What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Black Women, Property Twice

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     


Sara Bartman/Venus Hottentot & Rapper Lil Kim  Courtesy of Str8OuttaNYC
(Video of an Altercation between Black Israelites
and some Black women passerbyers.)

About a month ago I was sitting a Professors office explaining my
research interests (labor, sex, Black women), how I was working
on a theory of how Black Women are Property Twice. He listened,
became agitated then finally
said, "I really don't like when people
try and connect slavery
to things going on now, there is no data."

In the conversation, I was trying to connect the Video Vixens to
Venus Hottentott (word to Dallas Pen) and he was like, NO.

Property once, property again.

The Professor agreed that hip hop was global, but felt that
the Vixens
constituted a minute part of the hip hop equation.
Really. All I could think was, have you seen BET lately?
Uh, okay.

I looked at him and continued talking to him and thanked him
for sharing what I would imagine would be a critique of my work.

I was reminded of this experience when I stopped in Barnes and Nobles
on Saturday and read that Charles Johnson has been critiquing
Toni Morrison, saying in so many words that "she needs to stop writing
about slavery."

Funny, I don't think Johnson could fix his lips to critique Holocaust
scholars, and say that they need to stop writing about it.

Again. The message was, "no slavery talk, people."

Later Saturday Night
I went out Saturday Night and my experience made it clear to me
that I, and arguably many black women, and perhaps women in general
have been trained to
tolerate being touched in non consensual ways.

A friend of mine who is a DJ had invited me to three things in the
last month. He sent me a text regarding an event that was by my house,
so I decided to go.
I have been under a rock for the last 6 weeks.
So this was special.

We both LOVE boom bap, and I knew he would be surprised to see
me, as I saw him last June of 2007, so I figured it would be a nice
break in my routine.

So I am there, rapping along to Black Moon, or Ghost or CL
and this dude grabs my wrist and I unfurl his fingers from around it.
A little bit later, and he does it again and I almost flipped out on him.

I remember that historially, I would take my thumb finger and stick
it into a dudes hand if he ain't get the picture. In many ways,
it was a small act of resistance.

The more I thought about it, I realized that him touching me was
typical dancefloor behavior that many of us
have been subjected to since we first started going out.

The second time he grabbed my wrist I was reminded of going
to a party in the Bay over Christmas break, after my first semester
of school in New York. I wasn't even 21 yet.

The party was in Hayward, and was typical California in the
cut hood ish. I remember dancing with this guy, and he kept rubbing
on my booty. I don't remember how

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
PhantomDog 5 pts

Can I comment as a man who USED to enjoy porno?  I see situations supporting this blatant lack of respect for women daily, sometimes too subtle for many to see or accept.  Sadly, people, men AND women, don't want to see something that should abhorred by all for whatever reason.  Having a daughter, for me, means changing things and forcing (too strong?) yourself and people around you to pay respect.  I do my best for my daughter to grow up proud of being strong and to never let someone be less than honorable with her.  How do I teach the rest of the world the same thing? 

ThatDeborahGirl 5 pts

Three times in my life I've been hit by men. Once, a boy I had been dating for a while got angry with me because I wasn't in the mood for sex. We had had sex before but that day I just didn't feel like it and he hit me and threatened to drive me to another city and leave me there. I was frightened but I fought back and he drove me home.

Another time, I was in college and were at a party, again someone I had known for a while, but had never dated. He wasn't drunk but his friends claimed he was to campus police when he asked me to dance and I pulled my arm away and he slugged me so hard I saw stars for a while. All because I wouldn't dance with him.

And the last time - same scenario - guy tries to push up on me, I say no and before I know it we're fighting. I actually wrote about this on my blog ( http://deblite.blogspot.com/2006/02/why-i-dont-tru... ) and how because of  this incident and another, I do not trust our local police.

And I consider my life to be fairly normal. But I see now that these incidents of violence have changed me.  And I can't help but think and pray for the sistahs who have to endure this sort of violence every day.

m.dot 5 pts

@ BrownImani

I thank you. Sara Bartman thanks you and one day Lil Kim will too.

=====

Im blinking back the tears love.

Thank you for reading and for sharing.

@ snobographer ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... )

All women's bodies are public property, but WOC, AA women particularly,
are more sexualized. White women are put on pedestals, to be taken down
for lulz. Black women don't get the pedestal in the first place.
/thinking aloud

========

Thank you for commenting and sharing.

You are thinking aloud, and you are accurate.

My stance is that the power dynamics around gender realtionships

can be traced back to binaries produced and rooted in slavery,

Madonna/whore, wife/slut etc.... Paula Giddings "When and Where I Enter"

clarifies this and also offers some insight into Prop 8.

Alphanista 5 pts

This is very interesting.  We have to keep being reminded. 

Alphanista™-It's A Blog Dedicated to the Alpha Female Perspective

http://wwww.alphanista.com ( http://wwww.alphanista.com/ )

BrownImani 5 pts

Wow m.dot. Please please continue your research. I stopped watching BET years ago and refuse to let my child and my sisters children watch many of the Black videos that are out here now. They are so toxic. Some of them are subtle too. The music is funky and you sing along or dance and then when you think about it later you are like OMG ! I mean I like Snoop and Tupac too and the lists goes on but OMG, their images of us is mind boggling. I see young sisters emulating these images too. Trying to be what they think Black men want us to be and then they call them names and use them for sport.

Other cultures see these images too and think that this is what it means to be an African-American woman. Black women, property still. This is how it feels to me.

PTSD is real. I see it everyday when I leave the safety of my home. Sometimes it creeps into my home and my life. Many people will never agree with you but once you know the truth you are obligated to speak on it. I thank you. Sara Bartman thanks you and one day Lil Kim will too.

snobographer 5 pts

I've only gotten through about six minutes of the first of the three videos you linked, but it's got me seething over here. First these guys blame women for all their own weaknesses and shortcomings. Then, when a woman calls them out on their hypocrisy, they silence her by shouting her down with misogynist insults. Way to be "manly," if "manly" means being a bigot and stridently refusing to take responsibility for your own failures.

That professor of yours is an idiot too, m. dot. Like an institution that existed for about half a millenium and only ended about 150 years ago would have no reverberations in society. I hope he wasn't a history professor, but it wouldn't surprise me if he was.

As far as sexual harassment, the experiences you write about don't sound too different than some harassment and assault experiences I've had as a white woman. But I think WOC are subjected to a more virulent, insistent form of harassment. I'm still learning how to sort that out. All women's bodies are public property, but WOC, AA women particularly, are more sexualized. White women are put on pedestals, to be taken down for lulz. Black women don't get the pedestal in the first place. /thinking aloud

m.dot 5 pts

Roger,

Thank you for sharing and for the reccomendation.

 I am familiar with Joy's work. ( http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/search-handle-ur... )

rsg2003 5 pts

"Post-Traumatic Slave Syndrome" by  Joy Degruy Leary ( http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/search-handle-ur... ) and research 'post-traumatic slavery disorder'.  There may not be a large body of literature tying slavery to modern-day maladaptive patterns in a demographic BUT the literature can bolster an argument stating that untreated abuse can normalize maladaptive patterns over generations and lead subsequent generations to embrace those patterns as 'commonplace'.  take the thesis from there. 

Roger S. Gil, M.A.
www.rogergil.com/blog ( http://www.rogergil.com/blog )
www.luvbuzd.com ( http://www.luvbuzd.com/ )