Bio
Laina Dawes is a contributing editor for Blogher and is also a music journalist whose writings can be found at Exclaim! Canada and...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Bloggers at the Democratic National Convention – Is it an accurate representation?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

The Democratic National Convention Committee (DNCC) started taking applicationsfor blogger credentials to attend the National Convention in December. The amount of bloggers the DNCC granted credentials to have expanded from other cycles and more importantly, there was an addition of selecting one blogger from each state and territory to ensure that blogs that covered local politics would be adequately represented. In addition there is the selection of the general bloggers pool, which consists of video and ‘niche’ bloggers – those who do not specifically write about politics. But as soon as the list of selected bloggers was released, the problems started.

As with any type of contest the people who are not selected are bound to be upset, but in this case, especially in this historical election, issues of race, gender and the media’s influence has greatly affected the nomination, it seems as though the DNCC is being a bit wary.

It has been reported that many bloggers, even those who were selected but questioned why some in their blogging community were not have started to ask questions about the DNC selection process. Some feel that there is a bias against those who posted content that is critical of the Democratic party and some feel that the selected bloggers are simply da facto spokespersons for the party. Others wondered why some blogs were picked as according to the blog selection process, the selections were based on readership, Internet ratings and most importantly, posts that centered on the local and state politics where the bloggers reside.

However, Daily Kosdoesn’t quite agree that those requirements were necessarily practiced in the selection process:

In New Jersey, the inimitable Blue Jersey got passed over for PolitickerNJ -- a non-partisan, corporate owned site run by the guys who own the New York Observer. Somehow, I doubt that's inline with the spirit of Dean's 50-state strategy, online organizing, or being agents of change.In Alabama, Left in Alabama was passed over, as was Cotton Mouth in Mississippi, passed over in favor of a site, Natchez Blog, devoted to Natchez MS, population 18,000 -- a site, by the way, that didn't have a single post or action alert on the MS-01 special election we won last week. Cotton Mouth was one of the best resources on that race (and the Senate race as well).

From Cotton Mouth:

We at Cotton Mouth must disagree with the selection of The Natchez Blog to represent Mississippi’s blogging community in Denver. We like and respect Casey Ann who in addition to writing there has posted on Cotton Mouth, but her blog should not have been selected over Cotton Mouth. We’ve had 33 posts so far THIS WEEK. The Natchez blog has had 24 posts so far THIS YEAR.

As well, the lack of diversity in the first selection of bloggers (the second selection of bloggers will be released at the end of this month) as also raised a few eyebrows. From the Dallas News:

But some members of the self-titled “afrosphere” — blogs written or published by African Americans — are angry that the “State Blogger Corps” appears to be mostly white, particularly since the party appears poise to nominate a black candidate, Barack Obama, for president. “OK, folks, black bloggers to the back of the bus,” read the headline on the African American Political Pundit blog. Party leaders said the factors in determining state bloggers were readership, Internet ratings and focus on local and state politics, not race. The Texas representative, the Burnt Orange Report, has several writers, including at least one Hispanic contributor.

This article raises a salient point. What constitutes as a black blogger? The DNC application does not request the ethnicity of the applicant, and not everyone’s blog name or username reveals their racial identity. But because there are specific criteria that are being used, the selection committee is looking at every applicant, so by reading the contents and reviewing the links if the blogger does write –even occasionally about race and ethnicity, they will find it. However, because the expected Democratic Nominee is African-American the other candidate is a woman, is there a presumption that there should be an attempt

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

A friend just fowarded me this WaPo article ( http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/artic... ) today about the issue.  Don't you love it when you're ahead of the MSM? (okay had to say that! sorry!) 

Jill
Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

DrumsNWhistles 5 pts

The bloggers announced last week are those who are embedded with the delegations.  There are still many others waiting for general credentials.

 When many bloggers are applying for one slot, it's expected that someone will feel slighted. I didn't even apply for the embedded blogger slot, mostly because the focus of my blog is not on state politics, but national.  It makes sense to embed state bloggers with state delegations.

 I've subscribed to many of the bloggers embedded, including the Calitics blog (the California selection for state blogger), and they're all excellent.  

karoli

odd time signatures ( http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ ) (life)
bang the drum ( http://politics.drumsnwhistles.com/ ) (politics)

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

Hmm - this is kind of off topic but I wonder whether quotas have ever served a good purpose - I don't know - I've NEVER studied them - I don't really know what I'm talking about - but what I'm curious about is whether we'd be better off if we never had that word - or that it's gotten mangled or something.  The linguistics of diversity really fascinate me - probably because I don't know anything really about it. ;)

Jill
Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

Elisa Camahort 8 pts

"“Do we want to include certain blogs of poor quality to fill a sort of quota? No, that would be ridiculous.”"

Who was suggesting that? Whoever says: we need more diversity represented, and we don't care about quality to get it.

People who make that argument betray their bias that there aren't quality diverse bloggers to be found. but I bet most of them haven't even LOOKED. The just assume a minority or woman blogger couldn't be as strong.

The point is to go find quality diverse voices.

Grrrr. Makes my head explode every single time.

Elisa Camahort
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.org

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

But I'm already kind of an outcast in the Ohio sphere as only one of a very few women political bloggers.

There are a couple here in Ohio that didn't get chosen and they are pursuing a  "who's blog is bigger" contest - it is absolutely ridiculous! While, meantime, not one single top blog has minorities involved at the top - women or POC.  And this is Ohio - where we definitely have women and we definitely have people of color - but all they are whining about is who has more traffic - it's nuts. 

The blogger who was selected at least called me and said, please, we need you as a woman etc. If there is a way I can include you, let's do it.  But I really can't go.

Anyway - I think you are right and others are right to be concerned -but that one instance with the female blogger v. the minority female blogger noted in the Dallas news - that's a tough one.  Nice that it doesn't get nasty.  Trust - we have to TRUST. But it's hard, I know that.

I hope you get to BlogHer and we can meet. 

Oh - and jimi - well - we couldn't be more different in a lot of ways - I have to get him to translate his hiphop writing for me!  But oddly, the very same person got us started in writing and she is in fact getting an award this year from the National Assn of Black Journalists.  So that is kind of cool. 

Jill
Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

lainad 5 pts

I'm afraid to see what happens if there are not more POC bloggers given passes at the end of the month.....

Jimi is cool. I disagree with him most of the time but he was one of the first bloggers I started to follow when I started blogging in 2003.

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

Hi Laina - I didn't apply and I don't know how many from Ohio applied but I'm satisfied that the one that was chosen for Ohio is a good choice.  You can find out more about the discontent among some Ohio bloggers here ( http://www.buckeyestateblog.com/im_madder_than_a_b... ) if you're interested. 

But I definitely wondered how many of the 55 already named are written by women and how many by other  minorities, and what should the breakdown be.  I don't know that there are any easy answers.  You are right - we'll have to see what happens at the end of the month.

By the way, I worked with jimi izrael on a writing project a few years back - we're still in touch once in a while.  Glad to see him on your blogroll! 

Jill
Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )