When I hear Dr. Oz is going to be on Oprah, I usually try to watch. So today my daughter and I tuned in. One of the things Dr. Oz was talking about, was how eating eleven pounds of vegetables a day can be helpful in losing weight and in lowering blood pressure. At that time a big platter full of fruits, vegetables, and nuts was brought out and put in front of Dr. Oz and Oprah. It looked yummy to me.
It was when that platter of fresh fruits and vegetables was brought out that it occurred to me...I love all of those foods...So why do I have such a hard time sticking to a healthy diet? If it isn't because of the taste, could it be because of the cost?
For several years now, I have been battling uncontrolled hypertension and high cholesterol. And as a nurse, I know the best way to conquer these problems is with a healthy diet. So Dr. Oz wasn't really talking about anything I didn't already know, just something I haven't really been able to "stick" with.
Can someone actually lose weight by eating eleven pounds of food a day?
After 12 days, their cholesterol dropped by an average of 25 percent, their blood pressure dropped by 10 percent, and they lost about 10 pounds each—including two-and-a-quarter inches of their waists. "The results were … remarkable," Dr. Oz says.
"When you eat this kind of food, you're sending a very clear message to your brain," Dr. Oz says. "You're taking calories and nutrients. What we normally do in America is we give calories to people without nutrition. … The natural colors are gone, and so your brain sits back there and says, 'Am I still hungry or not?'"
By the end of that segment of the show, I had come to the conclusion that the best way for me to lower my blood pressure and cholesterol would be to follow this type of diet. But blueberries, broccoli, walnuts, and all those healthy foods aren't cheap...and I'm pretty sure my budget can't handle it.
Others have tried...
Does Eating Healthy Cost More?
Sam and I have recently started a new diet–a combination of Dr. Oz’s YOU diet, and Bob Greene’s Best Life Diet. Our focus is not so much on losing weight, but on making healthy eating and lifestyle changes. One thing that may have to change is our grocery budget. At least half of my grocery shopping is now done in the produce aisle–all the fresh fruits and veggies seem to add up. But am I really going to spend more in the long run? Some things I’m NOT buying lately: a lot of meat, cold cereal, huge bags of cheese, and white bread. Also, I’ve cut way back on eating out.
From The Daily Table...
Last week, CNN reported on a "new solution" to the obesity crisis: allowing employers to charge their obese employees a larger per-paycheck co-pay on their health insurance. Apparently, in July, new federal rules went into effect allowing for the "positive" reinforcement. But is hitting people in the pocketbook the answer to America's expanding waistline? Probably not--just yesterday, researchers at the University of Washington reported a link between property values and obesity, which confirmed what most of us already knew--that folks who live in low-income areas are more likely to be obese.
From The Naked Truth...
Oprah reviewing the raw food diet? They were discussing an experiment at the Paignton Zoo, in Devon England. Volunteers were monitored at the zoo, where they lived for 12 days, eating like apes. No monkey chow for them, just 11 pounds of raw fruit, nuts, and veggies!
Thoughts on Life, Love, and Loss - Eating Healthy, Losing Weight
The simple fact is fad diets don’t work. You might end up losing weight at first, but keeping it off is the difficult part. Focusing on permanent and realistic life changes is much more effective. Eating less fatty foods and opting for more fruits and vegetables will take the weight off and keep it off as long as you make this a lifelong practice.
And from Bev Sklar at That's Fit...
Can You Pass Dr. Oz's Push-up Test?
Now here's a test. Dr. Oz says a 30-year-old woman should be able to nail 45 bent-leg push-ups, while a man the same age should be capable of 35 standard push-ups. Take away five push-ups for every decade thereafter. Hold on, let me take the test. My face is red and hands are shaking, but I passed ... barely. Any takers?
So...What do you think? Can anyone "afford" to eat healthy? Can you? Do you?
I'm beginning to think that...
Money doesn't buy happiness, but is does buy healthy foods. I'm pretty sure that if I could afford to eat all these wonderful and healthy foods, I would be successful at lowering my blood pressure and cholesterol.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
Comments
Your budget can handle healthy
When you buy those healthy foods you need to also stop buying the really snack foods, I know that sounds obvious but many people continue to buy what they always have PLUS they buy those "new healthier foods".
