Bio
I'm a writer/artist/alt.minister/urbanmama from Seattle, Washington now living in Copenhagen, Denmark. I write about spirituality, creativity, paren...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

A Chance to Live it Right

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

How much time are we willing to spend debating right thinking at the expense of right living?

The last couple of years I’ve been captivated by the idea of orthopraxy as opposed to orthodoxy. Orthodoxy is the concept of 'right thinking,' or 'right belief.' In a system which requires orthodoxy, belonging requires one to believe a certain set of assertions. If one cannot ascribe to those beliefs, then membership in that system is denied, and one can no longer belong.

Orthopraxy on the other hand is the idea of having ‘right practice.’ Rather than requiring alignment to doctrinal assertions, an orthopraxy places the emphasis on living according to a certain collection of practices.

Karen Armstrong, an interfaith specialist who writes and teaches about Islam, Judaism, and Christianity, writes in her autobiography about her own realization that one could be a person of faith without holding orthodox beliefs.

As a part of her research work, Armstrong was introduced to Jewish scholar Hyam Maccoby, who introduced her to the idea that one could have a faith based upon right living rather than right belief. In fact, he told her, the idea that faith is primarily about right belief is largely a Christian phenomenon.

“It is easy to see that you were brought up Christian….Theology is just not important in Judaism, or in any other religion really. . … We have orthopraxy instead of orthodoxy…right practice rather than right belief. That’s all. You Christians make such a fuss about theology, but it’s not important in the way you think….We Jews don’t bother much about what we believe. We just do it instead.” The Spiral Staircase P. 235,236

This is probably an oversimplification, and certainly striving after right practice can easily become a legalistic lecture about ticking things off your holy checklist. Still, after a life time of worrying about my orthodoxy, it feels good to focus on how I’m living for awhile.

I’ve been especially inspired this week by soulful folks who have found small and beautiful ways to, as Maccoby says, “just do it” in the world. Each one is an example of an orthopraxy that reflects the beauty and creativity which lies at their spiritual cores.

Tess at Anchors and Masts is spreading the word about World Water Day and inspiring people to take simple, practical steps towards getting communities access to safe drinking water.

Over at Dahl Bat small-sized projects in literacy and fair trade in Kolkata, India.

Young Laura over at Twenty Five Days to Make a Difference has taken her values viral and has inspired kids and adults alike to do something proactive every month to make the world a better place.

And finally, in an act that hits close to home, a small group of Small is Beautiful bloggers are working together to do an on-line auction for sister-blogger Jenni Ballantyne of The Comfy Place. Jen is living her last days with fierce honesty as she looks at the end of line in her fight against colon cancer. To find out how you can help raise funds for her final treatment and for her son’s future, go over to Jena’s place at Bullseye Baby and do some orthopraxis of your very own.

Here’s to orthopraxis in all the best sense of the word. Shalom!

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
lauriewrites 5 pts

I just came across her blog, the Comfy Place ( http://thecomfyplace.blogspot.com/ ), via Jen Lemen ( http://www.jenlemen.com ), and I immediately came over to BlogHer to see if anyone had written about her yet. Her story has touched me and I really hope the blog world continues to come together to support her.

Laurie

LaurieWrites  ( http://lauriewrites.typepad.com )

ElaineE 5 pts

Oops, I think I lost the first version of this comment -- apologies if it appears twice.

Hi Rachelle. I commented on this post on your other blog. I said I'd track down the links to a couple of Karen Armstrong interviews I recently listened to. Here are the links to the podcasts:

http://www.cbc.ca/tapestry/archives/2008/031608.ht...

http://speakingoffaith.publicradio.org/programs/ar...

After I finish blogging tonight, I'm going to continue reading the Spiral Staircase -- I'm on page 259. Funny -- the excerpt you quoted jumped out at me when I first read it in the book.

Mata H 5 pts

Just let it flow....that which is true will rise to the surface all on its own with a voice that is clear and beautiful and undeniable. You'll know it when you hear it.

hugs, mata 

~~ Contributing Editor, Mata H. also blogs relentlessly at Time's Fool ( http://timesfool.blogspot.com )

Rachelle Mee-Chapman 5 pts

Oh, I'm sorry you are getting bruised by life of late! I'm holding you in my thoughts today. May there be warmth and gentleness around you, and may healing arrive at your door.

Shalom!

