Most Popular

The Ethical Carnivore: Pleased to Meat You

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It's not like you're suddenly going to go cold turkey, if you'll pardon the pun. We humans didn't claw our way up the food chain so we could eat quinoa.

Meat-eating and ethical eating don't have to be mutually exclusive. There are ways to eat meat that are sensitive to the environment, to our health, and to the animals involved.

All meat is not created equal.
We all know that factory farming is a grotesquery. It's basically institutionalized animal cruelty and it creates a product that is unfit and unhealthy for human consumption. It depletes resources and is destructive to the environment.

Then there's grass-fed or pasture-raised beef.
These animals are raised in open, humane, sanitary conditions. They conserve resources by passing on a diet of grains grown with petroleum-based fertilizers and pesticides. Better for your health, grass-fed beef contains fewer antibiotics and hormones, is leaner than grain-fed and grain-finished beef, and has a more favorable ratio of omega fatty acids.

The well-managed pasture system sustains natural resources by reducing erosion and water pollution, conserving carbon, and preserving biodiversity and wildlife. Their sales methods—either operating as an independent, selling directly from their own property, or selling through small, locally focused producer groups—help support local communities, promote local foodsheds, and earn a fair price for the producers.

The industrialization of the calf.
We took an earth-friendly, solar-powered ruminant and turned it into a fossil-fuel powered machine.
The problem with banishing all meat from the dinner table is that ranchers of conscience are caught in the sweep, demonized along with factory farmers. These ethical producers should be celebrated as the vanguard of a growing revolt against industrial agriculture.

Let's face it, we are not heading toward a meatless society.
But we can be a society of ethical carnivores. We need to eat meat in moderation and avoid animals raised in confined spaces and fed an unnatural diet. Choosing grass-fed beef can have a lasting impact on our health and the health of the planet.

Gigabiting: where food meets culture and technology.

gigabiting.com

Main page photo: AJ Leon/Flickr
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Veggie Mama 5 pts

I'm a vegetarian, but I still encourage others to make ethical choices even if they're not. I think it's fabulous that this kind of dialog is taking place. And this is a well-written part of that dialog.

midnightbliss 5 pts

we raise our own chickens in our yard for our own consumption. in that way we know what goes with the chicken we eat.

Polish Mama on the Prairie 7 pts

I totally agree with this. And want to add that I was raised with these principles, if you will, of meat eating.

1. If you choose to eat meat, then once a day the size of your hand is all you need.

2. If you refuse to eat the offals and other less "pretty" cuts of meat, then you are being a snob and wasting a part of that once living creatures life and body, which you had killed in the first place to eat. If you're gonna eat it, eat it all.

3. Meat variety. We make sure to change up what animal we eat constantly. You don't have to eat only beef, chicken, or pork. There are other delicious options.

4. Don't waste it. If you took a piece of meat to eat, you better eat it.

5. Know and appreciate that it was once a living being, just like us. It ate, used the "bathroom", felt, saw the world around it. And died. Appreciate that.

That being said, we eat meat in our house 5 times a week. Once a day. Not counting Polish and Catholic holidays that call for eating no meat. And my 5 year old has decided she wants to become a vegetarian, her own decision. And I am proud.

gigabiting 5 pts

You are 5 for 5 with your principles! Polish Mama on the Prairie

redwritinghood 5 pts

"We all know that factory farming is a grotesquery" .. I actually worked on a feedlot for a year and felt we took quite good care of the animals.I spent many hours walking through their pens on foot with my dog... "checking pens" as it is called, the goal is to get an animal to slaughter healthy so we walk through the pens each day and it's amazing that you can get to know many of them and their little quirks.

Of course I'd much rather prefer they be grass fed with a lot more room... but then we couldn't afford to eat them! I choose to eat local farm raised meat as much as is economically possible for my family.... we usually choose a butcher who gets his meat from ranchers known to him. However I do know that smaller producers are not as regulated in terms of how/when they administer medications here... (I'm in Canada) whereas larger operations have to report what they've given and when and that determines a lot on when we can slaughter the animal.

I love the ethical meat movement. And I'm not defending all factory farming... I just wanted to offer up that not all factory farms are equal... and not all locally raised meat is equal. Just make sure you know where your meat comes from if you can is all I'm saying.. ;)

gigabiting 5 pts

Perhaps my statement should have been so broad and absolute. It just seems that the economics of large-scale production dictate the practices. I for one am happy to pay a premium to producers that I trust, all of which are, by definition, not factory farms.

redwritinghood

blackgirlinmaine 8 pts

Love this! My 19 yo is a vegetarian and I am a former vegetarian. My son often chides me for eating meat but I eat local farm raised meat and not in excess. Having gone the veg route, it is not for me but I believe I can be quite ethical in my meat choice.

gigabiting 5 pts

That's my point. Eat ethically and you can be a carnivore with your head held high. blackgirlinmaine

Otsdawa Junction Farm 5 pts

Amen. And add humanely-raised small farm chickens to your shopping list, too. If you ever saw how the birds are treated at the large-scale operations, you'd never eat chicken again....

"Support a Farmer - Eat your vegetables.

Support a Doctor - Don't."

Farmer Julie

Otsdawa Junction Farm

www.OtsdawaJunctionFarm.com

bellesouth 5 pts

Have you read _Ecotopia_? I was a vegetarian when I read it, and it completely changed my outlook on meat-eating and environmentalism. There's a portion in the novel that goes back to our earliest civilizations, that would use the entire animal for meat, clothing, tools, furniture, housing, etc.

gigabiting 5 pts

Funny that you mention that book. I was a San Francisco teenager when it came out in the 70's, and it was considered essential reading. Here on the east coast, a mention of it is meant with blank stares. I am glad to see it is still remembered.

DesiValentine4 25 pts

I like this. There is so much conflicting information about what we should be eating for health, ethics, and environment that it's freakin' overwhelming. Pay attention to where your food is coming from, right? Then the ethical, environmental and healthy decision becomes a no-brainer. I couldn't agree with you more.

Conversation from Facebook

Koryn Sheppard
Koryn Sheppard

In fairness, I like quinoa. :) But really, this issue is close to my heart and why I changed my eating habits towards vegetarianism. I still eat organic meat occasionally. I prefer my meat free of hormones and antibiotics and humanely raised. I am glad there's a discussion going.

Angie Rapids
Angie Rapids

Ethical implies food politics - of which I don't partake. We eat responsibly. We raise our own meats that we consume and we don't ask other people to do the dirty work of slaughtering them. We birth them, raise them, love them and put them on the table ourselves.

Melissa Fritcher
Melissa Fritcher

I definitely try. :)