Bio
I'm the BlogHer Contributing Editor on parenting children with special needs, and I'm at your service.  I am more than a parent, but with three...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Did Autism Cleave Jim Carrey and Jenny McCarthy?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Gleeful tweets and DMs starting rolling onto my computer screen shortly after Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey announced their separation via Twitter. People wanted to know how I felt about the implosion of the Generation Rescue-fronting Hollywood couple's five-year relationship. Didn't I hate them? Wasn't I happy?

Premiere of Yes Man held in Los Angeles

To which I respond: No, I am not pleased -- why would I be? I may not agree with Jenny McCarthy's autism opinions and efforts, but that's political, not personal -- I do not wish heartbreak upon anyone. Besides, I worry about her son Evan, whom his mother describes as "recovered" from autism but who likely still thrives on routine and stability. Jenny's breakup with Jim, Evan's de facto stepfather, means Evan is experiencing big home life changes, and will be needing more support than usual to navigate his new reality. Who can gloat when a child touched by autism has their world disrupted?

Theories about the Carrey-McCarthy breakup are still percolating - even Hugh Hefner has an opinion. Did Jenny and Jim break up because Carrey had gone off his meds and was being beastly? Was Carrey cheating? Or was Carrey not up to the challenge of parenting a child with autism?

Now, I have no idea if any of the guesses being floated around the Internet are true, but I do want to talk about that last one -- that stereotype of a child's autism or special needs being the catalyst when parents part ways. It's true that parenting a child with special needs can be stressful -- McCarthy has publicly stated that Evan's father's inability to cope with his son's autism led to their divorce. But should we believe her oft-quoted 80 percent divorce rate for parents of kids with autism? Especially when other surveys indicate that the divorce rates for our families are actually lower than those for parents of neurotypical kids?

What do you think? Does having a child with special needs make our partnerships and marriages weaker, or stronger? And how does it affect kids with special needs when their parents' relationship ends? I'd love to hear your opinions. In the meantime, I asked bloggers who parent children with multiple special needs to talk about the state of their own marriages.

Jennifer Byde Myers from Jennyalice says:

While I feel that children change the direction of any marriage, having a special needs child changes the direction of everything in your life, and often.

I feel lucky because I got to figure out really early on that I married the right man, and that I want this marriage to last my lifetime. We have learned how to be a team, how to give each other space, how to argue while still taking care of some pretty big or stinky jobs.

I do think marriage is harder when you have a special needs kid. Just finding a babysitter to go to therapy can feel insurmountable, and where is the money for date night supposed to come from when all of your dollars seem to be going towards therapy or special shoes, or another stroller that's even bigger because your kid still can't walk? Everything is just a little bit harder, fixing dinner, bath time, childcare, hours you keep at the office versus home; having a special needs kid impacts the choices you make in every category of your life, it's not like "marriage" could really stand outside of that.

Beth (Niksmom) from Maternal Instincts says:

There is no doubt that Nik's special needs are a huge part of our marriage. We struggled to get pregnant, his delivery was premature and scary, and the medical staff weren't sure if our son would make it through the first night. We knew ours would not be any easy parenting/family road, though I don't think either of us had any idea just how difficult it would get.

I didn't get to see Nik until several hours after he was born. Christian and I held hands and cried tears of joy, grief, confusion. The first thing I said to Christian was, "This can either make or break us. I don't want this to break us." He assured me it wouldn't. That's not to say there haven't been times we've both worried that we'd bend under the weight of all that life has dealt us.

But I think that holds true when there is an absolute commitment to the

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Katastrophes 5 pts

My son doesn't have autism, he has cerebral palsy. So I hope you don't mind my commenting on something about families with Autism but I think that as a parent of an 11 year old boy who is totally dependent on me for everything in his life I may be able to add my take on this subject.
I think that what dictates whether a family will break up after having a special needs child diagnosed depends on the dynamic of that family.
I'm not going to lie, it's hard. But then my family has the outlook that life is hard, everyone has it tough, someway or another. What makes you special is the way that you deal with it.
You can shake your fist at the sky and lament what could have or should have been or you can continue on with a smile on your face and celebrate the things that are.
If both parents share the same outlook and are positive about their family than it will probably make a successful marriage but if they are different and can't come to terms together and learn to lean on each other and not take the bad days to heart then there isn't much hope for them.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

I put this update (published just this week) in the main post body as well:

80 Percent Autism Divorce Rate Debunked in First-Of-Its Kind Scientific Study: Kennedy Krieger researchers find autism does not affect family structure. ( http://www.kennedykrieger.org/kki_news.jsp?pid=885... )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa
Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com ) parenting first, autism second
CanISitWithYou.org ( http://www.canisitwithyou.org )
real tales of schoolyard terror and triumph

martian momma 5 pts

I've also heard the 80% quoted as a statistic for AS/NT marriages. I would imagine if you had an NT/NT marriage having a child with a disability would draw you closer together because you would be able to support each other.

