Blog
KludgyMom
Bio
Gigi writes her snappish take on parenting, life, popular culture and blogging at KludgyMom. She is a free-lance writer and mom of 2 living in Austin...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

A Call for the End of Birthday Party Presents

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 89
  • Sparkle (
    )
     
I just got home from Wal-Mart. I had to buy a birthday present for my daughter's friend who is about to turn 4. And now I have barely $40 to get me through the rest of the week, and I haven’t finished grocery shopping yet. My children’s combined social calendars, namely shameless displays of parents outdoing one another birthday parties to which they’re invited, cost my family a modest vacation every year. Since I spend most days refining my best impression of a donkey on the edge, a vacation would be helpful. Rejuvenating, maybe. Depends on how hard we push our children to the brink of meltdown. But you get my point.

Having my kids attend birthday parties is a budget item in my life – one that is expensive, and annoying, and time consuming. And so, I make a call for the end of having to buy other kids birthday presents.

Below, I have drafted an email that I plan to send to any parent who invites my child to a birthday party, effective immediately. Feel free to use this email in your own social circles. I like providing useful tools like this to my friends.

Dear Parent, Thank you very much for inviting my children to your bratty child Cameron’s birthday! They would love to come and are SO excited to celebrate with him/her! How sickeningly wasteful ADORABLE that you’ve rented a petting zoo, bounce house, scary clown AND giant hamster ball!!! However, to avoid any disappointment, insult or confusion at party time, please be advised that it is a policy of this family not to bring birthday presents. So that you don’t throw me under the bus with my son’s teacher understand our rationale for this new policy, let me outline the thinking behind it.

1. Your kid doesn’t need any more toys. No kid does.

2. You really don’t want any more toys around your house anyway, especially the cheap and craptastic ones that I buy. $10-$15 doesn’t go that far.

3. You will be insulted anyway by the gift bag I re-use from my own kid’s party and the lack of tissue paper I put in it. I don’t like spending money on tissue paper to make the gift bag all poofy. You will also turn your nose up at the fact that I will write your kid’s name on the bag with a Sharpie instead of buying a ridiculously overpriced sentimental birthday card.

4. I don’t want to shop for your kid’s toy. I don’t know enough about Cameron. Remind me again, is Cameron a boy or a girl? You’d be so peeved if Cameron got a Bionicle and she was hoping for a Littlest Pet Shop playset. Besides, shopping for your kid is a waste of my precious me time.

5. My kids don’t want to shop for your kid’s toy. Why? First, shopping for your kid’s toy means my kids don’t get a toy themselves.They want a toy when they go to Target. I don’t allow them to have one. I would like to, because shopping with them makes me want to poke a sharp stick in my eye. But I can’t afford to placate them every time we shop, so it would be all Cameron’s fault if my children have meltdowns in Target and call me a mean and evil mother. I hate to put that burden on Cameron. Second, shopping for your kid’s toy is a depressing event for my kids. They are as certain to hand select a toy for your kid valued at $50 or more as I am certain that Bret Michaels looks freaking nasty without that bandana and cowboy hat. Actually, he looks nasty anyway. Well, we don’t spend $50 on birthday party toys and so again, it would be Cameron’s fault that my children feel bereft and poor. I can’t do that to your child. I’m a giver that way.

In lieu of gifts, my children will be making donations to my blog design fund a very worthy local charity. I am confident that you think, I’m a heartless bitch support, and understand our choice in this matter. The kids look forward to seeing you at the party. It’s a drop-off, right? Because I can’t stay.

Cheers, Gigi

I think if we can go
  • 89
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MommyKerrie 7 pts

oh, and i feel like I have to buy like a $100 gift for singletons b/c they come to 5 parties a year at my house with nice presents. that's dumb, i know, and i don't actually do it!

