Bio
Like most women I know, I'm a highly committed, over tasked mom just trying to do it all.   By day, I am the lead contributor at Shot...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why Everyone Should Get a Flu Shot

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 53
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Last year at this time, the H1N1 virus, also referred to as the “swine flu,” had us all rather panicked. People were anxious to get vaccinated against the flu then. But what about now?

My guess is that the media attention given to the H1N1 epidemic last year left a skeptical public uncertain about the impact of the flu, and the safety and effectiveness of flu shots in general.

Regrettably, H1N1 made itself personally known to my family last year when my own 9-year-old daughter, Marissa, received a positive diagnosis. Unfortunately, she contracted H1N1 before a vaccine became available. I’ll admit that my husband and I were very concerned. In the back of our minds, we knew that she could easily become a tragic statistic, and the feeling was one of helplessness.

We did our best to quarantine her in order to keep the virus from spreading to our other four children. We tried to make her as comfortable as possible in her room, and gave her a walkie-talkie to call us with when she needed something. My husband even downloaded a week’s worth of Brady Bunch, Partridge Family and Happy Days reruns to keep her entertained. Her sisters slipped get well cards under her door and we served her meals on special trays that only my husband or I would handle and deliver.

After a week or so, my daughter recovered and resumed life as usual. It sure is interesting how a brief brush with an unpredictable disease can change your perspective. The unspoken fear that we faced last year has faded into a childhood memory for Marissa. Surprisingly, it appears that public memory has been short-lived as well — which troubles me as a mom of five active kids.

Due to the heightened concern from last year’sH1N1 outbreak, I would have guessed that more people would be inclined to get flu shots this year. Unfortunately, it appears that a significant portion of the public is more concerned about potential side effects of the vaccine than with the consequences of falling ill with influenza.

A survey of 1,500 adults, recently conducted by The Consumer Reports National Research Center, indicated that 30 percent of those surveyed will skip the flu shot this year, citing concerns about side effects, exaggerated epidemic messages, and a desire to build up their own immune systems.

Another recent Time article indicates that this sentiment is echoed among many parents. The National Foundation for Infectious Diseases (NFID) questioned more than 600 mothers of kids ages 6 to 18, and revealed that 80 percent of mothers said their attitude toward vaccination was not swayed by last year's H1N1 scare and one-third were opting to forgo flu vaccination for their children, citing fear of side effects as their main concern.

What the public may fail to understand is that seasonal flu vaccines are extremely safe. Consider the fact that flu vaccines are administered year after year to a large percentage of the population. Because of this, they are some of the most widely used and well tested immunizations being administered today and their safety record is proven.

So what is all the worry about? Some minimal discomfort and minor side effects?

Unfortunately, many of the common worries are actually based on unfounded myths. From your local news to nationally regarded CNN, reputable news organizations are constantly working to dispel these myths with information readily available from the CDC. For instance, contracting the flu from the vaccine … out of the question. Building up your immune system by skipping the vaccine … not happening. In fact, experts explain that the vaccine itself is what generates the immune response, which is exactly what prevents you from falling ill. That minor side effect of redness and swelling at the injection site that some may experience is further indication that your body is responding as it should. To avoid a needle entirely, healthy children and adults between the ages of 2 and 49 can even opt for a sniff of the nasal flu vaccine (FluMist). Really, there is little excuse not to get vaccinated, especially since

  • 53
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
mstigerlily 5 pts

I'm an RN at one of the biggest women's hospitals in our area. During the swine flu scare I saw many miscarriages and late term losses after the flu shot. I realize these were incidental, however, and losses are very common.

 

I have three children and three stepchildren, all between the ages of 8 and 22. They have never had a flu shot. My husband and I have never had a flu shot, thankfully my employer doesn't push it, we just sign a waiver. My family and I are fully vaccinated on all other shots. I am not against flu shots entirely but I don't feel they are warranted. One of my girls got H1N1 during the "big scare" year, it passed in a few days without Tamiflu. Of course I've personally had the flu several times during my lifetime and my kids have had it a few times - and I only count the times they had a positive swab so I am not counting parainfluenzas and other viruses - and I remember the suckiness of it but to be honest norovirus was must worse, although passed quicker.

 

This year in February, we were about to take a family trip to Las Vegas for a nursing conference. The day before my husband suddenly developed body aches and a 102 fever, I sent him to urgent care, he returned with a positive flu swab and an RX for Tamiflu. We went on our trip anyway and spent five days in a hotel room with each other. We all took Sambucol, Vitamin D and oscillococcinum prophylactically. He took his Tamiflu. Only two days of fever for him, and the rest of us stayed well. Nothing to panic over. 

