Blog
ShortWoman
Bio
I am a research analyst and professional Realtor who writes about the Economy, the World, and other Important Things. You can find my work at ShortWo...

Penguin
Bookmarks

Top Picks


The Next Always

Nora Roberts

The Weird Sisters

Eleanor Brown

The Ideal Man

Julie Garwood
 
 

Book Club in Your Inbox


Sign up for our email newsletter!

Reading Next!

A savvy, page-turning novel about a woman torn between her husband and the man she thought she'd marry. Stay tuned for The First Husband!

Recent Comments on Book Club

 
 

The Beach Trees: "All Truths Rise to the Surface Eventually"

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 2
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Death and loss, they plague you. So do memories.

If I had to describe Karen White's The Beach Trees in two words, those words would be "surviving loss." In these pages you'll find one heirloom painting, one murder mystery, three missing women, and a whole lot of truths nobody wants to face.

Julie Holt arrives in Biloxi with a battered minivan, two suitcases, and custody of her late best friend's 5 year old son. She's come thinking she's heir to a beach house -- which was destroyed by Hurricane Katrina.

Julie soon meets Aimee Guidry, the boy's great grandmother and current matriarch of the strange but proper New Orleans family Julie's friend left behind at age 18. Aimee and Julie would both like to know why she left -- and what it has to do with a picture of Aimee's mother-in-law painted by Julie's grandfather -- but they will have to figure it out together.

There are two points of view in this novel, clearly labeled for the reader's convenience. Julie tells her story in present day Biloxi and New Orleans, amid wreckage and rebuilding from Hurricane Katrina. Aimee tells her story to Julie as remembrances from the 1950s and 1960s, until Hurricane Camille in 1969.

The trees mentioned in the title are actually along Beach Boulevard in Biloxi. Left dead after Katrina, artists have turned them into lovely sculptures that celebrate life.

I found this a compelling book, and one whose mysteries I wanted to see solved. I am very picky about book endings, and found this one largely satisfying. There is one bone that I have to pick -- not with the author but with the publisher and/or editor. I found the addition of "questions for discussion" in the last few pages to be insulting to my intelligence. I do not like leading questions that attempt to force my thoughts and opinions down a narrow corridor. Let's trust the author to tell her own story, without the assistance of some "freshman lit" essay starters. At least these pages are easily avoided. Perhaps they will be culled from future editions.

  • 2
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
sassymonkey 31 pts moderator

They are pretty common in these kinds of books. Sometimes I really HATE the questions but I think people are probably more apt to read them than an author's note and I do like the little bit of extra insight we get from the author in them.

BlogHer Book Club Host Karen Ballum also blogs at Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca ).

EmSun 6 pts

I've always loved the discussion questions at the ends of books - not because I'm unintelligent, but rather because I have found through my literature classes that people always have different insights and thoughts to such simple questions! It's one of the reasons I like reading the book reviews. I've already read it; I don't really need to know someone else's opinion. I know how I felt. However, it's interesting to see what things OTHER people took from the book and what insights they have - what twists they noticed. I like using the discussion questions as a starting point when discussing a book. If the book is at my children's age - even better! I can ask them a million questions from my brain and I still might not have come up with some that are on the discussion questions page. Just a nice starter for a conversation.

______

Jen Rothmeyer
www.emsun.org ( http://www.emsun.org )
Living life happily in small-town Mount Vernon, Iowa.