Bio
Laina Dawes is a contributing editor for Blogher and is also a music journalist whose writings can be found at Exclaim! Canada and...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Black Women in Rock, Pt. 2

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Tonight I will be heading to NYC to check out what might possibly be one of the best Metal shows of 2008, Neurosis and Mastodon. Having missed the last two times that Mastodon played in Toronto out of sheer ignorance and poverty, I knew that if I didn’t go see them play I would be kicking myself for the rest of the year. Since none of my friends nor NYC acquaintances share the same passion for Metal that I do, I will be heading to Brooklyn alone, so if this ends up being my last post you know what happened……

No seriously, I have been going to punk and metal concerts for over a decade. Not as much as I would like, but I try to go when I can. I have written previously at Blogher about my interest in the black representation in the alternative music scene, (most notably, metal) and some of the women that are (hopefully) are paving the way for the next generation to get loud, excited and involved in the genre that I have been passionate about since I was a kid. I’ve written about this before on Blogher here.

For some reason I happened to come across a post today about the metal band that African-American actress Jada Pinkett Smith fronts, Wicked Wisdom that fellow Blogher CE Nordette Adams wrote in November of 2006. Before I begin, let me say that I have heard some tracks from the band, and while they aren’t bad, they aren’t my cup of tea. I personally prefer harder, more hyper-white angry boy-masculine stuff, but regardless, they are a really good band and she is no fool. I have a feeling that if she knew she sucked, she wouldn’t be doing it. And that type of metal is taken so seriously by fans that Sharon Osbourne who tapped the band to appear on the second stage of Ozzfest a couple back, wouldn’t gave given them the coveted spot.

In Nordette’s post, she expresses her dismay over something that is written on the band’s MySpace page which was This ain’t no R&B Shit. Her argument is threefold: 1. The presence of the slogan is a sign of disrespect for a musical genre that is steeped in African-American culture; 2.The perceived ignorance of Pinkett Smith’s knowledge about the history of rock; and 3. A sign that Ms. Pinkett Smith has some personal issues that she is using this particular musical genre to work out. Obviously I vehemently disagree with Nordette’s post, but I did find it extremely interesting, as even though it probably didn’t mean to, it raised some interesting questions about identity and musical tastes.

While I can completely understand Nordette’s stance about the offending statement that introduces Wicked Wisdom’s site, I think that what the band was trying to do was to say that they are not playing the “stereotypical” genres of music that it is thought that black folks should be playing. That when the music hits you when you check out their page, it ain’t going to be no R&B. They are acknowledging the surprise that probably greeted them during Ozzfest (apparently it took awhile for the fans to warm up to them) and to folks that see a young pretty black girl and figure that she is going to be on some Mariah Carey shit. That’s not it, and I think that’s what the band was trying to say. Maybe not well, but hey…..

Since I remain a rarity at metal / rock shows, I have always wondered why there aren’t more black folks into the heavier genres of music. After all, if you grew up in the ‘70’s and ‘80’s (especially moi, since there were no mainstream ‘urban’ radio stations in Canada until the late ‘90’s) there is a good chance that you grew up listening to some straight up Rock n’ Roll.

But there is such a cultural component to what we listen to, as we use music to identify who we are, which has always bothered me. As a kid I was drawn to groups like Public Enemy because I liked their lyrics of black empowerment. I was also drawn to Judas Priest because I loved their rapid-fire playing and the energy that pounded it’s way out of my crappy Radio Shack speakers – not because I hated myself, hated my blackness or was particularly angry at society. The energy is addictive, the aggression makes me feel powerful – even

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
titilayo 5 pts

that Santogold was black, or a woman. I've heard a very few tracks by her, and I always assumed that Santogold was the (male, white) DJ behind the voice. Goes to show what they about assume making an ass of me (but not u, of course!)

I'm not a big fan of the harder, heavier stuff myself. but I would like to see/hear more black women doing things musically that are outside the mainstream, and being really brash and bad-ass about it.

gallimaufry.ws ( http://www.gallimaufry.ws )

Yvette Perry 5 pts

Lainad, this post has given me an idea about a joint Black History Month effort I am working on. I'd like to talk to you about participating. Can you drop me a line? Thanks!

Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast ( http://blog.lib.umn.edu/perry032/impossible/ )

Yvette Perry 5 pts

I can very much relate to what you are writing about in your music posts, Lainad. In my case, however, it was not being a Black girl in a hard rock/metal world but being a Black girl at Elton John concerts. But at the same time, that did not stop me from loving the J 5, or the Temptations and jazz that my parents listened to, or any other artist/genre.

As to your question: "I have always wondered why there aren’t more black folks into the heavier genres of music."--I, too, grew up in the 70s. I liked some artists and individual songs that you might classify as "heavy" but it did not resonate with me more broadly. Partly I think this was because I was a rather bookish child, and the music I got into first tended to be heavy on easy-to-hear lyrics and storytelling--Elton, but also folks like James Taylor. I think another reason was because the kids at my mostly White school who seemed to be into this music were in groups I was not a part of. That was just not who my own similar peers were into. (And actually it was my 2 guitar-playing uncles who got me into the likes of Yes and Led Zepplin.)

Gena, I can relate to the idea about not "fessing up" to listening to some stations. Some friends and I have sort of a listerve "meme" where we confess to each other the songs that other African Americans would be most surprised to hear we love. There has been a HUGE range of artists, songs, and genres during these discussions. So I guess in the end here are likely more Black folks who are/were "into" this music than would actually enjoy it publicly...

Anyway, great topic!

Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast ( http://blog.lib.umn.edu/perry032/impossible/ )

Gena Haskett 6 pts

When I was coming up there was only AM radio until the early 70s,.

I lived in a major urban area but you had a diversity of content. You had a heck of a lot of good music being produced and exposed to consumers. Not talking about the dreck that is currently promoted as R&B and Soul music of the time.

You had one hit wonders, experimenters and regional favorites that didn't go national. So the creativity and experimentation was always there but Philly didn't know what Atlanta was grooving on and California didn't know what Houston was doing.

Many of the black AM radio stations had a mandatory sign-off at sundown. This meant that either you pulled out your 45s and LPs or you tuned into the white radio stations.

You didn't tell anybody that you tuned into the white radio stations. Some of them were bubble gum pop and some of them had a mixture of pop, rock and similar music.

When FM came along you had a merger of both Rock and progressive soul bands like Maxane, Chamber Brothers and a bunch more. That lasted for about two years and then you had hard rock separated from progressive soul as the stations started to market and program to their respective audiences.

Folks were still listening to each other stations but you still didn't fess up to it.

The women rockers have it much harder now. If they just want to promote their musics mainstream companies don't want them unless they look good in a pair of Daisy Dukes. And if the music isn't package into existing formats (Hip Hop) so called urban radio will not play anything that deviates from the format.

Terrestrial radio is stagnant on the verge of disintegration.

It is hard to find the artist and they have an equal hard time getting there work out to those that would be willing to take a chance.

Gena - Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com )