Bio
My name is Amy Gates (also known on the ‘net as amygeekgrl or the Crunchy Domestic Goddess). I live in Colorado with my husband Jody (yes, he’s a guy...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Child-led Weaning: They Aren't Going to Nurse Forever

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

A little more than two years ago, I wrote about my experiences nursing a preschooler. At the time I discussed the fact that my nearly 4-year-old daughter was still nursing and how I never planned or expected to be nursing a 4-year-old, yet it just happened.

"I didn’t set out to nurse a preschooler, but somehow along the way my sweet little baby grew from an infant to a toddler and eventually blossomed into a preschooler in what now seems like the blink of an eye. I am confident this won’t go on forever and when I look back on this time when she’s 10 or 20 or 30, and I look at the young woman she’s become, I am hopeful that I will feel good about the choices I made and have no regrets."

As I suspected, it didn't "go on forever." I never blogged about it when Ava weaned, but that milestone occurred almost four months after my post. She was 4 1/4 years old. At that time I was also nursing my son -- her younger brother. From what I can remember, she and I had talked about weaning and being done with mama milk for a while. I felt like after a long, mostly* wonderful nursing relationship with Ava, I was comfortable with the idea of her weaning. Although she wasn't excited to wean, I felt like Ava was pretty ready too.

I remember one night she went to bed without nursing (which is the only time she would nurse at that point and had been since she was 2 1/2). After all of the discussions we'd had about weaning, it seemed to me like the perfect stopping point. The next night as we cuddled to go to sleep, she asked for "na-na" and I explained to her that she was done having na-na. She cried a few tears that night, but we cuddled and she went to sleep without na-na. The next couple days she continued to ask for it before bed and sometimes cried a bit or was sad, but I never felt like it was unbearable for her. If I had felt it was absolutely unbearable for her, I would have put off weaning longer, but I never got that impression. Yes, she briefly mourned the loss, but the transition went well.

After several weeks had passed and I felt fairly confident that she had lost the knack of suckling, she would -- once in a while -- still ask for na-na and at that point I would let her try. As I'd suspected, she couldn't figure out how to get milk out any longer. It was a little frustrating for her, but I think it was comforting that I let her try rather than just tell her "no, you don't have na-na anymore." Letting her try seemed like a gentle way for her to discover on her own that she had, in fact, weaned.

While I wouldn't call what I did with Ava exactly "child-led weaning," it felt like a pretty gentle transition and was what I deemed best for our family at that time. After nursing two kids (although usually not at the same time) for a year and a half, I was ready to go back to nursing just one child.

And that brings us to the present, when my now 3 3/4-year-old son is still nursing. This time around, however, it didn't come as any surprise to me that I'm nursing a preschooler. He seems like he might wean before Ava did, but I'm not holding my breath. Lately, he will go a few days at a time without asking for it, so I think we are heading in that direction. He went five nights without nursing while I was at BlogHer this year, but when I got home -- sure enough -- he wanted to nurse before bed. Most recently he went about four or five nights without asking to nurse while I've been home. I thought he might be done altogether, but then asked to nurse again. I talked to him about possibly being done and he insisted that he was NOT, so he nursed before bed. But then the past two nights, he did not.

I'm not in a big hurry for Julian to be done. I know it will be bittersweet just like it was when Ava weaned and perhaps a bit more so since I'm fairly certain I'm not going

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
JynMeyer 5 pts

I breastfed all 6 of my kids at least until 8 mos. My 6th I am still nursing, and she is 13 mos old. I found out last week that we are expecting my 7th and Im wondering how this is going to play out.
I have supported her on my right breast only for these past 13 mo due to an inverted nipple issue on my left which led to three separate bouts of mastitis. I felt like I was literally robbed of the first 4 mos of her life with me going through this.
I have no clue how long my daughter is going to nurse and even now, one of her favorite things to do is stick her foot in my mouth while doing nursing gymnastics. I dont know if my milk will hang around since Im exclusively on one side- but I'm just leaving that up to what is meant to be.
Im REALLY hoping, though, that when this new bean is born I will be able to resume breastfeeding again on my left side and bypass all the issues I had. One can hope!

-Jyn Meyer

amygeekgrl 5 pts

Thanks for sharing your experiences, Paxye. I'm not sure I can imagine nursing 3 at the same time (well, not simultaneously, but you know what I mean), but I think that's great that you were able to give your children what they needed. :)

Amy

Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
Contributing editor at BlogHer ( http://blogher.com )

Twitter: @crunchygoddess ( http://twitter.com/crunchygoddess )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

What a sweet story. :) Thanks for sharing!

Amy

Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
Contributing editor at BlogHer ( http://blogher.com )

Twitter: @crunchygoddess ( http://twitter.com/crunchygoddess )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

Too cute! :)

Amy

Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
Contributing editor at BlogHer ( http://blogher.com )

Twitter: @crunchygoddess ( http://twitter.com/crunchygoddess )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

I think that's a great (and healthy) way to look at it, Steph.

Amy

Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
Contributing editor at BlogHer ( http://blogher.com )

Twitter: @crunchygoddess ( http://twitter.com/crunchygoddess )

CrystalsCozyKitchen 5 pts

My son basically weaned himself around 15 months. The night time and middle of the night feedings (he never did sleep through the night) were the last to go. He has not wanted to nurse since. (maybe once or twice when he wasn't feeling very well, but that's it.)

