Bio
Unwilling to fully abandon my Chicago-area upbringing, I live in Manhattan with my husband, my teddy bear, and a 10 lb. rabbit, but insist on calling...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Celebrating the Gender Pay Gap on Labor Day

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Today is Labor Day, the federal holiday in which we honor working people by giving them a day off (unless they work in retail or emergency services) and offering exciting sales to entice people to use their day off to spend their hard-earned money. Recently, Bitch PhD lamented the words of a student enrolled in her gender studies class. The student complained:

I believe that woman have just as much privilege as men do. I don’t feel less important than men and I don’t think society is in that state of mind today. Feminism is a thing of the past. With so many women today having top paying jobs and high governmental status it’s hard to see why feminists still exist. With the numbers of women graduating from higher education growing and the numbers of men declining why do some women feel the right to parade around shouting for equality and “woman power!” We don’t need it. We got it. Those women need to turn around and help our young and struggling men get their power back.

Labor Day is actually the perfect day to illustrate why what this student "believes" and what reality is are two - very sadly - different things. One thing the student got right is that more women are graduating from higher education than ever. However, research from the American Association of University Women (AAUW) shows:

Women have made remarkable strides in education during the past three decades, but these gains have yet to translate into full equity in pay — even for college-educated women who work full time. A typical college-educated woman 25 years and older working full time earns $50,600 a year compared to $70,800 for college-educated male workers 25 years and older — a difference of $20,200!

AAUW also reports that "women typically earn 78 cents for every $1 that their male counterparts earn." The gender pay gap is not unique to the United States. Australian Women Online reports that:

...female graduates on average earn $2,000 less per annum than male graduates when they first start working and the 2008 Graduate Pathways Survey estimated males earn around $7,800 per year more than females in their fifth year after graduation.

Macquarie University researcher, Ian Watson, recently estimated that as much as 70% of the unexplained part of the gender pay gap is due to discrimination.

In the UK, Vonnie at Adventures of a Lady in Training reports that:

According to Close The Gap” the full-time gender pay gap is 14%. The part time pay gap jumps to a massive 33% – that means women working part time receive 67p per hour for every £1 per hour received by a full-time man. Do you think that is okay? Do you think it’s fair and equal?

Still not convinced. Here are more disturbing figures: Womenstake reports that the Institute for Women's Policy surveyed 500 occupations, and men earned more than women in 495 of them:

The occupations in which women earn equal to or more than men include counselors, two traditionally male occupations in which women account for less than four percent of all workers, special education teachers, and a subcategory of physical and social science technicians.

The fact sheet shows that men outearn women in the ten most common occupations for women, which include registered nurses (women earn 87.4 cents for a man's dollar) and retail managers (women earn 71.2 cents for a man's dollar) as well as the ten most common occupations for men, which include truck drivers (women earn 76.5 cents for a man's dollar) and janitors (women earn 80.5 cents for a man's dollar). In addition, men are paid more than women in the ten highest paying occupations for women, which include physicians and surgeons—an occupation in which women earn merely 64.4 cents for every dollar paid to men.

Yes, clearly so many women have top paying jobs and men are so far behind that they earn more than women. I will immediately put away my parade gear now that the facts are out there. (Incidentally, Sept. 1 is "Equal Pay Day" in Australia. Probably they should cancel it since women are already believed to have achieved equality.) Bah. My brain is exploding.

Of course, Labor Day is also a very good time to reflect on the amount of unpaid labor performed by women every year. A Happy Hospitalist notes that:

It looks like, on average, women do 10.8 more hours per

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Suzanne 5 pts

I've been thinking about your comment since Monday, and every time I come to that last point - about the college kid who makes more than you - I am so enraged that I can barely see straight. Your point about women keeping jobs in this economy because we are paid less is spot-on also. Yet what I read in the papers is how men are now disadvantaged and losing their jobs to women and how society will fall apart any second now. Why don't people care about the details?

Suzanne Reisman ( http://www.blogher.com/member/suzanne-reisman ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://blogher.org/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

zoedoom 5 pts

Reading that student's comments was like a slap to my face!

When I was 20 years old and in college, I worked at a coffee shop in a well-known book store chain. I was joking around with a coworker one day and I found out that he made more money than I did. Not much more, about 50 cents an hour more. But I was making about $6.15 at the time, so that's quite a difference. I had been working there longer than he had. He had never been to college.

Years later, I was out with some friends, and I struck up a conversation with a girl I'd just met. She worked at the same chain I had worked at, but at a different location. We were just talking about it and with no prompting from me she said "Did you know that the guys make more than the girls?" I guess it's routine.

I worked at a biotech company years later, and many women I spoke to made less than their male counterparts --even in cases where the women had more education or experience. One of the women I spoke to about this does not have children. Another one has adult children, so maternity leave was not an issue. The childfree woman complained and eventually got a big raise, but ultimately left the company. The woman with the adult children, however, was able to use her lower salary to her advantage. When it was time for layoffs, she kept her job while her male counterpart (who made about $10,000 a year more) lost his. She saved the company some money just by being a woman.

Even at my last writing/editing job, my former coworker (who started the same day I did) made slightly more than I did. I'm 30 with years of experience and a master's degree. He graduated college in December and had never held a full-time job.

Modern Poverty ( http://modernpoverty.wordpress.com )

Suzanne 5 pts

You are right to some extent about the role that motherhood plays in depressing women's long term earnings, since most times when a kid enters the picture, the mom is the one to leave the labor force for whatever reason. However, since the salary disparity begins so soon after college graduation, parenthood doesn't entirely account for the gap. Plus, the motherhood factor only shows the impact of all of the unpaid labor that women do on our long term financial health.

Suzanne Reisman ( http://www.blogher.com/member/suzanne-reisman ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://blogher.org/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Oth ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

LucindaA 5 pts

I'm seriously not trying to dismiss your data.  But I honestly wonder, and perhaps you have information regarding this, how much of the pay discrepansy is due to women taking time off to raise children or changing jobs to follow their husbands? 

I worked for 7 years as a teacher before quitting to stay at home with my kids.  I also moved jobs when we got married and took a cut in pay to do so.  Now a classmate of mine is still teaching and obviously earning more than I am.  His wife is home with their kids and he didn't switch jobs.  So my fewer earning are due to choices I made.

It is also important to note that my husband offered to stay home with the kids and let me continue to work but I didn't want to.