Bio
Software engineer and manager by day, mom and blogger by night.
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Children and Clean Rooms - An Oxymoron

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It must be a rite of passage into adulthood, the knowledge that clean and orderly surroundings lead to peace of mind.  Of course not all adults make it to cleanly bliss, but one thing is true, no children are born that way.

My husband and I are both relatively neat people.  Our house can get a bit cluttered, but on the whole, it is organized and clean.  When our son was born, we instinctively cleaned up after him and taught him early on that he could not play with a new toy until the first one was put away.  He was a relatively neat toddler, and as most toys never wandered far, it was easy to show him how to put things away.  Then came my daughter.  To say that she is a tornado is an understatement.  Not only does she make a mess in one room, she likes to bring things from one room to another, making clean up a nightmare.  Having two children also meant that we were no longer in control of our house.  We were too exhausted to constantly remind them to pick up after themselves and point out the messes that they apparently cannot see under their noses.  Soon my son also got into the habit of making a mess of his room as well.  His favorite floor covering is a mixture of Lego's, Bakugan and ninjas on motorcycles scattered with books, playing cards and Nerf darts.

Whenever we asked the kids to clean up their rooms, histrionics ensue as though we are asking for the ultimate sacrifice.  My daughter is often overwhelmed and would rather spend an hour crying hysterically instead of cleaning up her room. When that happens we have to break down the task for her so that she can handle it.   Pick up all the dress-up jewelry and put them in the box, gather up all the dolls and put them in the dollhouse, put the books in the bookcase, etc.  It is often more work to direct her than to do it yourself, but hopefully it is sinking into her chaotic brain.

I asked my son recently if having a neat room felt good.  He said no.  Do you feel happy when your room is messy?  Yes.  How about when you need to find something?  I'll just throw things around until I find it.  What if you need to find it in a hurry?  I'll just throw things faster.  Organized bliss is obviously a lost cause on him!

In the meantime, we still need to get our kids to clean their rooms even though entropy rules their lives.  So how do we cope?  Here are some tips that we've used in the past:

  • Bribery - The promise of a cookie can work wonders.  Magically, tears disappear and rooms get cleaned up in minutes.  Of course, this approach must be used sparingly as not to add obesity to list of ways we are ruining our kids.
  • Taking away privileges - This is our general approach to discipline.  Video games, computer time and play dates disappear when they don't listen.  This is not as effective as bribery when it comes to cleaning rooms as they often get more upset and feel persecuted.
  • Donating old toys and books - This is also a great way to teach charity.  The biggest problem when it comes to cleaning up the kids' rooms is finding a place for all their stuff.  The less stuff they have, the less they have to clean up.  We always let them choose which items they want to keep or donate, with parental line-item veto of course.

I don't remember when I first turned around and got the urge to clean and organize on a semi-regular basis.  All I know is that my kids at age 8 and 5 are a long way off from that point.  And hopefully they will someday appreciate all our efforts to get them to clean their rooms.

Contributing editor Angela blogs about her kids' exploits in entropy at mommy bytes.

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
mysailorsmistress 5 pts

I am in the same boat. I like to keep a neat house but my room is NEVER fully clean. My daughter is getting a bit better. If it is just to tidy up she is good. If the roomis bad then I help her. I get frustrated but I help.

Bribes do not even work at that point.

I try to teach my son. He will clean up at the point if mess but NOT after. He just has no desire.   

Jennifer

www.mysailorsmistress.net ( http://www.mysailorsmistress.net )

moonfever0 5 pts

I remember as a kid that cleaning my room was always a chore, but then I don't remember it ever being a total pig sty. My parents would prod me long before it got to that point. But when I went to college and lived in a dorm, I distinctly remember one night looking at my room full of dirty clothes mixed in with engineering projects because I was too busy with schoolwork to clean it up. You couldn't see the floor and it was truly a pig sty. That was when I realized that it wasn't any way to live and I turned myself around. There comes a point when you take responsibility for your messes and I'm afraid it may be a while for your stepson to get there. But while he is still living under your roof, keep prodding!

