Bio
Yes, Janssen is my real name. I live in Austin, Texas, where I revel in the warm weather year-round. I used to be an elementary school librarian in Bo...

Penguin
Bookmarks

Top Picks


The Next Always

Nora Roberts

The Weird Sisters

Eleanor Brown

The Ideal Man

Julie Garwood
 
 

Book Club in Your Inbox


Sign up for our email newsletter!

Reading Next!

A savvy, page-turning novel about a woman torn between her husband and the man she thought she'd marry. Stay tuned for The First Husband!

Recent Comments on Book Club

 
 

Caleb's Crossing: So Much More Than I Expected

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I didn’t think I read a lot of historical fiction, but when I checked Goodreads (which I use religiously), I realized I’d read 52 historical fiction books in the last four years. So, when I say that Geraldine Brooks’ new book, Caleb's Crossing, is one of the finest historical novels I’ve read in some time, I feel like I have some leg to stand on with that claim.

Some books are pretty straightforward -- you read the back cover for a summary of the plot and then you read the book which basically just fleshes out that plot. This book is nothing like that. You start out knowing that it’s about Caleb, the first Native American to graduate from Harvard University and that he’s friends with Bethia, a Puritan girl he met as a young teenager. When he goes off to Harvard, Bethia has a job as a housekeeper nearby and she watches his transformation from “salvage” to scholar. But, oh, it’s so much more than that.

The book is not just about Caleb, and it’s not just about Bethia, either. It’s about a whole rich community of people trying to figure out how to live together. It’s about individuals trying to navigate a social system that doesn’t value them. It’s about trying to make sense of histories and values that are completely different from your own. It’s about making decisions that have long-lasting consequences.

Like the very best kind of historical fiction, the story isn’t just about people who died a long time ago, but also about how humans think and feel and function in every period of history, including today.

I wouldn’t have guessed I’d have much in common with a teenage girl living over three hundred years ago, denied an education because of her sex, who could be indentured for four years at the whim of her guardian and had little say in who she married, but I found myself highlighting line after line, thinking, “Yes! Yes! I know exactly what she is talking about!”

And the fact that the writing is so beautiful doesn’t hurt, either. It’s the perfect combination of beautiful prose and gripping storyline, neither stepping on the toes of the other.

Four years ago, my mom gave me a copy of Geraldine Brooks’ book Year of Wonders and I, shamefully, never even cracked the cover. Now I’m anxious to finally read it; if Caleb’s Crossing is any indication, her books are worth every minute spent reading them.

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
kbojar 6 pts

I disagree that Brooks "imposes too much progressive thought into her historical characters."

We know so little of 17th c. women’s interior lives. I thought it was interesting that Brooks “to find Bethia’s voice... relied on the captivity narratives of Mary Rowlandson, the court testimony of Anne Hutchinson...”

Women like Randolph and Hutchinson had ideas that would resonate with many 21st c. women. Throughout the (very scanty) historical record there have been women who have been so ahead of their time. Christine de Pizan writing in the 13th c., Mary Wollstonecraft in the 18th c., sound at times very much like contemporary feminists.

So it is certainly possible and consistent with the historical record that the daughter of an educated man would long for an education and would at least implicitly question gender roles and racial hierarchy.

Karen Bojar blogs about retirement life, feminist activism,  grassroots politics and gardening at http://www.the-next-stage.com/

janssen.everyday@gmail.com 5 pts

I've definitely thought that about other books (A Family of Readers has an excellent essay in it about just that very topic), but this one didn't strike me that way.

Bethia does want to be educated which is uncommon for the women of the day, but I saw it more as a natural desire from seeing her brothers and father read and learn together. And she still very much accepts her own role as a housewife and caretaker, which rang true to me for that time period.

I'll have to read some of her other books and see what I think.

janssen.everyday@gmail.com 5 pts

I listen to a lot of audiobooks while I cook or clean or run. And I'm also a very speedy reader :)

lattelove 5 pts

interesting. I've read two of Geraldine Brooks' novels in order to give her a fair chance, but I was really annoyed with the way she interprets history.
I'm not sure if this book is the same (I've also read March and People of the Book), but it seems to me Brooks' authorial lenses are so clearly filtered through our current era that she imposes too much progressive thought into her historical characters. It's too presumptuous, IMO.

sassymonkey 31 pts moderator

Caleb's Crossing was very different than what I expected. In a way, as you said it, more but also less in that I was expecting it to be more about Caleb.

The whole indentured thing kind of blew my mind. I wanted to kick her family in the shins.

Contributing Editor Karen Ballum also blogs at Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca ).

kbojar 6 pts

I was wondering the same thing. I thought I would be reading at least a book a week now that I am retired, but it has not worked out that way.

Karen Bojar blogs about retirement life, feminist activism,  grassroots politics and gardening at http://www.the-next-stage.com/

Lisa Stone 12 pts

Okay, you're right, I trust your opinion with that kind of record. Now I'm dying to know -- how do you find the time for your reading, do you use an e-reader?

Lisa Stone, BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/politics-news ).

TexasRhea 5 pts

When you said that this book was also about "how humans think and feel and function in every period of history, including today" you nailed it! That's what I love best about books, their ability to connect you to the past and create a shared feeling, an understanding. This was a fun book to read, but even more than that, I love discussing it with everyone who read it!