to get consolidations approved outside of the top 20 markets,
I hope you are right about there being greater competition. Like you, i have my doubts,
Meanwhile, I wonder what you think about the list of bidders that was released this week for next month's wireless spectrum auction? As you know, analog television stations are giving up their share of the spectrum as part of the switch to digital TV in 2009. The list of bidders for the Jan. 24 auction includes some you'd expect, (AT&T and Verizon), some suprises (especially Chevron) and Google, who could redefine the whole game. Hard to see where the little folks -- the startups, community groups, researchers -- will fit into the game.
Kim
BlogHer Contributing Editor|Professor Kim|