Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Does Your Daughter Breastfeed Her Dolls?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 33
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I bet she does not.  But maybe she should. But would that be weird?  Would it be weird to see a four-year-old hoist a Cabbage Patch kid to her unformed breastlets?  Would it make you uncomfortable?  

Boy oh boy oh boy oh boy oh boy.

Wyliecat wrote recently about playing dolls with her daughter and realizing they were bottle-fed only.

I sat there, happily playing doll-babies with Rosebud, when I suddenly realized we were bottle-feeding these lumps of plastic.

I've never had this conversation with my own four-year-old daughter, perhaps because she fed all her dolls solids ever since they came out of the package.  And because I breastfed my own daughter for exactly seven weeks, I probably wouldn't have given her a lecture on breastfeeding.  

However.
Maybe I should.

Maybe, as her mother, it's my responsibility to start filling her in now that no matter what choices she makes if and when she becomes a mother, and if and when she has a biological child that she even could breastfeed, society will, you know, probably tell her she's wrong.  Particularly the large part of society that could sell her an accessory to do it another way.  

And if she has trouble with breastfeeding and chooses the bottle, there will be another large portion of society, particularly the society that hangs out on parenting message boards or whatever they use in the year 2030, that will tell her that she is poisoning her baby if she doesn't breastfeed.

But regardless of whether or not a woman chooses to breastfeed, shouldn't she learn the basics before she's, say, eight months pregnant?  Couldn't we model breastfeeding with dolls the same way we do bottle feeding?  Clearly, some people are.  Check out Heather's adorable daughter, who has better technique than I ever did.

Breastfeeding baby?

Perhaps if we taught our daughters about breastfeeding with their dolls, they would grow up with a different relationship with their breasts, maybe one that's stronger than what they see on a semi mudflap.  I, for one, had a hard time with breastfeeding because of my strong mental connection between breasts and sex.  Some women have no issues with that at all, but for some reason, I just never thought of my breasts as food deliverers, even when it came time to use them that way.  Which is a damn shame.

It turns out, there is a doll for kids out there with a magnet in the mother's breast and a magnet in the baby's mouth that models breastfeeding. And apparently (bonus points -- Mattel, are you listening?) it comes in any hair or skin color.  (Editor's note:  I have never been contacted by this company - I just found the doll while researching this subject.)

There is another doll that is for mommies or soon-to-be-mommies who are trying to get the hang of breastfeeding. It apparently has an open mouth.  And yes, what comes to mind IMMEDIATELY when we think of dolls with open mouths?  According to Karma:

To clarify: yes, that is a big hole where her mouth is supposed to be, making her somewhat reminiscent of those "party" dolls you can buy at those "specialty" shops. Have to admit, even though I probably shouldn't, that that was the only thing I could think of when Nadine first pulled Sherry out. She sort of looks like a Cabbage.patch kid who's been around the block...a few times. But she does the trick, in terms of getting a sense of breastfeeding holds and positioning.

Breastfeeding doll for mothers

Sex and breasts and breastfeeding and maternal love and romantic love and sex.  I think part of the problem for me is that I have trouble juxtaposing the Judeo-Christian culture in which I was raised with the XXX standards of today's society.  You're not supposed to have breasts or show your breasts or let anyone touch your breasts, but then again, everyone else is running around selling cereal with theirs.  This is confusing to an adult, let alone a child.  Or maybe, in the case of Heather's daughter there in the photo, it's not confusing at all. She clearly knows what boobs are for.

And I'm a little jealous.

  • 33
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
uberbrun 5 pts

My nephew was 2 years, 4 months old when his sister was born.  My sister struggled after both deliveries with supply issues so spent a lot of time breastfeeding and pumping to try and feed her children.

 Imagine her suprise one day when my niece was about 4 months old when she emerged from the pantry to find my nephew laying across my niece who was playing on a mat in the floor.  My sister rushed over to rescue my niece and told my nephew he couldn't lay on her because she couldn't breathe.  "But mommy," he said, "I'm feeding her milk from my nippies."  I loved this!  Thought it was wonderful.  I intend in using it in my toast wwhen he gets married...well, maybe not.

madeintaiwan 5 pts

Why would it be weird to see a kid simulate breastfeeding but not bottle feeding?  People don't give it a second thought to see a little girl with a pretend bottle.  My first daughter hated nursing so I tried as long as I could and then let her be blissfully food-coma happy with her bottles, and then I had two little nursing monsters who nursed (last one still nursing) for 2 years.  Either or, as long as baby's happy....  Their pretend play reflects that - bottle or nursing... but always with love, love, love. :) 

http://watermelonmama.wordpress.com/

Hotmama 5 pts

 Who finds this a little disturbing. Especially the doll with the mouth? That just seems to wierd to me. Yes girls should know about breastfeeding and how great it is for a baby nutritionally and emotionally, but come on, these are kids.

