About

This BlogHer Spotlight was picked by the editor as a post you'd love to read. Learn more about the .

 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Blogger Racially Profiled and Strip Searched on 9/11

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

While most of the country was remembering the victims of September 11, a Midwestern mom was handcuffed and strip searched, along with two men from the Frontier Airlines flight from Denver that had just landed in Detroit.

The three did not know each other. What they had in common was their dark skin and Middle Eastern appearance. The two men were Indian, and the woman was -- half-Arab, half-Jewish -- blogger Shoshana Hebshi. All three were released without any charges.

Like any good blogger, Hebshi tweeted from the plane and wrote about her experience on her website, (quite ironically) titled Stories From the Heartland:

Someone shouted for us to place our hands on the seats in front of us, heads down. The cops ran down the aisle, stopped at my row and yelled at the three of us to get up. “Can I bring my phone?” I asked, of course. What a cliffhanger for my Twitter followers! No, one of the cops said, grabbing my arm a little harder than I would have liked. He slapped metal cuffs on my wrists and pushed me off the plane. The three of us, two Indian men living in the Detroit metro area, and me, a half-Arab, half-Jewish housewife living in suburban Ohio, were being detained.


handcuffs

Read more from Blogger Racially Profiled and Strip Searched on 9/11 at Stories From the Heartland

  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
rooftopshouter 5 pts

I am surprised so many people are "shocked" and "appalled". This is the country we live in - and have brought on ourselves. We are obsessively paranoid. We are mercilessly racist. We tolerate the unthinkable. We express shock and horror - but what do we do about it? When we live in a country where people support and believe people like Rick Perry and Michelle Bachmann, where Ron Paul can make wild allegations and not one reporter calls him on it. When we ignore the abrogation of our rights to a point where we simply don't have any. Where the FBI reports that in 2009 over 13.5 MILLION Americans were arrested.

What happened to Shoshanah Hebshi can happen next week to any Native American or Latina (and does in Arizona) because of racial profiling. We don't have any rights, people. I speak 5 languages two of which are Middle Eastern. Overhead in a coffee shop speaking Hebrew or Arabic with my friends, I can be arrested and held too - because the person in the next booth doesn't know what I'm talking about and "it's better to be careful" than not.

What's more frightening? A group of dark eyed, dark skinned students sitting in a booth in a coffee shop speaking a language no one around them understands - say Urdu - or a politician who believes that the rapture is just around the corner and who would willingly get us into an end of days war because it will hasten the second coming. Sadly most Americans today would say the former.

I am not surprised by any of this. Profoundly saddened. Yes. But shocked - no.

Grace Hwang Lynch 19 pts

rooftopshouter I have to agree that I'm not that surprised. Appalled and saddened, yes, but I think this happens more often than we know.

They just happened to pick on a blogger, who very eloquently and effectively told the world about her experiences.

Polish Mama on the Prairie 8 pts

I'm sorry. That doesn't do you any good. But I am sorry, nonetheless.

I tried to put myself into the shoes of a fellow passengar. Let's say I'm paranoid, clueless about various ethnicities, a moron. Let's say I have no idea about using cell phones in safe mode on planes. Let's say I have no clue that there can be people of different color all sitting in the same row on an airplane purely by coincidence. Let's say I have no clue that people can go to the bathroom as is their god given right. Then, yeah, I could see why that moron would call about suspicious activity.

I'm sorry there are morons in the world. Please share your story so that others can see and perhaps learn.

That being said, I hope the FBI are not blamed for this, they just respond to a call. And that ignorant comment about being from the desert means you are used to heat? Wow. Just wow. That was so idiotic. I'm sorry about him. That kind of mentality does not make our nation safer.

ajwilson412 5 pts

Wow, I want to say that I can't believe this happened to you but I can. It makes me so sad and actually brings tears to my eyes to know this was your experience. This is scary. I understand safety, etc. but 1. you're an American citizen and you have the same rights everyone else has and 2. Even if you weren't, you're still a human being. I'm glad they weren't worse than that; however, I think they weren't only because you managed to not freak out and suppressed your emotions. You're so strong because I would've been crying and screaming that I couldn't call a family member and that would've gotten me into trouble. You're INCREDIBLY brave and intelligent for how you handled this and I'm SO glad you posted this! I will share this story with everyone I know. You need to be heard! :) Thank you for posting this and my heart is with you and your family!

Patton 7 pts

People should get worked up about it. In some people's world it happens a lot. Question is what can be done about it.

EveMoon 5 pts

To Shoshana: I know that a "sorry" from a stranger doesn't fix anything as nothing can take back your such a horrible experience, but I'm so sorry that you the others were put through all of that.

Conversation from Facebook

Danielle Barnsley-Cervo
Danielle Barnsley-Cervo

cin, the passengers WERE paranoid, racist assholes. Not a good enough reason in my books, whatever day it would be to strip search people based on their ethnicity. Substantiated reason to strip search? Go for it, but based on some paranoid asshole? Not good enough. There is a fine line between security, and abusing that security.

Danielle Barnsley-Cervo
Danielle Barnsley-Cervo

That article makes me sad on so many levels. Outrageous! Although, I'm shocked at the comments; racism is still wide and rampant, and now we're cloaking it under "freedom" and "safety". Disgusting.

Funkidivagirl.com
Funkidivagirl.com

Yes, I read the article and I'm outraged!

Linda Hudrick
Linda Hudrick

This is seriously outrageous! I feel for the three "victims", what happened to innocent until proven guilty? To be detained is one thing, but strip searched that is appalling!

Renee Parmelee
Renee Parmelee

I'm in shock that's all I can say.

Cin Langston
Cin Langston

I heard about it. It stinks that this is where we are in our society but it's not really a nightmare. We all know that being strip searched is a possibility when we fly these days. I don't mean to sound cold, but it was the anniversary of 9-11 and even if the passengers who complained were complete paranoid assholes - the risk in not taking concerns seriously is too great. Does the system need to be tweaked? perhaps. But let's not get people worked up in the other direction.

Kate Dickman
Kate Dickman

Oh my God... I am shocked! This is absolutely APPALLING.