Most Popular

Recent Comments

Dear HuffPo: Divorce Is NOT Like Death, It's Like Divorce

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

My children will never see their father again. He will never be late picking them up for "his weekend." He will never spend another birthday with them, another Christmas, or see them in another Halloween costume. They will never call him on the phone. He will not attend their weddings.

They can't. He can't. His body was cremated. His ashes are buried.

apples to oranges

To compare the loss of my husband to a divorce? Those aren't the same animals. That's why you don't do it. That's why I don't do it.

Pain shouldn't be compared. It requires you to make assumptions about my life, my loss, my world. Making assumptions is never a good idea.

I haven't been through a divorce, so I'd never presume to compare my loss to yours. I'd never presume to compare my grief to the grief of a divorcee.

But I do know that there's a difference between having parents and not. I do know there's a difference between having the ability to interact with your parents and not. I do know that there's a difference between burying your child's parent and watching him walk out the door. I'm not saying one is easier, but it is different.

So, please don't tell me it's similar when you haven't walked in my shoes.

Yes, there are rituals surrounding death and grieving the loss of a parent, but there are also stigmas about death that often result in children and the surviving parent being alienated by former friends and family members. People don't know what to say because becoming a widow at 40 is rare. Losing your parent at 12 or 13 is unusual. Friends don't know how to act. Family members are struggling with their own grief. It's not as neat and tidy as the author of Divorce is Like Death Without the Support or Rituals would have you believe.

While I appreciate her desire to have rituals and support through the loss and grief that happens as the result of divorce, there was no need to liken it to the death of a spouse. While my husband remains in the ground, her ex is above. Let's not compare apples and oranges. It trivializes both of our experiences.


Leah has been writing at Califmom since 2004. She became a 40-year-old widow in April of 2010 when her husband and love of her life for 21 years died from Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma. She and her two children continue to live in the San Francisco Bay Area.

  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
scorpiomiss 5 pts

there is no comparison - how dare people of divorce compare their loss to a death - when someone dies you never see them again - period.  unlike divorce.  period - so how dare someone try to put them together in the same realm is disreptful to people who have had someone they love die. 

22dots 5 pts

I have been married twice. I lost my first wife of 8 years to cancer. I was left after 25 years by my second wife and I can tell you the loss, grieving and the emotional carnage is EXACTLY the same. So since you have no divorce experience please remain silent on this issue.

meerKat 5 pts

Leah, you are so right! I went through a terrible divorce several years ago and even as bad as it was, I would never compare it to the loss of a spouse.

withduckandgoose 5 pts

Amen to everything you said. I can't imagine comparing divorce to death on any level because, well, they're not even remotely comparable.

I'm so sorry you've lost your husband.

FragrantLiar 5 pts

My divorce resulted in my four children's father leaving not only me but them in every respect. He left and never looked back. Never wrote, never called, never sent cards, never paid a dime of child support. He hid out and severed all ties despite my attempts to make it otherwise. His four children haven't seen him since then, and that's been 25 years. Yes, it was like death for them.

Kimberly Cockrill
aka, Fragrant Liar
Mmmm! Something smells yummy! Hey, it's my blog!
http://fragrantliar.blogspot.com ( http://fragrantliar.blogspot.com/ )

22dots 5 pts

FragrantLiar The same thing happened to my daughter...so now she says she hates her mother. Now i wonder what kind of woman my daughter will become. What identity will she choose and when will her pain end.

yvettefrancino 5 pts

When I went through my divorce, I took a class in which they combined those who had lost a spouse either through death or divorce.

I was actually embarrassed for the comparison. Though I haven't lost a spouse, I've lost a brother and a father, and I know that grief is completely different from that of a divorce. I get really offended when I hear someone divorced claim that the pain is worse because you have to suffer from rejection. As you say, you can't compare pains. But I know the grief I felt from losing people I loved to death was far worse for me than the pain of divorce. I can't imagine how painful it must be to lose a spouse to death.

I'm so sorry for your loss and for the lack of sensitivity of people who compare the grief of divorce to the grief of death.

22dots 5 pts

yvettefrancino You must have not loved your spouse...or at least loved him/her as much as your father or brother. If true it's a little wierd.

garney77 5 pts

I watched this happen to my sister-in-law, her husband was killed in a car accident and she became a widow at the age of 30, and again to one of my oldest friends again car accident this time age 32. My family and friends will never have the opportunity to "deal" with their ex's. Their children will never get to miss a weekend with their parent. They are gone forever. It truly saddens me to think that someone would be so careless with their words, so self pitying to say their divorce is even similar to the death of a spouse. I'm so sorry for your and your childrens' loss. I pray you have the strength to remember the love you shared and can show your children who that person was to them
Best Wishes ,

Kim

bethbugs 5 pts

Leah,

Thank you for your words. I do not know that pain as a spouse. However, I do know the pain of a child as I lost my own father at 12 years old. So, thank you for speaking up for not just the spouse, but for the children left behind.

My dad couldn't give me away at my wedding last year, he couldn't snap a picture with me at my high school and college graduations, he won't be there for the birth of my children, and he wasn't here for my first holidays as the hostess.

But, at least I know he's not here because he didn't want to be. I know if he could, he would have been here for it all! And, I know he is watching over me and the family I have started.

Leah, I'm sorry for the loss that you and your children are going through. And thank you again for speaking up!

casadecruz 5 pts

You are absolutely grace under pressure, Leah. Great piece. Thinking of you.

Tina@SendChocolate

cheaper than candy...half as sweet

 life, autism, homeschooling, free. Sarcasm is a bonus, aren't you lucky??

Some people say I'm funny.  Me? 

naturallyalise 5 pts

I agree wholeheartedly... pain should never be lumped together, every pain has a unique set of emotions that go along with it.

JennaHatfield 188 pts

I hate the Pain Olympics and unnecessary comparisons. Thinking of you.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

sister_earth 5 pts

I am so sorry for your loss...my prayers are with you and your family

kimt205 8 pts

So well written Leah. And so very true. Love you. Thanks for putting what so many of us widows feel when this comparison comes up. Having been through both, it's not the same at all. XOXO

Redneck Mommy 8 pts

I don't know what it is like to bury a spouse, mine is still alive. And I'm thankful for that every second of every day. Nor do I know what it feels like to divorce a spouse and have to carry on with a family and feel that burden of pain, as I've been happily married for almost 14 years now.

But to me, it is like comparing apples to oranges.

Well said Leah. Well said.

When Tanis Miller isn't writing on her blog Attack of the Redneck Mommy ( http://theredneckmommy.com ) she spends her time beading errant chin whiskers.

Judy Schwartz Haley 34 pts

People really say some stupid things. When my developmentally challenged foster brother died, a nurse (yes, a nurse) said to me "it must be like losing a pet." No, it's not like losing a pet, it's exactly like losing a brother.

I'm so sorry for your family's loss.

And thank you for this post.

Judy Schwartz Haley is currently battling breast cancer while raising her toddler daughter. She is a full time college student, as is her husband. It's a lot to juggle, and she blogs about it all at CoffeeJitters.Net ( http://coffeejitters.net/blog )

grace134 5 pts

Beautifully stated, Leah.

Miss Grace's Disgrace ( http://www.missdisgrace.com )