Bio
I am a 44 year old single mother of two beautiful children; Brian 20, and Nicole 17. Being a mom is the thing I am most proud of; I could sit and ta...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Depression: Do the benefits of anti-depressants outweigh the risks?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Anti-depressants have been in the news a lot recently.  There are new questions about anti-depressant use and the risk of suicide.  Questions about why anti-depressant use seems to be on the rise.  Questions about the risks of using anti-depressants during pregnancy.  And questions about the safety of using anti-depressants in adolescence.  Unfortunately, there are more questions than answers.

For me, these types of questions boil down to...Do the benefits outweigh the risks? And there is no right or wrong answer, I believe these questions need to be addressed on a case by case basis.

As with everything in life - Knowledge is power.  So in this post we will take a look at the latest news surrounding anti-depressant use, as well as links to information on diagnosis and treatment of depression.

From NPR - FDA Considers Fresh Warning on Anti-Depressants...

We know depression can cause suicide, but can antidepressants do the same thing? Today the Food and Drug Administration is taking up one of the toughest questions facing the agency, whether certain types of anti-depressants known as SSRIs are dangerous.

NPR's Joanne Silberner reports that a panel convened by the FDA may have a hard time making a recommendation on what to do about this class of popular drugs, which includes Zoloft, Prozac and Paxil.

From USA Today - Depression Diagnoses Fell After FDA Antidepressant Warnings...

It was already known that antidepressant use among young people had fallen since the drugs began carrying a so-called "black box" warning about risks. But the data showing an extended decline in the level of depression diagnoses are new.

In some cases, untreated depression can be more dangerous than suicidal feelings when starting antidepressants and a spike in teenage suicides in 2004 worried some experts that could be another unintended result of the FDA warnings. Then, teen suicides fell slightly the following year, offering hope that the suicide increase was just a blip.

From The Examiner - Are Antidepressants Linked to Suicide...

There has been a long standing debate on the safety of antidepressants since the U. S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued its "black box" alert in 2004. This alert was printed on all antidepressant packaging warning patients and parents that children and adolescents have an increased risk of suicidal thoughts and behavior. (www.webmd.com)

Since then, depression diagnoses have fallen in all age groups and people who need help are not receiving treatment because they are afraid of treatment. When the warning came out, the public overreacted thus keeping people from seeking help and possibly committing suicide. Depression is not only a serious illness but it is also fatal.

From L.A. Times Health - Older Antidepressant Spurs More Suicidal Thinking In Men Than Newer Medications...

The largest clinical trial to date comparing an older, tricyclic antidepressant with a newer antidepressant of the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) class has found that the emergence of suicidal thinking was almost 10 times more common in men taking the older drug than in those taking the newer medication.

The study also found that for men and women taking either medication, suicidal thinking was spread over the first six weeks of treatment, but peaked at roughly the fifth week before declining significantly after week six. Taking place at academic medical institutions across Europe, the trial, called Genome-Based Therapeutic Drugs for Depression--or GENDEP--gauged the responses to antidepressants of 811 persons ranging from 18 to 72 with depression.

From World News - Antidepressant Use During Pregnancy Linked With Some Adverse Outcomes In Newborn...

Exposure to a certain class of antidepressant medications during pregnancy may be associated with an increased risk of preterm birth, a low five-minute Apgar score (a measure of overall health of the baby) and admission to the neonatal intensive care unit, according to a report in the October issue of Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, one of the JAMA/Archives journals. More than one in ten pregnant women are estimated to have depression,...

From Furious Seasons - Study: SSRIs Linked To Pre-Term Deliveries...

A Danish study out in the Archives of Pediatric & Adolescent Medicine asserts that women taking an SSRI anti-depressant while pregnant had double the risk of having a pre-term baby and had almost two and one-half times the risk of having their baby wind up admitted to a neo-natal ICU.

The study comes on the heels of an earlier study this year linking anti-depressant use during pregnancy to premature births.

From Neuroskeptic - U.S. Antidepressant Use

  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Catherine Morgan 5 pts

I'm so sorry for your loss...I can't even imagine.  Thanks for sharing your story, it's important for people to know that all medications do not work the same for all people.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at Catherine-Morgan.com ( http://catherine-morgan.com/ ) and Women4Hope ( http://women4hope.wordpress.com/ )

Catherine Morgan 5 pts

Thanks for taking the time to talk about your personal experience with depression and anti-depressants.  I totally agree with everything you've said...especially that taking anti-depressants is nothing to be ashamed about.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at Catherine-Morgan.com ( http://catherine-morgan.com/ ) and Women4Hope ( http://women4hope.wordpress.com/ )

pookielocks 5 pts

I was first officially diagnosed with depression at age 19. My dr. told my mom to watch for increased suicidal tendencies. He explained that when kids/adults 1st go to the dr for depression, they're usually sooooo far down in the hole that they don't have the energy to go about acting on suicidal thoughts. as the meds start to work, they feel "better" & are more likely to act on those suicidal thoughts. i agree with that school of thought as i've been there and experienced it. i believe adults are more likely to take a step back & think through those moments & remember they have reason to live (like family, children, job etc) than teens and children are. by nature, they are more likely to be impulsive and in-the-moment.

i'm 32 now & still on meds. i'll most likely always been on some form of anti-depressant, but i am not ashamed by this. it's a chemical imbalace not unlike diabetes/insulin. i don't agree with shoving meds down every sad person's throat, but they work for me. meds do no solve interpersonal problems or issues, but they do help those of us who have a chemical balance be able to lead a more stress-free life than we would without them.