MommieJoys 5 pts

If you read the linked article on my blog, and scroll down to picture at the bottom. It's real, taken by a nurse friend of mine. The picture is WHY we have chosen to NOT get the flu vac.

http://mommiejoys.blogspot.com/2012/01/vaccines-are-they-killers.html

Autism Mom Rising 6 pts

While I am sorry to hear of your daughter's illness and respect your decision to give your family a flu shot it is the title of your piece I take issue with, "Why everyone Should Get A Flu Shot". No medication is safe for all people, so IMO saying that all 300 million of us should take this proceedure, the vast majority of whose medical history you have no idea about, is just wrong, IMO. You have no idea about each person's unique ability or inability to clear mercury and aluminum from their bodies. I am generally a supporter of most vaccines, but such I find such blanket statements presumptious.

theoutcast 8 pts

Confused enough not to know my own body?

"Anti-vax cult-devoted wing-nut"? Thanks for that clever nickname. For the record, though I question the accessive use of vaccines in our society, please know that I have had certain ones administered to myself and my son (please review my comment earlier, the part where I said I had a Hep A & B vaccine). You can read all about my thoughts on the topic in my post right here on Blogher called "The Mother of All Taboos".

Not everything is a coincidence when it occurs outside of a science lab just because it could not be replicated within a science lab. Encouraging wellness has it's place.

I certainly consider the risk factors and I weigh them, too. I am very concerned about the risk of the flu when have populations of young people who grow to be adults have no knowledge of their own ability to withstand an unexpected season of the flu. They may not be inclined to take the shot as adults. The shot may not be available en masse 20 years from now due to limited access to resources for example.

My son has caught H1N1. His antibodies will likely protect him for the rest of his life. The risk of death from many of these flus in healthy people are probably far less than driving daily on interstate highways in America (with a seatbelt).

Since you don't seem the least bit wary, maybe you would consider being among next year's test subjects instead of leaving that process to others.

Regardless, we will view this topic differently. I sincerely do hope that the shots protect your family.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

NaturalMamaNZ 6 pts

"I have co-workers who refuse to get vaccinated and bring their germy persons into the office because they don't want to stay home and risk getting the SAHM and kids sick."

You still carry the virus even when vaccinated! Those who are vaccinated are the worst, because they don't show the symptoms and unknowingly pass it on to everyone around them.

At least when you display the symptoms you know you have it and stay away from others and they stay away from you.

If you get the toxic shot, you still have the virus and pass it on, you just don't display symptoms.

NaturalMamaNZ 6 pts

D Shear,
Do some research, please! Just google 'vitamin d', 'study' and 'flu'. It is there in black and white.The study shows Vitamin D is more effective than the flu shot! How is that so hard to comprehend? Sounds like you need to research the functions of vitamin d in the body too.

I feel sorry for the woman who brought up vit d in the first place, you were so condescending to her, why? We all have our children's best interests at heart. She mentioned potentially THE MOST IMPORTANT STUDY regarding flu shots, and you weren't even willing to investigate the possibility of it's validity (and it's a more valid study than any study sponsored by vaccine producers).

If you really care about your children, as you imply, GO READ THE STUDY.

feelingbeachie 269 pts

I used to always get the flu until I started getting the shot about 15 years ago... I have never had any reaction. I will always opt for the shot.

MadamJ 5 pts

The "flu shot" is not something I want to put in my body.

D Shea 5 pts

Wait, wait, let's enjoy the irony. At the same time, you think I ought to be more mindful of individual, personal experiences-- but you also decry what you claim as insufficient testing of vaccines. Why do we need testing, when anecdotes are sufficient to make up your mind? What's the point of science in your little world of "I developed thyroid problems one month after a vaccine, so the vaccine must be causal?"

You're thinking like a dark ages shaman. "That woman looked at me funny, and I got a wart, so she must be a witch! Burn her!"

Then, the usual anti-vaccine straw man argument: "If tylenol can have side effects so can vaccines." Of course vaccines can have side effects. Is anyone denying that? You have to balance risks and benefits to make decisions. Vaccines have risks, vaccines have benefits (it's only the anti-vax wingnuts who deny that statement); not getting vaccines creates risks (again, anti-vax wingnuts deny this, but there's no arguing with someone so devoted to that cult.) You want vaccines, or anything else, to be 100% free of risk? You're living in a dream world.