MommyKerrie 7 pts

i love this! since we have 5 parties a year we usually ask people to bring nothing, but grandparents lately give money so the kids can buy what they want. other kids can buy if they want but it's not like the ticket to get them in the door. the kids are just happy to have their friends over.

lakeschooling 7 pts

Love this!!!  We accidentally set a precedent of planning a small, fun activity with one or two friends and keeping the gifts to a minimum (accidentally because my eldest was easily overwhelmed by lots of people and attention).  This happy accident has served us well as they invite the same people EVERY year and those same people always either get them something small or make them something.

SingleMomtism 12 pts

Like someone else here mentioned, I am also the queen of the regift. My kids get so many duplicate or unwanted presents at their parties, it's an easy thing to set a few aside in a closet somewhere and re-use when necessary. Our neighborhood had a great "no gift policy" that we all agreed on - no gifts before the age of three! That's about when kids start really wanting them (and really understanding that it's their special day) and before that, it's just more stuff that we see scattered across our living rooms and breaking under our feet.

alexmom1 5 pts

Brilliant!  I nodded and laughed the entire time reading it, so thanks for that!  I can't help but agree with the underlying principle here though, and will be happily joining the "Heartless Mom's Depriving their Kids Club".  Aside from the usual deluge of toys he'll get from family, a book exchange in lieu of gifts for the friends party is the plan, and I know of at least one other mom in my son's class who is thinking the same.  I thought about doing a full no gifts, but I honestly think that will make some parents uncomfortable and stressed out, as much or more than what gift to buy.  The idea of going to a party empty handed is just too weird (or downright offensive) for some people to accept, and then others are bound to worry about "what if other people bring one and my child is the only one who doesn't?".  I know I would.  No, in today's material world, even simplicity can't be simple!  As to school rules about inviting the whole class, that's another weird trend.  Thankfully my son's school doesn't do that, but in the ones that do have that rule, it only applies if you're handing out the invites there.  If you send them out by mail or email, you can invite whoever you want.  Of course, in this day and age, it is not easy!  Right now it's grade 1, and I'm lucky if I know the names of the other kids parents, let alone their contact information!  

young4uf 5 pts

...and one more thing, what's up with the school's telling us you have to invite the whole class. My son doesn't like everyone in his class.

saraidec 5 pts

 young4uf From a teacher- it's fine not to invite everyone in the class, but you can't pass out the invites at school.  It's rubbing it in that not everyone gets to come, and it causes hurt feelings. 

 

Invite whoever you want, but mail the invites.

young4uf 5 pts

I thought it was hilarious. C'mon, we know she's exaggerating, but it is out of control. I can't believe how much these parents spend and I'm pretty sure I make more money than they do (you can just tell when someone lives in a trailer). I had the cheapo birthday party at the park with hot dogs, chips, fruit & cake. No gift bags for the other kids - it's out of control. I wanted to put on the invitation, please give my son the $10 you would have spent on the chinese lead paint plastic crapola and I will save it in my son's 529 plan instead. He will thank you for the gift of compounding when he's old enough to get it.

liontamer 5 pts

I refuse to make it my part time job to drag my kids to everyday bday party they are invited to. I fondly remember the days when parents hosted parties for only significant bdays (5, 13, 16, etc.). For kids today, every day is a party. They don't need more things, events or bouncy houses.

(As a disclaimer... our kids are still pretty young. I'm sure the standoff will get tougher as they get older. )

We haven't figured everything out yet about being parents :-) but I think we are doing this well... We throw our kids a party for their 1st bdays only. It's more of a thank you to the people who have helped us survive the first year. We ask people to donate to a local charity in lieu of gifts. We've hosted a drive to collect toys, shoes and canned goods.

Maybe someday we'll adopt a family in need and host a party for one of their kids. Kids who really need things and more fun.

