Bio
I'm the mom of two kids, ages 8 and 11. I write the blog, Beyond The Brochure, for parents applying to private elementary schools in Los Angeles and...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Abandoning Prada: Why This Shopaholic Is Walking Away

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I’m an admitted shopaholic. I’ll spend my last dollar on a great designer handbag or a good-fitting pair of jeans. I devour virtually every fashion magazine and clip pictures of my favorite looks. I even buy pricey European fashion magazines. And, I’ve recently started buying my ten-year-old daughter pieces from J. Crew’s fabulous Crew Cuts For Kids.

So, the other day, on National Public Radio (NPR), a story about NY Fashion Week 2011 caught my attention. Pulitzer Prize winning fashion writer Robin Givhan, one of a small group of black fashion editors, was interviewed about the continuing lack of black models in top designer fashion shows. This unfortunate trend also carries over to lucrative cosmetic contracts and other fashion advertising. It’s not hard to see that while some progress has been made, the industry is still primarily interested in white models. In a piece for New York Magazine called, “Why Fashion Keeps Tripping Over Race” (February 16, 2011), Givhan astutely writes that when it comes to race, “the fashion community tends to play dumb or be disingenuous.”

Essence Magazine reports that in March 2010, Jezebel.com released its annual tally of models of color walking runways and found that about 16% of the nearly 4,000 models hired at New York Fashion Week were women of color. Of that figure, only 8% were Black.

My favorite designer is Prada. I love Prada’s minimal, well-crafted, timeless pieces. Their clothes fit me perfectly, and I always feel great wearing them. Well, my Prada obsession has effectively ended now that Givhan has enlightened me by writing,

In fact, when the black model Jourdan Dunn appeared in 2008 in what had been up until then a relentlessly all-white Prada show, I marveled in my blog: “Black girl walking!” It was the first time in more than a decade that I recalled seeing a black model in one of Miuccia Prada’s shows.

For me, as an African American Prada customer, this is too much to handle. I just bought my last Prada dress in December. Farewell, my beautiful Prada. It’s a good thing the Prada pieces I own will last a long, long time!

In 2003, history was made when the stunning Ethiopian model, Liya Kebede, landed a lucrative and prominent Estee Lauder Cosmetics contract, making her the FIRST black model to represent the company. I immediately went out to buy a collection of Estee Lauder makeup. Not because I love Estee Lauder (although their products turned out to be great), but because I wanted to applaud their bold decision to hire Liya. I sent the message with my wallet.

The NPR story and Givhan’s piece in New York Magazine started me thinking about the lack of models of color… again. It’s an issue I haven’t really focused on for some time. But, it’s 2011 and the fashion industry is STILL underrepresenting models of color. Why? I can name my favorite models and Liya is at the top of the list. So are Chanel Iman and Joan Smalls (she’s Puerto Rican). Why should I, an African American woman—and admitted shopaholic—spend money on designers who refuse to hire models of color? The answer is, I shouldn’t and I won’t.

There is good news, however. According to Givhan, “Now black models are on the upswing, with Liya Kebede, Chanel Iman, Sessilee Lopez, and Jourdan Dunn among them.”

Starting with my next purchase, I will look carefully at the designers who do work with diverse models. The same way some consumers scrutinize labels for organic content or grams of fat, I’ll be looking at magazine ads, runway shows and cosmetic contracts for models of color. Oh, and those fashion magazines who refuse to feature black models of color on the covers. Bye-Bye!

I’ve always been an equal opportunity shopper. I love Prada handbags and dresses, J. Crew jackets, Diane Von Furstenberg anything. But, if upon further investigation, my favorite designers aren’t equal opportunity employers and won’t use models that reflect diversity, this shopaholic will hastily

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
nellewrites 6 pts

While the country has grown more accepting of diversity in some ways, on a retail level, with our clothing in particular, we have been inundated with chains that wiped out local shops - and the unique products they offered.

I can go across the country to the Bay Area, and find the same choices I can get two miles from here. I lament that loss, I hate that loss. When I go someplace else, I don't wish to feel like I'm in my own back yard.

I watched a documentary on Rastafarians, and whilst I'm not diving into the belief, I loved loved loved the colourful clothing.

nellewrites ( http://nellewrites.wordpress.com/ )

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

about this is that every few years we keep trying to break new ground on this. When I was young - Naomi Sims was a black model who broke a lot of barriers and then my contemporary Beverly Johnson, etc. No one was more beautiful than Naomi Campbell. But for every black model who got work, recognition and national ad campaigns, there have always been designers and companies who don't use black models, asian models or latino models. If you've ever been to one of the old Ebony Fashion Fair shows where all the models were black you know that they can strut each and every designer and truly represent. Like you, I support products that reflect the real world and an expansive idea of beauty (like the Dove campaign and the United Colors of Benneton of yore).
Thanks.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Christina4646 5 pts

Hi Everyone, thanks for your comments!! It's such a great topic for discussion. I love fashion, high and low. I love Michelle Obama's style. I agree completely about Abercrombie and Fitch. Uggh!

To the designer, 28Squared. I appreciate your comments and you've given me some insight into the fashion design world. I like Tracey Reese, but it's not my style and her stuff looks terrible on me. To me, it's important to see women like me (race, age, etc.) represented by designers. I do support local trunk shows and designers here in LA. But, I will continue to wear and use my Prada stuff. After all, I paid good $$$ for it.

alyssaroyse 5 pts

As a seamstress and generally crafty woman, I know that I am lucky to be able to opt out of all this brand-name nonsense. And teach my daughter to do the same.

While I certainly understand your feelings about being underrepresented as a black woman, I feel like the whole industry violently misrepresents us as people. Of any color. Any shape. Any background.

By buying into any of the "beautiful and stylish and cool people wear this" messaging, we support the kinds of unrealistic expectations that degrade the fabric of our society.

Beyond body image - WHICH IS AN ENORMOUS ISSUE for both men and women - is the idea that our clothes should be of uniform style, that homogeneity is desirable, that other people should tell us what to look like, that our clothing is disposable - and that encourages such wastefulness.

From a marketing perspective, after spending years working with clients to get their logos all over the place, the fact that these people have tricked us into paying good money to be their billboards is just incredible to me. I admit that when I see someone prominently sporting a designer label, I think less of them. Is it wrong of me? Sure. But I see a person who values a shallow stamp of society's judgement more than.....

More than the experiences they could have bought with that same money. More than the good they could have done with that money. More than their own right to express themselves in a unique way.

Personally, I think we need to opt out.

I love fashion, I too read the magazines. But I read them to look at the clothing as art. What does this inspire in me? How can I find myself in here and reinvent it?

Again, I know I'm lucky that I was taught to sew at a young age. And I'm doing the same for my daughter. I felt a pang of "guilt" when I heard her ask someone else why they wanted to be a billboard. But it was ameliorated when I came home one day and she had turned one of her father's old work shirts into a seam-on-the-outside funky dress for herself and made some smiley face pillows out of scrap fabric.

Fashion should be about expressing ourselves, not selling ourselves out as advertising space while mortgaging our homes and dismissing our diversity.

____________

Alyssa's Endless Musings on Life & Everything Else: AlyssaRoyse.com ( http://www.alyssaroyse.com )

28squared 5 pts

First up I will apologize up front for my passion, but there are so many misconceptions on the issue…
Robin Givha is one of my favorite fashion columnist and the article is a gem! However, I not sure I applaud your decision! I am a black designer that currently runs a program helping designers start their lines !
Unfortunately the Black designer does not expect the financial vote of the Black high end shopper! If I am to ask shoppers to name a black designer… I’m almost sure you’d say TRACY REESE
I am not saying this to be offensive it is a sad fact I realized around the time of Michelle Obama’s dress hoopla; when in private discussion African American designers admitted they NEVER expected to be selected!
I started the incubator program at one of the one of the leading African American boutiques, in NY. We would see clients enter dressed in Prada, complaining about the $45 cost of hand worked earrings! During the time I was there 60-65% of the clientele was… NOT BLACk, the black consumers were at Bendles, Lord and Taylors and Saks… he quality was comparable , many hav e worked for the designers who show at fashion week… but lacked financial backing and resources!
There are so many excellent designers of color who would love an opportunity to cloth a customer such as you;!
The irony is that “Essence Magazine is;- (a Black magazine that once championed the cause of black fashion designers and models) now reports on the state of models from quoting from “Jezebel.com”
We’ve come the wrong way baby!
Many would be surprised but as a black designer I have always felt strongly that a designer should have the right to choose the model that best suits their vision… I do not believe that white designers should be forced to hire black models simply to “Satisfy Numbers!
Get Black designers on the Fashion Week program … which means investors!
I have served both black and white clients and with both my color, design aesthetic and more importantly FIT shifts slightly during the design process to suit the clients! As a Blogger I use my own images not stock… and often pull friends in for photo shoots!
I have been called on more than one occasion for using solely Black “models” at the time I was working from my creative expression( the old fashioned blogging style) these were my friend.
I have had white models fit the clothing… but it was their inner personality that made it possible! My models are stronger, bolder, fuller healthier and HAPPIER than the seventh on sixth model, for a while the waif was the muse and black models do not do “waif very well!
Recently a Fashion Incubator was started in New York, One of the prerequisites for entrance was press coverage by a major news outlet! Designers of color who could have benefitted from this opportunity could not fulfill that requirement; what designers of color would have given for an article by the likes of Robin Givha !

