BlogHer of the Week: Sweetney

I am not a mom. I never wanted to be a mom. I'm nearly 45 years old, and that biological clock never kicked in. Of course, Lisa is a mom. And Jory is still contemplating motherhood.

Despite our different experiences and different perspectives, we all read Sweetney's post Self(ish) and found it deeply affecting and compelling.

For me, it's that Tracey articulates much of what I thought (and feared) about parenthood. I long ago made the decision I was indeed too selfish to be a parent, but I didn't mean "selfish" exactly. I think I meant that I thought I had a big enough job taking care of my life and all that I was always trying to accomplish. And I never changed my mind. When she writes about the energy it takes to take care of a child, it sounds exactly like what I feel when I imagine being my sister with her two kids, and just imagining it is completely overwhelming to me:

The things she wants, the energy she needs, her questions that require answers, the endless barrage of busywork and errands related to taking care of another, much-less-able human being, is just so, so exhausting. And by "exhausting" I don't even mean tiring or physically draining. I mean that, in my case at least, it exhausts ME, who I am. That it drains not just energy from me, but my sense of self, whatever it is I've come over the course of 38 years to think of as my identity, and the integrity of my mind.

Of course that's not the whole story. There is the overwhelming love too:

The love I feel for my daughter is enormous. I can't even wrap my head around that kind of love sometimes, it's so big. And its profundity is what has kept me going even when I've been mired in the blackest tar pit of depression -- it is the infallible engine inside me that will not quit even when my spirit collapses.

If I had to name only one thing that I, as a non-mom, have observed MommyBlogging accomplishing, it would be this: It has given some women permission to acknowledge and honor their entire mothering experience. Not just the deep love and heart-gripping joy, but also the self-doubts, the frustrations, the exhaustion.

This has permeated beyond the blogosphere, by the way. When I used to state my lack of intention to have kids, no one accepted it and moved on; everyone had something to say. But in the last few years I've heard more and more moms tell me that it's a lot of hard work. Rewarding work, but hard work, and if I didn't think it was for me...that was probably OK.

I believe it is writers like Tracey from Sweetney that have paved the way for more women to be more honest about the entirety of their parenting experience and perspective. Tracey captures the bitter and the sweet, sometimes all in one paragraph:

Of course I don't blame my daughter for any of this. She was and is beautiful and perfect, and I very much wanted her, and I would do everything again to have her here with me now. I do wonder though if any of it could have been different for me, or if the part of me that holds the equipment necessary to being a mother is simply broken, damaged, incomplete.

That is her absolute heart-tugging truth right there. And it's why Tracey from Sweetney is our BlogHer of the Week.

Thanks to everyone for continuing to send in your nominated posts. Remember to nominate individual posts, not entire blogs, and keep them coming!

Best,
Elisa

For Elisa, Jory and Lisa
BlogHer Co-founders

Comments

48 yrs old and no mommy DNA whatsoever

I am gratified to read that I'm not the only one whose biological clock is MIA.  I have NEVER felt the call to mommyhood.  I am childless and single by choice.  I too knew from the beginning that I would be too self-ish for children - I understood that one must subjugate one's very self in order to properly raise children, and I didn't want to do it, period.

 I'm happy to hear that there are more like me.  It's a difficult road, sometimes - but it's MY road, and no one else's, which is what matters most to me.  I make all the decisions.   If that makes me selfish, so be it; at least I knew better. 

 I do think we need to form a society and stick together.  It can be rough out there.  The companionship of women is important to me, but I don't know anyone else like me, so inevitably a chasm opens between us that is filled with husbands and children and all the trappings thereof - all those things to which I cannot relate.  I wish I knew more women like me.

 Tink *~*~*

My Mobile Adventures *~*~*

 

We Are Not Alone

Great post! Motherhood can indeed be draining. What has been hard for me is the guilt over having such feelings, so hearing that others feel the same way is quite comforting.

 

Well deserved

Really great pick - Tracey knocked it out of the park with this post! I've often thought very similar things, but wouldn't have been able to put it together so sensitively.  

 

 

Seriously?

I find it so odd (and more than a little disturbing) that a woman that decides not to have children is determined to be "too selfish."  Seriously? Whose perscpective is this?

I, as many women, never found "Mr. Right" and I work hard support myself (and my tax dollars go to support many others' children).  I determined that having a baby in my situation would not be in the best interest of the child. Here I thought I was being responsible not bringing a child into my life just because I adore kids.

 So, Octomom is "selfless" and I am "selfish."  Go figure.

 

StuccoHouse, sounds like you're a different story

Hi StuccoHouse - sounds like in your case, you wanted children but did not find the conditions right to bring them into the world.  That's not the same thing as having more self-interest than interest in being a parent.  And anyway, "selfish" is a word that has gotten a bad rap.  All it means, to me, is that one is taking care of one's self.  That in and of itself is not bad.  It only starts to creep toward the negative when one is taking care of one's self to the exclusion of others to whom you owe care and nurturing.  One definitely cannot do that when one has children.  Also, it doesn't sound like you or me, regardless of the reasons for our childless state.

 Tink *~*~*

My Mobile Adventures *~*~*

 

Thanks

I don't know if I'm supposed to comment on this or not (how does this crazy thing work?!?), but I really want to thank everyone -- the BlogHers, and the readers -- for being so supportive about this post. I can tell you that I seriously considered not publishing it. I've been in some hot water on the internet before -- in some instances rightly so, in others very much wrongly -- but I feared how this would be taken. I went so far as to have a friend read the post before I published it to reassure me/talk me down, because I was CERTAIN its contents were either 1) Troll Bait, or 2) going to bring about all sorts of Tsk-Tsk-ing from my fellow parents. What an astonishing relief to find that so many people understood, could relate, felt the same way or at least felt sympathetic. Sometimes the internet brings out the worst in people, and I've definitely seen that. But sometimes it brings out the best, and for me this is one of those wonderfully affirming, positive moments. Which is why we're all here ultimately, right?