Have you seen the half a dozen bloggers who were eating healthy or eating organic on a "food stamp budget"?
It certainly is possible to eat healthy - or healthier - on every budget. (unless you are poor and black and live inner city and at the mercy of tiny grocery stores... totally different issue.)
Make a one week menu, including snacks - make a grocery list buying ONLY what you need to create those meals - then go virtual shopping.
- ~Denise
Fast Times @ Homeschool High & Flamingo House Happenings
You make a great point Denise.
Hi Denise. You make a great point about not just adding the "new healthy foods", to what you normally buy. This might be why it always seems I spend more when I buy a lot more healthy foods. I continue to buy many of the same things, because my kids still want all the foods I normally get. I know I should just get them on the "healthy" lifestyle too...but that's easier said then done with a 13 and 16 year old. Any ideas?
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
Feeding the Kids
I think a better question would be, "Can you afford not to eat healthy?" The results of eating poorly will cost us dearly in the long run ... in more ways than one.
There are ways to gradually wean the kids into better eating habits. I am always talking about healthier foods to my kids, and while they frowned at first, I now see them making better choices on their own. In fact, to my surprise, two of my kids have started ordering water with their meals at restaurants instead of soda. Also, if I'm going to talk about the foods, I had better provide them, so I always make sure I have them on hand.
There are ways to get kids to eat healthier without them even knowing it too. For instance, I put flaxseed in casseroles; I throw broccoli sprouts in my salads; I make smoothies out of yogurt or frozen yogurt (with live probiotics) and frozen strawberries and blueberries and fresh bananas. I serve pomegranate juice with their breakfast, and I serve high protein meals. Peanut butter sandwiches can be fattening, but are very healthy if you don't go overboard.
A big key is to read labels - all of them! I recently heard a couple of women bragging about some bottled green tea they drink every day. They felt good about the fact that they were doing something good for their health. But when I checked the label, green tea was the first ingredient and the second was high fructose corn syrup. I think the dangers of the second ingredient were far out weighing the benefits of the first one.
Julie Alexander
www.wellnessandbeyond.net
I agree...
Hi Julie. I agree. We are already doing things like drinking water and not soda (we have actually never been soda drinkers). The kids do enjoy salads and fruit...but they also enjoy ice-cream and chips.
My daughter did agree that we should stop buying the junk foods and start buying more of the healthy stuff. With her on board with making these changes, it will be a lot easier.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
There's another alternative
Hi Catherine,
I just came across your post and found it to have some fantastic resources and your questions and concerns are being echoed by millions of Moms. Like another poster, I've found way to "sneak" in good stuff like flaxseed and some veggies but my daughter (2) just won't have it most times. If it's not noodles and red sauce it's not eaten. I made changes like bread....buy Healthy Life bread with flaxseed and all noodles are whole wheat noodles so those changes are great and helpful but getting a piece of broccoli down my daughter, simply not going to happen. I found another solution that has done WONDERS for the health and wellenss of my family. Juice Plus. I know your thinking, great another gimmick but I promise you it's not. Juice Plus are capsules/chewables and gummies that contain the nutritional essence of 17 different fruits and vegetables. It is also the most heavily researched (double blind, placebo controlled, peer reviewed studies) nutritional supplement out there. I have such a passion for this product that I'm now a distributor and trust me it's not because it's going to make me rich. After reading the research, hearing doctors recommend it I couldn't NOT tell everyone I know and hope they tell everyone they know. Sure, eating 5-9 servings of raw fruits and vegetabls is ideal but it simply doesn't happen and this product can fill those nutritional gaps. I'm not trying to hard sell you but I want you to know about it because I was going through the EXACT same struggles as you with my family before we found this. If you have further questions, visit my site and feel free to contact me any time.