Words fall short of genuine support!
May I suggest that you vote by supporting a local designer in your area who chooses to produce locally!
Let me drive it home…
You’ve made your last purchase but will “still wear Prada” For the cost of a “Prada” you can support the budding career of a local designer (black or otherwise) who would in turn provide employment! O When you step out you represent a woman of color, with the means to afford designer clothing Choosing a Prada!

To the mom I applaud you on ensuring your son (we often forget them) has positive image models!
At the other extreme… we have been led to believe cheaper Is better, with devastating results to the planet and local economies! Everytime you make a purchase you vote for the right of a workers … across the globe!
Buying thrift is one thing… buying, cheap may be doing more harm than good
Is it not better to pay a fair living wage to sales and service staff., who will in turn go out and buy, simple items that they need but the local economy will be stimulated! As I look at businesses that sell “cheap”; such as some of the institutions mentioned, their entrance into communities are followed by closure of local businesses and loss of jobs! Distribution is at the managerial level!
Managers who NEVER shop in the communities they pillage from!
Cheap i s not always economical or sustainable!
In fact consider that the production cost of the item are probably one fifth of their retail!
I can assure you that in any country producing an evening dress that retails for $9.99 should be a warning sign that something is not on the up and up! They claim fair wages…
My definition of “fair”;- ”do unto others as I would have others do unto me”…
$5-10 US a day, which is what many are paid! I simply cannot buy the excuse of eliminating poverty; when there is poverty at this level right here in The US… but they cannot legally pay that because of laws!
A $5 item may be a vote of abuse!

Grace Hwang Lynch 7 pts

Good for you! Although I've never been in the market for Prada, I do notice when designers or major magazines use a model of color. It's so rare to see an Asian model on the cover of a fashion magazine, that I will buy it on the spot, just to vote with my dollars.

Whether we intend it or not, what we wear says a lot about what we value: who models the clothes... who makes them.

That's one thing I love about Michelle Obama. She doesn't just wear the most famous designers, she picks young, relatively unknown, diverse talent.

Grace Hwang Lynch blogs at HapaMama ( http://hapamama.com ) and A Year (Almost) Without Shopping ( http://www.blogher.com/ A Year (Almost) Without Shopping ).

Jane Byers Goodwin 5 pts

I do not share my pitiful bank account with ANY designer who hires 85-pound women of ANY ethnicity to mince up and down on stick legs, that stiff mannequin expression that makes them all look alike - dead - artificially dilated eyes, and hair that's either being spit out of their mouths or that wouldn't budge in a gale wind, pimping a quarter-yard of fabric held together with a safety pin, four sequins, and a fake fur scarf that cost more than my house. I do not pay to advertise a designer; they should be paying US to pimp their pretentious names.

When I look at Oscar dresses, or watch Ugly Betty, or check out the mortuary look of a designer window, all I can think of is how many warm coats, mittens, and shoes for little children could have been purchased for the price some women/men would think nothing of paying for one purse. If I HAD that kind of money, I wouldn't support a designer with it; I'd support hungry kids with it.

I do own a Vera Wang shirt. I found it at a thrift shop for five dollars. The fact that it was Vera Wang meant nothing to me. It was the five dollars that caught my eye.

I'm with Lisa.

"Don't be content with being average. Average is as close to the bottom as it is to the top."

Jane blogs as "Mamacita" at Scheiss Weekly, ( http://janegoodwin.net/ )hitting the fan like nobody can.

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I wonder if it's the designers themselves or if it's the modeling agencies. If models of colour can't get their foot in that door, they certainly can't get chosen by a designer. I'm not sure how it works, but I'd love to know how the major agencies break down in terms of their representation of women of colour.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her novel about blogging is Life from Scratch ( http://www.life-from-scratch.com/ ).

Denise 9 pts moderator

I've seen (and heard) Lisa Stone say a lot of brilliant things in the 10+ years I've known her and this goes down as one of my favorites:

In fairness to the store, I just visited their site and checked out their model search. A few kids of color, but I get the drill. This is why I'm sticking to Target, Walmart and Sears. I can afford it for their outsides; they can afford it inside.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

Lisa Stone 6 pts

...or do I mean strut that talk? :)

I agree wholeheartedly. One day I was walking through a Bay Area mall with my then 13-year-old son, past an Abercrombie and Fitch. We stopped and stared at a 10-foot poster of an outrageously muscled, white, male torso -- his head was cut off by the top of the photograph.

"Wow," said my son. "Am I supposed to look like that?"

No way, I told him. I don't want my sons to be the new teenage girls, pressured into body insecurity. And my boys are white, so they at least see examples of (someone's) future self.

In fairness to the store, I just visited their site and checked out their model search. A few kids of color, but I get the drill. This is why I'm sticking to Target, Walmart and Sears. I can afford it for their outsides; they can afford it inside.

Lisa Stone, BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/politics-news ).