Bio
Tami Winfrey Harris writes about race, feminism, politics and pop culture at the blog What Tami Said. Her work has also appeared on The Guardian’s Co...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

New Blackface Not Fashionable; Still Racist

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

constance_5_092810

In a society that privileges a typically European (read: white) standard of beauty — pale skin, straight hair, slim noses and lips — there is a penalty for being the opposite of that standard, for having physical features common to people with African ancestry. Black people pay the cost for their physicality everywhere from the bedroom — where blackness can reduce a woman's sexual currency — to the boardroom, where employers develop policies that penalize African-Americans for wearing their hair in natural styles. But in no career is the penalty for "looking black" higher than in fashion, an industry devoted to beauty and to framing, promoting and defending whiteness as its standard. Read more...

I lamented the fashion industry's marginalization of black women in a recent post on Change.org's Race in America site (excerpt above). The near invisibility of black women, and other women of color, in fashion magazines and on the runway has been an ongoing controversy. Jezebel.com, which has been tracking participation by models of color in New York's fashion week since 2007, called this year's shows "almost a total whitewash." From within this context comes the disturbing trend of "blackface" in print fashion -- painting white models and adorning them with afro wigs. It would seem that the fashion industry doesn't want black women ... even when it sorta does.

The latest photo spread to attract attention appeared in the October issue of Numero magazine and featured blond, blue-eyed, white model Constance Jablonski sporting darkening makeup, faux tribal prints and accessories, and various afro wigs, while cavorting with a naked black baby in some savanna-like locale. It is a veritable stew of race fail -- at once managing to offend, appropriate culture, further stereotype and discriminate against black women. As difficult as I imagine it might be for a black model to participate in this hot stereotypical mess of a fashion shoot, why not simply hire a black model rather than paint a white model to look like one?

The answer may be found in what the fashion industry considers "acceptably" black. In the Canadian short film, The Color of Beauty, which followed a black model hoping to make it big in modeling, photographer Justin Peery offered that black women who succeed in the fashion industry have "the very skinny nose, the very elegant faces"  that make them appear "like white girls that were painted black." That, Peery said, is what agents see as beautiful — girls who have a different skin pigment, but the same features as any other white model. As for girls with "big eyes, big noses, big lips — big whatevers, all traits that are common to African Americans" — well, it's a lot harder. Of course, black women come with a variety of facial features and skin colors. But, it seems, in the end, the blackness preferred by the fashion industry is a "blackness" best supplied by someone who is not black at all. And so, while models of color continue to go underrepresented on the pages and covers of magazines, we are treated to fashion spreads like this one, or this more horrifying one from L'Officiel Hommes.

500x_officiel_1

It seems a little silly, I suppose, to hope black women might be treated well in a misogynist industry. Racial discrimination is but one of the fashion industry's sins, and its sins against women are too numerous to explore here. And fashion is so frivolous, isn't it? Surely there are more pressing problems facing black womanhood. 

This trend matters, though. It matters because all racial discrimination matters. It matters because it is time we laid blackface to rest (and pan-African exoticizing along with it). It matters because women and men of color working in the fashion industry are entitled to the same opportunities as their white counterparts. And it matters because as long as the keepers of the beauty aesthetic deem the physicality of black women unacceptable, we remain "broke" in a sexist society where female beauty is currency. 

Tami also blogs for What Tami Said, Change.org's Race in America site and writes the column, Colorstruck, on Psychology Today.

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
AlesiaMichelle 5 pts

I actually wasn't really offended by this... Yeah, they could have just hired black models, but it wouldnt have made a statement. Think about what white women do when they have plastic surgery: bigger lips, higher cheekbones, bigger butts, tanning... all black features... This was a statement.

www.RealTalk123.com ( http://www.RealTalk123.com )

howertons 5 pts

Has there been any sort of public backlash about these photospreads? Like the previous posters, I don't know how this stuff got past the photographers, much less editors. Someone should be losing a job over this . . .

www.rageagainsttheminivan.com ( http://www.rageagainsttheminivan.com )

( http://www.%3C/div )

Kristi_Bernard 5 pts

This is really horrible. I think we've been set back about 100 years on this one.

ausetkmt 5 pts

Tami you have it right indeed.
as a lightskinned curly hair Blackwoman, I'm even asking myself What's up with this Blackface instead of Black Faces in Fashion Lately ? for too long Black Models have complained about exactly this. now we see it becoming mainstreamed as a fashion concept for what ? Exotica;

BS. that's what this is.
BTW, Reposting with comments on mysite since this is a very important piece and needs wide exposure in the blogging world.

I Applaude You for Your Truthfulness.

Skye 5 pts

I can see where one ignorant or hateful person might have such a terrible idea, but a photo shoot like this doesn't happen overnight with just one person's effort. How many meetings, sketches, proposals, signoffs, budgeting decisions, etc. were involved with this - and no one said "Um, hey, this is REALLY RACIST AND A BAD IDEA"? Yuck!

Skye Kilaen

Flooded Lizard Kingdom ( http://www.lizardkingdom.org ) | Heroine Content ( http://www.heroinecontent.net )

veryveryfine 5 pts

I saw this spread in the magazine and my thought process went something like: errrmm, WOC, okay, but I'm surprised the model was okay with being exoticized like tha...WAIT WHAT??!!

So disappointing to think of the number of hands this passed through to make it into mine. Gross gross gross.

Kim Pearson 5 pts

Carla Williams and Deborah Willis did a wonderful book about 10 years ago, "The Black Female Body: A Photographic History" ( http://www.temple.edu/tempress/titles/1356_reg.htm... ). This fits right into the body of material that they reviewed in order to document the ways in which black women's bodies are routinely appropriated, exploited and demeaned. When I first saw this, I wanted very much to hear what they would have to say about it.

Then again, maybe this requires a Marlon Riggs "Ethnic Notions" kind of analysis to put it in focus:

Kim Pearson
BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://blogher.org/blog/kim-pearson )|KimPearson.net ( http://kimpearson.net )|

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Sometimes it feels like the whole world is going backwards. The documentary was depressing, but if people don't talk about it ... Thank you for writing this, Tami.
Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

everydayjill 5 pts

Rarely am I speechless, but this magazine photo spread leaves me absolutely speechless.

Okay, maybe not speechless. What in the hell were they thinking?

j_gumieny 5 pts

I see your point and completely note your frustration especially towards the fashion industry. The photo you posted is offensive to me on an additional level... My husband and I are white and we've been blessed enough to adopt our beautiful Ethiopian daughter - she is truly a miracle... For me this picture not only stereotypes 'Africa' it also suggests that a white woman painted black is 'okay' but not a white woman with a black baby. Honestly, the social media is misguided and so on the verge of hopelessness, that I am thankful for sites such as this and for your insight. You've provided some sense of reality and clarity!
Blessings.
j
www.gfinkfamily.blogspot.com ( http://www.gfinkfamily.blogspot.com )
Beneath the Acacia Tree