Caleb's Crossing Is No Snooze-Fest

BlogHer Review

My initial reaction to Caleb's Crossing was not unlike my reaction to Johnny Tremain circa 8th grade. In other words, a snooze-fest. The prose was written in ye olde English, which made it cumbersome to understand and left me wanting a translator. For example, the sentence "Once, on a stormy night two winter's since" left me wondering if they were talking about two years ago? In the future? What? When? I'm tired.

And then!

I got past the first couple chapters and found myself completely engrossed in this delicious tale of 17th century life on the East Coast - specifically in Martha's Vineyard and Cambridge, Massachusetts. The author, Geraldine Brooks, took a small factual piece of history -- a Native American boy from the Wampanoag tribe living on Martha's Vineyard becomes the first Native American to graduate from Harvard -- and weaves an entire story around it. The narrator is Bethia -- a spunky and intelligent girl who crosses paths with Caleb in their youth, setting off a series of events that keeps them connected for life.

I really loved this book. I loved the description of a primitive Martha's Vineyard, I loved the way Brooks gave Bethia the ability to be a forward and free-thinking woman without it seeming false given the century, and I loved how easily she intertwined the life of a young Native American boy with that of a colonial era preacher’s daughter.

Fair warning, though, this book is not all sunshine and glory days. There are a lot of sad things, which were troubling and depressing, especially in my current pregnant state. Of course, any historical fiction from this time will contain a fair amount of sorrow. In that, I thank this book for the perspective that while early America seems enchanting at times, it was also a fairly brutal place to live.

In the end, I highly recommend this book. Push through those first few chapters and the language will start to flow easily and you won’t find yourself re-reading sentences with a furrowed brow. The subtle history lesson will leave you feeling smart and the thought-provoking story will leave you satisfied.


In order to comment on, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.

Recent Posts by Navigating the Mothership