
I've gotten so many private emails from BlogHers who want to meet these women that I decided to open a conversation about the BlogHer '09 Saturday keynote I'll emcee with Tina Brown, Donna Byrd and Ilene Chaiken.
Given that each woman has made media history offline, I plan to ask about their experience -- so far -- bringing their creativity and strategies to social media. What do they love about it? Or hate? Can they tell their stories on the Web better than in traditional media -- or are they limited by the medium? And is there any profitable business model in sight for online news and culture, news and culture from an African American perspective, and mainstream storytelling that happens to include lesbians? (Don't throw eggs on that last one, I want us all to learn from the brilliant arguments these women clearly know how to make for quality content.)
I simply kick-off the conversation -- in the BlogHer tradition, many of the questions are up to you. What will you ask Brown, Byrd and Chaiken? If you're not going to join us in Chicago in person, what can I ask for you? As always, if I use your question, I'll credit you and your blog if you have one. Please leave your question in the comments below. Thanks.
Do NOT be shy: I can confirm they are writers first, famous second, after this week's conversations. They are looking forward to meeting you as much as you look forward to getting to know them. Brown, Byrd and Chaiken all plan to attend sessions at BlogHer and to learn more about this community.
Here's a little more on the speakers, including links to their extended bios.

Tina Brown is the Founder and Editor in Chief of The Daily Beast. She is the author of the 2007 New York Times best seller “The Diana Chronicles.” Brown won many awards for her leadership of three magazines -- Tatler, Vanity Fair and The New Yorker. She has written for numerous publications including The Times of London, The Spectator, and the Washington Post. >More

Donna Byrd is Publisher of TheRoot.com, a daily online magazine that provides thought-provoking commentary on today's news from a variety of black perspectives. As publisher, Byrd leverages her expertise in marketing, strategic business planning and digital innovation to lead one of the top African American-focused daily magazines on the Web. >More

Ilene Chaiken has been a pioneer in the portrayal of lesbians on television, with a penchant for storytelling and a passion for her community. Chaiken has worked openly as a lesbian in Hollywood for over 25 years and is internationally known for her creation of the groundbreaking series, “The L Word.” Chaiken spearheaded the launch of OurChart.com, a fully-featured social networking and media site on the Web for lesbians and their friends. >More
Okay, bring on your questions!
Best,
Lisa
Comments
I have a question
If you could go back in time and confront your 21 year old self, what advice would you give yourself about the journey ahead? -Florida Girl Meets the Midwest
www.floridagirlmidwest.blogspot.com
Right on - Tina, will you be at the
conference?
Want to make sure I reference you correctly. Love your blog name.
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
This is for Ilene
First off a compliment that scene during the fifth season where Jenny introduces the cast of Lez Girls to their counterparts and Shane makes party brownies? That is the best party scene ever.
Now burning questions from friends who almost died when I told them I'd be in your presence:
1) Why did you kill Dana? So many people took her death very hard. Were you prepared for such a strong reaction from your fans?
2) Jenny Schecter. I shake my head just thinking about her. Leading up to the final season you had many fans positively thrilled that she would be dying. But we get to the end. Everyone is looking for her. Alice returns from the balcony and she's dead. But we never find out who killed her. Sooooo? After all of that lead up and suspense, why not tell us who killed her? I did see on Twitter that you are writing The L Word movie but will we find out then?
Heather B.
No Pasa Nada: www.nopasanada.org
BlogHer: http://www.blogher.com/blog/heatherb
HeatherB, fantastic question! Dana (sob) and
Jenny.
Perhaps Ilene will read us a line from her evolving script? HINT HINT MCHINT... :)
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Why?! And Who?!
I've got to sort of echo Heather, here.
Breast cancer is a huge health issue for lesbians, so having a member of the show with breast cancer was important. Having her die, not so much (since the majority of women who get breast cancer do not die, thankfully.) I think the show would have been better had you kept our beloved Dana alive...
And who really did kill Jenny and why, oh why, couldn't they have killed her sooner? I mean really!
~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Flamingo House Happenings
Spoiler Alert
I killed Jenny.
(The genius of the mystery around who killed Jenny is that we could all project ourselves in the roll of killing her, which was very satisfying. Should I admit that?)
Lisa,
Our comments reveal the strong ownership that viewers, especially GLBTQ viewers felt about the L Word. I'd love to hear Ilene's thoughts about the power of this demographic as early adopters and communtiy members, and how to best tap into that power.
Deb
www.debontherocks.com blog
www.3smartgirlz.com consulting
www.queerosphere.com story ranking for GLBTQ content
www.hotblogstars.com celebrating bloggers
Deb, probably a stupid question by me but
...have you visited OurChart.com? Love this: "I'd love to hear Ilene's thoughts about the power of this demographic as early adopters and communtiy members, and how to best tap into that power."