RE: your repeated, unreferenced opinion that vaccines are somehow untested, here's a good place for you to start, with particular emphasis on the flu vaccine: http://theness.com/neurologicablog/?p=2467#more-2467. I particularly enjoyed the irony of your example that because I, personally, wasn't involved in a study of flu vaccines that this is somehow germane to the quantity of research that has been done. Once again, personal experience, feelings, recollections, and expectations are the primary tools of your "thinking." Back into the dark ages we lurch.

theoutcast 8 pts

An adult just gave you an example of something that went wrong her her body. Her informed, personal, mature experience. This is the problem with vaccines. Side effects are wildly underreported. About ten years ago, I developed thyroid problems 1 month after the Hep A & B. I was like you and didn't consider a link.

But my mom did. Doctors didn't consider a link either but guess what? When I was researching vaccines for my son MANY people have report this happening to them and guess what it is still being "studied".

Adults know their bodies. If tylenol can have side-effects so can vaccines.

By the way the shots are not as tested as you may think. Did you offer yourself or your child up as a test subject? Why do you think others would be so willing so that you would benefit?

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

D Shea 5 pts

A year later, and you're still weary? Perhaps you should take a nap.

I got a flu shot and didn't end up in the ER. What does my experience prove? Nothing.

What if you got a flu shot and won the lottery? Or what if you didn't get a flu shot-- but maybe had a tasty Starbucks peppermint latte, and then ended up in the ER. What would that prove? Nothing.

What if you had a flu shot, and then got hit by a bus? Or got a phone call that you'd inherited an emu farm?

Because one thing happens after another doesn't mean that one thing causes another. Science is a tool to decipher causes, to not rely on biased or occasional uncontrolled experiences to twist and thwart logic. ER two days after a flu shot, and you decide it must be because of the flu shot? I weep for the future. Welcome back, dark ages.

nextsteph 5 pts

I got a flu shot last year and ended up in the ER with an asthma attack 2 days later. So understandably I am weary.

D Shea 5 pts

You have no problem with Dr. Buttar, who preys upon families, bankrupts them with outrageous fees for absolute nonsense-- typical. He gets a pass, but every doctor is painted with the Big Evil brush because they're allegedly in the pocket of Big Pharma. Who, exactly, has the conflict of interest here?

Of course flu vaccines have side effects and can be harmful to some. It's all over the package insert, there are lists of side effects, there are no secrets here. Mild side effects are easily managed; serious side effects are very rare. Influenza itself is not rare, and complications of influenza kill about 36,000 Americans each yet. Not all of those cases could be prevented with vaccinations-- but many of them could.

"Experimental," you say, as if you have any understanding of what that means. No medical therapy undergoes more safety studies than vaccines. Repeating lies doesn't make them true.

theoutcast 8 pts

...and it doesn't turn my stomach because it clearly states he did no harm. Yes, people may have paid more money than necessary and the treatments experimental if what the article is saying is true. But so what? That is big pharma's business model.

What turns my stomach is that flu vaccines clearly can harm some people but those facts are hidden and the vaccines are usually not "proven" safe before they are administered. Would you offer your child up for this type of medical testing if you knew it was experimental?

I'm not anti-vaccine (in spite of a personal bad experience). My son has some, not all because I question motives and incentives. But if I can reduce the chemicals in our bodies, I opt for that.

I hope the shots work for you.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

D Shea 5 pts

75% percent, such an exact figure. You're saying that 75% of the doctors in the world have financial ties to pharma? Golly, those filthy-rich pediatricians, they're rolling in the dough! And one even has a patent on a vaccine?? Surely, that invalidates the opinions of ALL physicians, the scumbags.

How about all of the money made by the quacks, the alt-med hucksters, the "biomed" industry, those who prey on suffering families by promising that their magic elixir is the cure? You think their motives are more pure than those of the scientists? You're deluded.

Of course I have children, six. Why would you assume I don't? I've sat up with them when they're vomiting and sick, and I will do everything I can to keep them healthy. I trust their pediatrician, who is a wonderful woman (she happens to drive a 1994 Volvo. She's good as disguising the tremendous wealth she's accumulated from owning pharmaceutical firms.) My own kids have not had side effects from vaccines, but of course that doesn't mean that children never do. The side effects are much milder than the illness, and protection is worth the risk-- that's protection not only for my kids, but for yours, and for my parents, and for the community.