"Being bisexual means you have twice the chance of having a date on Saturday nite!"

Kpvega 5 pts

She just naturally did it with her first doll, and always has since. Of course, I smiled and thought it was funny at first, but I am glad that there's nothing funny or weird about it to her, or to her older brother, or even her little friends. They are ALL are used to breastfeeding as the norm, and I am so glad for the healthy shift in our culture that they will carry into their own parenting someday.

Kristi

Small Things ( http://kristivega.blogs.com/smallthings )

Baby Philosophy - diapers, slings, & baby things ( http://www.babyphilosophy.com )

rshannigan 5 pts

whenever my girls get dolls I toss the plastic bottles in the garbage.  we might have 1 oe 2 in the house somewhere, in case of emergency, I don't know.

My 2 yr old finds a baby or bear to nurse every time I feed the real baby.   I think it's sweet, modeling.

http://mrshannigan.blogspot.com

stephfoster 5 pts

So cute, especially when it drives my father-in-law nuts to see a boy
doing that. My son's only 3, so it's not like a big deal for him.

campclan 5 pts

I haven't seen any of my girls nursing dolls in quite a while, but I've seen it when I was nursing another baby.

The nursing mommy and baby doll in the link are so sweet.

Dawn

My Home Sweet Home ( http://myhomesweethomeonline.net/ )

amygeekgrl 5 pts

My daughter has been giving her dolls "na-na" for a few years now (she's 4 yrs old). After her baby brother was born especially, she did a lot of nursing of her baby dolls. There's a picture of her here ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com/2006/11/ ). Most of our friends breastfeed so it's really all she's ever known. I have a feeling my son will be breastfeeding his dolls when he's a little older too. ;) I think it's wonderful.

Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess ( http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com )
BlogHers Act contributing editor ( http://www.blogher.com/special-events/bloghers-act )

Nourished Mother 5 pts

My girl has done it since about 18 months old. Lately she actually tries to nurse herself- squeezes the nipple and puts her head down and makes sucking sounds :-)

Blogging about herbs, food, parenting, community, culture, evolution, and more at www.NourishedMother.com ( http://www.NourishedMother.com )

chasingjoy 5 pts

I breastfed my son for 13 months and hope to be as lucky with my daughter (arriving soon). 

I thought I would have a problem with the sexual connection and I guess I did.  My hubby is a boob man to be sure but the ta-tas were off limits during those 13 months.  It didn't stop him from trying but he didn't get very far. :)

naptimewriter 5 pts

My son nurses his stuffed mammals. Before he weaned he sat reverently in the bath and nursed his boat, a doll, a fish, and a dolphin. We never corrected him, but he started asking which animals had nipples. Now he nurses only that which nurses in nature. :)

By two he could tell mammals from reptiles, and still, as soon as he learns about a new animal, asks if it has "nay-nays." We're torn on whether monsters have nipples. He and dad say yes; I say I don't know. I haven't met any nursing monsters, but I don't want to infringe on their right to nurse.

My son was also very clear, without any instruction, that bottle feeding is still nursing. We only knew one person who used a bottle, but before he could talk he signed to me that baby was nursing. I agreed, because any time you feed a baby with love, it's nursing.

I hope he learned through our attitutes about breasts that they're baby-feeding glands, not objects. I doubt that ideal will survive puberty, but maybe as a dad he'll make room for function over form, like my husband did.

--------

www.naptimewriting.wordpress.com ( http://www.naptimewriting.wordpress.com )

Doris 5 pts

 My sons all breast feed their dolls.  With all three of them John and I took the opportunity to discuss our feelings about breast feeding, and the differences between mom's milk and bottles.  We also discussed why we felt one was better then the other, and why their grandfathers kept telling them they shouldn't breast feed dolls!

It really turned into a good experience for all of us.  Now, well they are all over 6 feet and in their teens.  Boy I miss those days!

 Doris

( http://www.leakynews.com )

 The Leaky Cauldron ( http://www.leakynews.com )
Everything Harry Potter.

