Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Do You Fight in Front of Your Kids? I Do. Sort of.

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Some parents never fight in front of their kids, and their kids grow up fine. Some parents scream at each other day, and their kids grow up fine. And some in each camp end up with kids who either think a fight means the end of the world or that love is best expressed by yelling and cursing.

What's the right thing to do?

I can't even begin to answer this question without first defining "fighting." Do we mean a civil disagreement? Or do we mean throwing cats? Because I personally believe even screaming at each other is fine as long as you are both fighting fair and you end the whole affair by apologizing and accepting responsibility for the emotional meltdown in front of your kids, as well.

Every couple has a fighting style, just as every individual comes out swinging in his or her own unique way. I'm a writer, so I tend to want to turn every argument over and over, talking it to death long after the other participant has walked out of the room in disgust. Nothing makes me more angry than being ignored or being shut down before I've said my piece.  So if I'm ticked off about something, I want to have it out, get resolution, and move on as quickly as possible. I don't like to sit and stew in my own juices, which tend to be acrid.

My husband would die if I wrote about our personal fighting style on the Internet, so I'm not going to drag him into this post. Suffice it to say that in eight years of marriage, we've had to accept our differences and learn to agree to disagree. We've learned to really examine whether or not we care about the subject at hand. I'm always tempted to win every argument just for the sake of winning it, and I had to learn to just let it go. Winning an argument doesn't mean you are better than your opponent. It just means you either cared more about the topic or were more willing to invest yourself in winning it. That, in and of itself, is both freeing and a good example for kids -- in my humble opinion.

As parents, I think we have to model fair fighting. It's nearly impossible to never fight in front of your kids, but I'm not sure you should have your knock-down drag-outs in front of them. Arguing over who's going to wash the car? Game on. Arguing about how to parent or money? NUNCA. I don't think you should argue about anything that might make your kids feel insecure in front of them. Kids don't understand money or parenting the way we do, and they may either fear life as they know it hangs delicately in the balance or that they somehow cause all of your arguments if you thrash that stuff out in front of them.

If you do happen to let loose (and we all do at some point), at the very least explain to your kids that just because you two fight doesn't mean you don't love each other or them. Adults fight just like kids do, and kids get that. The important part is letting the argument have a beginning and an end -- old arguments that drag on and on aren't going to win you any parenting awards.

Also? I think as often as possible you should agree to disagree in front of your kids. It's the foundation for civil disagreement, and kids don't learn civil disagreement nearly enough in their day-to-day lives, at least from my vantage point. Teaching kids when to stand up and fight and when to let it drop will be invaluable lessons to them later in life -- and can in fact even make their lives better and easier.

So yeah, I think you should fight in front of your kids.

Sort of.

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Rita Arens 7 pts

My husband and I were not even arguing the other day -- we were having a heated political discussion, but we weren't mad -- and my daughter wrote us a note that said "stop arguing." Except she totally misspelled the "arguing" part. It shut us up pretty fast.

Rita Arens writes at Surrender Dorothy ( http://surrenderdorothy.typepad.com ) and BlogHer and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

masalachica 5 pts

We both grew up in households where we saw a lot of fighting.  Not just bickering but some hard-core, throw down fighting.

SO . . .  we really, really try not to. Our two year old seems to be picking up on it now and so we really try to table it. BUT, despite our efforts - it still happens.  My husband knows exactly how to rile me up - and after saying what he has to say, when I start responding - he will be like 'uh uh uh - not in front of the kids." which is really just infuriating!  So i sit there and simmer and come up with all the things I am going to say once its just the two of us.

Cuz that's when he's REALLY going to get it.

http://masalachica.blogspot.com/

AmyMusings 5 pts

My parents never fought. My husband's mom and step-dad fought until his mom ran out of steam. I avoid conflict. It makes my guts tie up in knots. The dog hides, the kids are on eggshells. So he doesn't understand why I always say "let's talk about it later." He wants to tick this "discussion" off of his to-do list. I think fights where you have your buttons pushed and it's not behavior you want to model for your children, should be fought when the kids aren't around. But to fight over things that you know you can resolve are constructive fights that the kids need to learn from so they know how to do it. There are healthy fights and unhealthy fights. The goal is to model the healthy fights, not no fighting at all and not fight until you drop.

Amy Kehoe

www.amymusings.com ( http://www.amymusings.com )

HappyHer 5 pts

Great Article!  Children learn relationship dynamics at home.  I think it's imporant to allow them to see their parents in all facets of their relationship, including fighting.  I feel you need to discern what the appropriate topics are though and to use respectful and healthy communication tools when you do fight. 

Allowing your children to see that you can disagree, compromise, and to continue on in a loving manner will help them learn life lessons that will allow them to create their own healthy adult relationships.

Tracy Morrow Intimacy Specialist http://www.HappyHer.com/Blog

Motherhooduncensored 5 pts

Definitely depends on how you fight.

I think it's great to model disagreement AND resolution (make sure they see that as well). But if you're name calling and yelling (which I admit, I've been there - it's embarrassing and guilt inducing, but I'm human), then you might want to think again.

I think we often feel as though our kids need to see things "perfect" - that they shouldn't be tainted. But having a disagreement is a part of life - and being able to voice that is important for them to see, especially for my girls. AND, even better, it's good for them to see how to come to resolutions.

Kristen Chase

Motherhood Uncensored

http://www.motherhooduncensored.net