CrystalsCozyKitchen

http://crystalscozykitchen.blogspot.com

bri 5 pts

I left it up to my son and he weaned himself rather suddenly at 29 months. One night he was congested and nursing was hard for him. I think my milk was also greatly diminished, since we had only been nursing at bedtime for months. He took a lame suck or two and then said, "Dat not working. Try other side." He lamely tried the other one and announced, "Dat not working!" The same thing happened for the next two nights, more fake each time. By the last night he wasn't even making contact with my boob. Still, he announced, "I twy and I twy and I twy and it not working!"

And that was it.

- Briar

www.unwellness.com ( http://www.unwellness.com )

LizaWasHere 5 pts

I just weaned my 2 year old daughter -- starting with my 5 day trip to BlogHer a few weeks before her birthday. She was also ready, although we had a few days of sad requests after The Last Day.

I won't forget it, either. On the night before I left for BlogHer, Josie only nursed one side before she fell asleep, and didn't ask to nurse the next morning.

Liza Barry-Kessler
Personal: LizaWasHere ( http://www.lizawashere.com/ )
Professional: Privacy Counsel LLC ( http://www.privacycounsel.net/ )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

Aww, thank you. I have a feeling I'm not going to remember the last time my son nurses either. *sniff, sniff* But I do have a lot of memories of him nursing over the years and that makes me smile. :)

Amy

Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
Contributing editor at BlogHer ( http://blogher.com )

Twitter: @crunchygoddess ( http://twitter.com/crunchygoddess )

paxye 5 pts

Before my first was born I thought that I would nurse for at least a year... but the moment I started nursing him I knew that he would be the one to choose when he would stop. He weaned just after his 5th birthday... I was nursing two others at the time...

My second son also weaned after he was 5...

Now I am nursing my 3rd and 4th and my 3rd is down to just a few seconds a day. I have a feeling that just nearing 4, he will be the youngest to date to wean himself.

My 4th is only 7 months and the breast is still her only food... she is my last andI hope that she follows in her brothers footsteps and weans when she is ready to do so on her own terms...

~paxye~

a hippie with a minivan... ( http://paxye.com/blog )

hobomama 5 pts

We're at 3 years and almost 3 months and still going strong. I also had thought my son would have weaned before now, but he's not ready, and I can respect that because it's been and still is such a happy part of our relationship. It's finally gotten to the point for me where I can see the end in the future, though, and am not as scared about the transition as I was before. To prepare, I love hearing these stories of gentle weaning, whether child- or parent-initiated.

www.HoboMama.com ( http://www.HoboMama.com ) | A natural parenting blog

zanepaul 5 pts

i breastfeed my first until 20 months, when i was 7 months pregnant with my second. i never imagined we'd go that long, but if i hadn't been pregnant, we'd probably have gone longer. it is so lovely to nurse a toddler! i hope my 10 month-old has a long way to go:)

what drives me nuts? the assumption that "if they're old enough to ask for it, they're old enough to be done." that assumption is so arbitrary and ridiculous (not to mention it completely removes the child's needs/wants from the when-to-wean equation.)

http://somuchshoutingsomuchlaughter.com/2009/08/br... ( http://somuchshoutingsomuchlaughter.com/2009/08/br... )

http://somuchshoutingsomuchlaughter.com/

@ShoutLaughLove

KhadijahOnline 5 pts

Thanks for your post!

I was sharing with friends this past Sunday about my weaning experience with my daughter who I stopped nursing when she was 3. We laughed as I shared how nursing became my daughter's after-school drink for comfort like an adult may choose an alchoholic drink to wind-down. My daughter and I actually had a conversation about her easing off her "ninny" after-school but not the after-school hugs that always accompanied ninny. When she said "ok" and didn't show signs of weaning being a problem, I wondered then, as I do now, why I hadn't had the conversation earlier. She immediately stopped once we discussed it and now, as a "big girl" at 6, she tells me she wishes I would stop telling her nursing stories to people because its embarassing. Lol. Oh, how quickly they grow!

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ "Conformity is costly. You pay in soul credits. Stay unboxed." -Moon www.KhadijahOnline.com ( http://www.KhadijahOnline.com ) www.LiberatedMuse.com ( http://www.LiberatedMuse.com )

Adventures In Babywearing 5 pts

My goal with extended breastfeeding was to be more child-led but also only continue if breastfeeding was pleasant and comfortable for BOTH myself and my child together.

Steph
www.adventuresinbabywearing.com ( http://www.adventuresinbabywearing.com )

Adventures In Babywearing 5 pts

This is exactly how it seems to be going for me. I do think Gray would have nursed longer (until almost 3) if I hadn’t had so much pain and dehydration in my pregnancy with Ivy.

Ivy is almost 2 and still going strong- it’s funny how it just happens and you don’t even pay attention to age. It just feels so normal and natural. On top of the fact that I think it’s very healthy for both of us as well as sometimes the ONLY time she will sit still and snuggle and I love it. :)

Steph
www.adventuresinbabywearing.com ( http://www.adventuresinbabywearing.com )

unwrapping 5 pts

thank you for sharing this beautiful story!

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I never got to experience this, so I learned a lot from your post.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

JennaHatfield 9 pts

I added this post to my favorites. I still don't remember the exact day/night/moment that LittleBrother weaned... and I wish I did. I blinked and it was over. Sad, sad me.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.