http://www.juiceplus.com/nsa/pages/Home.soa?site=kc77819
It can be done within budget and in a kid
friendly way
Hi Denise and Catherine,
I once felt your pain! My family (husband and two daughters ages 14 and 11) eat tons of fruits and veggies and stay within budget. And, p.s. - it keeps us slim and more importantly energized. Here is what I did - first, I completely stopped buying anything that had high fructose corn syrup (hfcs) in the label. It was not easy and was time consuming at first, but once that was out of our diet, the cravings for junk food went away all together. If you want more info on how I eliminated the hfcs, just ask. Next - we live in New England but can get locally grown food from farmers' markets from about June to November. I stop by a farmers market at least once a week (go to localharvest.org to find one near you). The fruits and veggies taste unbelievable and are cheap (i.e., $1.50 for a pound of peppers, a few bucks for 12 ears of corn, 75 cents for 3 cucumbers (a candy bar costs more than that). Even when the farmers markets close down, I continue to only buy fruits or veggies that are in season which keeps the costs WAY down and has proved to be a healthier way of life for us. These are just a couple of suggestions - from my personal experience, once we started to eat tons of healthy foods, we no longer wanted unhealthy ones. Most important, we all have a very nice relationship with our food now - it is good to us - no more belly aches, sinus infections, runny noses, asthma or IBS - YEAH! Hope this helps.
Warmly,
Sue Muro
Great Post --
I try to look at this question with a "per serving" orientation -- if a pound of vegetables costs $2 and serves 4 - $.50 per serving, meat $4 - $1 per serving. Then check dried beans and oatmeal and eggs and other 'whole' foods - they're far lower.
(And maybe this could be tagged for Food & Drink, too?)
Alanna Kellogg, A Veggie Venture
I agree...
Hi Alanna. When you compare per serving it does seem it would be cheaper to go healthy. My problem is...I still need to cook for my kids, and they won't have anything to do with the eating healthy stuff.
And thanks for the tip...I tagged the post for Food & Drink too.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
I'm having trouble imagining..
I'm having trouble imagining eating 11 pounds of fruits and veggies a day, and I eat fairly healthy. Eleven pounds sounds like more than 11 servings and I even struggle to achieve that goal.
It's got less to do with the cost (well that's a differentissue for me) than the sheer volume of food this represents. To eat this much fruit and veggies plus the 6+ servings of whole grains is simply more food than I can eat.
Debra
A Stitch In Time
Deb's Daily Distractions
It does sound like a lot of food...maybe too
much.
Hi Debra. I agree that eleven pounds of food a day seems a bit excessive. You won't be going hungry that's for sure.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
11 pounds
I've never actually heard Dr Oz say that but I've only watched a few clips and read a lot of articles about his diet. I have not had time to read his book.
What I have heard him say is cut your calories by 100, walk 10,000 steps every day, eat "9 handfuls" of fruit & vegetables every day and a small handful of nuts. (Along with fish a few times a week, I believe.)
~Denise
Fast Times @ Homeschool High & Flamingo House Happenings
Nine Handfuls...
Denise,
Nine handfuls of fruits and veggies I can do I eat 5-6 times a day, I just need to be sure that a fruit or veggie is part of each "meal." Thanks.
Debra
A Stitch In Time
Deb's Daily Distractions
I believe he was talking about new studies,
not his book.
Hey Denise.
Dr. Oz talked about several different new studies yesterday, I don't think this eleven pounds of fruits and veggies idea was in his book. The reason this particular idea was so compelling to me, was because of the results. In less than two weeks the people in this study had dramatic reductions in their cholesterol levels.
I think personally, this might be too drastic of a dietary change for me (maybe something to work towards). It's just a "wake-up" call to me that I need to get my blood pressure and cholesterol down...at the beginning of the show he talked about how high blood pressure can reduce a persons life by ten years. Since I have actually been having a problem with extremely high BP and HR for almost twenty years...that statement was a little disconcerting.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
Doesn't he claim the same thing...
Doesn't he claim the same thing in his more realistic diet, though? And Ornish makes similar claims with a similar type of diet.
I've been avoiding nutrition studies lately, maybe it's time I started peeking at them again. Heh.