I know Ilene has a ton to say in response -- and the data to support her. Great!
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Killing Jenny
Boy, that's the question I want asked too. I was never so angry at the end of a show in my life. I had ZERO interest in watching the "interviews" on the internet because I felt I'd been royally cheated. I didn't read any comments from people who didn't feel the same way.
This is what I want to know.
I was a faithful fan of that show, but the finale left a bitter taste in my mouth, as it did for everyone else I talked about it with. I would just like to know who killed Jenny so I can
applaud themfinally know.- Maria
http://immoralmatriarch.com
Immoral Matriarch, let's see what we can get
from Ilene...
Was this approach perhaps a brilliant strategy to build audience for a feature film? Did a master storyteller here build her own case for her film? How do we as viewers feel about that?
I personally think it's brilliant -- LOOK at all of us! We really cared about this story.
There's a classic challenge for women's or lesbian or African-American programming, as a creative enterprise and as a for-profit business: How do you produce content so fantastic that it becomes mainstream? Looks like The L-Word nailed it, which was one of Ilene's goals -- because not everyone in this thread is gay, but we were completely sucked into the drama too. I'd like to ask Ilene more about that too.
TheRoot.com is doing a great job along these lines as well -- check out these stories:
Toward an 'Authentic' Black Barbie
Stay In Your Lane, Beyonce
The Best Year In Jazz Ever
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Strategy?
If it's a strategy to build an audience for a future film, it has failed with me. I am still so angry about the time wasted on the last season of The L Word that I have no interest whatsoever in a film, were it to be made.
Basykes, shall I ask Ilene about the risks of
tying
your viewers into knots by killing off favorite characters, making them feel "royally cheated" as you describe?
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Question
It's not that she killed off a favorite character -- everyone wanted her dead -- it's that she spent the entire last season hinting at who was the murderer and then ended the series without ever revealing the answer, leaving legions of fans feeling royally cheated.
And yes, I'd love to know her answer to that.
Finding a voice
My question is more for Tina Brown and Donna Byrd, as Ilene Chaiken's site seems more tightly topic focused...
Both The Root and The Daily Beast cover a wide range of topics yet both have distinctive voices that seem grounded in a common reference point - a black perspective for The Root and I would love to know what it is for The Daily Beast. It has felt unique from the start yet I can't articulate what it is. Perhaps it is Tina Brown.
What I am hoping is that they can share any insight for those of us bloggers who don't have narrowly focused topic blogs (say something like shoes, veganism, raising Chihuahuas...) on how we can identify an organizing concept and then find, define and express our bloggy voices when we would like to blog about our general interests. Or, how do you cover food and politics and fashion and pop culture and news and relationships and more all at the same time, as both their sites do, and entice rather than confuse and annoy readers?
I hope that makes some sense. I am really looking forward to this powerhouse session.
Thanks, Lisa!
BlogHer Contributing Editor
PopConsumer
Beyond Help
Maria, you nailed it
I struggle with this myself. On the relatively rare occasions when I post on Surfette these days, I'm all over the place -- a far cry from early this decade when I was (a) all about Election 2004 or (b) all about the Supreme Court nominations of Harriet Miers, John Roberts and Sam Alito. Great one!
(Although, when I read your blog, I feel all those topics hang together quite fabulously. I want to hear the world according to Maria, that's why I'm there.)
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
A question for Ilene Chaiken
Could you reflect on the influence of The L Word on non-cable network programming and story lines? How much progress do you see, and what changes would you like to see happen?
More urgently, when is season 6 going to be available on Netflix!
Virginia DeBolt
BlogHer CE
Web Teacher
First 50 Words
Is there a prime-time television drama
focused on a lesbian now?
If there is, I'm not aware of it. Great question Virginia, I'm sure she'll have an opinion! I'd also like to expand this question to ask Donna how she feels about this re: African Americans and Tina re: women.
Edited to add: And, btw, I'm sure each of these women have opinions on the media offerings for all three communities!
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Is media and technology separating us or
bringing us closer?
40 years ago there were 3 major networks and a handful of national newspapers. Now the outlets for media are countless, and we can create our own social networks.
It's great to have all of this, but it's overwhelming. 40 years ago a person who made an effort to watch the news and read a major paper every day felt well informed; now it's impossible.
How do you think we will handle this? Will media, technology and more outlets bring us closer together and better informed, or further apart in our own niches - unaware of what others outside our niche are doing?
Would love to hear your insights on this.
Great question Bev: Is the "national
conversation" over due to
...social media?
Along these lines, btw, Elisa Camahort Page is emceeing a futurist conversation that I can't wait for: Who We Will Become, with PBS Frontline's senior producer (and one of the early instigators of their Digital Nation initiative) Raney Aronson-Rath, Northwestern University professor and sociologist Eszter Hargittai and Berkman fellow and Microsoft Researcher danah boyd.