D Shea 5 pts

Seriously, vaccinationcouncil.org? Why don't you wander right over there right now, if you're genuinely curious to see what that organization is all about. The lead article, right now, featured right on top, is from super-uber-quack "Dr. Buttar"-- that would be the one who treats autistic children with urine, and takes advantage of suffering families for hundreds of thousands of dollars for absolute quackery. You want to read more about him? It'll turn your stomach, if you have any interest in genuine help for people:
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2010/04/beware_north_carolina_beware_d... ( http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2010/04/beware_north_carolina_beware_dr_rashid_b.php ).

Christine Vara 5 pts

I once believed that only those who were health compromised were likely to die from the flu. However, I have since learned that healthy people can, and do, die. Unfortunately, I have had a personal experience with this. Sadly, just yesterday reports were made of the first pediatric flu death this season...an otherwise healthy 4 year old boy from NY. It concerns me that some think that healthy people do not die from the flu, as I have personally witnessed the opposite. http://bit.ly/hJIlpo

As I tried to relate in this post, while I appreciate that people are concerned about possible side effects, I feel that the risk of suffering severe health problems from the flul is greater than any risk of side effect.

theoutcast 8 pts

Physicians from around the world are coming together to discuss vaccine safety concerns on this blog:

http://www.vaccinationcouncil.org/

It's newly formed and called the "International Medical Council on Vaccination". Doctors on the site are providing their first-hand knowledge and stating clearly their names on that site.

If you don't question the safety of vaccines, why do these doctors?

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

theoutcast 8 pts

I tried to post a comment on your blog a couple of days ago. Didn't you have an article about a hospital stay with your son? The comment wouldn't work. Send me an e-mail (on my site) and I can tell you what was wrong.

I really liked that movie "V". You're right, total craziness abounds. It's been awhile since I've seen it.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Okay, I get it. You believe that the WHO, NIH, AAP, AMA, etc... with over 75% of them having financial ties to the pharmaceutical companies... they are unbiased and truly have YOUR best interest at heart?

When a pro-vaccine doctor holds A PATENT on a vaccine, it's very hard for me to hear his "evidence" for all the $$ I'm seeing.

You obviously don't have children, or you would take a little more seriously any advice that tells you to inject multiple toxins into a little person. And, oh, the screaming, fever, lethargy, and other adverse reactions? 1. It's normal 2. The vaccine didn't cause it.

We choose to remain healthy from the inside out, not subscribe to all the fear-propoganda, and stay as far away from manmade chemicals as possible.

D Shea 5 pts

"And you do realize there are just as many reputable experts in the medical field who are concerned about it's safety and effectiveness, right?"

Every single medical professional organization supports influenza vaccination. The AMA, the AAP, the AAFP; let's add in there the ACIP, the CBC, the NIH, the WHO, all staffed by experts whose entire careers are health and vaccine science. To imply that just as many experts are doubtful is ludicrous. You accuse the pro-vaccine poster of "blatant propaganda"? Are you reading the nonsense, lies, and just plain silliness pervading the comments here?

Adults die, pregnant women die, kids die. And it's treated like some kind of joke.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 10 pts

You've been lucky in avoiding illness, which is not a great argument. It's like saying you don't need car insurance because you've never been in an accident.

As for the H1N1 vaccine & miscarriages, I'd like to see that data -- as I suspect there was much coincidence rather than causation happening if you consider how common miscarriages are (though each is heartbreaking), and how many of them were statistically likely to happen anyhow.

I'd like to thank Christine for writing this piece -- I'm surprised how many people (evidenced the comment above, as well as several below) still buy into to misinformation about vaccines in general, and flu vaccines specifically.

Seattle Mama Doc has been publishing a conversation series on vaccine information and pediatricians' experiences treating vaccine-preventable diseases, for those who need a current information booster:

http://seattlemamadoc.seattlechildrens.org/do-you-believe-in-vaccines-pa... ( http://seattlemamadoc.seattlechildrens.org/do-you-believe-in-vaccines-part-iii-experience/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-rosa ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

connectedmom 5 pts

"I’d like to see the current epidemic of apathy toward an easily preventable virus come to a swift end this flu season."

I find this extremely condescending. If you've done your research and feel comfortable with your decision, that's great. However to assume those of us choosing not to vaccinate are apathetic is patronizing. How is it apathy to have concern for side effects? And you do realize there are just as many reputable experts in the medical field who are concerned about it's safety and effectiveness, right?

Your post message to be informed about your child's health applies to you as well.I think if you had done real research you wouldn't have published such blatant propaganda. This post is dismissive, fails to consider the counter-argument, and does nothing to add real discussion to this topic.