Trig 5 pts

Wow, sorry, but the mom in that blog sounds like she has bigger problems than a kid's birthday party. If the children aren't close and you're that upset that he/she has been invited to yet another birthday party (*so tragic*) and the mere thought of it makes you that nasty, don't go. Take your kid to the park that day instead. If the children are close and Johnny/Susie wants to go, then spend $10 on books/coloring books at the dollar store and let your child go and have fun. It's not the birthday kid's fault that your child has a meltdown in Target when you shop. It's not your child's fault that he/she gets along with everyone in the class and has been invited to more than one birthday party in the last year. It's not the other parents' fault that you neither know nor care to know your child's friends. Birthday parties are supposed to be a fun part of childhood. Sounds like it would be more fun for everyone involved if she stayed away.

tayjo2011 5 pts

Ask guests to bring a letter or handmade card for the birthday boy or girl or have a book exchange. You could also have an DIY activity themed birthday where attendees bring beads or chalk or something. I found some more ideas from http://www.redtri.com/ideas-for-gift-free-birthdays if you are interested.

Azhita 5 pts

Totally agree. I love kids birthday parties. I love planning my kids parties, but hate the presents. I seriously want to tell people NOT to bring presents. Just come and have fun. We have enough crap, as I'm sure everyone else does.

Tracey B. 7 pts

One word for you:

REGIFT.

I do it all the time. I take presents from my own kids' parties that aren't especially exciting and hide them. If said child never notices that present then goes into my "party drawer." Yes. I have a drawer of $10 presents that my children have never opened. It's awesome. I never spend money on birthday parties anymore!

Cheap = ME!

Tracey B from http://tracey-justanothermommyblog.blogspot.com/

pinkiefae 5 pts

I have to say that a year ago I would have completely disagreed with you. But now...I'm all for it. My daughter just turned 3 and we had a small (or I had hoped "small") party for her at my MILs. My child go so many presents it was unreal. She's still discovering toys she got at Christmas and now she has even more to deal with. I almost sent out an email saying "please come to the party but no gifts". But since my daughter is so young and recently been to other parties I knew it wouldn't work. I have a smaller dream of killing the goody bags at these parties. No one ever rewarded me for coming to a party. Dang, getting to go to a party was reward enough! But I do agree with you that our children already have too many toys and receive way too many at these parties. And I also 100% agree that it kills your budget to have to buy all these presents, too.

Pinkie

Catootes 5 pts

Can I use this for the rash of Sweet 16 parties my son has been invited to recently? For one, the entire 10th grade class was invited, it was held at a dance club and the sweet 16ers? Twins.

I have very strong unfriendly feelings about this trend and have limited attendance based on how close the friendship has been since entering high school. The expected pay-up for these parties is in the $40 range.

Who makes up these ridiculous guidelines?

magpie 5 pts

I totally hear you on all of this.

-magpie ( http://www.magpiemusing.com )

tonyaw 8 pts

My son isn't even two yet and we've been to a dozen birthday parties and spent a lot of dough. I'm with you. Something's got to give!!

I love the idea of charitable donations.

Greta piece, Gigi!

Tonya writes Letters For Lucas ( http://lettersforlucas.blogspot.com/ ) and at any given moment can either be found there, changing a diaper or enjoying a glass of Cab all most likely in her jammies.

IWantThursdays 6 pts

I don't have birthday parties for my son. Granted, he's only turning 2 this year, but I don't see the need, or the purpose, to have one. Yes, family and very close friends will be there and that is it.

I also tell people not to worry about gifts. If they persist, my child can always use more shirts or socks. Really. I mean that.

I buy a few new age appropriate gifts and books (he loves books!) and that is all. And old stuff goes out when the new stuff comes in.

I am the parent that will never invite you to my son's birthday party. Not because I don't like you or your kid, but because I don't want the hassle, the pressure, or the stuff that comes with hosting one.

tara

More of me at: http://iwantthursdays.blogspot.com

Kit'sCat 5 pts

Well done on your clever letter to parents!

How about one for wedding invitations such as this one:

Was recently invited to a wedding of a relative -
Bride and Groom, second marraiges, mid 50's in age. Between them there is a house and a vacation house, fully furnished - a boat, a plane, a Mercedes Benz, a giant diamond ring.