I want someone to ask about the singularity...
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Will you commit to Zero Tolerance to Sexism
on the Daily Beast?
Editors of Femisex.com
Tina Brown—
I recently listened to you speak at the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, in New York. (I am an alum of that school.) It was very clear from that speech that you have liberal leanings. As a liberal, how can you justify the sexist leanings of your heds and deks on the Daily Beast. Recently when David Letterman attacked Gov. Sarah Palin on her “slut” look, you responded by announcing that David Letterman was Palin’s "latest victim."
The message you so loudly sent was that public figure woman have no right to stand up and complain when they are called sluts or when their female children are sexualized by the media. You have even suggested that Palin react more like Hillary—that is, not complain at all; to ignore such sexism.
A short time later you had this header: “Palin’s Polarizing Departure.”
We promptly wrote a piece that showed that Polarizing was a term used primarily against women to disembowel them politically. To Wit: David Geffen, against Hillary. (Geffen made the case--as Obama did throughout his campaign--that Hillary was too polarizing to be an effective leader.) It would seem to many reasonable people that by propagating the term Polarizing in relation to women and by ignoring the very troublesome use of the word Slut to describe a sitting governor you are only setting women’s rights on a backward path.
What will it take for you to pledge to Zero Tolerance to sexism on the Daily Beast in the manner media so clearly adheres to in terms of racism?
It seems impossible to ignore the fact that when powerful women, such as yourself, accept sexism aimed at women they don’t like, ALL Women suffer. If it is OK to sexualize “that” woman, then it is equally OK to sexualize “this’ women.
The Editors of FemiSex.com
http://www.femisex.com/content/the-polarizing-sarah-palin-and-hillary-rodham-clinton-andany-woman-who-wants-be-king
http://www.thedailybeast.com/big-fat-story/2009-06-12/the-wrath-of-sarah-palin/
http://www.femisex.com/content/the-s-word-it%E2%80%99s-not-breakfast-anymore-psst-someone-tell-media
http://www.femisex.com/content/slut-word-used-most-often-rapists-they-rape
Duly noted, editors of Femisex.com
Related: Both Huffpo and The Daily Beast have received criticism for leveraging naked babes and celebrities to drive traffic:
Mediaite: Dueling Sex Watch: HuffPo and Daily Beast Battle over Bikinis
Trashy Parasitism as a Get-Rich-Quick Scheme? Hi, HuffPo
HuffPo response to Dumenco via Howard Kurtz's column: Not Safe for Work
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Could You Talk More About the Evolution and
Vision of OurChart
First off I am thrilled out of my mind to hear this panel & hear Ilene speak in person again (had the thrill of listening to her on an Olivia cruise a few years ago). I will be running, not walking from my lunchtime commitment to this panel. The person skidding in last minute in a suit will be me.
I know OutChart has taken a few evolutions from its beginning to its current incarnation on the Showtime site. In previous seasons it played a prominent role in The L Word and in the last season only a passing mention. Ilene can you speak to your original vision for that site and how it has evolved? What you learned worked, didn't work and your lessons learned as well as current hopes for it.
Oh & ditto on the Jenny thing, we were praying she'd die in season 2 (even built a season cliffhanger board game for it that year)...and it drives one nuts not to know who killed her.
Warmly
-Paula
Paula Gregorowicz
The Paula G Company
http://www.thepaulagcompany.com
The evolution of OurChart...
...and how about its future? :)
Thanks Paula!
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Question for all three women
Think about a female author whose writing you admire - who was publishing 40 or more years ago. What do you think she would be blogging about if she were writing today?
Bev, dare I mention Evelyn Waugh?
That name has a likelihood to come up with Tina Brown. I love this question, thank you!
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
Thank you!
Lisa, you are so kind to comment on my suggestions. I am a newbie blogger and am already enjoying all the encouragement from BlogHer.
I was actually thinking about Edith Wharton! But Evelyn Waugh would work too and I'd be glad to hear Tina's viewpoint.
I'll be there and I'll be listening.
Bev
Questions About Journalism's Future
@Tina Brown
I'm a freelance journalist. I've heard some people in our field speculate that because of the economy, the days of news orgs hiring a lot of permanent staff will be no more. Instead, most news orgs will hire freelancers because it's more cost effective. Do you foresee this happening?
@Donna Byrd.
I interviewed spiritual author and speaker Iyanla Vanzant for The Root earlier this year. My question is about the black press and new media. Black newspapers are hurting in the economy. Some suggest if black papers just publish strictly online that could save them. However because of class issues, many black people don't have access to computer resources like other groups. If black papers went digital, do you think they would lose black readers?
Also what role should black news sites play in bringing more black people up to speed in the age of new media?
Thank you for your time.
Jenee (Juh-Nay)
Cocoa Fly blog