Bio
I'm a single black woman living in the NYC area. I work in the media and love tennis, movies, television and pop culture. I get fired up about poli...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Election '08 Media Coverage: The Highs and The Lows

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Halleluljah! The 2008 election is almost over. It's been exciting, inspiring, historic and incredibly contentious. Soon we won't be hearing anymore about John "Mr. Grumpy Puss" McCain and Barack "Mr. Tax and Spend" Obama or Sarah "We're Mavericks" Palin or Joe "I"m From Scranton" Biden. But before we move on to the next act in this political drama, let's take a look back from a media standpoint.

In a campaign year when many Americans got their news from the internet: YouTube, Facebook, campaign websites and hundreds of blogs on the internet that helped shape public opinion and motivate voters, it would be a mistake to forget the power the mainstream media (MSM) still holds over shaping a candidate's image.

Here are some Election 2008 MSM highs and lows.

Highs

CNN's Campbell Brown's "Race Baiting" Rant: Way to go Campbell Brown for calling it the way it was.

More Blacks And Women Around The Pundit Table: Though it should have happened ages ago, it finally took having a woman and a black man running for president to make the MSM realize you need more than a bunch of the same old white men sitting around the pundit table.

Katie Couric's Interview With Sarah Palin: It gave Katie back her public credibility and it gave us a rare yet unsettling glimpse of Sarah Palin.

Charlie Gibson's Interview With Sarah Palin: Charlie Gibson didn't need to get his credibility back, but he conducted a fair interview.

Bob Schieffer At The Last Presidential Debate: Schieffer's a pro and it showed. He fought a losing battle trying to pry the candidates off their talking points, but it was the most substantive of the presidential debates and Shieffer was one of the reasons.

Tom Brokaw's Interview With Colin Powell: Colin Powell's endorsement of Barack Obama on "Meet The Press" was big news and Brokaw challenged Powell with all the questions he knew needed to be asked.

Hot Topics On "The View:" Love her or hate her, ya' gotta tip your hat to former host Rosie O'Donnell for putting "The View" on the political map. Her clashes with resident Republican Elisabeth Hasselbeck might have been noisy, but they were refreshing. Here were two women arguing passionately about 9/11, Iraq, George Bush and other issues important to every American. When Whoopi Goldberg arrived as Rosie's replacement, she brought a cooler head and less confrontational style, but the Hot Topics segments still made for good television. The show even had Cindy McCain and Michelle Obama co-host---separately of course---and the Gabby Girls' grilling of John McCain on his one visit since becoming the nominee made headlines.

Barbara Walters deserves to be commended for seeing which way the wind was blowing and allowing political discussion to make "The View" relevant in a big way.

David Letterman's Interview With John McCain: The folks at "Meet The Press" should consider having Letterman replace the late Tim Russert, 'cause Letterman conducted a Russert-worthy interview. McCain pretty much stuck to his talking points, but Letterman asked all the questions I would have asked and didn't let him off easy.

Keeping The Candidates' Kids Off The Table: Including the unmarried, pregnant teen daughter of Sarah Palin.

Dad and Daughter Talk Politics: Check out this email exchange between CBS political correspondent Jeff Greenfield and his daughter, an associate at a law firm about the media coverage of Hillary Clinton. Who says there's no intelligent conversation left in this country?

Lows

Fox News Channel, King of the Lows: There were so many examples, but exhibits A and B would be the non-existent "Terrorist Fist Jab" and the "Outraged Liberals: Stop Picking On Obama's Baby Mama" graphic. They were obnoxious and racist...yeah I said it...racist insinuations designed to undercut two very smart and accomplished black professionals.

Writing Off John McCain Last Year: Campaign staff shakeups in the summer of 2007 had many in the MSM writing John McCain off as dead in the water. Obviously he had the last laugh.

Overuse Of Un-Named Sources: It's one thing to use un-named sources once in a while and on an issue of national security, but the now consistent use of un-named sources, especially over gossip items, undercuts the little bit of credibility the MSM has left. Like the story from last February that suggested John McCain

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Michelle,

After Obama's win maybe now we can put the whole idea of the "Bradley Effect" ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bradley_effect )to rest. 

You're right, the McCain campaign was responsible for picking Palin in the first place and they should bear the burden for making such a bad choice. 

As far as her performance during the debate, I think she benefited greatly from the pre-debate lowering of expectations.  I'm also not sure why more people didn't call her out for the ridiculous winking at the camera she did during the debate.  I have a feeling it was so bizzare, the pundits didn't even know how to criticize it, so they just left it alone. 

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Jill,

You might have missed the post because I posted the night before Election Day and you, like so many others, might have been a little busy around that time.  :)

I thought the video clip linked to in Eric Deggans article ( http://blogs.tampabay.com/media/2008/06/its-tough-... ) was particularly good act showing some of what went on during the campaign. 

Megan  

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Kim,

I think a lot of the hyperventilating reporting---I'm talking to you Wolf Blitzer---the fast talking, the urgent tones, were an effort to get ratings.  Barbara West, for example I think was simply trying to make a national name for herself.

Unfortunately, some of the other stuff, the racist comments, the sexism, the pandering to the audience---I'm talking to you FOX News---was a grab for ratings but also was an actual snapshot of how some of those pundits and guests really felt.

These were white men---for the most part---who saw their grip on power being snatched away by a woman and a black man.  It was a new and very uncomfortable feeling for them and their insecurities and biases came out in full force. 

On the flip side, so many good and reasonable people of all races and sexes were appalled by the lows, that can only be seen as something positive.