In the inviation there were two printed cards, one from a department store and one from a specialty store, asking for us to look at where they are 'registered' (which although practical I find annoying anyway.)

Is this the height of tackiness? It used to be the bride and groom (in their 20's or just starting out) would have the mother of the bride or the wedding planner be the mouthpeice for what was needed in terms of a gift, not advertisements inside the invitation for crying out loud.

When another couple we know got married - both for the second time and had furnished houses - they put on the rsvp note: "applause and prayers only please" - something like your presence is all the present we need, would have sufficed.

So - I wish I had borrowed your clever letter to re- write for the bride who didnt seem to have good taste. Or perhaps is just incredibly materialistic - or both!

practicalmama 6 pts

Ah, I knew I wasn't alone in this thinking! I often encourange my kids to make something for someone, saying it's much more special and unique and creative and fun, blah blah blah, but they just laugh and say, "Mom, really?!" So I reluctantly head to the store and steer my kids to the book section.

I'm on a more subtle crusade (that hasn't quite caught on...yet) but I applaud your article and am ready to pass it along! Thanks for saying what needed to be said.

www.mommylingo.blogspot.com ( http://www.mommylingo.blogspot.com )

NotJustAnotherJennifer 7 pts

We just had everyone over to our house to play on the swingset and in the baby pool and grilled some hot dogs and hamburgers. I almost put "no gifts" on the invitations, but didn't at the last minute. Should have. Will next year.

NotJustAnotherJennifer is a wife and working mom of two beautiful girls, 3 going on 13 and 1, which means she's sleep deprived but constantly kept on her toes! Most of those experiences are chronicled on her blog, http://midwestmomments.blogspot.com.

Chole 5 pts

With our first child, we jumped on the bandwagon of insanity and threw ginormous parties and invited everyone we knew. And we missed out on the simple joy of the birthday because we were so wrapped up in making sure that everyone was having a good time.

But this year we got smart. Our daughter's party was much smaller and far less stressful and for our son's first birthday party, we invited just a few children. Less stress=more joy.

For us, inviting fewer children justifies not attending so many parties, thus buying fewer craptastic gifts and losing another two hours of my life every other weekend.

Signed,
The Big Meanie

Great post, Gigi! So happy to see you here!

Nichole

in these small moments ( http://inthesesmallmoments.com/ )

alysia75 5 pts

My daughter was invited to three birthday parties this weekend alone, and two of the hosts actually made a point to say "no gifts required." Maybe because I live in Michigan where everyone is broke and unemployed. However,I wouldn't feel right not sending a gift at all, even though we don't spend a lot on birthday gifts for friends. A token gift, preferably no more than $10. But yeah I have 4 kids so even that can definitely add up. My kids always make cards for their friends, and we recycle gift bags. I love the idea of sponsoring a family and asking guests to contribute to that. But it is fun for the kids to get birthday gifts, even if most of it is useless crap. My kids' parties are always laid back, usually at home or maybe at a park and I never do goodie bags. Mainly because I always hate when my kids bring home that little bag of garbage which I then have to sneak and throw out when they're not paying attention.

Alysia blogs about family life, parenting and other stuff at Michigal ( http://michigalmom.blogspot.com/ ).

pfposse 5 pts

Birthday parties do get out of hand. I think kids have too much stuff and don't need anymore. I however hate to have them go empty handed to a party, since it is the social norm to bring a present to the party. I usually hit the Scholastic book fair warehouse clearance (50-80% off) sale two times a year and stock up on $1-$5 books. The kids will pick out a book for the birthday boy/girl from the book box and we are all set!

Sluiter Nation 6 pts

With only one child's bday party under our belt, we haven't been invited to too many either. But we HAVE decided that E would not have huge bday bashes (other than his first). Only family from here on out.

I suppose that could change when elementary school hits, but until now, we haven't been invited to many other than first birthdays, thank goodness.

