Pam
Bio
I'm a freelance technical writer with a terminal case of wanderlust. I make most of my living explaining how technical things work to people that nee...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

The Carry-On Luggage Conundrum

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

...perhaps it’s not surprising that in a letter faxed to travel agents last Friday, Continental Airlines announced a “downsize for carry-ons. ”What does this mean exactly? It means instead of 51 linear inches - the previous size limit, passengers can only bring bags on board that are a total 45 linear inches - 9″ by 14″ by 22″ (height by width by length).--Tripso

Maybe you squeaked through Thanksgiving travels without getting stuck by luggage rules, but don't expect the airlines to look the other way when everyone is loaded with extra packages and presents. Airlines are cracking down on what they see as "oversized" carry-on bags.

American Airlines, planning to "provide the best customer service possible and to consider the needs of all passengers" has put additional restrictions in place between Nov. 29th and January 10 for certain routes - there's more information here. (I can pass on editorializing about how this is hardly the best customer service possible, right?)

Note that carry-on sizes are different between airlines - you may find yourself getting on board with no problem but being required to check your bag for a connecting flight. I can't say this often enough, check your airline's website for up to date regulations about baggage before you fly! And you folks that travel heavy, keep in mind that most ticket prices don't show you the cost of checking luggage up front, so calculate that in your budget when you're shopping for the best fare. (Tip from an airline PR contact. He told me that if they included luggage fees, they might not end up in the top results for best prices.)

If you should be very unlucky and find yourself forced to try and squeeze your carry-on into an unforgiving luggage template by the gate, even one extra inch - if your bag is already at the maximum - will be enough to mean it doesn't fit and you have to check the bag.--The Travel Insider

A carry-on bag, a good one, makes a great gift for the traveler in your life. But don't just buy the first "regulation" sized bag you see. Check out a few different airlines sites or baggage regulations charts, then buy the smallest, that's right, the smallest, sized regulation bag you find. Some airlines will take a 51" bag, but what are you going to do when you're flying an airlines that only takes a 45" bag. And measure before you buy - don't be fooled by the published dimensions, which may be capacity, or interior space, or who knows what.

I know, I know, you're saying "I have NEEDS!" be it toys for the kids you're flying with, or medical supplies, or maybe you're just a product junkie. Always, always, always, check with your airlines (all of them, not just one) and the TSA to find out what whimsical things they have in mind for you on the day before you fly. Always. You may end up paying the fee and checking your bag because it's the best thing for you. But you won't be surprised.

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Pam 5 pts

But you're on the job. Not everyone bothers to check. 

Passport and handkerchief. Heh. It's funny because it's true. 

I have watched people get OFF an international flight and be told they have to check the carryons they took with them on the trans-Atlantic haul. No kidding. And seen people be liberated of bottled water they got ON THE PLANE.

It's maddening.

Nerd's Eye View ( http://www.nerdseyeview.com )

Cynthia Clampitt 5 pts

 I wasn't questioning your facts, I was just surprised to learn that there is variance -- and fairly substantial variance, at that. International flights seem to be a bit less variable (except for when there's some scare, and all you can carry on is your passport and a handkerchief). I haven't run into different sizes (other than those little planes where even carryons get checked). Either that, or if I'm checking luggage, I have a much smaller carryon. I still check before trips, however, because you never know when it might change

 So not disagreeing, just surprised.

Cynthia

http://waltzingaustralia.wordpress.com 

Pam 5 pts

I've checked a few lists, it still varies.

Heads up! The tricky thing when you're shopping for a bag is to  make sure the dimensions they give you are the OUTSIDE, not the INSIDE. 

Nerd's Eye View ( http://www.nerdseyeview.com )

Cynthia Clampitt 5 pts

The only thing I find surprising about Continental's new measurements is that these have been standard for other airlines for years, particularly for international flights. I've had my 9 x 14 x 22 carry-on bag for maybe 10 years. The only time it isn't accepted as a carry-on is when I end up on a puddle-jumper with no extra space, and then they just check it at the gate, as you get on the plane, and so far, I haven't been charged for that. 

 I love traveling light, so unless I have to have an evening gown and hiking boots on the same trip (it does happen), I always try to go carry-on only. I just got back from two weeks in Japan, and I made it with just a carry-on. I agree with the previous poster about mix & match and hand laundry, but I always prefer to limit it to what I can get in my carry-on, because then, not only do you not have to wait for baggage claim, you're also better prepared for such budget-friendly options as hopping on the Underground in London or the train in Tokyo, without having to wrestle with too much luggage.

Of course, I do absolutely agree with the point made in the original post -- always check with the airline first. I do this, even though I feel fairly confident with my luggage. Because things change. For example, British Airways now requires that the 22-inch length includes the wheels. So yes, do check. And don't try to push the limits, especially during the holidays, when most flights are completely full.

Cynthia

http://waltzingaustralia.wordpress.com  ( http://waltzingaustralia.wordpress.com )

MrsWsKitchen 5 pts

After quite a bit of travel myself I can honestly say that there's not much that I need in a carry-on.  A laptop.  Chapstick.  Lotion.  Tissues.  Okay, and maybe a light change of clothes in case they lose my luggage--those drapey no-iron fabrics that squish down into a carry-on are great for an outfit you can wear to work.

I definitely agree with overnighting a box of your needs instead of trying to fly with it--that's brilliant!

As far as packing lightly in your checked luggage, think garanimals for adults:  mix & match pieces, reversible dresses.  Two pairs of pants, one jacket, 3 shirts and one reversible dress can last me 2 weeks at least.  One or two pairs of shoes (one sturdy, one dressier if needed).  2-3 sets of underthings are certainly laundry you can do in your sink and dry overnight.  I remember being in Geneva and laundring a reversible dress in the sink and hanging it at my window to dry overnight (with a towel underneath to catch the drips.  Gotta love drip-dry synthetic fabrics!

Amanda
Mrs.W's Kitchen ( http://mrswskitchen.blogspot.com )

Danielle Ricks 5 pts

I've said it before and I'll say it again... I cannot travel with only one bag.  Yes, I'm a product junie and I like a few changes of clothing.  I've had to pay extra to check my bag and I've had tp pay for an over weight bag.  I think the next trip I'm just going to Fed Ex my things to my hotel and call it a day! 

In my opinion...

Danielle Ricks

KBestOliver 5 pts

This is totally exasperating.  I fly once a month to Minneapolis, usually just for an overnight trip.  Obviously, I carry on, especially if I have to connect.  I have a larger regulation rolling suitcases that I carry on when I need the space for bulky cold-weather gear.  Do not want to deal with the hassle of checking, so I guess I'll pack relatively light this weekend.  Thanks for the heads up.