Bio
I write at Rocks In My Dryer, , and I'm a BlogHer Contributing Editor (Mommy/Family). I also write at The Parenting Post.  In February, I traveled to...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Commuter Families Cope With Challenges

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

The normal demands on a growing family are, in and of themselves, substantial.  But imagine combining the "everyday" demands with the added pressure of a marriage in which circumstances dictate that spouses live in different locations (often called "commuter marriages").  This situation can take a significant toll on a family, for obvious reasons.

Jennifer Conlin of the New York Times wrote about this ever-more-common scenario earlier this month.  Due, at least in part, to fewer job choices in a faltering economy, Conlin reported that that

In 2006, the Census Bureau reported that 3.6 million married Americans (not including separated couples) were living apart from their spouses. In March, Worldwide ERC, the association for work-force mobility, released a report revealing that three-fourths of the 174 relocation agents surveyed had dealt with at least one commuter marriage in 2007, a 53 percent increase since 2003.  

She went on to discuss the reality that while economic pressures may drive families to this difficult choice, modern technological advances (Skype, e-mail, etc.) make the physical separation a little easier for some families to bear:

“A couple of hundred years ago a sailor went to sea and you didn’t know if he were dead or alive for a few years,” says Tina B. Tessina, whose latest book, The Commuter Marriage: Keep Your Relationship Close While You’re Far Apart, gives couples tips on how to stay connected, which include making use of the latest technology.

Nancy Jamison of Jamison Consulting reflects on how such technology is benefiting not only families in the corporate world, but in the military one as well:

Outside of corporate life, feel good press pieces have also made much about the use of video for keeping armed services families in touch with each other. This is on top of the fact that troops now have cellphones, which they can often use from anywhere in the world (when allowed) to call home. This in itself has amazed me the most as never before in any conflict have we kept so close to the troops by getting everything from phone calls, to pictures and videos sent by cell phones and other devices.

With or without the technological aids, it's hard to imagine that this scenario is one that families would enter into lightly.  Dad reading books to the kids via webcam may be helpful in a pinch, but it's no substitute for the real thing.  Many families feel it's a leap they just couldn't make, including Betsy Shaw of MOMformation:

...Leaving the country to pursue career goals, and not seeing your children for weeks, months, possibly even years, is not a choice I think I could make.

Perhaps this is the spoiled, sheltered American in me talking. I realize that many immigrants have been doing just that– working in foreign countries and sending money back to their families to keep them fed– for decades, not to mention active military members, but it’s a concept this child of the sixties and early seventies can’t easily grasp.

It's a valid point.  I agree with Betsy , knowing the dynamics of my own marriage and family, that this option would be unthinkable for me.  But perhaps it's unthinkable to me because it's not required of me, and it doesn't appear that it will be any time soon.  Families have had to make tough choices for generations, long before webcams made it seem more palatable.

When Rachel Emma Silverman of the Wall Street Journal Juggle (a blog geared entirely toward handling work/family balance issues) addressed the topic of commuter marriages, commenters reacted strongly, with a majority of them expressing their own discouraging experiences with the arrangement.  One wrote:

My DH and I subsisted in a commuter marriage for 5 years back when we were in academia (it is very very common in academia because it is so hard to find jobs in the same geographic location). It was horrible and we would have to be on the brink of losing everything before I would do it again. The person doing the commuting (in our case, it was me) always feels like a guest.

Anissa Mayhew puts a very personal face to commuter marriages in her post "Getting to THAT point." A job opportunity for her husband required that he moved, but Anissa, for many reasons, including having

  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Carrie Blankenship 5 pts

I am the product of a "commuter marriage" myself.  My dad was a commercial fisherman during my childhood which required he be gone for 2-3 months at a time.  Granted, that is small potatoes compared to the 12 plus months military families have to endure being apart, and like Anissa's family, but it was constant.  He was always coming and going and sometimes we'd relocate w/him, but most of the time we didn't.  My parents have now been happily married for 37 years.

Being married to a firefighter, who is gone for 24 hour stretches, I am happy to have my parents example to live by.  However, I do find myself wishing that he just had a "regular" 9-5 job just like normal people due to the fact that it is just so hard to go back and forth between being the one parent in charge, to sharing the responsibility for his long stretches of time off between shifts.  I hate the inconsistency and although I love having him home, I'm fine when he's at work too.  I can't imagine if he were gone for 12 months, but you are right to point out that technology has come a long way in helping people feel more connected while apart.

Now I'm rambling.  I guess when I look around at the successful marriages and how each couple/family copes with the time apart.  I see a lot of support and love and people making it work.  Granted, it isn't always easy - but it can be done.  And I applaud those of you who have gone through it.

Carrie at Stop Screaming I'm Driving! ( http://stopscreamingimdriving.com )

Pam 5 pts

And honestly, there were things about it that I really liked. I liked having my very own life, I like the adventure of jetting off to my husband's home country (yes, I said COUNTRY), I like the totally cosmopolitan nature living in two countries gave us. But ultimately, I couldn't deal with it any longer and put my foot down, hard. 

I don't recommend it. You need a lot of trust and security, you need to be without doubt that this is your mate. It takes a toll on the wallet - all that jetting around is expensive, as is having two homes - and too much time apart leads to getting used to being solo, bad if you're in a relationship. I think it's okay if you have a plan to end it, but as a permanent lifestyle, no thank you - ours was permanent enough, it lasted nearly 10 years. 

I can't imagine putting kids through this - we don't have any and I would not want a bungee partner in parenting, nor would I want to shuffle kids between places, schools, friends, etc... I feel more like a survivor of something difficult than a person who particpating in something cool. 

P. 

Nerd's Eye View ( http://www.nerdseyeview.com )@nerdseyeview

Watch Her Back 5 pts

Watch Her Back (http://watchherback.blogspot.com ( http://watchherback.blogspot.com/ ))

This is a very timely piece, as many commentators have lately been discussing how the Obamas are going from having, essentially, a commuter marriage during the time he worked in DC and during the campaign, to all living together in the White House.

 I don't think this would ever work for my family, but I do know couples that function so much better in a long-distance marriage. They learn to love it and eventually need their "space" on a regular basis. Not sure how good that is long term but it seems to work in the short term.