Broke and Childful: Middle Class Money Malaise
by Rita Arens

I recently attended the wedding of a college roommate and dear friend. It required travel, and in doing so, I was able to spend some time with my other roommates, friends I have known since we were all buying pizza with the coins we found in the ashtray of an ancient Festiva, friends who now range in professions ranging from psychologist to speech pathologist to elementary school principle. Well-educated, dual-income couples. Out of the five of us, three couples have kids. Actually, everyone but us that has kids has TWO of them.

And we’re all broke.

What gives? I have an (I’ve been told) unrealistic expectation for stability in my life. I dream that there will be a time when I won’t worry about money. I thought that was what being an adult, particularly a parent, was all about: You trade your wild spontaneity and dining-out dollars for security, company and being able to go to Target without wanting to vomit. I thought being in a two-income relationship would protect me from the financial worries I know affect many stay-at-home-moms. I thought there was a damn good reason I was doing the whole going-to-work-and-missing-the-milestones thing: MONEY. I thought in addition to contributing to more than half of our monthly bills, I would maybe have a little extra left over to buy myself something pretty. Then the daycare bill went up. Twice.

I got curious. I started broaching the delicate question of money to colleagues. It seems this is happening to everyone, whether they’re sticklers or spenders. At first I thought we were all just living hopelessly beyond our means, but then I saw this.

Here’s a quote from MSNBC’s article:

The basics, according to Warren, now take up close to three-fourths of every family's spending power (it was about 50 percent in 1973), leaving precious little left over at the end of the month — and leaving many families with no cushion in case of a job loss or health crisis.

Here’s another.

In the end, the portion of an average family’s budget spent on fixed costs like housing has risen much faster than wages and inflation, while spending on discretionary items has declined. That means mortgages, more than lattes, are the source of middle-class anxiety, says economist Jared Bernstein of the Economic Policy Institute, a generally liberal think tank that focuses on the interests of low- and middle-income Americans.

I’m not surprised. My company has great health insurance, but I just found out from a colleague it’s going up $60 a month for a couple. I have three people on mine. AWESOME. That’ll effectively eat my raise pretty quickly. Stuff like that happens every month – the daycare that costs more than 25% of my take-home salary goes up $25 a week. Property taxes reset. Open enrollment means higher health insurance rates. If you use the tax-deferred childcare account, you have to give yourself a monthly swing loan to cover the float until you get the reimbursement check. And the vise on our collective heads goes squish, squish, squish.

I’m talking about this in mommy & family instead of personal finance because the 1973 rates the MSN article quoted were based on a one-income family, and the current ones were based on a two-income family. OUCH. So both parents working doesn’t even help?

Sometimes I think about how it would be if I or my husband had five whole days a week like my mother did to do the housework, laundry, meal preparation, bill-paying, budgeting and shopping that we squeeze into nights and weekends now. I like my job, my day job, just fine, but though I would always write, I wouldn’t choose to work full-time if we didn’t need the money – not while my daughter is three. Now I’m looking at these numbers and wondering whether achieving my parents’ one-income standards are even possible by the time my daughter is in school. Will we even be able to afford childcare for another child? Would I ever be able to afford to work part-time?

So what’s the answer? I’ve done a bunch of digging in response to that depressing story (and got Warren’s book from the library), but all the really good sites seem to suggest cost-cutting efforts that involve TIME, as in the time you have when you’re not working more than 40 hours a week and then commuting on top of it. Everyone knows you can accomplish anything with enough time or enough money, and I think that in addition to low-income, working parents, the problem may have extended to the middle-class more than we realize. Time/Money. Time/Money. We’re not pissing it all away on shoes – we’re paying our bills – the same bills our parents paid on one income. What.The.Hell?

So what do we do? I’m not sure. Any ideas?

If you do have time, I highly recommend this site, written by a husband and wife team who have been debt-free for 13 years. (Yes, we all hate them.) I liked the suggestions a lot, but of course would have to stop breathing to fit in the “make your own snack food” task.

If you’re out of time like me, here are some Dancing With the Stars-based suggestions from The Frugal Duchess.

1) You're only as good as your last dance. It doesn't matter if I saved money last year or last month, the discipline of saving has to be a steady dance. You have to constantly show up and perform well every day.

2) Pace yourself. Apparently, Sabrina had an off week because she was doing so much. I've been there and I've done that. Sometimes in a push to earn lots and lots of freelance money, I over commit. I promise editors more stories with unrealistic deadlines. It becomes a lose-lose situation and I feel financially and emotionally bankrupt. And I lose points with my judges (editors).

3) Remember there are no dress rehearsals: Too often I've made serious missteps that I've later regretted. Unfortunately, there are no do-overs in life. Bottom Line: Give your best effort in the here-and-now. It's hard to repair damage on credit reports and memory accounts.

I feel that “you’re only as good as your last dance” thing, because up until we bought Chateau Travolta, we had six months of living expenses saved. Now we have the goose egg. But a good school district!

We’re trying to claw back to where we were. This month, my husband and I did what we could: We stopped eating out. At all. Not even the Costco pretzels. Only no one was home to prepare dinner. As a result, our mealtime and the little angel’s bedtime have been pushed back farther and farther. She’s waking up again at night. It pretty much stinks. We’re crabby, feeling overstrained and exhausted, so we can save money. The funny thing is that we both like to cook when there is time.

Or maybe it’s not so funny. I’m hungry, and as I write this, it’s 6:07, and I’m still working, and I’m an hour’s commute away from home.