My latest BlogHer Post - Dolphins: The Truth About Our Friends From the Sea ( http://www.blogher.com/dolphins-creatures-healing-... )
SBAB ( http://www.shebecameabutterfly.net/ ) & ( http://www.msmodern.com/ )

Frances Ellen 5 pts

<!-- /* Style Definitions */ p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal {mso-style-parent:""; margin:0in; margin-bottom:.0001pt; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:12.0pt; font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-fareast-font-family:"Times New Roman";} @page ( http://twitter.com/page ) Section1 {size:8.5in 11.0in; margin:1.0in 1.25in 1.0in 1.25in; mso-header-margin:.5in; mso-footer-margin:.5in; mso-paper-source:0;} div.Section1 {page:Section1;} -->

I agree with Tserisa that depression must be treated on a case to case basis especially where teenagers are concerned. The problem with young people is that there is a fine line between normal teenage angst and abnormal teenage depression. A parent must be careful to avoid putting the notion into a youth’s head that there is a pill to cure everything. Once an anti-depressant is prescribed, there must be careful follow-ups every year to determine whether the pill is still necessary or not.

I hope I do not come off sounding like a person who is anti antidepressants. There have been instances when help, in the form of medications, has been crucial in my own life. My fear is that if you do not encourage a child to swim against a strong current by using his own inborn skills while he is a teenager, you may be forming an adult who will be unable to withstand a nasty rip-current when it hits later in life.

I’m saying: be careful, be sure, and then do what you must. A child’s life depends upon your choice. Make your best educated decision.

Frances Ellen is the Narrator of the Story of Nadia ( http://storyofnadia.wordpress.com/ ) - The continuing fiction story of a card reader named Nadia. She is also the voice at Frances E ( http://francesellenspeaks.com/ )llen Speaks

Catherine Morgan 5 pts

Thanks for your comment...I totally agree.

:-)

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at Catherine-Morgan.com ( http://catherine-morgan.com/ ) and Women4Hope ( http://women4hope.wordpress.com/ )

Willful Woman 5 pts

I have to say that the benefits of antidepressants most definitely outweigh the risks. I think the increase in the use of antidepression meds has to do with the fact that our society is finally getting more educated about mental illness. Medical breakthroughs have been made and people suffering from these diseases don't have to suffer in isolation or in institutions or in silence their whole lives any longer. There are viable treatments. There is not quite the same amount of shame associated with admitting you suffer from depression as there was in decades past. The stigma is beginning to lift. Depression and anxiety are debilitating and complex diseases that have stunted and prematurely ended too many lives. 

The alternative is pushing people back into suffering in shame. Institutionalizing people, making them suffer in silence, lobotomizing them or giving them electric shock treatment (although even that has come a long way.) I think it is irresponsible to raise only the red flags of antidepressants when they have saved so many people's lives. There are still so many people out there who feel they should be able to "pull themselves up by their bootstraps" all by themselves without any help from anyone else even when they are in the middle of a mental health crisis. Playing on people's fears about antidepressants only discourages them from seeking help. Discussing the pros and cons of any medication with a trusted physician is how one decides when and what kind of medication to use. Do we use too much pain medication as a society? Should we just suck it up and accept that pain is a part of life? Do we take too much cholesterol-lowering medication in this country? Should we just deal with the fact that heart attacks are a part of life? If you are genetically-prone to a disease, you need to watch out for it. If it heads your way, you treat it. That's depression and anxiety. Period.    

Always a... Willful Woman @ ( http://twitter.com/ ) www.besidethestonewall.com ( http://www.besidethestonewall.com ) Visitors always welcome! Bring your stories to share!

Catherine Morgan 5 pts

Hi Tserisa.  Thanks so much for sharing your personal story with anti-depressants.  I agree that in many cases these medications are a true life saver.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at Catherine-Morgan.com ( http://catherine-morgan.com/ ) and Women4Hope ( http://women4hope.wordpress.com/ )

Tserisa 5 pts

I *definitely* think it has to be a case by case basis.

I have been on antidepressants for many, many years, despite very successful cognitive-behavioral therapy with an incredible psychologist -- the best therapist I have been to, of many. I've also been through gestalt and other kinds of therapy. Although I'm much better than I was years ago, I still can't function without my antidepressants. It used to be I was super depressed without them, and just depressed on them, but now I am usually a very happy person while taking them, because of the combination of therapy and medication.

Now, I am rarely suicidal while on the medication, while I am pretty much always suicidal when off it. I have tried many times to go off of it, out of worries about the long-term side effects, and a desire to not be dependant on it, but at this time I can't. I still hope some day to be free of them, but for now, they keep me healthy, functional and happy.

For some people, like me, the benefit of antidepressants is *being alive*. I definitely would've killed myself long ago without the medication. Without antidepressants, my ability to think logically about my situation goes out the window. I'd say that benefit, for me, definitely outweighs the risks.

loraleechoate 6 pts

I am just starting to talk publicly about this, but I had a suicide attempt after the death of my baby from SIDS in 2003.

While I was obviously depressed, I was misdiagnosed with Bipolar disorder and put on a pharmacy. I absolutely KNOW that being on anti-depressants contributed to the utter deterioration of my mental state and lead to that dark moment. I did not start getting better until I went off of everything.

BUT.

I know that they are lifesaving for many, many people.

I have tried them a few times, each time is a no-go, so I stopped trying.

I wish that they DID work for me. It would make many things easier.