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Kim,

I think a lot of the hyperventilating reporting---I'm talking to you Wolf Blitzer---the fast talking, the urgent tones, were an effort to get ratings.  Barbara West, for example I think was simply trying to make a national name for herself.

Unfortunately, some of the other stuff, the racist comments, the sexism, the pandering to the audience---I'm talking to you FOX News---was a grab for ratings but also was an actual snapshot of how some of those pundits and guests really felt.

These were white men---for the most part---who saw their grip on power being snatched away by a woman and a black man.  It was a new and very uncomfortable feeling for them and their insecurities and biases came out in full force. 

On the flip side, so many good and reasonable people of all races and sexes were appalled by the lows, that can only be seen as something positive.

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Southerngirl 5 pts

If I hear about the Bradley effect one more time I am going to SCREAM!  That has to be one of the lows for me.  There are quite a few Black canidates representing mostly White districts.  This alone should have been enough to keep this from being a consistent conversation for the pundits.  My other low was Palin's debate performace.  Great, back in the game, showing she can hold her own.  I was wondering what debate they were watching as my son did better with his second place finish in his 6th grade debate.

The lowest for me is that I do now feel the need to defend Palin.  The responsibility for picking a running mate was squarely on John McCain's shoulders.  He failed, this failure is not hers to bear alone.  That is why canidates are vetted.  There is probaly some brillant small town mayor or school board member out there going WTF? That person would have worn her T J Maxx and Marshalls finds on stage, gave great speeches with the chops to back them up and made even me agonize over who to vote for. 

Michelle

I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/

KeegsMom 5 pts

I really feel she was in over her head (sorry if that sounds patronizing) ... and pretty much all the blame lay with the GOP braintrust. If campaign people advised or handled her inadequately (once you get past the question of an adequate vetting), and now are making her a scapegoat, well, super shame on them.

KeegsMom blogs at
KIDSFLIX ( http://kidsflix.blogspot.com )

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

What a fantastic inventory - thank you so much. It's so important to have this here, Megan, because I don't know about you or other readers, but I can't count the number of times I hear someone say, "sexism? what sexism" or "racism? what racism" or "bias? what bias?" and on and on.

Great job.

Jill
Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Yeah, my thing with FOX is if they were just honest about being Republican shills, I would be fine with that.  It's that pretense of "fair and balanced" that makes me nuts.  That and the majority of their reporters.

As far as Palin, I feel a little---make that a little---sorry for her because it appears she's being made the scapegoat for McCain's loss by many in the McCain camp.  Now if reports are correct that the RNC told her to go out and buy three suits and not to spend more than $20,000, I'd say eyebrows should have been raised quite high.  But stories like that have a way of changing to cover up bad decisions after the fact.

When you say:

Let's face it, the clothing story would also have been blown up with a male candidate marketing himself as a Wal-mart dude purchasing $3000 suits at Saks. It was the hypocrisy of it all...

I agree with you, but because it was Palin who already had so much going against her in the public eye, it was all the more worse.

Thanks for commenting. 

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Kim Pearson 5 pts

How much of the idiocy do you think was a function of the desperate competition for ratings?

Kim
BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://blogher.org/blog/kim-pearson )|Professor Kim ( http://professorkim.blogspot.com/ )|

KeegsMom 5 pts

They have to take the award here... How can they possibly call themselves journalists, let alone "fair and balanced?" It's really astonishing what they get away with... the last few weeks, hosts and reporters would blatantly say things like, "Well, it's bad news for McCain, these polls, but we can hope something shakes it up!" They would catch themselves and try to cover up... I'm talking about the Fox people who TRY not to appear biased, no point in discussing the others (like the morning crew).

They should have worn McCain buttons through the whole damn thing.

Also, the media getting bashed now for being hard on Palin is interesting... I think they only reported the things she did and said, whatever criticism befell her was brought on by her own actions. Let's face it, the clothing story would also have been blown up with a male candidate marketing himself as a Wal-mart dude purchasing $3000 suits at Saks. It was the hypocrisy of it all...

Anyway, enjoyed your list, Megan.

KeegsMom blogs at: KIDSFLIX ( http://kidsflix.blogspot.com )

Megan Smith 5 pts

I got a note from someone whose Pakistani husband said the name is pronounced Tal-ee-ban.  If anyone else has any thoughts, let me know.

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Okay so I finally saw the CNN Hologram.  Anderson Cooper just did an interview with Hologram Will.I.Am.

I don't think it's a high or a low, just kinda weird.  It works but it makes me think someone at CNN had a little too much money in the election night gadget budget.

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Denise,

I had unexpected guests---my aunt, uncle and cousin, who showed me video of them voting today---so I'm only now starting to watch the coverage and I haven't seen the CNN hologram.  As soon as I do, I'll let you know if it's thumbs up or thumbs down.

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Denise 9 pts moderator

Within seconds of the CNN hologram, twitter went crazy. Is the CNN hologram a low or a high?

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager

Flamingo House Happenings ( http://www.flamingohouse.net/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Virginia,

One thing I won't miss about this election season was all those low points, many of which pandered to the worst in the electorate. 

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Kalyn,

I have no life!  :)

Megan

BlogHer CE, TV/Online Video

My Personal Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

One part of the political process that strikes a low point again and again with me is pandering to fear and ignorance to win votes. I get upset to see pols do it, and even more upset to see voters respond to it.

Virginia DeBolt
BlogHer Technology Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/virginia-debolt )
Web Teacher ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ )
First 50 Words ( http://first50.wordpress.com/ )

Kalyn Denny 5 pts

You've obviously been paying a lot more attention than most people; great job recapping this. (And I second the nomination for "sexist slugs of the year.")

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )