Bio
I'm the Family, Moms...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Fake Pregnancy, Real Difference

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When I was a senior in high school, my main concerns were getting into college for something music related, managing my crazy curly hair and spending time with my Varsity basketball star boyfriend. I had a senior project; it was music related. I certainly wasn’t concerned with what society thought about teen pregnancy. In fact, I was one of those who judged girls in my class who got pregnant. (It’s okay. Karma got me by the end of college.) So when I heard that Gaby Rodriguez faked a pregnancy as a social experiment for her senior project, I was amazed.

Rodriguez is a senior at Toppenish High School. She decided to do this project due to the high rate of Latina teen pregnancy in her area. She held an assembly last week to inform the student body that she was not, in fact, pregnant. She actually took off her belly. This girl has some guts. She essentially “gave up” her senior year to do this project which could arguably be the most famous senior project ever. Was your senior project talked about on CNN.com by Dr. Drew Pinsky? Mine most certainly was not.

Neither was it on MSNBC, which you can watch for yourself.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

However, when I saw this news start flooding the web last week, I got one of those feelings in the pit of my stomach. I knew some people wouldn’t receive her hard work well because of preconceived notions, fear of de-stigmatizing teen pregnancy and/or single parenting and the almighty judgery that we all participate in at one time or another.

A discussion at The Blog Frog made me sad -- because I was right.

The article made it sound like she had done this groundbreaking thing, but... teenage girls actually DO get pregnant every day. It's not like she was looking into something rare or unheard of. She was replicating something that happens every day. Rumors and gossip that could actually be witnessed with any teenage pregnancy.

I'm just not sure that anything she came out with was all that earth shattering or important.

And I disagree. Yes, teens get pregnant all the time. But as a society, we pass judgment without question. Even good girls with great grades are automatically written off as no longer worthwhile. And now the teens, teachers and other community members who said nasty things, who passed that judgment and generally wrote her off are forced to pause and ask themselves: Should a teen pregnancy redefine a girl for the rest of her life?

The answer, of course, is no. And I want to give Gaby Rodriguez a high five. And a fist pump. And a belly bump, just because. What she did was brave. It took guts to make her boyfriend’s parents think that they were expecting a grandchild (though that is the most argued offense that I've seen thus far). It took some chutzpah to stand firm in a social science experiment when people starting saying not-so-nice things. She not only got the reaction, but her final report will feature important things like statistics. This wasn’t just a shock-value project; she’s addressing the problem at hand and the problem at hand involves the statistics and those who want to point fingers and pass judgment. This was a girl doing something that needs to be done: Taking a stand and saying that neither are good. She’s making a difference, far more than the naysayers are.

Reaction, for the most part, sided with Gaby being generally awesome.

u235 at The World of Suck defends Gaby, not society.

Bold. That's how I describe what she did, pure bully boldness, and I'm using the world 'bully' in a way that most people won't naturally intuit: to force others into retrospection about their own instinctive actions and behaviors.

Ms. C at The New Forty couldn’t help but cheer for Gaby.

I hereby crown Gaby Rodriguez one of my heroes

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
justlinda 9 pts

I'm on the sidelines of this one for now. I can't quite come down on one side, and yet I don't feel comfortable on the other.

I WAS pregnant my senior year, I lived it. Well, the version of it from 1983 in my geography - might be different for this girl in 2011 in the place she lives.

Maybe I need to see the outcomes - what she learned, and thus what can be gained and taught - before I form my opinion.

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

jennyonthespot 5 pts

Everything she just said... yeah, me too - DITTO!

Jenny Ingram writes at Jenny On The Spot ( http://www.jennyonthespot.com ) and wears glitter everyday. She also digresses over there on the Twitter @jennyonthespot ( http://twitter.com/jennyonthespot ).

laura capello 5 pts

As a mom of four boys, I'd want in on the experiment - not because of her, but because of my son. I would put him through the ringer because I would hold him accountable for his actions.

I keep hearing about the social impact on girls, where is it for the boys?

erelyea 5 pts

I agree, that as a parent, I would rather know that my son's girlfriend was faking her pregnancy for a school project, but then I start wondering: where would that circle of trust stop? Wouldn't the best friend's parents also like to be in the loop? Or the potential great-grandparents?

Otherwise, I am completely in awe of Gaby. When I was a senior in high school, my biggest concerns ran to juggling my job and school. I didn't have to do a senior project, but I certainly wouldn't have had the guts to come up with a fake pregnancy as a project.

nellewrites 6 pts

I'm not sure how I feel about this.

It would be different, that is I'd be less straddling a fence if she had done this outside of her social circle, as would happen if this were research.

Within that circle, she knowingly created false anxiety, and maintained that façade through not days, not weeks, but months. Imagine being the parents of her boyfriend. How would you react if your high school age son was on his way to parenthood? What kind of angst, what kind of reaction would you have? That deception bothers me. When I confide in someone, if they confided in me, it had damn well be the truth, and not a potential try for an Oscar. If it turned out not to be, if it turned out they were taking my trust and manipulating it for some public project, I'd be a bit miffed.

I get what came of it, what it showed - we know that exists, and we know we all could do better on such issues. As I write this, I'm trying to change the context in my mind, on the fly. What if someone I knew faked being TG to prove a point? What if they told me 'I'm TG' or 'I'm a dyke' and then go on to tell everyone this, to prove that people need to take a look at how they handle these issues?

I'm for her cause, but there has got to be a better way - and that better way to me would be those who are preggers telling their real stories and working to integrate them into high school life free of judgement. What I see here is all the publicity going to a faux pregnancy, and not to her classmates who actually face the life consequences of teen pregnancy.

nellewrites ( http://nellewrites.wordpress.com/ )

kirida 5 pts

I'm sure there was a reason why she didn't let her bf's parents in on the project. Perhaps they would have blabbed when they received criticism and the project's useless at that point.

Mona

kirida dot com ( http://www.kirida.com ) : from saipan to seattle

2commentaristas 5 pts

What this young lady did was brave and a wonderful demonstration of activism. So many people complain that Generation Y is aloof or simply "unplugged" from the social issues of our time, yet here we have an example of a young lady bringing the important issues or prejudice and bias to the forefront.

Good for her!

BlondieChicago 5 pts

I think her idea was genius and she will go far in life. I do agree that the boyfriend's parents should have been told though. A circle of trust is important in all large ventures. If I had a child who was smart enough and dedicated enough to take this kind of issue seriously and go for it all the way, I would totally support her. Again, awesomeness.

Blondie writes at Tales From Clark Street ( http://www.talesfromclarkstreet.blogspot.com/ ).

@TravelatedRease 5 pts

If I were a mother, I'd let my daughter fake a pregnancy, but I am with you on letting the boyfriend's parents in on the secret.

I admit that I can be judgemental of young pregnant girls, but not for the usual reasons. If you get pregnant, fine, you were having sex and maybe the condom failed you, that sucks but ti doesn't make you a harlot. What I judge is their ability to step up and be a mom, which means dropping the smoking and drinking habits and getting real. There was a girl in my high school who got pregnant her senior year. I knew her and never liked her, but I really respected her for finishing school. She wasn't a super smart girl but she studied hard and arranged to take her finals early so she could still graduate. That's definitely awesome.

fouragainsttwo 6 pts

I think a lot of people missed the point with her project. I was under the impression that she was doing research to find out how pregnant teens were treated from all aspects of society. Of course her project also provided awareness and conversation on pregnancy. I would let a daughter of mine do this project if I thought she was mature enough to handle it. I think she did well, but like you I think the boyfriend's parents should have been in the loop.
Mandy W.

FourAgainstTwo.com