Bio
Thea Newcomb is an American broadcaster and now film maker. Marrying her Scotland-based penpal, Newcomb relocated from her native California to Gla...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Break up lines that make us say... huh?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

“I love you but I’m not in love with you”, “It’s not you, it’s me”, or how about “I just need some space”? Yes, we’ve heard them all before – haven’t we? Since launching soyouvebeendumped.com in 2000, thousands of lines have been sent into us from all four corners of the globe.

The line that inspired SYBD was given to me one Sunday night after I’d just flown from San Francisco to Glasgow. It was a delivered by a guy I’d merely dated for a few weeks. We had a lovely romantic reunion that night. I gave him loads of little presents. And later, when snuggled up in bed, he rolls over, sighs and says, “I could totally fall in love with you” which I thought was rather lovely, until he added “but I’m thinking of becoming a priest”. That was it, we were finished who wants to two-time God? (’Sad thing is, he never did become a priest and married the next girl he dated!)

TYPES OF DUMPS

Over the years it seems like dumping lines fall into less than ten categories. Some are harsh, some are martyrs, and still others are confused. There are break-up lines pertaining to families, religion, work and some are just plain unexplainable. What follows are actual lines that have been sent into us.

FAMILY DUMPS

Sometimes dumpers pass the buck and it’s the family that takes the blame. "I can see us together forever, just not with your two kids. If you didn't have them then we would have something." Or “I've decided I love you more as a sister, so I can't see you anymore.” Or “I can't go on. The stress I am getting from my mother is just too much.” Some people blame it on mothers, even more bizarrely, “I know you're not The One - because you leave the lid off the toothpaste and my mother would never do that.”

Or they make a generic excuse about their life and work –being too busy off comes up but I prefer when they cite work in more unusual ways like, "You scientists just don't understand.", "You're the philosopher, you work it out" or "It's a corporate finance thing. That's why it's so hard to do this."

THE HARSH DUMP

Some times a dumper can be down right nasty, “Did you really think we were going to get married and have children?” – was one of the more memorable lines over the years. And the rather classy, “It’s not like if we tried for the rest of our lives, you would get to be better in bed” also stood out. And “I met someone else who doesn't bore me to tears” was a bit of a cracker.

THE MARTYR DUMP

Sometimes people opt to be more of a martyr and make it seem like it’s in your best interest to call it quits, “I am breaking up with you now before you get too attached to me...so I am doing you a sort of favour, aren't I?”. Or “It's just that you might be the one for the rest of my life and I don't want to blow that by going out with you now.” Huh? A better attempt is, “I'm just not ready for you yet! You make me want to be a better man and I have to work at it!”

One similar to this was given to me - “Just give up on me, I am not worth the trouble. I am just going to be alone for the rest of my life.” Just what can you say to that?

THE RELIGIOUS DUMP

Religion can play a big part in break ups – regardless of the faith. I always liked “Even though we’ve been together for two years, you’re Jewish and I’m Catholic, what would the Pope say?" and the classic “We have religious differences...you think you are God and I don’t agree.” Let’s not leave out the, “It wasn't the will of God” line.

THE CAKE AND EAT IT DUMP

Some dumpers are rather greedy, “Can't we get divorced and still be together? I mean it's just a piece of paper....” and “Can't you just be in my life like the rest of my female friends?” or the ole chestnut, “I am not ready for a relationship, but I still want you in my life.” I especially loved “I'm confused, but I'd like to see you both - her on the weekends and you in the commuter parking lot.” Huh?

I thought I’d leave you with some of my favourites over

  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
cryssteen 5 pts

This one's not mine, but totally worth repeating.  After 2 years together, a friend of mine was fed this:  

"You're not the one, but you're ridiculously close.  I didn't mind being with you."

A few months later, he came crawling back.  What a loser. 

maryrwise 5 pts

Well, one guy didn't break up with me using a line; he used a non-verbal technique. We went out on a sort of double date. I drove, because his car was a two-seater. On the way home, he got into back seat with the other girl and made out with her all the way to her place.

Yeah, that got the message across.

The Blog: Red Nose ( http://bozoette.typepad.com ) The Book: Girl Clown ( http://www.lulu.com/content/45470 )

maryrwise 5 pts

The last guy I dated before I met my husband did that -- apparently with every girl he dated, because he used to say "I never break up with anybody; they always break up with me!" The reason became very clear when the jerkdom started.

The Blog: Red Nose ( http://bozoette.typepad.com ) The Book: Girl Clown ( http://www.lulu.com/content/45470 )

kaiteykat 5 pts

"It's not you, it's me...

Oh no wait. It is you."

Katie

www.katielewis.ca ( http://www.katielewis.ca )

JC 5 pts

When I'd gotten tired of putting up with the Peter Pan I was dating and broke things off with him, I'll never forget the line he used.  "Well, I never said I was the Christian Dior of dating."

http://www.storyrhyme.com/jcsblog

Mata H 5 pts

In college --
"I have to tell you something. Before we started dating a month ago, I slept with XX. She's pregnant.. and we're Catholic .. and I have to marry her -- BUT I don't want that to change things between US. We'll just have to lay low for a little while..not see each other for a few months.... It isn't as though I love her."

Yep. warmed right up to THAT one. (not)

~~ Contributing Editor, Mata H. also blogs right along at Time's Fool ( http://timesfool.blogspot.com )

nellewrites 6 pts

what words officially ended our marriage of 23 years and 11 months, perhaps because the helmet on my head blocked out the sound.

nelle ( http://refractivethoughts.org/ )

/

llhaesa ( http://llhaesa.org/ )

mashadutoit 5 pts

That one about the fake boobs made me laugh. That really is classic.

As for that last one of jessica's - "I cant face conflict so I'll just be a jerk till you break up with me" is probably very common!

Not a breakup line, but a girl I knew in school, who took valium to avoid epileptic fits once told me how she used it to break up with her then boyfriend. She took some before the phone call -  "It was so convenient.  I just felt so calm and peaceful".  I found that REALLY disturbing. 

jessica.schafer 5 pts

 This isn't technically a break-up line, but my "favourite" scenario went like this: guy acts like total jerk until finally I say, "this is over", he then says, "yeah, I've been thinking about breaking up for a while now, but I didn't want to hurt you."

In Between Words

http://jessicaschafer.wordpress.com

Denise 9 pts moderator

I have never been quite that "creative" when I've broken up with people.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager

Flamingo House Happenings ( http://www.flamingohouse.net/ )

Denise 9 pts moderator

Ok then. Four years? Wow.

That is harsh!

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager

Flamingo House Happenings ( http://www.flamingohouse.net/ )

washwords 5 pts

washy || http://washwords.com/words || washwords.dc@gmail.com

this is seriously one of my favorite topics:  oh let's see "I'm jsut not THERE" (which in fairness I then used on other exes) or how about "when people get to a certain age, they should be responsible for their own transportation needs" (after making me taking the train home from a baseball game HE wanted to go to, with two broken toes) or how about "let's be friends but just sleep together." these and others are featured in a series of x365 posts I'm running all this week on my blog....

http://washwords.com/words/tag/x365/

troubledcrystal 5 pts

My bf of 4 years told me: I think you're crazy and I don't think you are a very good person.

Denise 9 pts moderator

But TW says if I break up with her, she'll write a song about me (a la Audrey, Wait ( http://www.amazon.com/Audrey-Wait-Robin-Benway/dp/... )) and also she doesn't want a milk snake which has been promised to the youngest child only in the event that her mother and I break up.

Darn.

What a waste of a good break up line.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager

Flamingo House Happenings ( http://www.flamingohouse.net/ )