Comments

 

A real gasser

I ache every sentence of this post. My childcare, only half time, while I work full time, is 50% of my take home pay. I have another bay due in April and between now and then Blue Shield is going up 12-15% and our gas bill is sure to skyrocket. It is such a struggle. I suppose some would say we ought not have kids if we can't afford it, I am choosing to find different ways to make ends meet. I think the birth of diaologues such as this one are a good start.

Thanks for another great post.

Amanda
http://lifewithbriar.blogspot.com
http://toddlywinks.blogspot.com

 

Makes me feel better

Glad to know it's not just me that feels this strain...

 

making it

We have to make it on 1 income. the deficit created by putting 2 kids in full time daycare and 1 in part time day care, plus the cost of work clothing and commuting would leave us in the hole every single month. I can afford 10 more kids if I stay home, but if I go back to work I'd have to sell at least 2, if not all three to gypsies.

Fidget
Finding Yourself Despite Yourself

 

Childful and Child Support

It's even more painful if your spouse has to pay child support to the tune of 25% of his gross income plus summer camp/day care when the kids are with their dad for the summer! It all makes it seem impossible to live the lives our parent's had...although, as I write this I realize my mom worked at least part time after the youngest went into kindergarten.

Helene
The Modern Woman's Divorce Guide
http://themodernwomansdivorceguide.com

 

Am there now

No wisdom, just understanding.

Busy Mom Blog
GenBetween
Career and Kids

 

it's a squeeze...

and not just in America.
in our adopted city (Canberra), two income families are the norm. childcare is booming, and increasingly scarce. the economists have invented a new term here, housing stress. it means more than a third of gross income is being spent on rent or mortgage repayment.
we have over a half a million families in australia officially in 'housing stress'.

it's not all bad news. i'm a member of an online community called Simple Savings. there's a lot of support and advice for families and everybody else, and lots and lots of time/money saving hints. but you have to have the time to read them of course...
here's the link to the American version of the site
http://www.simplesavings.net

 

I wonder what..(and a few suggestions)

I wonder what top financial adviser Suze Orman would say about this. Send your blog to her?
And..why is there a HUGE Advertising space right in the middle of your blog? Do they pay you? If they did, that might help with the budget. :)

From what I've gleamed from Suze's financial books and advice, you either have to earn more or seriously control your spending and 'pay yourself first' before the bills. That works wonders when you have leftover cash after the mortgage, I understand. Aside from buying the large pretzel bag and dividing it into portions (this I read from the site you created a link to), I have some tips that have worked for me in the past.

1) Examine your tax deductions at work. Talk to your tax person but if it's possible, increase the deductions to increase your take home pay - therefore not giving the government a loan.
2) Go to the same tax person or get one, and really take a look at your business deductions if you are writing for a living/working other than a 9-5 salaried job.
3) Make family-sized meals. A big pan of whatever you feel like that will freeze nicely. When you cook, go all out.
4) Send a financial adviser your budget and ask for tips.
5) try not to put anything on a credit card, esp. not gas, food, or consumables. transfer all cc's to 0% cards. make all of your payments on time to avoid negative credit and therefore high rates.
6) If you have a mortgage, do you have the option to take out a small equity line and pay off all debt? you can write off the equity line on your tax return and therefore get more money back. Also, the consolidation will help.
7) Make more than the min payment after you consolidate.
8) alternative childcare? nanny instead of daycare? shared nanny? relative part-time?
9) you might not like this one. you and your husband cut back alternating hours to watch the children (the idea is a little less salary but a lot less daycare money spent). Instead of a raise, negotiate less hours/same pay? this would also cut down on the gas bill.
10) I don't know where you live, but if it's expensive to live there, could you live elsewhere? you write so that may be flexible..if you wish to stay near family, is there a true benefit to do so or is it hurting you financially?
11) Do you really need a land line? Could you consolidate cable with internet, etc?
12) Have you truly identified where you are spending your money - on an annual basis? For example, a monthly budget does not include the annual car sticker fee, auto maintenance, gifts, and surprise bills. Do you budget for these expenses monthly?

I hope any of this helps,

D

 

A lot of interesting

A lot of interesting thoughts and suggestions here. I've sort of been there-done that. My five sons are all raised and gone (although one may be back to roost soon) but I now have a grandson living with me.
I commute over 50 miles one way to work, and my husband's work (bricklaying) is sporadic, so we depend on my income.

When I look at my paycheck, about 50% goes to taxes, health insurance, retirement, etc. While my income has gone up steadily as my position has advanced, I'm really no better off financially than I was when my salary was half of what it is today!

I'm one who keeps her spending down. I shop second-hand. Our mortgage is low by today's standards, and if we sold 30 acres of our land we could pay it off. We carry a lot of bills from the years we raised 5 sons and I went to college and grad school. We garden, don't eat out much or go out on weekends, except to grandchildren's events. We heat with wood, provide a lot of basic needs for ourselves (well water, septic) and stay out of stores. We're finally at a point where there is occasionally money to put into savings.

And yet...I resent seeing my paycheck disappearing before I even see it. I'm considering giving up the job that I struggled so hard to attain, and just focus on my writing and my professional storytelling career. We'd be broke again like we were 20 years ago, but I think we'd be more satsfied. I have security now, but satisfaction? That has become even more important.

Granny Sue
Stories from the Mountains and Beyond
www.grannysu.blogspot.com
susannaholstein@yahoo.com