Bio
Unwilling to fully abandon my Chicago-area upbringing, I live in Manhattan with my husband, my teddy bear, and a 10 lb. rabbit, but insist on calling...
 
 
 
 

Recent Comments

Feminism, Gender, and Pets

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Women are so closely associated with cats that even our genitalia share a slang name with the lithe furry beasts. In darker times, cats were believed to be the animal forms of witches. Today, the myth of the single spinster living with 27 cats is still a mocked stereotype. While feminists know better, whenever we joke about becoming the "crazy cat lady," there is often an underlying concern that one day, that's exactly what we'll become. (Elaine Vigneault, tongue firmly tucked in cheek, titled a post about a woman who had 136 cats in a three room apartment, "I Wonder if She's a Feminist Too.")"

My friend Count Mockula, who has a cat and is pregnant, reminded me that people project social anxieties and women's issues onto cats all the time. Myths about cats sucking the breath out of children or killing babies out of jealousy persist to this day, although that is a funny thing to believe about an animal derided for being "haughty" and "indifferent." (Why would a cat care any more than any other animal if a baby is in the house?) Is it the same as blaming doting mothers for "suffocating" their children or working mothers for being neglectful of their children's needs?

Given the sociological background ascribed to felines, is it any wonder that single men who share their lives with cats are often regarded with suspicion? Cats are not manly. What kind of guy would want a kitty hanging around his bachelor pad? Unlike dogs, cats are not chick magnets – you can't walk you cat (for the most part) to get women's attention. While I know several men who owned cats when they were single, usually people assumed that they acquired them through girlfriends.

Even though dogs are "man's best friend," they are more gender neutral. If a single woman enjoys the presence of a dog, it is as understandable as a guy's love of the friendly and protective beast. Plus, dogs do double duty as loyal companions and guardians. It makes sense that a single woman would want a dog just in case someone breaks into her home.

In "researching" the link between pets and gender, I came across an interesting theory cited at ChildFree Hardcore that blames feminism for substituting pets for children:

When people don't have kids, they tend to focus their time on things like weird hobbies and pets. And then they become huge weirdos. I think you're supposed to like, not love, pets. I think you're supposed to enjoy, not love, certain hobbies. But when you have too much time for you, that's what winds up happening…I 'm talking about grown men and women who could conceive, but choose not to because they want to spend more hours working, more hours hanging out with with their friends, more time cuddling with their pets, etc.

I think this is an off-shoot of feminism, to be honest. I think feminism hasn't really taught women to celebrate and rejoice in their womanhood, instead imploring them to celebrate and rejoice in behaviors they have co-opted from men.

This post doesn't actually specify that these pets are cats, but other anti-feminist blogs were very clear that women were replacing babies with kittens.

Suzanne also blogs about the other type of pussy at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants and lives with a 13 lb. rabbit because she is allergic to cats

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
maomau 5 pts

i totally agree with you. i'm sure most of my friends & neighbors think i'm the crazy cat lady, just because i have more than 2 cats. I'm probably one of the few that don't have kids at my age (late 30s) it was never my intention to have more than one cat in the beginning but things just happen and they really don't take more time to feed or clean after than with two cats. i can't imagine not seeing in and around the house.

i hate that when others feel that i have given up the idea of having children for cats. yes, they are my kitty kids but its no ones business if i had a cat or child. i hope that if we do have a kid or not, that i don't end up abandoning my kitties.

thanks

anna 

ladylarke 5 pts

 Well I can't have kids, and I've known it since I was 18 yrs old when I found out I had endometriosis. Yeah, you may be thinking to yourself, "but my friend has it too and ..." let's just say I haven't tried, didn't want to and still do not now that I'm a few years from 40. And it's OK with me, and my hubby.

So I have cats, several. And they are not typical cats (so says she who adores them and lavishes them like children) in that they do not require a can opener to come hither! But know their names, come to their names and even know what N O means lol. Of course they ARE my kids and I can't imagine being without them.

I can very well imagine being without a kid, or several. Though it seems that society thinks I must lack severely in some way to have to resort to being a "crazy cat lady" with no children. I must have something wrong with me, I must! 