Angela at mommy bytes ( http://www.mommybytes.com )
BlogHer Contributing Editor in Mommy & Family Cribsheet

jennifergreene 5 pts

Does it get any easier when they get older? My 14-year-old stepson is moving in with us in mid-July, and he's anything but neat. We're talking dirty clothes on the bathroom floor, dishes left in the living room, etc. This drives me nuts and sometimes becomes a source of contention! As far as I know, he's never really had many responsibilities or chores, so that is something his dad and I are planning to implement, along with a weekly allowance (provided that the chores are completed) to help teach money management. I guess we'll see how it goes!

TKMom 5 pts

We have run the gamut from, total standoff - clean up or perish, to oh the heck with it, my rooms a mess too and I'm tired!!  

Something that has helped us is keeping at it a little bit everyday... incorporate clean up into winding down play time, play music, designate a certain time each day to tidy up - for one or two minutes (before nap or bedtime works well).  Kids build habits much faster than us grown-ups. 

Check out some fun, creative kids teaching kids videos at www.tidykidz.com ( http://www.tidykidz.com )

moonfever0 5 pts

We also have clothes in limbo at our house. But the have to be put on a chair and not on the floor!

Angela at mommy bytes ( http://www.mommybytes.com )
BlogHer Contributing Editor in Mommy & Family Cribsheet

Biz Shrink 5 pts

Read my post  on this topic - http://www.blogher.com/those-piles-dirty-clothes-k...

Dr. Anne Perschel, President of Germane Consulting, is a leadership coach and business psychologist. 

AmberS 5 pts

My daughter is 4, and she finds cleaning overwhelming a lot of the time. I find that by doing it with her, and giving her small tasks she does better. Although there are still histrionics and a lot of objections. I don't sweat it at this point - whatever it takes to get the floor visible, right?

~ Amber

www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

moonfever0 5 pts

If you can make cleaning up part of a routine that is great. Sadly we have enough trouble with the morning and evening routines (which include wiping the sink after brushing teeth), that cleaning as taken a back burner. It would be much better if we didn't wait until the house was an explosion!

And we never make the children do more than they can handle when it comes to cleaning up. We do break it down for my daughter (see paragraph 3). But if there is a bribe involved, this suddenly becomes unnecessary and she can magically do it all by herself.

Angela at mommy bytes ( http://www.mommybytes.com )
BlogHer Contributing Editor in Mommy & Family Cribsheet

jill380 5 pts

I'm a terrible cleaner-upper.  I always have more important things to do than tidy (like play on my computer).  Clearly, I'm not a good role model and I've been hoping my kids will turn out neat just to spite me.  

No such luck.

I find the best way to get their rooms clean is to do it together.  We set aside a half hour, put on some lively music and do as much as we can.  

Jill

Hailey Hacks ( http://www.haileyhacks.com/ )

humanbeing 5 pts

Elementary school kids, even smart ones, have a hard time breaking a big job into pieces. They aren't developmentally ready to be that independent of thinkers. You have to help them break the task down into logical how-to steps. This is something my 2nd grader is just learning to do in school.

She has a list of daily chores that are single steps: pick up your clothes. brush your teeth, etc.

Every few days, we pick up her room together. This doesn't mean she's lazy. She just doesn't have the cognitive abilities yet to get it all done by herself. By helping her, I teach her how to do one step at a time. She's getting better at it.

I make it easy for her to put things away by having specific areas for everything. This is your paper drawer. This is where your books go. Here is your sock drawer. I'm not so anal as to label everything. Eventually, it all gets messy and we start over, but it works for a while.

I let her have general control over the state of her room.She's a creative girl, and from my experience with artists, they are rarely neat freaks. As long as there isn't food and trash everywhere, and her stuff is generally well cared for, I'm fine with it. Occasionally she hasn't taken care of her things and they've gotten lost or broken, and she's out of luck. If she wants a new one, she has to do extra chores at $1 a pop to buy it herself.

I have to do a lot of reminding. She says I'm nagging, and I tell her than when she can do something like take her breakfast dishes to the kitchen, rinse them and put them in the dishwasher 7 days in a row without me reminding her, I'll stop reminding her. Until then, well, it's my job to nag. But it's also my job to teach her, step by step, until she can do it on her own.