Bio
Several years ago, recovering from surgery, I read the article and photo that changed my life.  The article was Plastic Ocean and the photo show...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

From Cheeseburger Lover to Overnight Vegetarian

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I stopped eating animals two months ago. Thank you, BlogHer Book Club.

So what happened?

Eating Animals by Jonathan Safran FoerTwo months ago, I read the book Eating Animals by Jonathan Safran Foer, whose novel Everything is Illuminated is one of my all-time favorites. I didn’t choose to read Eating Animals because of the topic but because I loved its author and because it was a BlogHer book club selection; I honestly didn’t expect to learn anything more about the meat industry I hadn’t already read about in The Omnivore’s Dilemma or Fast Food Nation or seen in the film Food Inc. I knew how bad the conventional meat industry was. I knew that the conditions for chickens, cows, and pigs were abysmal and that raising them, as well as overfishing the oceans, was wreaking havoc on the environment.

And yet, I loved cheeseburgers.

McDonald's double cheeseburgerI mean, I really really loved them. And believe it or not, the cheeseburgers I craved were not even made from organic, humanely raised meat, but came from McDonald’s. I loved McDonald’s double cheeseburgers, to be exact. And I also reserved a special place in my heart for McDonald’s Egg McMuffins with their slabs of Canadian bacon. I mostly resisted these “foods” and felt extreme guilt when I occasionally succumbed to the urge. But the negative consequences of eating that kind of meat were purely intellectual to me. In practice, I had a hard time connecting that burger with the animal it had been. Eating less meat, especially less factory farmed meat, was something I did because I knew I “should.” I knew it was bad, but I didn’t know it.

And I should have known. I used to drive past the Harris Ranch feedlot every time I visited my brother in Coalinga. The rank smell preceded it for miles. And when you finally came upon the “ranch,” the sight was appalling. Thousands of cows jammed together, feeding from troughs, and standing and lying in their own shit. It was depressing. And yet still, there was a disconnect in my brain between the cheeseburger that tasted so good, and this:

Harris Ranch feedlot sucks

According to Wikipedia, Harris Ranch keeps about 100,000 cattle on 800 acres. That’s .008 acres per cow. Compare that to the 1-2 acres per cow needed for pasture grazing, which is how calves are raised before they are weaned and forced to spend the rest of their lives in these deplorable conditions. Passing the feedlot, I would feel a momentary twinge of sadness and guilt before turning my head to look away.

If seeing a sight like the Harris Ranch feedlot didn’t stop me from craving meat, perhaps my knowledge of the environmental damage resulting from the meat industry should have.

Environmental Consequences of Industrial Meat Production

Consider the following points from the United Nations Food & Agriculture Organization’s 2009 report: The State of Food and Agriculture – Livestock in the balance (PDF):

  • Livestock production generates about 18% of human-derived greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Animals confined in feedlots produce a larger concentration of waste than the environment can absorb, resulting in pollution runoff into our waterways and groundwater.
  • The grain and forage required to feed livestock has led to the destruction of large portions of the world’s forests for crops and grazing land, forests necessary to sequester carbon dioxide and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Industrial meat production requires huge amounts of water — for feed crops, for animals, for cooling and cleaning facilities, and for processing the meat itself. For these reasons, the livestock industry accounts for 8% of global water use.
  • Cattle contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions directly through exhalations of methane gas (burps and farts) as well as nitrous oxide from their manure.
  • Illnesses such as swine and avian flu are more likely to mutate into more aggressive diseases in intensive feed operations where animals are crowded together and pathogens can gain access to an abundance of susceptible hosts.

Those are just a few of the major environmental effects of the industrial meat industry. And the industrial fishing industry contributes to the destruction of entire marine ecosystems. Knowing these facts prevented me from eating flesh foods on a regular basis. I

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
midnightbliss 5 pts

i live in a house that have an extended family and the same food is prepared for everyone, though i tried to be a vegetarian, its just difficult not to eat the foods that everyone is eating, specially in a family that is used in eating meat.

Beth Terry 5 pts

I've heard from so many other people who had similar experiences after reading *Eating Animals* and simply could not continue eating meat. I've been trying to figure out what it is about that particular book that can reach some of us when others don't. And I think it's JSR's personal experience and utter humanity. Plus, he's just one of the best writers today.

I lent the book to a friend this weekend. I wonder what his experience/reaction will be.

Beth Terry: attempting to live plastic-free and blogging the heck out of it at FakePlasticFish.com. Follow her on Twitter.