Well, to those that think only children and a man can complete a woman, pfffft! And to those others who think I have too many cats, or can't or won't come by my home because I have cats, see ya! Don't let the door hit you on the way out :D 

Warm Regards,

Shannon

Cattery-Index.com ( http://www.cattery-index.com )

Grumpy-kitty.com ( http://www.grumpy-kitty.com )

fnm1gll 5 pts

I have a dog now but I've had cats most of my life. I think of myself as an animal lover, not a "cat person" or a "dog person". (I could never understand why people feel like they have to choose between them or make it a competition for which one is "better".)

When I had cats, my friends with dogs seemed to think of me as cat obsessed. They gave me cat-themed gifts for birthdays and Christmas, cat themed-decor for my house, etc. despite the fact that my actual cat was the only "cat-themed thing" that I ever chose to bring into the house. (One year, two friends each gave me a daily calendar with pictures of cats for each day and both said it was the "perfect present" for me.) I haven't gotten a single dog-themed item since becoming a dog owner.

And while there are plently of crazy cat ladies in the world (and men too -- just visit a cat show!) there are also lots of crazy dog people in the world. It's just weird that people have to put a sexist spin on it.

And I like you point about men with cats. I tend to give a man extra points if he's a cat lover.

It's strange how some people get upset about love spent on animals. It seems that each time there's a story in the newspaper about money spent to help animals, or fights against cruelty to animals or something similar, someone writes an opinion piece to express outrage that people "waste" their efforts on animals when there are people that need help. Why people begrudge any expression of kindness between one creature and another is beyond me.

The Word Cellar 5 pts

A few years ago when I got my first cat, a male, I realized that I'd traditionally thought of cats in terms of the feminine and dogs in terms of the masculine. It's definitely something ingrained in our culture.

I'm probably not helping the pets vs. kids debate, either. When people ask if I have kids, I sometimes joke and say, "No, I have cats. We call them the kits." I don't truly believe you have to choose one or the other, but the joke may reinforce that idea, which is not good.

The weirdest moment of all was when my husband's boss, a nice but very straightforward lady from the South, asked me if I wanted kids. When I said I wasn't sure, this was her response: "Didn't you just get a cat? And don't you LOVE that cat?" I said something about a cat being different from a baby. She replied, "But once you had one, YOU'D LOVE IT SO MUCH!!!"

Geesh! I never said I was a baby-hater! :)

Jennifer McGuiggan
~The Word Cellar ~ purveyor of fine writing and editing
www.thewordcellar.blogspot.com ( http://www.thewordcellar.blogspot.com )

Suzanne 5 pts

I know - I think has a lot to do with people being completely wrapped up in ridiculous theories about pets as children. Obviously people can have pets and kids, yet it seems like we continually set up our society as women can have only thing or another. We can have pets OR kids; we can have a career OR a family. If we think we can have more than one thing, we are just fooling ourselves.

Redneck Mother ( http://redneckmother.blogspot.com/2008/01/dont-be-... ) has a great post on "big families" (ie - kids and pets), too.

Suzanne Reisman ( http://www.blogher.com/member/suzanne ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

Suzanne 5 pts

As you know, I have a large white rabbit. I think rabbits are very closely identified with girlish innocence, although any rabbit owner knows that rabbits have quite spirited personalities and, um, screw like rabbits, which is sort of a creepy association, then, with little girls. When I was growing up, I was allergic to all things furry, so I had a long succession of goldfish (Fishy I through XIII), a chameleon, and a newt. And see how I turned out? I'm not sure if that is a warning to parents or a boast...

Suzanne Reisman ( http://www.blogher.com/member/suzanne ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

Suzanne 5 pts

Since my post didn't communicate this properly, the quote from ChildFree's site is not her own thoughts. She quoted another person and was rather enraged by what the "mofo" (her description, but I agree) had to say on the matter. Sorry if I cause some confusion.

