Bio
I'm interested in technology, web education, and writing. I create a daily writing prompt at First 50 Words and write about web education and web tec...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Bloggers React to Google Plus

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 36
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Google+. Right now it's a limited field trial and it's invitation only. Naturally, the folks who got invited early are excited to let the world know what they think. Ah, the thrill of being first. Pretty effective buzz building technique, is it not? (People who didn't get invited to the first round are actually paying $20 for an invitation on eBay.)

google plus

Most bloggers are thinking positive on Google+.

Jessica Wallin asks, Is Google+ the New Facebook?.

The thing I like about Google+ best, though, is that it’s a little bit more private than Facebook…and I’m not just saying that because I only have one contact right now. What I mean is, you group your contacts into “circles”…friends, family, work, etc. You can choose to whom you share what. Honestly, I’m tired of having to watch what I say on Facebook, worried that some person I went to church with 25 years ago might get offended. Not to say that I’m some huge potty-mouth or anything, but do you really want your parents and coworkers knowing all of the details of your personal life? With Google+, you can post those drunken Saturday night pictures without worrying your boss or your mom will see them. And I really like that, even though I never post drunken Saturday night pictures.

At Technology for Moms, it's Checking Out Google+ (Review). Sarah mentions both the good and the bad. A good point:

So the things I like about Google+ so far is definitely the circles. Very easy to add people and compartmentalize them. I really like how in my profile I can add all of the places I’ve lived, which is quite a few, and see it on a map. If someone is looking for me, and they knew me from when I lived in Florida, they can see on my map, yep, this is the same Sarah that lived in Florida.

I also like how I can easily view updates from just specific people in those circles. On the main page you can click on “Friends” and only view updates and links from those people who you have included in your Friends circle.

GeekMom Jules wrote Google+: My First Impressions.

The thing that has me most excited about Google+ is that I have complete control over how my content is shared. If I want only one person to see a status update, then I can specify that. If I only want one circle to see it, then I can specify that. I can also specify multiple circles, all circles or the entire world by having the update posted to my public profile. For me, this is the best feature! This means that I can open up my Google+ to the entire world and still maintain my privacy; something I can’t do on Facebook.

There are other nifty features such as chat, group collaborations i.e. “hangouts,” and “Sparks,” which are like Google alerts based on interests that you specify. You can +1 individual updates, you can share them and comment on them, you can even edit your updates and comments after you post them. This last feature also greatly excites me.

Another feature that WordPress users will probably grok the most is the toolbar at the top of Google+. It is very much like the admin bar in WordPress. It is automatically integrated into any Google page, including search, allowing you easy access to all your Google tools.

At But You're a Girl, Adria walks us through her explorations of the interface in a video that records her instant reactions in Google+ First Look Video. Here's just one of the videos from her review – go to But You're a Girl for more.

Amy Gahran from contentious.com posted Google+, Facebook & mobile. She talked about the review of Google+ she wrote for CNN, and added,

Clearly Google+ is going head-to-head against Facebook, and I think it has a decent chance of winning in the long run, especially if it includes good mobile integration of core Google services like calendar, Gmail, and docs.

CIO.com lists 9 Reasons to Switch from Facebook to Google+. The number one reason? Integration with Google Services.

Have you been able to give it a try? What did you think?

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher and First 50 Words.

  • 36
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

Lifehacker published a cheat sheet for Google+ that might clear up some of your confusion.

http://lifehacker.com/5820794/the-google%252B-chea... ( http://lifehacker.com/5820794/the-google%252B-chea... )

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) and First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com ).

Denise 9 pts moderator

Liz said she invited everyone at BlogHer whose emails she could scare up at first glance.

Which makes sense to me - when you first join, it gives you a group of people who it thinks you might add. So I went through their recommendations, adding people to various circles. After awhile, I got tired of it and quit.

So no, I didn't invite everyone whose emails I had (from any of my "circles".)

If you've got a really big contact list, it can be pretty easy to not invite everyone -- or miss people who you might want to invite.

I'd be happy to invite you now - just in case you haven't already received an invite.

Anyone else need an invite? I'm not really using Google+ but I'm happy to invite folks. Just holler!

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

carrieactually 5 pts

the group video chat is the biggest draw for me right now. some of us blogher events team people have been trying to figure out how to have a free group video chat for months now.

BlogHer Marketing Coordinator Carrie Winegarden (@carrieactually ( http://twitter.com/carrieactually )) blogs at Carrie Actually ( http://carrieactually.com ) and Kuchen Together ( http://kuchentogether.com ).

niseag03 5 pts

I think for me, I'm just overwhelmed and a little annoyed to have yet another social media platform to figure out and understand.