~Denise
Fast Times @ Homeschool High & Flamingo House Happenings
Keep the doctor - and pounds - away
11 pounds of fruits and veggies sounds like an enormous amount to me. So enormous that I think it would scare most people - myself included.
We have always been really healthy eaters and exercisers in our house, and although we typically have a big salad with a meat for dinner, I was having a hard time working "enough" fruits and veggies into my diet. So I came up with a really simple "promise" to myself, that I knew I could keep.
1. I never let myself get really hungry, because that is just begging to binge on whatever I can get my hands on. So I snack.
2. I started out by always having the same snack. 1 apple, 1 handful of nuts, 1 handful of raisins and some slices of good quality natural cheese (or a glass of whole milk.)
I wound up having that snack twice a day. And I lost weight, for several reasons.
First, not being hungry cut the late-day binging. Second, all the natural fruit, fiber, protein. Thirdly, enough wholesome fats. And lastly, I honestly stopped craving refined sugar and carbs. So now that's still how I snack. With some modification - sometimes and avacado, cottage cheese...... but always the apple. 2 a day.
And yes, all those fruits and veggies are really expensive. We are lucky to have lots of "off price" fruit stands around us, so I opt for those - which cost a LOT less than most grocery stores. Also, plant a small veggie garden, that's great. (And if you have kids, it's a great lesson for them, even if you don't grow much.)
My favorite, however, is to take long walks and see who has fruit trees hanging over onto the sidewalk. No one ever eats all the fruits - it's always rotting on the ground. So I never think twice about plucking an apple that's hanging over the sidewalk. It's free, it's local, and it's part of an evening walk. What could be better?
___________
Alyssa Royse
JUST CAUSE
make some good news!
www.JustCauseIt.com
A lot of great info.
Thanks Alyssa, that is a lot of great information. I'll have to give it a try.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
Drought affecting fruit and veg prices
With the drought here in Australia not abating, watering for fruit and veg producers is scarcer therefore prices will apparently go up drastically.
This means the grocery budget will also go up and it will be harder for lots of people to buy and eat healthy foods.
I'd love to be able to buy some of the foods Dr Oz has suggested but I remember when I first saw him on Oprah I thought to myself well I won't be eating some of that stuff very much because of its price tag.
Jen at Semantically driven and Safari suit
Thanks Jen.
Thanks for your comment Jen. I did hear about the drought affecting the price of produce. There is also the problem of gas prices being so high, making it more expensive to get this stuff to the stores.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and Informed Voters
Meat and cheese are expensive
No doubt about it. All the processed foods Americans eat are expensive too! By cutting these items out of your diet, you should save money for sure.
So what should you buy? Organic or locally grown vegetables are definitely more expensive, so if you can't afford your grocery bill just get conventional produce. It's still better than any hamburger. Then, start focusing your meals around whole grains found in the bulk section of stores like Whole Foods. For under $1.00/lb. you can stock your pantry with brown rice, barley, rye, amaranth, whole oat groats, wheat berries, not to mention beans, seeds, and the occasional (though more pricey) nuts.
There are beautiful recipes you can make for every meal with ingredients like these! Soup is a great place to start. Plus, by moving towards a plant-based diet you are helping stave off future costs to your health and the environment.
http://doesabodygood.blogspot.com
Skinny B*tch
Has anyone read "Skinny B*tch"? It's a somewhat angry but very well-researched book advocating veganism, but also supporting changes like cutting out caffeine and aspartame. Since reading it, I've been incorporating tons more fruits and veggies into my diet and have cut caffeine entirely. I will still eat meat, fish, and dairy, but only in small servings and I treat it like "dessert". I've noticed a HUGE different. My skin looks better. I'm sleeping better (I can probably chalk that one up to the caffeine). I've lost 4 pounds in two weeks without trying. I totally believe that fresh produce is the way to go.
I'm very fortunate in that I don't have to worry too much about my grocery budget (two-income family, no kids), but I can certainly see where the high costs of produce and organic products would be a problem. The US has HUGE subsidies for sugar--couldn't we subsidize produce to make it more affordable for everyone?
Jen
Semi-Charmed Wife