Rachelle Mee-Chapman
http://www.magpie-girl.com

Rachelle Mee-Chapman 5 pts

Debra,

Right on! I love it when religious practioners say something healing like that! One of the catch phrases in my former neomonastic community was "All Truth is God's Truth." This phrasology doesn't work for everyone, but for our little tribe it helped us create a more generous set of beliefs and practices. (Hurrah for interfaith living!)

All my 'naturally religious' artists friends at the Fremont Arts Council in Seattle taught me more than any sermon. I'm so thankful for them!

Rachelle Mee-Chapman
http://www.magpie-girl.com

Rachelle Mee-Chapman 5 pts

Tess,

I had heard about her award, but hadn't see the video. Thanks for the link!

I adore Karen's approach to spirituality. I'm working on a manuscript proposal now that is based on something that inspired me from her autobiography. I send it to the publisher in two weeks. Keep your fingers crossed!

Rachelle Mee-Chapman
http://www.magpie-girl.com

Rachelle Mee-Chapman 5 pts

Mata -

I totally agree with you ! Acts of goodness can be done w/o religious motivations, or even w/o concious intention to 'do something good.'

As someone who is deconstructing/reconstructing her religious beliefs and practices, it's just been interesting to me to err on the side of orthopraxis for awhile, while I work up the gumptions to turn my mind back towards the hard work of picking apart my orthodoxy. (I am such a good heretic though! Still, one should strive for balance in these things, no?)

Much Affection,

Rachelle Mee-Chapman
http://www.magpie-girl.com

Mata H 5 pts

True, true -- something can be moral and ethical without being tied to a system. besides, even within a "system", people believe very differently one to another. Faith ican be on the one hand being part of a community, but also it is very individual.

~~ Contributing Editor, Mata H. also blogs relentlessly at Time's Fool ( http://timesfool.blogspot.com )

Tanis 5 pts

Dear Debra,

I wanted to mention, and firstly sorry Rachelle that I'm veering away from your post, that I am thankful that you take the time to read what others have written. Truthfully, after having visited this site I felt a few things - one of intimidation brought on by my lack of knowledge (comparing myself to others) and the other of noticing that everyone wants to be heard and so few are listening. Debra, you listen, and thank -you.

I've been having a "needy" few days, something I don't like about myself. I want to be heard and probably haven't been doing a great job of listening either.

My ethics are quite simple. Do the right thing, the right thing happens. The reverse is also true. Treat others as you wish to be treated. Love unconditionally every chance you get and be kind to strangers.

Kathy.

Debra Roby 5 pts

Years ago i got similar brilliant advice from a Rabbi. He explained that I could be a "naturally religious" person who lived morally and ethically without necessarily attaching myself to any one religious practice or set of beliefs.

Mata, that, I think, is the distinction. I have strong morals and ethics that I abide by. But mine are mine and mine alone (well, actually lots of people probably share a number of them). They are handed to me as part of a belief system. They ARE the belief system.

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Deb's Daily Distractions ( http://debsdistractions.blogspot.com )

Froniga 5 pts

Rachelle, thanks for the mention for me and World Water Day. And I'm so delighted to see you are also a fan of Karen Armstrong. The Spiral Staircase was the first of hers that I've read, and I've been devouring her stuff ever since. Every time I read one of her books I start muttering out loud to myself - 'Isn't that interesting', 'I didn't know that', 'Yes of course, that's exactly how I feel'. A bit off-putting for my fellow commuters...
Have you seen her recent award at TED? You can find details here: http://www.ted.com/talks/view/id/234.

Tess

Mata H 5 pts

Does it matter whether or not a good act was done with a belief-consciousness or not? I sure don't think so.

But there is a difference in form without function and function without form. Seems to me things feel best when they are aligned -- when what one does stems from what one belives consciously. But even as I say that, I cannot imagine a good act NOT flowing from some sort of belief about the world -- whether or not that belief involves religious dogma is another question.

Yet, on the third hand (I am starting to feel like Kali here with all these hands) there really is a difference between someone who does good because it stems from a larger faith and someone who does good just from good impulse. Neither is intrinsically better or worse, they just differ. ( I only say that because there seems to be some sort of emerging trend that smoooshes everyone together without acknowledging their differences as people.)

Thanks for the opportunity to blather on...

~~ Contributing Editor, Mata H. also blogs relentlessly at Time's Fool ( http://timesfool.blogspot.com )