Erin Groh 5 pts

I loved the way you used the photos to illustrate your point of "what is the difference?" For me, that was the reasoning for why I became a vegetarian at age 13. I grew up with animals that I loved dearly, most especially my horse. One day it just occurred to me, and this dialogue ran through my mind, "they eat horses in other parts of the world - where do I draw the line? And who am I to draw that line?"

Like you, I believe it's a personal choice, and I don't frown on anyone who chooses to eat meat. In fact none of my close friends or family are vegetarians. For me, it was the easiest decision I've ever made.

Great post!

Erin Groh

erin@blogher.com

Erin is a member of the BlogHer Events Team. You can find her here on BlogHer or on her personal blog, I carried a watermelon? ( http://carriedawatermelon.wordpress.com )

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

for this amazing post. I had the same response to "Eating Animals" and instantly stopped eating meat and fish. I don't know when I've ever been so repulsed by something in my life as I was by the knowledge that my support of factory farming and fishing enabled such horrific industries to exist. I will no longer participate in the process.

Virginia DeBolt
BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/virginia-debolt ) | Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) | First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com )

anglocelta 5 pts

Thank you for such an in-depth and thoughtfully written piece. Personally, I applaud your decision - and for ALL of the reasons you cover, including those pertaining to the environment. I find the vegan (and vegetarian, though since I can't really eat dairy anyway, vegan is frankly easier) lifestyle to be the best for me and my husband. The health benefits of a vegan diet are a huge, huge plus in my opinion and are almost too numerous to list here - everything from increased fiber and nutrients (from whole grains, legumes), elimination of saturated animal fats and increased consumption of fruits and vegetables to the fact that more and more studies point to meat consumption as being linked to various forms of cancer (stomach, pancreatic) as well as, of course, heart disease. Plus, it's extremely budget friendly. It's one of the better decisions I've made in my life and I wish you the best in your new lifestyle.

BudgetFresh 5 pts

I haven't been able to eat meat since I read that book...Foer and Pollan have completely changed how my family eats. To the point that I started blogging my journey to eat fresh, (more) local and less processed on a budget. It's been so fun!!!

Jamie
budgetfresh.blogspot.com

crousehaus 5 pts

I was a vegetarian when I was in college, but slowly slipped back to eating meat in my mid-20's. But on a recent drive to S.F., my hubby and I really looked at that ranch with the thousands and thousands of cattle. We REALLY looked, we smelled and then we decided to seriously think before we eat meat. That said, we haven't given it up entirely. We eat organic red meat maybe once every 2 months. We eat organic poultry about twice a week. We struggle with this and I see us moving toward a vegetarian diet in the near future. But as a busy mom, I admit that the ease of adding meat to a meal to provide protein for my young kids is my main obstacle.

corihughes 5 pts

Thanks Beth!
I am still a meat eater (only organic), but my family and I have cut back a lot and only eat red meat about twice a month.
I love the perspective, you have given me a lot to think about, and more books to read! Thanks for the recipe sites, it was actually just what I was looking for

Beth Terry 5 pts

I think whether to eat meat or not is a personal choice that is up to each one of us. I don't feel like I can criticize someone who has looked clearly at the meat industry and has made a decision to eat meat in a way that they feel is responsible. What gets me are the people who refuse to care.

For me, I can't see meat the same now. I can't eat it without thinking of the animal it once was and feeling sad. But that's me.

Beth Terry: attempting to live plastic-free and blogging the heck out of it at FakePlasticFish.com. Follow her on Twitter.

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

Hi, I hear everything you say and have read the Pollan (and other books( and just saw Food, Inc. Still, I believe that animal protein has a place. I am waiting to read The Vegetarian Myth by a former vegetarian that I understand upends some of our thoughts about how not eating meat at all is the way to go.
I have decided to only consume organically-and humanely raised produce and to only eat sustainable and wild-caught fish. Because of the costs and the challenges of finding this, animal consumption has gone way down in my life (and my husband's reluctantly).
Thanks for this post.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

booyah 5 pts

Funny you mention it...I became vegetarian in 1996 while in college and did a few years in the middle as a vegan. After my daughter was born last year, I decided to eat meat again (from a local farm that I can visit to witness how the animals were treated) to encourage her to eat a variety of foods. Somewhat surprisingly, I now feel healthier than I've felt in years. I'm convinced that for me personally (I wouldn't dare assume this applies universally to all humans), evolution selected for me to be omnivorous.

Elisa Camahort 5 pts

Pople ask me pretty often why I went vegetarian (since 1989) then vegan (since 2006).

From now on, I will simply direct them here.

Elisa Camahort Page
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.com
My BlogHer profile truly shows you everything I do online...Check it out!!