Most Popular

A Birthday Sans A Party

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In exactly 17 days, my son isturning 10. In exactly 17 days, we will not have a birthday party as usual and he doesn’t mind that at all. The first & last birthday party I had for my son was for his 1st birthday. I still don’t think it qualified as a party, till this day. There was cake, ice cream & three of my girlfriends and another 1 year old child. To say that it was small and quaint would be an understatement.  The only memories of that party are the ones that the photos can provide the both of us. He does remember the talking Barney doll he received, that was subsequently broke when he flung it down a flight of stairs, about two weeks later.

Growing up, my mother never made a big deal out of birthday parties for my siblings and I. Birthdays were celebrated usually with an ice cream cake, a candle and the four of us singing Happy Birthday Day to each other. We never had friends over or solicited gifts from friends; it was something that really wasn’t a big deal to us. I truly think this is why my household does without the pomp and circumstance of having birthday parties.

This year I figured I would ask my son what he wanted to do for his birthday. I even put out the idea of having an actual party, and to invite a few of his friends over.  It really didn’t take him that long to decide whether he wanted a party or not. He answered with an immediate no. The only request he made was if he could bring cupcakes to school that day. Fifteen cupcakes versus a party for fifteen kids in my house? No problem!

A few of my other friends who have children tend to think I’m cheating my son out of the birthday party experience. I always wondered what experience is that exactly. Is it the receiving gifts experience? The celebrating with friends experience? I just don’t get what the experience is that he’s missing out on. He gets gifts from family members. The cake is usually shared between him, his cousin and me and for the past 9 years, I have yet to receive a complaint from him. Usually the only complaint that he’ll make is in regards to the type of cake. For some reason,he just doesn’t like ice cream cakes.

For the record, my son does attend birthday parties thrown by his friends or classmates. I remember one party in particular; the mother asked if I was throwing my son a birthday party as well. I replied to her with a simple, “no”, as I looked around and saw screaming kids jumping in and around inflated balloon rides. I figured a simple no would suffice as an answer, but apparently it wasn’t good enough for her. She wanted to know why not? Jeesh. Pushy aren’t we? I went on to discuss with her that I thought birthdays were more meaningful when shared with a few close family members and that the whole ‘party’ experience wasn’t necessary. Once again, I got the whole “you’re ripping off your child” lecture. I couldn’t help but to roll my eyes and walk away.  If and whenever my son actually asks for a party, I’ll gladly throw him one, but until then, I’m not going to push the issue. So this year for his 10th birthday, cake and ice cream will be shared between 3 people and his new dog that he requested as a gift.

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
sugarbritches26 5 pts

I was bad about overplanning, overspending, overhyping my kids parties until the past few years. I've really scaled them back and now enjoy them sooooo much more. We just do a few bright decorations, cake, and a cookout with family and immediate friends who might as well be family.

I think that as long as your son is fine with it then that's all that matters.

A.A.

humanbeing 5 pts

Growing up, I always had 2 birthday parties: one with just my family, usually centered around KFC and an ice cream cake from Baskin Robbins, and another with 2 or 3 friends. Usually, my "friends" party consisted of a sleepover, pizza, videos and my mom's promise to keep my 2 younger siblings out of my hair.One year, my mom took me and my best friend to see The Empire Strikes Back, and a couple of years we went to an amusement park--me and my best friend and my family.

I never felt deprived. In fact, because our celebrations were so small, I learned to feel very special on my birthday.

I think the big birthday extravaganzas are teaching our kids bad lessons about what is important. I feel the same way about $50,000 weddings.

My 7 yo daughter turns 8 in June. Her dad, who I am divorced from and who earns twice my income, has thrown her birthday parties for the past 4 years. He insists on inviting all the kids from her class. Last year, he asked me to split the bill--$300 for 25 kids at his community pool, including cake and pizza. Ridiculous! I said no.

This year, her dad will likely throw her another party. I'm encouraging her to have a sleepover at my house with 2-3 of her friends.I thnk she's going to take me up on it. I won't be contributing to any huge party nonsense. That's her dad's gig.

I once tried to have a big huge birthday party for my 30th birthday. Slated as a backyard BBQ, it got rained out and I was so sad. I celebrate my birthday by taking the day off (this year, I'm turning 40 and blowing 2 weeks of vacation in celebration), going out to dinner with my parents, siblings and fiance/daughter and going to a spa with my best friend. My fiance's present to me is a weekend trip to Santa Fe, just the two of us.

Lynn @ human, being

http://www.humanbeingblog.wordpress.com

Kia 5 pts

At 4 and 6 years of age my children still very much enjoy having parties, so I'm games as long as they are. But I can't imagine thinking that this is some mandatory rite of childhood. if their personalities were different, I wouldn't force my love of event planing onto them.

And curiouschild, I think that the family who threw your child a surprise party have questionable parenting skills not the other way around. I'm always amazed at what some folks deem appropriate.

MrsWsKitchen 5 pts

We didn't have birthday parties growing up, ourselves--just the family.  I tend to celebrate now, though, as an adult, but modestly.

I think you have the right idea.  Why go to such tremendous expense every year to have a gaggle of kids running around your house if your son doesn't want it?

Good for you!

Amanda
Mrs.W's Kitchen ( http://www.blogher.com/mrswskitchen.blogspot.com )

curiouschild 5 pts

I have four children and I have not had a birthday party for any of them since they were about a year old.  Mostly because we celebrate with family and we like to kick back and just be silly.  My youngest's birthday came and went without a party (like every year) EXCEPT this year her friends' parents decided to throw her a surprise party without discussing it with me first or even letting me know about it.  My daughter called me from a sleep over and said "Mom, they threw me a surprise party."  I felt like it was a veiled (overt?) attempt to question my parenting skills.  I was hurt and more than a tad bit angry.  It's a birthday party, not the end of the world.  My children are happy, healthy and well-adjusted.  What's the problem?

Brooklyn OCallaghan 5 pts

That is definitely a great birthday present! I didn't have a birthday party until I hit 30..lol..and even after the fact, I would have just enjoyed a quiet night at home!

geniealisa 5 pts

First, my birthday is May 20 too!  This year I'm taking the day off from work but mostly because we're going for the ultrasound that will tell us if it's a boy or a girl growing in my tummy.  This is our first kid and I think that's a pretty groovy birthday present.  I don't really need much more than that.

I had exactly one big birthday party when I turned 5.  I have some vague memories of it but certainly would not have felt cheated had I not had it.  Otherwise we just did some small family stuff and my parents would get me a small gift.  No pony rides, no huge gifts. 

So I'm totally in agreement with your game plan for birthdays.  He'll grow up just fine :)