Blog
Parentopia
Bio
I am excited to be a Family CE at BlogHer! My primary blog is www.Parentopia.com/blog . I am an author of the award winning book "Mommy Guilt:Learn t...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Daddy's in the Strip Club, Baby's in the Car and Someone's on the Telephone Calling the Police

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

A 42-year-old father in New Zealand is facing criminal charges he left his one-year-old baby alone in a car while he visited a strip club. The incident was reported to the authorities by a passer-by, who noticed the baby in the vehicle around 3 a.m. in the parking lot of the club. Authorities arrived within seven minutes, removed the child from the car and brought the baby to a hospital for observation. The child appears to be physically unharmed and is now being taken care of at another hospital while family members make arrangements for his care.  The predictable route would be to rehash that a dad left his baby in a car while he went into a strip club, call out his lousy parenting, and then write it up with the requisite smug remark dooming the child's future.

 

Men sitting on couch watching stripper

I'm not going to go that route. I think we're all tired of it, and frankly, it offers nothing new to the conversation -- nor is it really news. We hear stories about kids in cars all summer long. And they are tragic stories. And they hurt our hearts -- so much so that I'm not going to link to any of them. We all know summer is heading our way, and kids dying in cars is bound to be in the news yet again. But instead of focusing on admonishing anyone, let's focus on what it takes to be a good Samaritan -- the person who makes the decision to get involved, to pick up the phone, to say a few words. In some situations, it's black and white: Witness a baby alone in a car, it's 3 a.m. and the vehicle is in the parking lot of a strip joint. But ...

What if I told you that in some states it is legal to leave a baby alone in a vehicle for up to 10 minutes? It's true. When I lived in Illinois, I watched on a lovely day in mid-May as a woman left her toddler in the back seat of her car and walked into a store. I was about to say something to her, but I noticed a police officer stood by his own car in the parking lot, not even 10 feet away. He witnessed the entire thing, and yet he didn't utter a peep. Not even a "Ma'am, your baby is in that car." Nada. Zippo. Silent. As a social worker, I am a mandated reporter, as are officers of the law. I was admittedly dumbfounded when the police officer just stood there, doing nothing and yet witnessing a potentially dangerous situation for a baby. It was a WTF moment.

I approached the officer and introduced myself, explained I had recently moved to Illinois and maybe the laws are different here. I shared with the officer that where I come from you can't legally leave your baby alone in a car. He told me, "In the state of Ilinois, you can. For up to 10 minutes. I've got my watch going on her." I believe, and you can quote me on this, I responded, "Are you shitting me?" I just could not fathom the state of Illinois could be so stupid. In 10 minutes, a child under six years old left alone in a car in the summer heat could be dead! The officer shrugged his shoulders as if to say, "I only enforce the law, I don't make the law." Holy wake-up call, Batman!

But even if the law is on your side, people are often afraid to get involved and offer assistance. Here are a few misconceptions folks have shared with me that make it difficult for them to pick up the phone when they observe a child in danger.*

"If I call the police or child protective services, that parent is going to have his or her child taken away." Well, to this I say "Thank you LifeTime Movie Network for depicting social workers as baby snatchers." The more serious answer is that typically it takes far more than one phone call to remove a child from a parent -- and even if a child is taken into custody, other family members are the first ones considered to provide temporary shelter and care. One phone call to child

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
susanmorgan 5 pts

I agree that people need to make that call if you see something in wrong with a child. The abusers bank on the fact that people don't want to get involved and they can do anything and get away with it. Thanks for this it might save some of these children.

kherbert 6 pts

My understanding of the 5 or 10 minute rule is that it is there so that the adult can put up the cart, step over to pay for gas without breaking the law. Also with the officer watching and keeping a clock on the woman you saw he could see if the child was in distress. 

 

I've reported 2 child abuse cases in 11 years of teaching. One child had whip marks across her arms and back - it was ruled there was no abuse. The other child made an outcry report that turned out to be a flat out lie. The family was 'on the radar' because some neighbors had seen my student hurting his little brother and reported that as neglect. The boy ended up getting anger management and other therapy.

 

I was critized for not reporting  a student's untreated broken hand as neglect. The hand was broken on Friday night but didn't swell or bruise till mid day Monday. Similar things have happen to a couple of kids in my family, including my little sister. (Almost identical Sis broke her wrist Friday night. There was no swelling or bruising. Sis complained of pain but wasn't crying and could move her hand and fingers. They actually finally x-rayed it because she refused to do some favorite activities. They thought it was a bad sprain and did the x-ray to prove to sis it wasn't broken. It was.)

juliep 5 pts

The law in Texas expressly allows showing porn to a minor *if you are the parent/guardian and are with them.* Porn itself is not illegal unless it includes minors.

There is a DA in Randall CO who is very frustrated by this. He is trying to show that it was an act that lead to mental impairment but that's not really flying either.

You can read my post for more details. In short, I think everyone did what they should have to help and investigate in this case, including the judge who awarded custody to the mother and only allows the dad to have supervised visits now.

Julie Using My Words ( http://theartfulflower.blogspot.com/ )

Devra Renner 5 pts

Isn't showing porn to a minor an offense in Texas? Wouldn't it be considered, at the very least, contributing to the delinquency of a minor? Plus there are pedophiles who may attempt to legitimize their abusive behavior by claiming they were merely trying to provide sex education to their kid. Therapist was absolutely right to report the dad to the authorities.

But I also see the flip side, that not all missteps in parenting are abusive. But when it doubt, help em out is what I recommend. And if it means calling up and reporting a suspected abuse, well then that's what it might take.

I feel for any family who has been falsely accused, however false accusations are a small drop in the bucket compared to the amount of cases which wind up being substantiated. I understand how it would make anyone feel wary of the system, but keep in mind the system's ultimate purpose is to protect children. But it's not a perfect system, that's for sure.

www.parentopia.com/blog ( http://www.parentopia.com/blog )

juliep 5 pts

Just today I wrote about the case here in TX where a father use live Internet porn, in which he was participating, to teach his daughters about sex. After months, the 8 yo (it was an 8 and 9 yo) finally confessed to her therapist, who reported it to CPS.

I'm going to add in a link to this post so readers can see when, why, how and what to report!

WRT my opinion: in the case I mentioned, I 100% agree with the therapist reporting it to CPS, even if it wasn't illegal, and I think CPS was right to investigate. Better to protect the kids.

I have known families that were investigated, in fact, one good friend was after a malicious report (but that's another story) and it was severely traumatizing to them, left them with a lot of anger. They weren't very happy about the whole deal, especially how they felt they were treated (which did seem extreme). That's made me wary.

But you are right and this post is a good guide. Thanks.

Julie Using My Words ( http://theartfulflower.blogspot.com/ )

Devra Renner 5 pts

As a school social worker, I also had to call in reports. Never a decision any of us make lightly and yes, it does come with the territory. As I told my husband when I decided to become a social worker, I may not make millions, but hopefully what I do will positively impact the millions.
Thank you for the kind words about the piece, I have been meaning to write up pointers about this issue for years, so the timing was right to do it now.

www.parentopia.com/blog ( http://www.parentopia.com/blog )

SusieKline 5 pts

Very nice article! I am a former child welfare worker (also a mandated reporter) in IL. I had to call in so many families in my role as crisis worker for runaways and lockouts and as a counselor at a child care center. It's sad, but it was my job.

Hopefully your article will make it easier for a lay-person to make the call when it's needed!

Thanks!
Susie
www.motherhoot.blogspot.com ( http://www.motherhoot.blogspot.com )