Thanks again, everybody.

Tracey Gaughran-Perez, aka Sweetney
CE, Entertainment & Culture
Author/Editor of Sweetney, MamaPop, & We Covet

 

If you could hear my sigh of relief!

I'm a non-parent, a choice I made mitigated by personal experience and circumstances. I blogged about it for the first time just a couple of weeks ago: http://www.thebuttercompartment.com/?p=1055  I'd made multiple attempts to write about it prior to that, but I was worried about peoples' responses because of the fervent pro-mommy culture in the diabetes community.

I've only been blogging since the summer, and in anticipation of the Chicago conference (and because I was hoping to find a roomie), I've been checking out the BlogHer forum and twitter group.  As in other realms of my life, I've felt like the oddball amongst the mommies, or mommybloggers in this case, which has been discouraging.  It's not that I didn't think they existed, but I'm just happy to find some other non-mommies here.

Blogging has united mothers and it "has given some women permission to acknowledge and honor their entire mothering experience", but based on my experience, it has yet to do the same for the rest of us, regardless of how or why we came to be childfree, which I find sad because being a woman without children is an especially isolating experience.

 

Lee Ann Thill

http://www.thebuttercompartment.com

A Lifetime of Type 1 Diabetes: War, Peace and My Mission to Help & Inspire Others

 

 

There is a childfree blogging community to check out

Lee Ann, I totally hear you.

There is a very, VERY big, active community for women who are childfree not-by-choice. Our own contributing editor Melissa has a blog roll of some 2,000 blogs around infertility and other pregnancy difficulty issues.

But here is also a childree by-choice community. I first learned of it via Teri and her Purple Women project, now ended. There's also the Childless By Choice Project. I'm sure there are tons of other blogs and sites, but those were the first two I found that pointed off in other directions.

Also, StuccoHouse: I do think there used to be a stigma of "selfishness" attached to women who chose not to have kids. And there probably still is, to some degree, and from some quarters. Not me though, that's definitely *not* what I was saying about myself or anyone else without kids!

Elisa Camahort Page
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.com

My BlogHer profile truly shows you everything I do online...Check it out!!

 

The portal of blogging...

As always, I'm a big fan of Tracey's honesty and sincerity. I hear you, Elisa -- I also think blogging has made a lot of us both more honest about our own experiences and more open-minded to other people's experiences. That's one of the greatest gifts my relationships through BlogHer have given me -- a portal into the world of single moms, gay families, single dads, not-married-but-families-anyway families, childless-by-choice couples and singles -- that portal has been extremely important to me. It's improved my life and made my political choices easier. It's made me think twice about writing mommy stuff just from a married mommy/daddy perspective. Writing honestly without crossing over into oversharing is tough, and Tracey did a great job of it in this post.

 

Rita Arens writes at Surrender Dorothy and BlogHer and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak.

 

Really gets you thinking

Elisa, thanks much for your intro to Tracey's post...there's really something to offering what the connection was / is for you....and that ties in with what I relate to well in your post Tracey....the sheer openness and honesty to just tell it.

It shouldn't make me pause anymore..how many of us seem to walk around with this silent expectation in our minds dictating we be all things to all whomever we've chosen in our lives in whatever roles we've assumed.

And it shouldn't still leave me in awe that so many find liberty in bloggin about that very issue.

But I am. Still. In awe. And gratitude for all who do.

For to me, whether you're a woman with children that you've birthed or adopted, whether you're chosing not to express the traditional role of motherhood in your life, whether you're married, partnered, single, or whatnot....we all share something that to me blogging invites almost more readily than face to face or spoken word: a desire for authenticity....a willingness to put it out there who we are and what we believe...and owning our right to do so.

There's probably other ways I can say that...softer, simply, or more authoritative and dictatorial. But the raw reality that blogging allows a window into that ownership...a glimpse at one's choices....no matter what they be, there's an invitation to connect.

You are never alone...none of us are. But that coming to the page...or screen..that writing it out and facing it and then birthing it for the blogosphere to see, it gets me every time....it's like all of us pledging to be our authentic selves and more share what's working and not working and yet being willing to stand.

So in this now way to long of a traditional comment (err mine typically are), I'll simply say this..for every time you feel 'ooh...i dunno if i should write that...maybe that's stupid..maybe that will expose too much...' blah blah blah...for being willing to face those doubts and fears and still being willing to put it out there.....thank you....thank you for your courage....your willingness to persevere, your stand. because in so doing, it gives another woman permission to do the same.

And if it takes blogging for another century,  I don't think any of us can do enough to defend the right of woman to voice herself.

Really huggin all of you and myself for being willing. To. Voice. Our. Truth. 

 

Tre~

tw:   @tresha

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

 

Most Commented this WeekMost Commented this Week

Featured PostsFeatured Posts

BlogHer NewsBlogHer News

BlogHer ConnectionsBlogHer Connections

ConferencesConferences

Upcoming
Featured Posts

BlogHer Voice of the WeekBlogHer Voice of the Week

BlogHer Voice of the Week: Seeking Elevation

Last year I went to Africa for vacation, in the Zulu region of South Africa. When I returned I didn't really have much to say. I feared any word...

Read more

Oscars 2010
Getting to 10 in 2010
BlogHer of the Week