Fit, Fabulous and Forty the Natural Way! ( http://fitfabulousforty.blogspot.com/ )

EliseO 5 pts

Actually, both my son and daughter breast fed their dolls...everything from Barbie type dolls to stuffed animals.  They are bigger now, but I remember them actually joking with me about what they could and couldn't breastfeed.  

ameliasprout 5 pts

My daughter is too young still (and still getting a daily dose herself), but I hope she does.  I can say that even though I extendedly breastfed myself (my mom keeps upping the number, I think we're set on that I did it until I was almost 3), and I saw my brother along with other kids I knew nursed, I was suprisingly uninformed about the mechanics/reality of the whole process.  My husband was worse, and he will never live down suggesting I use one side over the other (assuming that they were connected) since that was a more perky nipple.  Were it not for the Internet, I doubt I would have succeeded. 

The good news is, having been through that, M will have a far better education than I did, especially if we decide to have another kid.  That way she can make an informed choice for herself.  And I really hope she nurses her dolls. 

mommalittle.com 5 pts

My oldest wasn't quite 18 months old when my baby was born, so he was really a baby himself. He didn't breastfeed dolls, he did one better.

My wine bottler open has a curious little man on top of it and my oldest would get it, stuff it under his shirt and breastfeed him.

I don't know what that means about my parenting. 

Come share a laugh!

http://mommalittle.com

Liz Thompson 5 pts

All four of my kids (yes, even The Boy) bottle-fed their dolls, because I did not breast feed my babies.  Perhaps, I should have also told them about breast-feeding, it explains why they were shocked to learn that, "those jum-buh-lee things" are not just for squeezing and were made for a much higher purpose.  Either way, they know NOW.  Still. I hope that they are comfortable with the idea of nurturing their children however they see fit.  Great article, Rita and the picture of Rosebud IS absolutely adorable.

--------------------------------------------

This Full House ( http://thisfullhouse.com )

This Full House Reviews ( http://thisfullhouse.com/reviews )

New Jersey Moms Blog ( http://svmomblog.typepad.com/new_jersey_moms_blog/ )

Imperfect Parent ( http://www.imperfectparent.com )

Summerm 5 pts

I don't have girls, but both of my sons have "breastfed" their dolls. I think it's adorable and wonderful. I've even taken pictures to remeber the cuteness ( http://wiredfornoise.com/boob-boys ). 

Summer

http://wiredfornoise.com

Maria0305 5 pts

And they still fight today about who drank more milk from mommy's boobs. :)

- Maria

http://immoralmatriarch.com

HeatherB 5 pts

I come from a long line of breastfeeder. The kind tha didn't care whether or not they were in public, they'd just whip out a boob anywhere. So that was pretty much the only way I knew hot to feed a baby (they went from breast to solid food). My mother used to come to daycare or to my Aunt's house, wherever I happened to be that day, just to feed me and my younger brother. If that's all you see or know, it's hard to think that other people do it different. It wasn't until I was 9 or 10 when I realized that some babies are bottle fed. But I don't recall thinking "oh, that's weird" it was just that some people did things different than others. The end. And now they're starting the 'natural childbirth' and 'midwifery' propaganda. The next decade is going to be really painful. 

Heather B.
Personal Blog: No Pasa Nada ( http://nopasanada.org )
BlogHer CE: Business, Career & Personal Finance ( http://blogher.org/topic/business-career-personal-... )

themommy 5 pts

My little one plays with her dolls this way too...I think it's absolutely beautiful. I am a bit militant when it comes to nursing, and love that my daughter is picking this up. I have a 2 yo and a 6 month old, and my older loves to watch and say "nin nins are nummy for the baby milky mommy". Sometimes she'll say "messy milk"! when my baby unlatches and has a bit of a stash..it's awesome!

My Blog: Your Impact matters
http://www.yourimpactmatters.com

ReneeJRoss 5 pts

Children model adults. A daughter will follow what she sees. I only have a boy and I breastfed him for 14 months, if I have a girl I expect to teach her about breastfeeding. I read Natural Mothering magazine and I just love the photos that they post of children breastfeeding. The funniest photo was of a boy, he had the breast pump on one side and the cat on the other!

Renée aka Mekhi's Mom

Cutie Booty Cakes ( http://cutiebootycakes.blogspot.com/ )

Rivster 5 pts

I completely expected my daughter to hold her babies up to her chest but she never did.  Interestingly, though, my two older kids would use the word 'nursing' regardless if we were using a breast (me!) or a bottle of breast milk (my husband!) when we fed the baby.  They were able to sense an intimacy that had less to do with the feeding aparatus and more to do with the physical closeness.