Suzanne Reisman ( http://www.blogher.com/member/suzanne ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

A Elliot 5 pts

I'm not sure where to begin. First of all, I agree with Elisa that Childfree makes it seem like all women need to have children to be truly happy. Obviously such a generalization is not true. Second, what's wrong with wanting to spoil your pet? Yes people may think it's weird, but what is truly wrong with it? She basically assumes that there is a right and a wrong way to spend free time and that some hobbies are more worthwhile than others. My last comment on Childree comes from my perspective as someone who has postponed her admission to vet school but hopes to attend in the future: pets are not hobbies. Pets are living creatures. Many people seem to think that pets are disposable. If you want to have a pet (as opposed to having a cow at a farm where the animal is a working animal), then I think it is ideal that owner(s) love their animal. At the very least, they should respect it. Training for a triathlon is my hobby. I certainly don't put my two cats and my dog on the same level as my spinning shoes.

When I was reading your post, it did make me wonder if pet choices are about something deeper than just dogs being chick magnets. Dogs need to be walked. In our society we are very protective of women and unfortunately sometimes turn that around to blame women. I always heard that women should never walk alone at night. If you have a dog, it is most likely that you will have to walk it at night.

Alex Elliot, Formula Fed and Flexible Parenting ( http://www.flexibleparenting.com )

Crunchy Carpets 5 pts

What about those of us with kids AND pets. AND we had the cats before we had the kids!!!

I know lots of guys with cats and they get the 'gay' thing chucked at them rather frequently and some of them are..but the straight guys just like cats!

We originally had cats because they WERE a lot less hassle than dogs...but all my cats have been firm members of the family too.

I got a dog for the family and because I think I needed a third baby as she is so dependent on me. But I also just really enjoy DOG stuff vs CAT stuff.

I do think all this is a continuation of the ongoing mythos around cats and dogs.....cats were the subject to fears and misunderstanding for a very long time....the single lady with cats is just that mad witch in the woods with all the cats.

And sure if someone wants to spend thousands on their pets....on toys coats, etc great.

My big thing is the dog as accessory....and yes that is what they are being that the stores catering to all the cutesy clothing and accessories for them seem to focus on the trendy parts of town.......there maybe is a correlation between the single girl and her toys.

oh and check out my fem argument too

http://crunchycarpets.com/archives/351

Look for me at http://crunchycarpets.com or check out the ladies at www.wetcoastwomen.com ( http://www.wetcoastwomen.com )

Elisa Camahort 5 pts

That excerpt from ChildFree hardcore makes my head explode. I actually went and read the whole thing.

So the only way to celebrate and rejoice in our womanhood is to have kids?

Well, another one of that commenter's brilliant theories is that divorce rates are lower among couples who attend church because they're spending time not focused on themselves, but on things outside themselves...BUT having hobbies, interests, friends, and pets...*that's* all just more ways of focusing only on yourself. Has that person ever HAD pets...or friends, for that matter?

Gah!

Elisa Camahort
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.org

super des 5 pts

Maybe women like cats because they are a bit feministic. They are independent, clever, and can survive on their own easily without someone to watch over their every move. Most dogs (men?) can't do this. Men need to feel needed, they need to be the provider. Dogs are very needy (and I do love dogs, btw), so a man taking care of a dog feels more useful than if he tries to take care of a cat.

I could go on and on about this I think, but you get the point.

ps - what about pets like ferrets, birds, fish, reptiles, bunnies, etc.?

Debra Roby 5 pts

I bought my first stick shift car in 1979, not knowing how to drive it. News reported a dramatic increase in single women owning stick shifts that year, and decided that we all wanted the increased control at the wheel it gave us.

Me? I just bought a sporty car (wish I could honestly call it a sports car).. and believed that all sports cars must be driven with a stick. I'm still glad that car forced me to learn a new skill. Besides, then a stick shift was close to $1000 cheaper and I cut my car purchase close (AM/FM radio, no A/C, etc.). Control at the wheel was a happy coincidence.

When I got married in 1983, my spouse already had a dog; I already had my tubes tied. We were in our 30s. A couple years later the news reported that many of the couples who married around the age of 30 would have either pets or kids but not both. Whichever they "got" first they stuck with.

So according to that story the fact that our marriage started with a dog was the reason we didn't have kids.

Conclusions made from analyzing data without looking at underlying facts is always interesting, but from my experience, usually flawed. I'm sure the feminist/pet theory falls in the same catagory as the those above.

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Deb's Daily Distractions ( http://debsdistractions.blogspot.com )