The hubs and I were brought up with extremely simple birthdays. I had one sleepover that i can remember. He had one bday party in elementary school.

We plan to keep things simple. plan being the operative word.

Katie Sluiter writes about life as a working mom at Sluiter Nation ( http://sluiternation.com ), writes creatively at Exploded Moments ( http://explodedmoments.wordpress.com ), and reviews books at ( http://katiesbookcase.com )

Lady Jennie 15 pts

I have about the same budget for our gifts and although I hate buying them, I do like wrapping them. I like to make them look better than they really are.

ms_lorelei 6 pts

...is the first post I remember of yours. In fact, I even linked it in my blog I thought it was so damned funny.

And so right on. I mean good lord...WHO needs more plactastic crap?

Brilliant. Simply brilliant.

Lori, speech pathologist, writer, and business owner, blogs home-family-working-mom drama at In Pursuit of Martha Points. ( http://inpursuitofmarthapoints.com )

ConfessionsOfaDrMom 6 pts

This is hilarious Gigi! It really can get to be a little much when you are attending a birthday party almost every weekend.

These little presents can really add up!

I love the idea of the book exchange from Ash. Also? No presents...I think that's something we could all get on board with :)

BooyahsMomma 5 pts

Couldn't agree with you more!

Actually, I don't mind buying the gifts so much as receiving them in overkill. Some of the gifts my kids have gotten at birthday parties are, frankly, so extravagant it's a little embarrassing. I appreciate the gesture and the thought, I really do. But my kids don't need it. They'd be happy with a card and a dollar to spend at the dollar store. I think next birthday party, we might just put a little note on the invite for no gifts.

Booyah's Momma
www.chipandbobo.com ( http://www.chipandbobo.com )

Randa 5 pts

I agree wholeheartedly. I don't have a child but a lot of my friends are starting to bring little bundles of joy into the world. While I don't mind buying a gift because it is there birthday, I do hate that it seems like a competition amongst the parents [not for me since I don't have a bambino]. I either buy something educational [yeah, I'm that person] or give money. A lot of my friends have savings accounts for their children and so I contribute to that in lieu of a gift that the kid wont remember.

But I would also love to do this in the adult world. No Christmas presents, birthday presents, mother/father day presents, etc., unless it's from close family/friends and/or you really want to. I'm tired of buying useless filler gifts for other adults. They can buy their own gifts.

Sincerely,

Randa from About Life* ( http://aboutlifestar.blogspot.com/ )

mamikaze 6 pts

That has been our rule since preschool. My daughter gets to choose whether to get something she really wants or have a party. She also know that her friends are going to be asked to not bring gifts. Too many families we know are less fortunate and I don't want them to feel obligated to give anything.

Astacia aka mamikaze
( http://mamikaze.com )

mamikaze 6 pts

We buy our kids stuff all year 'round, so we go somewhere special for their birthdays. The zoo, the science center, etc, and she brings a handful of friends. The invite says NO GIFTS, PLEASE.. Several families have taken offense to it. As if we're trying to say "you suck at buying gifts," when it's really, "my kid has too much sh*t no, please don't add to the clutter."

We make birthday cards for the kid in lieu of gifts. On occasions when I know the family is strapped for cash, I enjoy buying a gift. We make sure it is something the birthday child wants, too. I get peeved when we go to a party where the gift opening is a way of showing your tail feathers.

Astacia aka mamikaze
( http://mamikaze.com )

Kristin Glasbergen 5 pts

I am all over this. I hate birthday presents coming to my house. Unless they are for me.
Unless it's family or close friends, we have a $15 budget and it's books (where I have a discount card) or crafts.

ltorres78 16 pts

I realize that the tongue in cheek-ness of my first comment may be misconstrued. We of course don't expect our friends to clothe our kids, and I have a feeling that before long we may go the no presents route too, if I can convince hubs. He's not a fan.