I've tinkered with Google+... I think I'll end up using it to focus my contact with other bloggers and anyone who is an "Internets Geek" like me. But, I'll be keeping my loyalty to Facebook for awhile.

I use Facebook Friend Groups heavily. I probably have upwards of 20 groups for organizing my friends list. I filter status updates, etc. based on those groups. Photo albums as well. I can filter my wall feed based on those groups as well. (Not to mention filter the wall to just photos or links or events, etc.) So Google+ Circles, frankly, have yet to impress me.

I've worked hard to build my footprint and nest in Facebook, and that's not something I'll give up easily. I'm going to continue to tinker with Google+... perhaps it'll grow on me. I will say I DO like Huddle. And their Android app rocks. I suspect my more tech savvy contacts will migrate over there and be another venue for contact with them. Past that... ehhh... only time will tell. But for now, my loyalty will remain with FB.

Denise
Musician's Widow ( http://www.musicianswidow.com )

PhotoHand 5 pts

I like the feel of Google+ The design is not geeky in comparison to Facebook's design. So far there are no annoying games, fake psychological tests or virtual farmers in sight.

It's also convenient to have the links to Gmail, Google Documents and Google Calendar in the same place accessible with the same login.

matersum 5 pts

I'm not yet on Google+, but I can't wait to try! I've noticed a lot of people's comments are about who sees what... by adding people to specific circles. But can Facebook not do that as well by adding people to Lists and making photos/status updates/etc available only to the people on those lists? As I said, I'm not on Google+ yet so I can't actually compare. Any thoughts on this would be helpful!!

------------------------@matersum
) http://www.matersum.com

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

feature will be a big deal for lots of reasons - group chats are just a start.

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) and First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com ).

tinagleisner 5 pts

Thanks for confirming that circles are just a newer, better interface, for Facebook type groups ... as you'd expect when it's being delivered 2+ years later.

~~ Tina Gleisner, helping women create home to support lifestyles at Home Tips 4 Women ( http://www.hometips4women.com )

tinagleisner 5 pts

I watched the recommended video by Adria and I can see that Google+ makes it easier to manage circles vs Facebook groups which I've not used much ... but aren't they about the same functionality?

What seems a little odd is everyone mentioning lack of privacy on Facebook but how much do you trust Google? I won't use gmail because they're mining that data, and not wild about Google docs. More important, I'm still angry that I can't recover my gmail address & have so many gmail accounts because of Google games like they're now playing with YouTube ... it's all nuts!

~~ Tina Gleisner, helping women create home to support lifestyles at Home Tips 4 Women ( http://www.hometips4women.com )

Valbee 5 pts

Personally, I think it's less complicated than Facebook, once you're actually in. I sent an invitation to my mom and was walking her through it on Skype. It was a little frustrating at first, but once she managed to add me to a circle, she was cruising right along.

I started a hangout with her and my son last night and we spent a half hour video chatting. THAT was very cool and we found the quality to be better than Skype has been lately. I suspect we'll use this feature quite a bit, since we're all scattered.

I love the circles. I love the circles a lot.

And wow, this is my first comment on BlogHer in forever, so this MUST be a big deal. :)

Disorderly Conduct ( http://www.infovirtuoso.com/blog )

Liz Henry 5 pts

I invited everyone at BlogHer whose email I could scare up on first glance and am pretty sure I sent you one! I could try again.

-----------------
Liz Henry
Composite: Tech & Poetics ( http://bookmaniac.com/ )
Badgermama ( http://badgermama.com )

Liz Henry 5 pts

If you use Chrome for your browser, there's an extension that hides that notification...

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/ogcfegji...

It's so tempting to click on it when it updates!

But I just can't!

-----------------
Liz Henry
Composite: Tech & Poetics ( http://bookmaniac.com/ )
Badgermama ( http://badgermama.com )

Liz Henry 5 pts

I really like it... WAY too much. I'm seeing incredibly good and deep online conversations!

Add me if you're on there, +Liz Henry and feel free to drop me a note saying you're from BlogHer!

8-)

-----------------
Liz Henry
Composite: Tech & Poetics ( http://bookmaniac.com/ )
Badgermama ( http://badgermama.com )

Denise 9 pts moderator

And I invited you both this afternoon. I never dreamed y'all wouldn't have an invite or I'd have done it sooner.

Y'all should always buzz me and ask, lol.

:-)

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

Natalie Conrad 5 pts

I had heard "whispers" about Google +. Thanks for putting together these reviews. How does one go about getting invited so I can check it out for myself?