D Shea 5 pts

Wait, I thought flu was caused by interference with magic moonbeams. I'll have to consult my astrologer. I heard once from my chiropractor that someone got a flu vaccine and immediately afterwards he developed a limp his hat no longer fit, but after 10 sessions of adjustment he could sing opera! So that proves that if only we'd all get daily miracle foot magnetic Reiki homeopathic imaginary broccoli enemas, we'd never get sick!

These comments, they have to be parody, right? Please tell me all of you germ-theory denialist, pharma-fearing conspiracy wackos are just poking fun? What? You're serious? And you have children??

God help us all.

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Healthy does NOT = "getting more than his share of colds". We can't redefine healthy just to support our views.

Was he breastfed? What was his diet like? What was his toxin load like in your home? Did you use commercial cleaners?

Our bodies are amazing by design, and our immune systems are well equiped to handle most infectious diseases thrown its way IF we have properly prepared them through nutrition and exercise. But, we have been brainwashed to not trust ourselves. We're fed corn/soy like cows, we're told "if you don't get this toxic chemical cocktail injected into your baby he will DIE!" It's so unethical...the whole system.

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Thanks Heather. I am in transition with many of these issues... and blog about it at lifeonthefrancofarm.blogspot.com.

It is time for us, the MOTHERS, to take responsibility for our own lives, children, and families. It is not Big Pharma's job to keep us well, it is not Big Ag's job to provide food (or McDonald's), and it is not the Gov't job to tell us how to raise our children.

I watched the movie "V" recently (again), and was dismayed at the parallels between it and our current reality...

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

So you vaccinated him against diptheria and pertussis just because he had a superficial cut? That's what I mean by living in fear. Parents don't even KNOW the protocol for treating wounds and run to the dr. for a shot to fix everything.

From the Mayo Clinic:

Keep the wound clean. Rinse thoroughly with clean water. Clean the wound and the area around it with soap and a washcloth. If debris is embedded in a wound, see your doctor.

Consider the source. PUNCTURE wounds or other DEEP cuts, animal bites or particularly dirty wounds may put you at increased risk of tetanus infection.

Get medical attention if the wound is DEEP and DIRTY.

Use an antibiotic. After you clean the wound, apply a thin layer of an antibiotic cream or ointment, such as the multi-ingredient antibiotics Neosporin and Polysporin. These antibiotics won't make the wound heal faster, but they can discourage bacterial growth and infection and may allow the wound to heal more efficiently.

ursulamargrit 5 pts

More and more studies by REAL scientists show that the flu is caused by a vitamin D deficiency. That is why people get it in the winter, because they can't make vitamin D since they can't get sunshine.

If your vitamin D levels are optimal, you simply won't get the flu or cold.

Which is why I take vitamin D3 (and other vitamins and minerals), and know I won't get the flu. The flu shot, on the other hand, would almost guarantee that I'd get it this winter, as it makes you not only MORE susceptible to getting the flu, but may also directly cause it. No thanks.

ursulamargrit 5 pts

So, you say you get vaccinated with every vaccine you can get. Yet you still got the flu. Doesn't that give you a clue that maybe the flu shot is utterly useless? Not only that, it is (like all vaccines) dangerous to boot.

theoutcast 8 pts

I agree with much of what you have said. There are risks in life. We weigh them the best we can.

Nutrition in America is terrible. What is great is that many moms are waking up to taking preventative measures and reassessing the pharma role. This is an achingly slow process.

I currently have a post on my blogher page on this very topic. You may be interested in it. It's called "The Mother Of All Taboos".

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

Amy_in_StL 5 pts

I always get the flu shot. I've never had the flu; however, I have co-workers who refuse to get vaccinated and bring their germy persons into the office because they don't want to stay home and risk getting the SAHM and kids sick.

My dad is in a high risk group and I need to be on-call to care for my parents, so I can't afford to get sick. I also pay more attention to getting enough sleep and eating a healthy diet this time of year.

For those that say they wouldn't get a tetanus shot for their kids, you should know that the shot is only recommended to be given up to a week after possible exposure. The incubation period for the bacteria is usually about 8 days. Even one bacterium left in the wound can propogate into an infection. You can not reliably bleed it completely out of a puncture wound - assuming the patient has a normal hemostasis process. Blood does not kill the bacteria, nor can it be depended to completely clean anything other than a superficial wound.

I do wish more people would do their own research and decide to get vaccinated or not based on science rather than based on something they read on a popular site on the web. Junk science is out there - we must all beware to protect our families!