She did ask for a sling, though, for her dolls :)

Love_Is_Dope 5 pts

I don't have kids yet and I don't think I've ever seen a little girl attempt to breatfeed a baby doll. The idea has never even crossed my mind. Now that I am thinking about it though, it only makes sense that a little girl would do that if she sees her mom doing that. I'd be fine with it.
-Love_Is_Dope
http://loveisdope.wordpress.com

Just_Margaret 5 pts

My girl does breastfeed her dolls...she also pretends to be pregnant with them (stuffs them up her shirt!) And,
well, my boy does it too! A challenge arose when I explained that
women's bodies are designed to carry a baby in pregnancy and to feed a
baby, and that men's bodies are not.

"But Mom," I was admonished, "You said that girls can do whatever boys do and that boys can do whatever girls do..."

~Margaret

http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com

tsjohnson5 5 pts

My sisters did 'cause they saw me brestfeed my daughter. It was kinda funny.

Wyliekat 5 pts

My girl hasn't been around a lot of breastfeeding since she was breastfed herself. Then again, she hasn't been around of bottle-fed babies, either. I think when they're witness to one or the other, that becomes normalized. When they're around neither? Well, that's apparently when my urge to present both kicks in. ;-}

poppy 5 pts

Both my children nursed their stuffed animals.

And once when we were watching a cartoon with Droopy the Dog, where the story revolved around attaching a cow to a bottle via a hose (?) so the baby could be fed, my son, then three or four, asked me "Why doesn't she just feed the baby?" I had to explain that sometimes people used baby bottles.

And it's not that we were so outrageously crunchy granola; it's just that he'd never spent much time with a bottle-fed infant. The only thing he'd really experienced was his younger sister, and she was exclusively breast-fed.

www.poppisima.blogspot.com ( http://www.poppisima.blogspot.com ) The Opiate of the Masses

glensgirl 5 pts

Thanks for the link-back!

My daughter breastfeeds her dolls because breastfeeding is all she's ever known. It doesn't seem weird or shameful to her, because no one has ever made her feel that way about it. To her, the function of breasts is to feed babies!

The problem is that society has sexualized breasts so much, that people forget what God created them for.

Shoegirl1970 5 pts

Yes, my daugther was 3 when I had my son and she breastfed her dollies when she saw me feeding the baby. I thought it was hilarious and I was glad to be inculcating such a wonderful habit in her. I'm pretty sure she will breastfeed her children one day.

cagey333 5 pts

My daughter does not breastfeed her stuffed animals and dolls.  Oddly, she does tend to stick a bottle in their mouths.  Weird, because she has had a bottle herself only a few times.  I am going to blame television for that bit of modeling.

Kelli Oliver George

http://rancidraves.blogspot.com/

http://abooblog.blogspot.com/

Wyliekat 5 pts

I think, because breastfeeding is more intimate than bottle-feeding, at least in terms of appearance it's much more disorienting to see a little girl performing that act.

It may be because breasts are also erogenous zones. It may be because I'm just not used to seeing it. But yeah, strange.

(I did both with my girl, at different ages, most notably when she
self-weaned from the breast at 8 months. Boob juice just wasn't as good
as solids, to her mind.) 

krissy 5 pts

My daughter is two, still breastfeeding, and loves it.  I don't see the end in sight, even though at times breastfeeding is not the activity I would like to be doing!  (I'm a busy mom, and don't have time to sit for this.)

And Yes, she does breastfeed her dolls.  In fact, both her daddy and I tell her whenever she asks about Mommy's "Miwk" that she will have milk in the same place when she gets older, too.  She grins, points to her 'milk,' and knows she will be like her mommy.  She knows Daddy doesn't have it, 'cause when I'm too lazy to feed her, I tell her get milk from Daddy.  She knows I'm nuts! 

I think it is important to teach our children the truth about as much as we can, with as little shame or secrecy as possible.  They deserve that, and will be better equiped to make decisions later on. 

Society will always have another way things should be done.  We will never  please everyoe, so it's importantto make our own choices!

Krissy

http://krissy-mylittleworld.blogspot.com/

Kathy333 5 pts

My four year old watched me breastfeed our youngest and yes, she does breastfeed her dolls (and she bottle feeds them as well!)

My oldest was not a successful breastfeeder; she lost a ton of weight right away, my milk didn't come in, and we switched to bottles around eight weeks. She didn't want the breast after that.

I tried again with number two and she took to it immediately and we had no issues. Actually, the reverse: She would not take a bottle until almost eight months of age!

Anyway, being both pro bottle and pro breast (I just say feed the child!) I think it is funny and cute and normal to watch my daughter breastfeed her dolls. I hope that she understands that the important thing is to make sure when you have a baby that the baby is fed, breast or bottle, and healthy.

Great post!

Kathy

Mama Marathoner ( http://www.mamamarathoner.com )