Birthdays are about celebrating a special day and having fun with your friends, not about "I can't wait to see what I got!" I would have for my kids to grow up with that attitude.

Mrs. Jen B 5 pts

Last summer, as we were leaving for yet another child's birthday party, I turned to my husband and said "We are SO putting everyone else through this when it's our turn so they can see how it feels". I mean, really. Does your small child care what I bought them for their birthday? No. YOU do, parents. They don't - they don't keep track of who bought what, or what they bought last year compared to this year or anything else. And then whatever I buy them probably sits and collects dust anyway.

So really, let's cut out the middle man and instead celebrate the anniversary of your efforts to bring them into the world and stop pretending that it's about the kid. Okay? And I'll just bring a small gift for you, parent. Perhaps a little set of pretty candles or bottle of wine because that is, after all, the ultimate default gift.

Gigi, you're a genius. Viva la Revolution.

gigi927 5 pts

are you agreeing with me or not? :)

thanks for reading either way! I grew up with very simple parties - even renting a skating rink would have seemed like a fancy party back then! Times have certainly changed - in most parts of the country, I think.

It doesn't take much to make kids happy. ;)

Read my snappish take on parenting, life, pop culture and blogging at KludgyMom ( http://www.kludgymom.com ). Or connect with me on Twitter @AKludgyMom ( http://www.twitter.com/akludgymom )!

gigi927 5 pts

For anyone who cares..here's my bio in case you want to come check my personal blog.

Read my snappish take on parenting, life, pop culture and blogging at KludgyMom ( http://www.kludgymom.com ). Or connect with me on Twitter @AKludgyMom ( http://www.twitter.com/akludgymom )!

gigi927 5 pts

don't get me wrong...I love throwing my kids fun parties. I usually make them a really cool cake myself and do burn CD mixes or make Tshirts for their friends as party favors...and I enjoy that a ton.

and I try to make them smaller-scale now and not invite SO many kids.

gigi927 5 pts

that's all I have to say about that. You get it. :)

gigi927 5 pts

Just wait. I had 6 in ONE WEEK right before Christmas between my two kids. CRAZY.

gigi927 5 pts

thank you for the read...and the sparkle :)

gigi927 5 pts

you raise a great point...our definition of special has gotten way twisted. Kids really require so little to be happy!

gigi927 5 pts

the issue with asking for no gifts is that people are going to bring anyway..and then the kids who actually don't bring gifts feel bad...ah, there's no winning on that one!

gigi927 5 pts

I always try to spend around 10 but fifteen only if I have to. Games and books always seem to be doable for $10.

Last year we had a sleepover for my 7 yo - just 4 friends over - and it was great.

gigi927 5 pts

when I can get away with finding a gift on sale, I rejoice!

gigi927 5 pts

I agree wholeheartedly. The party IS the present.

gigi927 5 pts

I know how you feel about the goody bags :)

gigi927 5 pts

Thanks for coming by and reading it, I appreciate it!

Sarah@workplayeatdream 5 pts

The first party my oldest daughter was invited to, when she was 2, specified no gifts. I was pleased and thought I was very clever to show up with a little gift my daughter had handmade. Not so much, as not only had everyone brought gifts, but the mom throwing the party --the one who put "no gifts" on the invitation(!)-- made all the guests sit down and watch the b-day girl open big pile of expensive store bought gifts. My daughter was confused. SO, when my daughter turned three and had her first party just a few weeks before Christmas, I specified no gifts and meant it. Again there was only one family who didn't bring a gift and they seemed to feel just as uncomfortable about it as I had.
So, I've given in. I try to re-gift things we have doubles of etc. when possible, but otherwise haven't escaped the birthday gift trap.
http://workplayeatdream.blogspot.com ( http://workplayeatdream.blogspot.com/ )

MultitaskMumma 8 pts

I couldn't agree more! I also love the idea of doing a book exchange!
The gift for children should be their friends getting together. Its too bad some children are being raised with the expectation of gifts.