Tracy@HallofFameMoms 5 pts

Here's part of my problem with getting flu shots...
#1- who's to say the shot I got is going to cover the exact flu I will be at risk for. New strains can come about any time, right? So its not a one-shot covers all in my opinion.
#2- With little testing and results, who knows how said shot will effect a person's body. Did you see the story last year (?) abot the pro cheerleader who got severly messed up after getting a shot? Is the chances of getting the flu worth the chances of taking a shot that your body might be allergic too? Not in my opinion- not if you're generally a healthy person.
#3- It just doesn't make sense to get a flu shot every year based on those 2 points above- in my opinion.

Thats not to say the flu shot would be a good choice for a few w/ certain illness issues already. But I'm not in that boat at the current time. If one of us should be, I might reconsider the flu shot.

http://www.halloffamemoms.com

ecbt-amy 5 pts

tetanus lives in the soil - it does not go away...ever. I would strongly suggest very thick soles on your shoes. My son cut open his foot on an exposed nail from our playhouse out back one week after his tenth b-day this year...did I rush to get him a Tdap booster...you bet I did....and I doubt it even made a blip in Pharma's pocketbook!

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Heather,

No one wants to address the bigger problem: nutritional deficiency! There's no $$ in veggies, though.

And to address something further up the thread.....while we do have responsibilities regarding our community, they do not come at the expense of my individual choices and convictions. My first responsibility is to my own household.

No one wants to talk science, ingredients, or the real problem. They only want to propogate fear.

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Tetanus cannot live in an oxygen-rich environment - fact or fiction?

No one's talking about cutting your leg and deliberately causing you to bleed. But if the wound is bleeding, then oxygen is getting to it and tetanus cannot grow. If the wound DOESN'T bleed, then you need medical attn immediately.

Obviously, I am not a doctor, but I wouldn't get a tetanus vaccine or take my kid in to be treated unless it was a very deep puncture wound that didn't bleed.

We are so far removed from common sense and nature... Big Pharma has convinced us that we should fear the very air we breathe, oh, and they have a drug for that too!!!

Karen Louise 5 pts

Christine--Thank you for writing this piece and for all your vaccine advocacy. For me, I am motivated to get a flu shot to protect the most vulnerable around us. My children attend school with some classmates who have asthma and others who are prone to serious respiratory infections. And, of course, I am happy to protect my children against influenza as well.

I do believe that all parents, whether they vaccinate or not, are motivated by wanting to do what is best for their children. Unfortunately, I think that when emotions get in the way, we become very bad at assessing risk. Thus, it is important to have advocates like you, Christine, who help us take a clear look at what we have to risk and what we have to gain by vaccinating our children. Keep up the great work!

BlessedSalt 5 pts

I think that too many times in this country we resort to vaccines to prevent everything possible when they don't prevent. Most of the time they will lessen your chance to get it or make it a little better if you do catch whatever it is but you are injecting your body full of chemicals and other items. What you are preventing now could be harmful to your body later on. Such as the chicken pox vaccine. It's only good for some long and then it wears off. If parents don't tell their college age kids that they will need the vaccine every two to four years and they don't get it, they will catch them as an adult, when it's more painful and the side effects are worse. Let the kids get chicken pox as kids and be done with it. I fully think that Shingles in older adults will be rampant in 40 years because all the parents are giving chicken pox vaccines and not letting the the kids catch it now.

We do not get the flu vaccine because everytime my husband gets the vaccine, he gets the flu from the vaccine. It never fails. It might only be a three day version but considering that he has never once gotten it since he stopped taking the vaccine five years ago, I think it's worse the risk.

Stop panicking and thinking that vaccines are going to save us. Live well and take care of yourself. If you want to get a vaccine, get it.. but do the research and be informed of the risks... just as I have done the research and am informed of the risks of refusing vaccines.

www.clumsycrafter.com ( http://www.clumsycrafter.com )

@clumsycrafter

spiritualmom 6 pts

Hi Christine,

Thank you for opening this discussion and I am happy that your daughter is safe and well. Please let me say that I honor the intent your message, but please, please think again about letting anyone immunize you or anyone else with this shot. I have two girls too, ages 7 and 8 so I can resonate with the worry and fear. While it was worrying for you to experience this, my belief is that you gave your child a huge gift by allowed her to go through this disease naturally.