On the other hand if you have an AS husband there is a good chance he is not going to react well to having other Aspies in the house (having two Aspie children I have often found that they set each other off, sometimes deliberately) and he is not going to be able to provide you with the emotional support you need to cope with your Aspie/Autist children.

I suspect the divorce rate really depends on how many Aspies/Autists are living in your household. The larger the number of ASDs, probably the greater your chances of splitting.

Unless of course you're all on the spectrum, in which case you can probably manage by writing out all the rules very, very clearly and nailing them to the refrigerator.

KylieE 5 pts

I have 4 children - the eldest is 9 and the youngest is 4. Two of them have ASD. I married with no intention of ever divorcing, and I thought that my husband felt the same way. He left after Christmas, after 14 years of marriage. Do I blame Autism? No. It is definitely not my children's fault. I don't think my husband would say that it because of Autism either... but I don't know.

I could write a novel about my thoughts on this, but the short version is that it isn't Autism that ended our marriage, but the way that we chose to live with the Autism in our lives played a part. Having a child with Autism changed many of my views about what is important, and I would say that it changed my husband's as well. They changed differently.

Again, definitely NOT our children's fault.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Thank you everyone, I so very much appreciate hearing your various perspectives. What I'm hearing the loudest is what resonates with my partnership as well -- yes, things can be hard. But there is no blaming the child(ren), and when things don't work out, it's usually because of exacerbated rather than generated differences in approach.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa
Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com ) parenting first, autism second
CanISitWithYou.org ( http://www.canisitwithyou.org )
real tales of schoolyard terror and triumph

Crimson Wife 5 pts

I don't have an autistic child, but I do know that it can be very stressful on a marriage when parents disagree about a special needs child.

lalagirl727 5 pts

Things can be stressful at times in my marriage - we're raising two sets of multiples, we have a teenager in the house, and we're dealing with autism - but I can't even imagine us ever deciding to separate. I don't see how any good could possibly ever come of it, where our son is concerned.

Mommy to a teen and two sets of school-age twins - eeek! Blogging at LaLaGirl - Twinfinite Chaos ( http://lalagirl.org ).

raisingbipolar 5 pts

Living with a person with bipolar disorder can be very difficult. Parenting a child with any special need is very difficult. Combine the two and you have a hard road. Who knows what the final blow was for them but Jenny had her hands full, that's for sure. I know with my son sometimes I just don't have the energy to deal with my husband's needs. Our situation (bipolar child) requires him to be very strong because most of my energy goes to dealing with my son's needs.

www.raisingbipolar.com ( http://www.raisingbipolar.com )

BarnMaven 5 pts

I would in no way blame my daughter for the end of my marriage. I will say that my marriage was not strong enough to survive the many things that caused us stress, including having a daughter who is severely bipolar and ADHD. We were already two stressed out and unhappy people -- rages and daycare expulsions and doctor bills and the ensuing money issues were big stumbling blocks for us.

I have always felt that my daughter's issues are simply a part of her, I love her and can't imagine life without her. I know her father loves her too, but whenever she has a bad string of days, he gets so panicked and strung out all he can say is that he thinks she needs to be in a home. Its one of the reasons I can no longer be married to him.

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.typepad.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.

Mir Kamin 6 pts

... to be caught agreeing with anything Jenny McCarthy's ever said... ;)

... I do think the divorce rate is higher amongst couples with special needs kids. Because it's hard and stressful to parent AND nurture a marriage, but it's hardER still to do all of that when your child takes more then the "regular" amount of time/energy, too. Now, I have no idea if the 80% figure is accurate, but I suspect the sentiment is correct.

--
Mir Kamin
(BlogHer contributing editor)

Personal: Woulda Coulda Shoulda ( http://wouldashoulda.com/ )

Having it all with less: Want Not ( http://wantnot.net/ )

planetjoshmom 5 pts

As a mom of a severely autistic 11 year old boy and now single after almost 14 years of marriage, I can tell you that my son's issues had absolutely NOTHING to do with the demise of my relationship. If anything, I think it kept us together longer than we would have been otherwise. It IS making things more complicated as far as the split goes as there are very long term issues to consider, but really, our relationship was broken before he was even born. Unfortunately on the surface of it, this will contribute to the Autism = divorce stereotype but the two are truly unrelated in my case.

Sarah

http://planetjosh.squarespace.com

Niksmom 5 pts

I'm sorry I wasn't as articulate (or concise) as I wanted to be when I wrote my reply to you. What I really wanted to get across is that my husband and I simply had a mindset that does not include divorce unless there are some pretty extenuating circumstances (abuse or infidelity come to mind). However, that doesn't mean we think marriage is easy. With that in mind, we have some rules that we keep in our marriage that work for us. The two most important rules are that we don't let fights get personal, we try really hard to stick to the actual issue. The other is that we don't go to bed angry.

Yes, there have been nights we haven't slept, but we either resolve the differences or come to accept that it's not that important that we agree as much as it is that we respect the other person's POV. That helps keep trust intact. Once trust is gone it's a slippery slope, in my opinion.

http://maternalinstincts.wordpress.com ( http://maternalinstincts.wordpress.com/ )