All the best,

Natalie Conrad

www.OrganizedHabits.com

carrieactually 5 pts

i got one this morning and then i invited virginia :)

BlogHer Marketing Coordinator Carrie Winegarden (@carrieactually ( http://twitter.com/carrieactually )) blogs at Carrie Actually ( http://carrieactually.com ) and Kuchen Together ( http://kuchentogether.com ).

Denise 9 pts moderator

Do y'all really not have an invite?

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

TessGilesMarshall 5 pts

I really do want to have a play with Google+ but like others have concerns about yet another social media "must have". I think that if I love G+, I would run in tandem with FB for a while then drop one.

But my main concern about it is around eggs and baskets. If I put almost all my social media investment into Google (I'm already on gmail, calendar etc) then they will have access to pretty much every piece of my information. Which clearly is part of their plan! That concerns me.

Tess Giles Marshall

Pilgrim's Moon - women growing older on our own terms ( http://www.pilgrimsmoon.com )

It's only too late if you don't start now - Barbara Sher

Lisa Stone 6 pts

Mashadutoit, you have nailed why I love Google+ and don't love (UNlove?) Facebook.

Seriously, so much so that I just posted on it:

http://www.blogher.com/whos-real-you-google-vs-fac...

The noise of everyone together on Facebook has always made me feel as though I could never give proper attention to any one community. It's a mom thing for me, sure, but it's also a work thing. More at that link.

Lisa Stone, BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/politics-news ).

outlawserenade 5 pts

I'm still not impressed with it. First thing I noticed is: although I use Chrome, there is no shortcut for it, or any other google services for that matter. I am also a bit miffed at google for disconnecting my other (gmail) emails that previously were forwarded to one address. Even after I re-forwarded the two addresses, I still need to open each e-mails individually. >.<

By the way, it's now 'over capacity' - and not accepting new signups. But if you still want one, drop me your e-mail & I'll send you an invite.

Whiiich... brings me to another thing I do NOT like: In facebook, I hardly e-mailed those in my lists (plural, yes, I have like 20+ lists of people). I don't e-mail people at random because I prefer my mailbox to be free of spam/solicitations.

In FB, I don't even need to show my email address. If people want to contact me, they can do so through my FB inbox. In G+, it's mandatory for them to know my e-mail address. Let's just put it this way: if you're not in my e-mail address book, that means I'VE never e-mailed you for a reason - probably a good one. So I'm not quite thrilled at this, at all.

On the contrary, it's challenging to find people's e-mails in the 'add friend' page. You get the name of the person in a box, a box that's supposedly for photo (which will have one if the person has a google profile), and that's it. For someone like me, whose friends has personal *and* work e-mails, it's annoying having to take a (near) literal guess on which box I should add to which circle.

'S'all I can think of for now..

outlawserenade 5 pts

Actually, you *can* make 'circle'-like groups in facebook. I have about 20 groups: school friends divided to about four or five, families also at 4 (mom's side, dad's side, etc), colleagues, online friends, and so on and so forth. If I want a photo/photo album to be shown only to a group, the photo uploader *has* the option to customize to the point where you can show it only to one person. As are the newsfeed/link/status updates.

It's not hidden, either, it's right there on your friends' page where you can see the button to 'Manage your Friends' List'. When you make a status update/link/photo album/uploads, it's right next to the 'submit' button.

freeismylife 5 pts

I just got in yesterday and created a few circles and found that a lot of people that I know from blogging are already using it. As with any new product, only time will tell how it plays out. I know the good and bad with Facebook. It will be interesting see how Google intergrates with tool with all the rest that they own. If they do it well, they could take over the world.

Rita Arens 7 pts

I have been sticking people who add me to their circles in my circles if I have actually spoken to them before. So far I'm only seeing bloggy friends and acquaintances, not my family or anything like that, which makes sense if it's in beta with a limited release. I haven't looked to see what anyone is saying because I, too, frequently feel like I don't keep up at all on Facebook or LinkedIn and OMG now there is another thing? I need to go read blogs! And books!

But, that said, I'm interested in any tool that will help me get the word out about projects or pieces of writing that are important to me, so this seems like a pretty decent amplification device.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy ( http://bit.ly/Qp0sS ) and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

mashadutoit 5 pts

Apart from using circles to control who can see what you share, you can also use them to filter what **you** see yourself.

So for example, I have a big circle of people I follow - and if I click on that "circle stream" I see EVERYONE'S posts. There is so much in this stream that I see some of it, miss some of it, no problem.

But I also have a smaller circle of people that I really want to keep up with. That means I can click on that "circle stream" when I want to see only those people's posts. Makes it SO much easier to keep track of the really useful people out there.

mashadutoit 5 pts

On Facebook, you can only control how your groups of friends see your content on a global level - and in G+ you have much finer control.