I'm sorry to say that my life has also been touched personally by H1N1, the vaccination, not the virus. My mother passed away this year 2 months after receiving the shot. She was immune compromised and got talked into having the shot. Her story is on my blog, but briefly will say she passed from fast-acting pancreatic cancer which no medical tests showed was present before the immunization. I have met somebody in my local store who's aunt died directly after receiving the vaccination. One of my reflexlogy clients was 15 and came to me after 3 months of severe body pain, having received the vaccination last year. Several treatments later she is much better, thank goodness. This is just my personal experience of the H1N1 shot. There are many more facts and figures out there. Please, please, don't think that this shot is safe. There has been little or no official research to prove that it has.

Homeopathy can provide immunizations much more safely and effectively than vaccinations. Please check out my FB page for videos and information http://www.facebook.com/momonaspiritualjourney . Also, check out my blog, there will be more info over time http://www.momonaspiritualjourney.com

Please raise awareness and share, our lives may depend on it.

Best wishes
Sarah Lawrence Hinson

theoutcast 8 pts

The many others here have cited the same reasons why we don't do the shots.

I would like to add my concerns about the long-term affects of this situation. When masses of people as children and adults are not healthy enough to weather the flu we have a bigger problem.

My son too got H1N1 last year among many other colds. He recovered just fine AND likely has life-long immunity from it.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

ecbt-amy 5 pts

Tetanus (also known as lockjaw) is a disease of the nervous system caused by the toxin that is released from an infection from a bacterium known as Clostridium tetani which lives in the soil. The bacterium usually enters the body when a person gets a cut or a puncture wound to the skin. Once in the body the bacterium produces the toxin which causes severe and painful spasms of the muscles. Commonly early symptoms of tetanus include a locking of the jaw, stiffness in the neck and abdomen, and difficulty swallowing. Later symptoms include fever, elevated blood pressure, and severe muscle spasms. Tetanus can be fatal when muscle spasms of the throat block the windpipe resulting in near instant death from suffocation. Tetanus can also cause severe damage to the heart.

Prior to the introduction of the tetanus vaccine in the early 1940’s about 600 annual cases of tetanus were reported in the United States causing 180 deaths. Currently in the United States an average of 43 cases of tetanus are reported annually with 7 deaths. It is important to note that since this bacterium lives in the soil, it can not be eradicated; therefore it is critical to receive tetanus vaccines every ten years (which is the length of time of effectiveness of the vaccine).
P.S. Bloodletting was based on an ancient system of medicine in which blood and other bodily fluid were considered to be "humors" whose proper balance maintained health. It was the most common medical practice performed by doctors from antiquity up to the late 19th century, a time span of almost 2,000 years - FYI - unless you are a vampire I wouldn't bother!
http://www.ecbt.org/parents/diseasevaccine.cfm

ecbt-amy 5 pts

wow, I'm blown away by the comment that healthy people do not die of the flu - families who tell their stories don't do so b/c they are fear mongers, they share b/c they care about other people and don't want them to suffer as they did. Please take one minute to visit www.familiesfightingflu.org ( http://www.familiesfightingflu.org ) and learn about how healthy children do die of flu. My son Antonio is featured on their site and I thank god every flu season that he is one of the survivors of flu. My son was a normally developing infant when he contracted influenza - yes he seemed to get more than his share of colds as an infant, but I was a new mother and hadn't the slightest clue whether he was high risk or just exposed to more viruses or just darn unlucky. Point being that I was already in public health and didn't realize how close my son came to becoming a flu victim until we were ordered to rush to the emergency room by our pediatrician. Don't take chances that you might be a flu carrier who might spread to others - we are in a community and should care about all around us! and shame on the registered nurse - I certainly hope you don't come across the elderly or infants in your daily routine!

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Cathy,

I couldn't agree with your assessment any more. They use fear and manipulate mothers' emotions instead of educating about good nutrition.

It's politically incorrect to tell people they're obese, Big Ag won't hear of ending food subsidies for corn / soy - so we get it in every processed food we buy. The Dairy industry won't admit that pasteurization kills the milk and vitamins added back in are synthetic and impossible to absorb. And then we have Monsanto and the GMO's... but no one will talk about that. Fix the problem.

Instead, we'll let the pharmaceutical companies tell us that the ONLY way to be healthy and prevent disease is to rely on a shot made in a lab with a number of toxic substances. If a vaccine falls on the floor with mercury in it, it's considered toxic waste. But it's okay to inject.

As for tetanus..it cannot survive in an oxygen rich environment, so as long as the person lets the wound bleed (blood has oxygen) for several minutes and then apply peroxide to it, tetanus cannot develop.

