Bio
Morra Aarons Mele is the founder of Women Online, a consulting firm for companies, not for profits and political campaigns seeking to mobilize women...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

The Cuddling Rebellion: The Bittersweet Transition from Baby to Toddler

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

So this is why you get pregnant again!! Now that my baby has –overnight—become an adventurous and defiant toddler, I look back at photos of him at eight months: all squishy deliciousness, a truly cuddly baby. My 11.5 month-old son, aka "The Ace," is a happy, curious, and extremely social little guy. But we stopped nursing last week, and since then I have realized how much I miss our cuddle time. It seems that now he wants to do his own thing and isn't nearly as needy or in need of me holding him. Instead, he wants to explore, cruise around, "read" his books and play with his toys. I really miss holding and cuddling him! But he just doesn't seem to need me as much. I'm determined to move through it though, so read below for some great ideas about how he and I can move on together.

I combed through discussions online. Many mothers feel sad when they wean, (except Rita Arens, who "wanted her boobs back"), but I have given up on those. I found this letter from mommyblogger, "So The Fish Said", to her 13 month-old baby and started to cry because it captured so well how I feel:

You stopped nursing this month, just quit one day. I tried for a while to get you to go back to it, but you are stubborn and willful and independent and when you set your mind to something it is difficult to divert you. You come by all of these qualities honestly. It was very sad for me when you stopped nursing. I loved that time we spent together, I loved the connection and the few quiet moments out of your busy, busy day. Not nursing has changed you so much, you are much more a little girl now than a baby. I love that you are growing up, that you are making your own decisions. I am proud of you for being strong enough to give up something that was such a major part of all the life you know so far.

Is this cuddling-rebellion normal? I don't want to smother him but I am sad. I posed this question to Ellen Galinsky, the child development expert who has also done path-breaking research on what kids want their parents to know.

Here is what Ellen replied,

“The traditional way of thinking about children's development was seeing it as a straight path from dependence to independence, from an almost fusion-like state with their mothers to becoming separate. But newer studies are painting a very different picture. For example, the studies of Daniel Stern of the University of Geneva reveal that children are born alone and their developmental main task is learning to connect with us—the important people in their lives—in many different ways as they grow up.

When I studied parent development for my book, The Six Stages of Parenthood, it was also clear that every new phase of children and PARENT's growth involves learning new way of separating and new ways of connecting. It is always separating and connecting, separating and connecting.

Stopping nursing is a milestone in your life so no wonder you are sad. Now the task for you is to find new ways of connecting that involve physical connections—playing peek-a-boo, horsey where you bounce your baby as if he was riding a horse, and other games where you can hold him but in ways that respect the drive for being more independent.

In my forthcoming book, Mind in the Making, I frame the important life skills that help us as parents and our children thrive. One of the seven skills I outline is taking on challenges. So amidst your sadness, see yourself and your son as learning to take on challenges—because that is what growth is all about.”

One commenter on Mamapedia summed up my feelings about this first transition to independence:

“Oh, and, yes, you can still snuggle and still have time togheter [sic], but it is not the same. It's sort of like when they lose the baby look, or start pronouncing a word the right way - but you liked it better the baby way! :-) You know it's part of their growing up - but that doesn't make it any easier.”

Then again, as I’m reading in Gail Collins’ amazing America’s Women, in 17th Century New England settlers called their children “it” until kids reached their teens. The mortality rate was simply too high to become too attached. That certainly puts my

  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
VelvetMinxx 5 pts

You have nailed it. This is totally why I want another baby. Good work, detective!

Mommy2JearBear 5 pts

Aww....I completely understand where you're coming from. I was never able to breastfeed my son due to complications so I didn't feel that kind of loss. However when my son turned 1 I felt loss. Even though he was still in many ways a baby I knew that it was only a matter of time before he became independent. My son is now almost 4 and he's certainly independent. While I am happy he is growing, I miss the baby days when I could just hold him any time I wanted. Now, he doesn't always like being cuddled, sometimes he won't give me kisses bye bye and sometimes he will literally ask me to leave his room so he can be alone. I know he still loves me but at this age he doesn't always want to show it. It's hard but I have hope he will come back around with time.

Sincerely Yours, Jessica Mommy to Jeremiah

getrealmommy 5 pts

My latest blog post was on this very issue. http://getrealmama.blogspot.com/2010/01/bye-bye-ba...

I have a 4.5 year old and a 19 month old. I stopped nursing my youngest at 14 months, so it isn't so much the mourning of the end of nursing, but realizing that pretty soon there will be no more babies. It is in fact so very bittersweet. I can't imagine life with three babies, but I am starting to feel tempted....

Morra Aarons Mele 5 pts

Of course, you want them to find their own way, but you want them to need you too. Parenting of a toddler is an exercise in separating your own needs from those of your kid, eh?

I'm proud of you too!

Morra Aarons-Mele
www.womenandwork.org

Cassandra 5 pts

Right now, we are going through a good-bye kiss rebellion in our house.  Amelia is almost 2.5.  I leave a few minutes before she and my husband do in the a.m., and for the past week or so, she runs off to play instead of giving me a kiss bye-bye.  I figure the less of a big deal I make of it, the sooner she'll be back to giving me kisses!

She weaned last June. :(  We had such a rough beginning (she was 3 months premature).  I had hoped to wean her at 2, but she decided to wean a few months before that.  *sigh*  I cried and cried.  And was so very proud of her.  And me.

Patience is a virtue that takes too long ( http://take3-cassandra.blogspot.com/ )