For example, in Facebook you can put your colleagues in one list, and your friends in another. Then you can specify that your colleagues cannot see your photo albums, and your friends can. Or that your friends can see certain of your personal details, but your colleagues cannot. But you cannot specify that your colleagues can see a particular status update, and your friends cannot. It's all of them, or nothing.

In G+, you can put your friends and colleagues in separate circles. Then, **every time** you post a comment, a photo, etc, you can choose whether that particular interaction is visible to a particular circle. And while that sounds cumbersome, the interface makes it possible to do this really easily.

Also - the process of putting people into circles in G+ is a lot more user friendly than the friends lists in Facebook are. Essentially, you cannot follow somebody in G+ without putting them in a circle, and the interface is very fluid and easy to use.

Facebook friends lists are something you need to remember to go and maintain, and I suspect that very few people use them in the first place because they are sort of "hidden" compared to G+'s circles.

From what I've seen, G+ has put the idea that you need to share content differently with different people at the very basis of their design, and Facebook's is sort of added on to the end and consequently, the G+'s is a lot more effective.

KatiesPickles 5 pts

You can make "circles" on Facebook too... Do people not know this?

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

It will be interesting to see if you take to it later, since you are into Google already.

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) and First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com ).

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

"I don't connect to a lot of people, so the circle thingie is no big deal for me."

I'm thinking the same thing about myself.

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) and First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com ).

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

including me.

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) and First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com ).

outlawserenade 5 pts

Am still not quite impressed by it. As a long time user of google services (gmail is my life-savior, hands down), I'm yet to be impressed by G+. That integrated user bar has been there for a while, though, it's nothing new.

Am also still not seeing where the heck do those +1s I gave out supposed to show. In facebook, my wall would show whenever I 'liked' a blog/page/news.

I would also like to point out that FB *does* have the option on limited sharing & grouping of people.

nellewrites 6 pts

given Google is in the information business, I don't think anything there is truly private.

First impressions... more complicated to use, and that will weed out 75% of FB's users. Only us dedicated internet aficionados will mess with it. Still, 25% of 500 million is a big number.

I don't connect to a lot of people, so the circle thingie is no big deal for me. If you have many hundreds of friends on FB, then it will work for you. For those of us under 100, not so much.

The tethering it to gmail is a big drawback in my mind, since I refuse to have anything to do with gmail.

Bringing in others is not easy. You can import from Yahoo and Hotmail, but I was gone for two years... whatever contacts were in Hotmail evaporated during that time, removed by MS policy on inactivity. I could import my email contacts into messenger and then into Google plus, but... that is a painful path to take for most.

What bothers me most about Google is as with blogger, you can check out anytime you like, but you can never leave. You can remove content for display, but they've got it indexed and cached.

I know people will like the +1, but it does nothing for me. If someone says 'hey this is interesing' and that rec is displayed, I'll check it out. I have no interest in checking out +1 scores, or accumulated recommendations. I'll find my own way, because exploration is half the fun. When I use 'like' on FB, it isn't to accumulate like points or tell someone else 'hey, I like this!' it is to tell the person and creator of what I like that I like it... personal feedback from me to them (which is why stumbleupon does nothing for me as well.)

I know, I know, grouchy old fart ;-) It isn't bad, and I'll play with it some, but a replacement for FB? Not happening.

nellewrites ( http://nellewrites.net/ )

carrieactually 5 pts

i'm still wishing for an invite...

BlogHer Marketing Coordinator Carrie Winegarden (@carrieactually ( http://twitter.com/carrieactually )) blogs at Carrie Actually ( http://carrieactually.com ) and Kuchen Together ( http://kuchentogether.com ).

mashadutoit 5 pts

One thing though, is it is very easy to get distracted. There is that little red number above your email - and when I'm working, I usually have my mail open...maybe a habit I will have to change.

I've set up mail filters to route all the G+ updates so they dont show up in my inbox, otherwise that could get really annoying.

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

That's exactly what I wondered: is this going to be one more thing that must-be-done in social media just because the rest of the world is there?

I'm thinking it might. As I've continued to read reviews published since I collected the ones above, they remain positive. With reviews like that, people are going to go there in large numbers as soon as it opens up.

Virginia DeBolt, BlogHer Section Editor for Tech
virginia.debolt@blogher.com

Virginia blogs at Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) and First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com ).

mashadutoit 5 pts

Just got in yesterday. Love the circles too :)

Am feeling a little social media fatigue though. Do I move to this as my main place, or keep the other places going too?

I love Buzz, and this seems to have the good stuff that Buzz has with more besides.