COMMON SENSE - but Big Pharma makes no money off common sense. When did we as Americans abdicate our right to think for ourselves and question every line the gov't/industry feeds us???

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

you still got it. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20614424

Have you ever read the ingredient list on those vaccines? Has any study ever been done on the synergistic effect of mercury + aluminum + polysorbate 80 + formaldehyde + anything else they put in there?

The only study that has ever been done on the safety of thimerasol was in 1929 when it was given to 22 meningitis patients. They all died.

My rule of thumb? If the gov't says it's good for you - run the other way.

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

Christine,

No where do I see you acknowledge the toxic ingredients in the flu vaccine (or any other) and all the possible side effects. Nor do you mention this study: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20614424 that concludes flu shots have modest effect on symptoms, and no effect on transmission or complications.

Using fear and a mother's emotions is dispicable. Rarely will a child die of a communicable disease if he/she is healthy. Why don't you guys spend more time on teaching parents the art of cooking nourishing food? Probiotics? That is the best defense of all. But of course, pharmaceutical companies can't make any money off of broccoli huh?

Life On The Franco Farm 5 pts

I am really sick of the fear-mongering regarding infectious diseases/viruses such as H1N1. Us humans should work instead on promoting a healthy immune system through nourishing food and exercise instead of toxins injected into our bodies.

Stop CAFO's, chicken battery houses, irrigation of vegetables with human waste, BPA and other chemicals in packaging, and GMO's. Parents start cooking for your children - no more fast food, sodas, or excuses.

There is too much information regarding the development of the vaccine (an announcement was made re: swine flu vaccine the DAY before the first reported CA case. Coincidence?) and subsequent stockpiling by gov'ts around the world.

The CDC has also admitted that cases were severely overblown (http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/11/24/Superstar-... ( http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/11/24/Superstar-CBS-Reporter-Blows-the-Lid-Off-the-Swine-Flu-Media-Hype-and-Hysteria.aspx )).

Here are a few links for your information:

http://www.naturalnews.com/030657_vaccines_miscarriages.html

CDC admits it begin in pig farms: http://www.humanesociety.org/news/news/2009/04/swine_flu_virus_origin_19... ( http://www.humanesociety.org/news/news/2009/04/swine_flu_virus_origin_1998_042909.html )

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/06/04/AR201006... ( http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/06/04/AR2010060403034.html )

Christine Vara 5 pts

@Cathy, I'm sorry to hear that you believe that healthy people won't die from the flu. I have personally known a healthy active Marine who died within days of falling ill. You can read this tragic story on Shot of Prevention (http://shotofprevention.com/2010/10/19/who-knew-what-the-flu-could-do/)

The misconceptions you have are exactly why I have taken the time to write this piece. Vaccinations are an important preventive measure. Not only for ourselves, but to help reduce the risk to others (including those who are health compromised and infant children who are too young to be vaccinated). I hope you and you family will reconsider.

Be informed about children's health and vaccine preventable disease. 

Join the blog conversation at Shot of Prevention ( http://shotofprevention.com/ )

cathyherard 6 pts

This article mentions those who are opposed to the vaccine are motivated by "fear" of side effects, yet she mentions that she DOES receive for "fear" of getting sick or possibly dying. Okay, let's look at those large statistics that were shared. Healthy people do NOT die from getting the flu. Researching you will find that those who die from it had other unlying healthy concerns or issues and contracting the flu contributed to a worsening condition. Much like if I step on a nail I will wait and see IF I get tetanus THEN treat it, rather than rush to get poked, I will use preventative measures to keep me and my entire family healthy.

mstigerlily 5 pts

Am over 40 and a registered nurse, mom of 3. None of us have ever had a flu shot and I don't think we ever will. My daughter had a positive swab last year for H1N1 over the summer when they were still testing. It was a pretty mild flu as far as they go. I see no reason for us all to get injected with something every single year when we've been doing fine so far. Got my TDAP shot last month though!

falnfenix 6 pts

I have only had a flu shot once, and that particular year I contracted a strain of the flu not covered by the shot.

That was the ONLY time I've ever had the flu. Since I am neither old nor very young, I'm in the lowest risk group for getting OVERLY sick from the flu...not to mention, the side effects are worse than I care to risk.

amberpagewrites 5 pts

I firmly believe everyone should be vaccinated for everything there is a vaccine for (including the flu).

So my whole family got vaccinated for the flu again this year.

Unfortunately, we still got the damn thing, and almost three weeks later, I'm still not better.

Damn flu.